Self-healing or self-assembling power systems that rely on local measurements for decision making can provide significant resilience benefits, but they also must include safeguards that prevent the system from self-assembling into an undesirable configuration. One potential undesirable configuration would be the formation of closed loops for which the system was not designed, a situation that can arise any time that two intentional-island systems can be connected in more than one place, e.g., if tie-line breakers are included in the self-assembling system. This paper discusses the unintentional loop formation problem in self-assembling systems and presents a method for mitigating it. This method involves calculating the correlation or the mean absolute error (MAE) between the two local frequency measurements made on either side of a line relay. The correlation and MAE between these frequencies changes significantly between the loop and non-loop cases, and this difference can be used for loop detection. This article presents and explains the method in detail, presents evidence that the method's underlying assumptions are valid, and demonstrates in PSCAD two implementations of the method. The paper concludes with a discussion of the strengths and weaknesses of the proposed method.
Due to their increased levels of reliability, meshed low-voltage (LV) grid and spot networks are common topologies for supplying power to dense urban areas and critical customers. Protection schemes for LV networks often use highly sensitive reverse current trip settings to detect faults in the medium-voltage system. As a result, interconnecting even low levels of distributed energy resources (DERs) can impact the reliability of the protection system and cause nuisance tripping. This work analyzes the possibility of modifying the reverse current relay trip settings to increase the DER hosting capacity of LV networks without impacting fault detection performance. The results suggest that adjusting relay settings can significantly increase DER hosting capacity on LV networks without adverse effects, and that existing guidance on connecting DERs to secondary networks, such as that contained in IEEE Std 1547-2018, could potentially be modified to allow higher DER deployment levels.
As part of the project “Designing Resilient Communities (DRC): A Consequence-Based Approach for Grid Investment,” funded by the United States (US) Department of Energy’s (DOE) Grid Modernization Laboratory Consortium (GMLC), Sandia National Laboratories (Sandia) is partnering with a variety of government, industry, and university participants to develop and test a framework for community resilience planning focused on modernization of the electric grid. This report provides a summary of the section of the project focused on hardware demonstration of “resilience nodes” concept.
Structural modularity is critical to solid-state transformer (SST) and solid-state power substation (SSPS) concepts, but operational aspects related to this modularity are not yet fully understood. Previous studies and demonstrations of modular power conversion systems assume identical module compositions, but dependence on module uniformity undercuts the value of the modular framework. In this project, a hierarchical control approach was developed for modular SSTs which achieves system-level objectives while ensuring equitable power sharing between nonuniform building block modules. This enables module replacements and upgrades which leverage circuit and device technology advancements to improve system-level performance. The functionality of the control approach is demonstrated in detailed time-domain simulations. Results of this project provide context and strategic direction for future LDRD projects focusing on technologies supporting the SST crosscut outcome of the resilient energy systems mission campaign.
Although there are increasing numbers of distributed energy resources (DERs) and microgrids being deployed, current IEEE and utility standards generally strictly limit their interconnection inside secondary networks. Secondary networks are low-voltage meshed (non-radial) distribution systems that create redundancy in the path from the main grid source to each load. This redundancy provides a high level of immunity to disruptions in the distribution system, and thus extremely high reliability of electric power service. There are two main types of secondary networks, called grid and spot secondary networks, both of which are used worldwide. In the future, primary networks in distribution systems that might include looped or meshed distribution systems at the primary-voltage (mediumvoltage) level may also become common as a means for improving distribution reliability and resilience. The objective of this multiyear project is to increase the adoption of microgrids in secondary networks and meshed distribution systems by developing novel protection schemes that allow for safe reliable operation of DERs in secondary networks. We will address these challenges by working with the appropriate stakeholders of secondary network operators, protection vendors, and standards committee. The outcomes of this project include: a) development and/or demonstration of candidate methods for enabling protection of secondary networks containing high levels of DER; b) development of modeling and testing tools for protection systems designed for use with secondary networks including DERs; and c) development of new industrial partnerships to facilitate widespread results dissemination and eventual commercialization of results as appropriate.
Over the past 50 years, the Renewable Energy Program at Sandia has advanced research in the field with a focus on three key goals; 1) reduce the cost, 2) improve resilience and reliability and, 3) decrease the regulatory burden of renewable energy. Sandia’s expertise, coupled with the Village of Questa’s expanding renewable energy portfolio, presents the opportunity to deploy the Labs’ deep science and engineering capabilities towards the energy goals of KCEC and the Village of Questa. Preliminary research efforts by Sandia technical staff has broadly identified early opportunities for further research, development, and demonstration in the emerging renewable energy segment of agrivoltaics. Agrivoltaics is an emerging and promising area of photovoltaics which entails land use considerations as well as concerns regarding landscape transformation, biodiversity, and ecosystem well-being. In recent years, agrivoltaics systems have been the subject of numerous studies due to their potential in the food-energy (and water) nexus. This document is a preliminary evaluation of the projects performance opportunities of agrivoltaics as a renewable energy technology strategy in the region of Questa, NM.
Increased penetration of Distributed Energy Resources and microgrids have fundamentally changed the operation al characteristics of Low Voltage (LV) network systems. Current LV network protection philosophy and practice are due for a significant re vamp to keep up with changing operating conditions. This workshop invites four of the major LV network users in the US to discuss the challenges they face today and the new technologies they have been experimenting with in light of this workshop discussion, use cases for further hardware-in-the-loop testing efforts are proposed to evaluate new LV network protection solutions.
