Publications

Goldflam, Michael G.; Musick, Katherine M.; Resnick, Paul J.; Whiting, Eric W.; Campbell, Sawyer C.; Kang, Lei K.; Sinclair, Michael B.; Werner, Douglas W.; Burckel, David B.

Abstract not provided.

Optics InfoBase Conference Papers

Gennaro, Sylvain D.; Goldflam, Michael G.; Burckel, David B.; Jeong, Jeeyoon; Sinclair, Michael B.; Brener, Igal B.

In this work, we investigate the linear optical response of a dielectric metasurface made of vertically-oriented germanium ellipses deposited on walls of a micron-scale cubic silicon nitride unit cell support matrix.

Burckel, David B.

Abstract not provided.

2020 14th International Congress on Artificial Materials for Novel Wave Phenomena, Metamaterials 2020

Burckel, David B.; Musick, Katherine M.; Resnick, Paul J.; Sinclair, Michael B.; Goldflam, Michael G.

A wall-first variant of membrane projection lithography (MPL) is introduced which yields three-dimensional meta-films; mm-scale structures with micron-scale periodicity and 3D nm-scale unit cell structure. These meta-films combine aspects of photonic crystals, metamaterials and plasmonic nano antennas in their infrared scattering behavior. We present the fabrication approach, and modeling/IR characterization results.

Optics Express

Burckel, David B.; Goldflam, Michael G.; Musick, Katherine M.; Resnick, Paul J.; Armelles, Gaspar; Sinclair, Michael B.

A complementary metal oxide semiconductor (CMOS) compatible fabrication method for creating three-dimensional (3D) meta-films is presented. In contrast to metasurfaces, meta-films possess structural variation throughout the thickness of the film and can possess a sub-wavelength scale structure in all three dimensions. Here we use this approach to create 2D arrays of cubic silicon nitride unit cells with plasmonic inclusions of elliptical metallic disks in horizontal and vertical orientations with lateral array-dimensions on the order of millimeters. Fourier transform infrared (FTIR) spectroscopy is used to measure the infrared transmission of meta-films with either horizontally or vertically oriented ellipses with varying eccentricity. Shape effects due to the ellipse eccentricity, as well as localized surface plasmon resonance (LSPR) effects due to the effective plasmonic wavelength are observed in the scattering response. The structures were modeled using rigorous coupled wave analysis (RCWA), finite difference time domain (Lumerical), and frequency domain finite element (COMSOL). The silicon nitride support structure possesses a complex in-plane photonic crystal slab band structure due to the periodicity of the unit cells. We show that adjustments to the physical dimensions of the ellipses can be used to control the coupling to this band structure. The horizontally oriented ellipses show narrow, distinct plasmonic resonances while the vertically oriented ellipses possess broader resonances, with lower overall transmission amplitude for a given ellipse geometry. We attribute this difference in resonance behavior to retardation effects. The ability to couple photonic slab modes with plasmonic inclusions enables a richer space of optical functionality for design of metamaterial-inspired optical components.

Burckel, David B.

Abstract not provided.

Burckel, David B.

Abstract not provided.

Optics Express

Adomanis, Bryan; Burckel, David B.; Marciniak, Michael

In this paper we present a design concept for 3D plasmonic scatterers as high-efficiency transmissive metasurface (MS) building blocks. A genetic algorithm (GA) routine partitions the faces of the walls inside an open cavity into a M x N grid of voxels which can be either covered with metal or left bare, and optimizes the distribution of metal coverage needed to generate electric and magnetic modes of equal strength with a targeted phase delay (Φt) at the design wavelength. Even though the electric and magnetic modes can be more complicated than typical low order modes, with their spectral overlap and equal strengths, they act as a Huygens source, with the accompanying low reflection magnitude. Square/hexagonal voxels inside square/rectangular cavities are thoroughly analyzed for operation at 8 µm, although the technique can be applied to different cavity geometries for operation across the electromagnetic spectrum. Results from full-wave simulations show the GA routine can repeatedly pinpoint scatterer geometries emitting at any Φt value across 2π phase space with transmittances of at least 60%, making these MS building blocks an attractive plasmonic alternative for practical optical applications. Full-scale metasurface devices are calculated from near-fields of the individual elements to validate the optical functionality.

Applied Sciences (Switzerland)

Pung, Aaron J.; Goldflam, Michael G.; Burckel, David B.; Brener, Igal B.; Sinclair, Michael B.; Campione, Salvatore

Metamaterials research has developed perfect absorbers from microwave to optical frequencies, mainly featuring planar metamaterials, also referred to as metasurfaces. In this study, we investigated vertically oriented metamaterials, which make use of the entire three-dimensional space, as a new avenue to widen the spectral absorption band in the infrared regime between 20 and 40 THz. Vertically oriented metamaterials, such as those simulated in this work, can be experimentally realized through membrane projection lithography, which allows a single unit cell to be decorated with multiple resonators by exploiting the vertical dimension. In particular, we analyzed the cases of a unit cell containing a single vertical split-ring resonator (VSRR), a single planar split-ring resonator (PSRR), and both a VSRR and PSRR to explore intra-cell coupling between resonators. We show that the additional degrees of freedom enabled by placing multiple resonators in a unit cell lead to novel ways of achieving omnidirectional super absorption. Our results provide an innovative approach for controlling and designing engineered nanostructures.

Proceedings of SPIE - The International Society for Optical Engineering

Musick, Katherine M.; Burckel, David B.

Membrane projection lithography (MPL) is a fabrication approach in which a novel process flow and mature silicon processing equipment combine to create three-dimensional metamaterials with size scales operational at optical frequencies. In its most common realization, MPL leverages microelectromechanical (MEMS) processing techniques to create cubic unit cells with silicon walls, planarized by chemical mechanical polishing (CMP), a technique that is not omnipresent in fabrication facilities. Here we show several variants of MPL, two of which do not require CMP to make the MPL process compatible with low-tech fabrication environments and open the MPL process to a wider audience.

Finnegan, Patrick S.; Washburn, Cody M.; Dyck, Christopher D.; Burckel, David B.; Blecke, Jill B.; Rector, Michael N.; Pfeifer, Kent B.; Satches, Michael R.

Abstract not provided.

Pung, Aaron J.; Goldflam, Michael G.; Burckel, David B.; Brener, Igal B.; Sinclair, Michael B.; Campione, Salvatore

Abstract not provided.

Electronics Letters

Campione, Salvatore; Burckel, David B.

Control and manipulation of polarisation is an important topic for imaging and light matter interactions. In the infrared regime, the large wavelengths make wire grid polarisers (WGPs) a viable option, as it is possible to create periodic arrays of metallic wires at that scale. The recent advent of metamaterials has spurred an increase in non-traditional polariser motifs centred around more complicated repeat units, which potentially provide more functionality. The authors explore the use of 2D arrays of single and back-to-back vertically oriented cross dipoles arranged in a cubic in-plane silicon matrix. They show that both single and back-to-back versions have higher rejection ratios and larger bandwidths than either WGPs or 2D arrays of linear dipoles.

Burckel, David B.

Abstract not provided.

2018 IEEE Antennas and Propagation Society International Symposium and USNC/URSI National Radio Science Meeting, APSURSI 2018 - Proceedings

Pung, Aaron J.; Goldflam, Michael G.; Burckel, David B.; Brener, Igal B.; Sinclair, Michael B.; Campione, Salvatore

Metamaterials provide a means to tailor the spectral response of a surface. Given the periodic nature of the metamaterial, proper design of the unit cell requires intimate knowledge of the parameter space for each design variable. We present a detailed study of the parameter space surrounding vertical split-ring resonators and planar split-ring resonators, and demonstrate widening of the perfect absorption bandwidth based on the understanding of its parameter space.

Finnegan, Patrick S.; Washburn, Cody M.; Dyck, Christopher D.; Burckel, David B.; Blecke, Jill B.; Rector, Michael N.; Pfeifer, Kent B.; Satches, Michael R.