Many Electric Power Systems (EPS) already include geographically dispersed photovoltaic (PV) systems. These PV systems may not be co-located with highest-priority loads and, thus, easily integrated into a microgrid; rather PV systems and priority loads may be far away from one another. Furthermore, because of the existing EPS configuration, non-critical loads between the distant PV and critical load(s) cannot be selectively disconnected. To achieve this, the proposed approach finds ideal switch locations by first defining the path between the critical load and a large PV system, then identifies all potential new switch locations along this path, and finally discovers switch locations for a particular budget by finding the ones the produce the lowest Loss of Load Probability (LOLP), which is when load exceed generation. Discovery of the switches with the lowest LOLP involves a Particle Swarm Optimization (PSO) implementation. The objective of the PSO is to minimize the microgird's LOLP. The approach assumes dynamic microgrid operations, where both the critical and non-critical loads are powered during the day and only the critical load at night. To evaluate the approach, this paper includes a case study that uses the topology and Advanced Metering Infrastructure (AMI) data from an actual EPS. For this example, the assessment found new switch locations that reduced the LOLP by up to 50% for two distant PV location scenarios.
Downtown low-voltage (LV) distribution networks are generally protected with network protectors that detect faults by restricting reverse power flow out of the network. This creates protection challenges for protecting the system as new smart grid technologies and distributed generation are installed. This report summarizes well-established methods for the control and protection of LV secondary network systems and spot networks, including operating features of network relays. Some current challenges and findings are presented from interviews with three utilities, PHI PEPCO, Oncor Energy Delivery, and Consolidated Edison Company of New York. Opportunities for technical exploration are presented with an assessment of the importance or value and the difficulty or cost. Finally, this leads to some recommendations for research to improve protection in secondary networks.
There are unique challenges associated with protection and self-healing of microgrids energized by multiple inverterbased distributed energy resources. In this study, prioritized undervoltage load shedding and undervoltage-supervised overcurrent (UVOC) for fault isolation are demonstrated using PSCAD. The PSCAD implementations of these relays are described in detail, and their operation in a self-healing microgrid is demonstrated.
This report describes a Late-Start LDRD project on a self-healing power systems (SHePS) concept called SHAZAM. SHAZAM is designed to solve difficult challenges associated with creation of self-assembling, self-networking microgrids without high-speed networked communications. The report describes the SHAZAM concept, outlines the development of modeling tools and infrastructure supported by the Late-Start LDRD, gives examples of simulation results obtained to date, and discusses conclusions and proposed future work.
Dynamic operations of electric power switches in microgrid mode allows for distributed photovoltaic (PV) systems to support a critical load and enable the transfer of electrical power to non-critical loads. Instead of relying on an expensive system that includes a constant generation source (e.g. fossil fuel based generators), this work assess the potential balance of load and PV generation to properly charge a critical load battery while also supporting non-critical loads during the day. This work assumes that the battery is sized to only support the critical load and that the PV at the critical load is undersized. To compensate for the limited power capacity, a battery charging algorithm predicts and defines battery demand throughout the day; a particle swarm optimization (PSO) scheme connects and disconnects switch sections inside a distribution system with the objective of minimizing the difference between load and generation. The PSO reconfiguration scheme allows for continuous operations of a critical load as well as inclusion of non-critical loads.
This article is the first in a two-part series on the influence of inverter-based resources (IBRs) s on microgrid protection. In part one, the focus is on microgrids deployed on radial circuits. This article discusses some of the challenges related to the protection of IBR-based microgrids and presents some ongoing research and solutions in the area. The different controls for IBRs are discussed to present how their short current signatures and dynamic response under faults impact microgrid protection. Recently, microgrids have gained much attention in the electric power industry due to their capability for improving power system reliability and resiliency, their impact on increasing the use of renewable resources, the reduced cost of distributed energy resource (DER) equipment, and the continuing evolution of applicable codes and standards.
Secondary networks are used to supply power to loads that require very high reliability and are in use around the world, particularly in dense urban downtown areas. The protection of secondary network systems poses unique challenges. The addition of distributed energy resources (DERs) to secondary networks can compound these challenges, and deployment of microgrids on secondary networks will create a new set of challenges and opportunities. This report discusses secondary networks and their protection, the challenges associated with interconnecting DERs to a secondary network, issues expected to be associated with creating microgrids on secondary networks, standards that deal with these challenges and issues, and suggestions for research and development foci that would yield new means for addressing these challenges.
This report details the test setup, process, and results for radiated susceptibility testing of multicrystalline silicon photovoltaic (PV) modules as part of the EMP-Resilient Electric Grid Grand Challenge Laboratory Directed Research and Development (LDRD) project at Sandia National Laboratories. Testing was conducted over October 10-17, 2019, where 8 photovoltaic modules were exposed to E1 transient pulses with peak field levels up to 100 kV/m. Modules were terminated in a resistive load representing connected components. State of health testing conducted via I-V curve tracing of the photovoltaic modules showed no observable loss of device function due to large electric field transients. Differential mode currents were measured on the order of 10's of amps for up to a microsecond following the radiated field pulse. Common mode currents took the form of a damped sinusoid with a maximum peak of 10's to 100's of amps with a resonance near 60 MHz.