Abstract not provided.

Proceedings of SPIE - The International Society for Optical Engineering

Burckel, David B.; Adomanis, Bryan M.; Campione, Salvatore; Sinclair, Michael B.

Three-dimensional (3D) metafilms composed of periodic arrays containing single and multiple micrometer-scale vertical split ring resonators per unit cell were fabricated using membrane projection lithography. In contrast to planar and stacked planar structures such as cut wire pairs and fishnet structures, these 3D metafilms have a thickness t ∼λd/4, allowing for classical thin film effects in the long wavelength limit. The infrared specular far-field scattering response was measured for metafilms containing one and two resonators per unit cell, and compared to numerical simulations. Excellent agreement in the frequency region below the onset of diffractive scattering was obtained. The metafilms demonstrate strong bi-anisotropic polarization dependence. Further, we show that for 3D metafilms, just as in solids, complex unit cells with multiple atoms (inclusions) per unit cell possess a richer set of excitation mechanisms. The highlight of these new coupling mechanisms is the excitation of the 3D analog to the 2D cut-wire-pair magnetic response.

Journal of Vacuum Science and Technology B: Nanotechnology and Microelectronics

Musick, Katherine M.; Wendt, J.R.; Resnick, Paul J.; Sinclair, Michael B.; Burckel, David B.

The manufacturing tolerances of a stencil-lithography variant, membrane projection lithography, were investigated. In the first part of this work, electron beam lithography was used to create stencils with a range of linewidths. These patterns were transferred into the stencil membrane and used to pattern metallic lines on vertical silicon faces. Only the largest lines, with a nominal width of 84 nm, were resolved, resulting in 45 ± 10 nm (average ± standard deviation) as deposited with 135-nm spacing. Although written in the e-beam write software file as 84-nm in width, the lines exhibited linewidth bias. This can largely be attributed to nonvertical sidewalls inherent to dry etching techniques that cause proportionally larger impact with decreasing feature size. The line edge roughness can be significantly attributed to the grain structure of the aluminum nitride stencil membrane. In the second part of this work, the spatial uniformity of optically defined (as opposed to e-beam written) metamaterial structures over large areas was assessed. A Fourier transform infrared spectrometer microscope was used to collect the reflection spectra of samples with optically defined vertical split ring from 25 spatially resolved 300 × 300 μm regions in a 1-cm2 area. The technique is shown to provide a qualitative measure of the uniformity of the inclusions.

Optics Express

Burckel, David B.; Adomanis, Bryan M.; Sinclair, Michael B.; Campione, Salvatore

This paper investigates three-dimensional cut wire pair (CWP) behavior in vertically oriented meta-atoms. We first analyze CWP metamaterial inclusions using full-wave electromagnetic simulations. The scattering behavior of the vertical CWP differs substantially from that of the planar version of the same structure. In particular, we show that the vertical CWP supports a magnetic resonance that is solely excited by the incident magnetic field. This is in stark contrast to the bianisotropic resonant excitation of in-plane CWPs. We further show that this CWP behavior can occur in other vertical metamaterial resonators, such as back-to-back linear dipoles and back-to-back split ring resonators (SRRs), due to the strong coupling between the closely spaced metallic elements in the back-to-back configuration. In the case of SRRs, the vertical CWP mode (unexplored in previous literature) can be excited with a magnetic field that is parallel to both SRR loops, and exists in addition to the familiar fundamental resonances of the individual SRRs. In order to fully describe the scattering behavior from such dense arrays of three-dimensional structures, coupling effects between the close-packed inclusions must be included. The new flexibility afforded by using vertical resonators allows us to controllably create purely electric inclusions, purely magnetic inclusions, as well as bianisotropic inclusions, and vastly increases the degrees of freedom for the design of metafilms.

International Conference on Optical MEMS and Nanophotonics

Burckel, David B.

Structured electromagnetic materials have experienced a renaissance with the emergence of metamaterial and plasmonic research. The ability to orient metallic plasmonic inclusions vertically enables orientation-dependent coupling arrangements which cannot be achieved in conventional planar engineered materials. In this paper we discuss these coupling arrangements and their effect on the measured far field scattering response to normally incident excitation.

Applied Physics Letters

Burckel, David B.; Campione, Salvatore; Davids, Paul D.; Sinclair, Michael B.

Three-dimensional (3D) metafilms composed of periodic arrays of silicon unit cells containing single and multiple micrometer-scale vertical split ring resonators (SRRs) per unit cell were fabricated. In contrast to planar and stacked planar structures, these 3D metafilms have a thickness t ∼ λd/4, allowing for classical thin film effects in the long wavelength limit. The infrared specular far-field scattering response was measured for metafilms containing one and two resonators per unit cell and compared to numerical simulations. Excellent agreement in the frequency region below the onset of diffractive scattering was obtained. For dense arrays of unit cells containing single SRRs, normally incident linearly polarized plane waves which do not excite a resonant response result in thin film interference fringes in the reflected spectra and are virtually indistinguishable from the scattering response of an undecorated array of unit cells. For the resonant linear polarization, the specular reflection for arrays is highly dependent on the SRR orientation on the vertical face for gap-up, gap-down, and gap-right orientations. For dense arrays of unit cells containing two SRRs per unit cell positioned on adjacent faces, the specular reflection spectra are slightly modified due to near-field coupling between the orthogonally oriented SRRs but otherwise exhibit reflection spectra largely representative of the corresponding single-SRR unit cell structures. The ability to pack the unit cell with multiple inclusions which can be independently excited by choice of incident polarization suggests the construction of dual-channel films where the scattering response is selected by altering the incident polarization.

Journal of Physical Chemistry Letters

Chou, Stanley S.; Swartzentruber, Brian S.; Janish, Matthew T.; Meyer, Kristin M.; Biedermann, Laura B.; Okur, Serdal; Burckel, David B.; Carter, C.B.; Kaehr, Bryan J.

Lead halide perovskites are increasingly considered for applications beyond photovoltaics, for example, light emission and detection, where an ability to pattern and prototype microscale geometries can facilitate the incorporation of this class of materials into devices. Here we demonstrate laser direct write of lead halide perovskites, a remarkably simple procedure that takes advantage of the inverse dependence between perovskite solubility and temperature by using a laser to induce localized heating of an absorbing substrate. We demonstrate arbitrary pattern formation of crystalline CH3NH3PbBr3 on a range of substrates and fabricate and characterize a microscale photodetector using this approach. This direct write methodology provides a path forward for the prototyping and production of perovskite-based devices.

Applied Physics Letters

Burckel, David B.; Finnegan, Patrick S.; Henry, Michael D.; Resnick, Paul J.; Jarecki, Robert L.

A method for patterning on vertical silicon surfaces in high aspect ratio silicon topography is presented. A Faraday cage is used to direct energetic reactive ions obliquely through a patterned suspended membrane positioned over the topography. The technique is capable of forming high-fidelity pattern (100 nm) features, adding an additional fabrication capability to standard top-down fabrication approaches.

Burckel, David B.; Resnick, Paul J.; Davids, Paul D.; Draper, Bruce L.

Abstract not provided.

Proceedings of SPIE - The International Society for Optical Engineering

Burckel, David B.

This paper demonstrates that another class of three-dimensional integrated circuits (3D-ICs) exists, distinct from through silicon via centric and monolithic 3D-ICs. Furthermore, it is possible to create devices that are 3D at the device level (i.e. with active channels oriented in each of the three coordinate axes), by performing standard CMOS fabrication operations at an angle with respect to the wafer surface into high aspect ratio silicon substrates using membrane projection lithography (MPL). MPL requires only minimal fixturing changes to standard CMOS equipment, and no change to current state-of-the-art lithography. Eliminating the constraint of 2D planar device architecture enables a wide range of new interconnect topologies which could help reduce interconnect resistance/capacitance, and potentially improve performance.