Public-facing solar hosting capacity (HC) maps, which show the maximum amount of solar energy that can be installed at a location without adverse effects, have proven to be a key driver of solar soft cost reductions through a variety of pathways (e.g., streamlining interconnection, siting, and customer acquisition processes). However, current methods for generating HC maps require detailed grid models and time-consuming simulations that limit both their accuracy and scalability—today, only a handful out of almost 2,000 utilities provide these maps. This project developed and validated data-driven algorithms for calculating solar HC using data from AMI without the need of detailed grid models or simulations. The algorithms were validated on utility datasets and incorporated as an application into NRECA’s Open Modeling Framework (OMF.coop) for the over 260 coops and vendors throughout the US to use. The OMF is free and open-source for everyone.
Before residential photovoltaic (PV) systems are interconnected with the grid, various planning and impact studies are conducted on detailed models of the system to ensure safety and reliability are maintained. However, these model-based analyses can be time-consuming and error-prone, representing a potential bottleneck as the pace of PV installations accelerates. Data-driven tools and analyses provide an alternate pathway to supplement or replace their model-based counterparts. In this article, a data-driven algorithm is presented for assessing the thermal limitations of PV interconnections. Using input data from residential smart meters, and without any grid models or topology information, the algorithm can determine the nameplate capacity of the service transformer supplying those customers. The algorithm was tested on multiple datasets and predicted service transformer capacity with >98% accuracy, regardless of existing PV installations. This algorithm has various applications from model-free thermal impact analysis for hosting capacity studies to error detection and calibration of existing grid models.
Accurate distribution system models are becoming increasingly critical for grid modernization tasks, and inaccurate phase labels are one type of modeling error that can have broad impacts on analyses using the distribution system models. This work demonstrates a phase identification methodology that leverages advanced metering infrastructure (AMI) data and additional data streams from sensors (relays in this case) placed throughout the medium-voltage sector of distribution system feeders. Intuitive confidence metrics are employed to increase the credibility of the algorithm predictions and reduce the incidence of false-positive predictions. The method is first demonstrated on a synthetic dataset under known conditions for robustness testing with measurement noise, meter bias, and missing data. Then, four utility feeders are tested, and the algorithm’s predictions are proven to be accurate through field validation by the utility. Lastly, the ability of the method to increase the accuracy of simulated voltages using the corrected model compared to actual measured voltages is demonstrated through quasi-static time-series (QSTS) simulations. The proposed methodology is a good candidate for widespread implementation because it is accurate on both the synthetic and utility test cases and is robust to measurement noise and other issues.
Before residential photovoltaic (PV) systems are interconnected with the grid, various planning and impact studies are conducted on detailed models of the system to ensure safety and reliability are maintained. However, these model-based analyses can be time-consuming and error-prone, representing a potential bottleneck as the pace of PV installations accelerates. Data-driven tools and analyses provide an alternate pathway to supplement or replace their model-based counterparts. In this article, a data-driven algorithm is presented for assessing the thermal limitations of PV interconnections. Using input data from residential smart meters, and without any grid models or topology information, the algorithm can determine the nameplate capacity of the service transformer supplying those customers. The algorithm was tested on multiple datasets and predicted service transformer capacity with >98% accuracy, regardless of existing PV installations. This algorithm has various applications from model-free thermal impact analysis for hosting capacity studies to error detection and calibration of existing grid models.
The widespread adoption of residential solar PV requires distribution system studies to ensure the addition of solar PV at a customer location does not violate the system constraints, which can be referred to as locational hosting capacity (HC). These model-based analyses are prone to error due to their dependencies on the accuracy of the system information. Model-free approaches to estimate the solar PV hosting capacity for a customer can be a good alternative to this approach as their accuracies do not depend on detailed system information. In this paper, an Adaptive Boosting (AdaBoost) algorithm is deployed to utilize the statistical properties (mean, minimum, maximum, and standard deviation) of the customer's historical data (real power, reactive power, voltage) as inputs to estimate the voltage-constrained PV HC for the customer. A baseline comparison approach is also built that utilizes just the maximum voltage of the customer to predict PV HC. The results show that the ensemble-based AdaBoost algorithm outperformed the proposed baseline approach. The developed methods are also compared and validated by existing state-of-the-art model-free PV HC estimation methods.
High penetrations of residential solar PV can cause voltage issues on low-voltage (LV) secondary networks. Distribution utility planners often utilize model-based power flow solvers to address these voltage issues and accommodate more PV installations without disrupting the customers already connected to the system. These model-based results are computationally expensive and often prone to errors. In this paper, two novel deep learning-based model-free algorithms are proposed that can predict the change in voltages for PV installations without any inherent network information of the system. These algorithms will only use the real power (P), reactive power (Q), and voltage (V) data from Advanced Metering Infrastructure (AMI) to calculate the change in voltages for an additional PV installation for any customer location in the LV secondary network. Both algorithms are tested on three datasets of two feeders and compared to the conventional model-based methods and existing model-free methods. The proposed methods are also applied to estimate the locational PV hosting capacity for both feeders and have shown better accuracies compared to an existing model-free method. Results show that data filtering or pre-processing can improve the model performance if the testing data point exists in the training dataset used for that model.
Residential solar photovoltaic (PV) systems are interconnected with the distribution grid at low-voltage secondary network locations. However, computational models of these networks are often over-simplified or non-existent, which makes it challenging to determine the operational impacts of new PV installations at those locations. In this work, a model-free locational hosting capacity analysis algorithm is proposed that requires only smart meter measurements at a given location to calculate the maximum PV size that can be accommodated without exceeding voltage constraints. The proposed algorithm was evaluated on two different smart meter datasets measuring over 2,700 total customer locations and was compared against results obtained from conventional model-based methods for the same smart meter datasets. Compared to the model-based results, the model-free algorithm had a mean absolute error (MAE) of less than 0.30 kW, was equally sensitive to measurement noise, and required much less computation time.
Due to their increased levels of reliability, meshed low-voltage (LV) grid and spot networks are common topologies for supplying power to dense urban areas and critical customers. Protection schemes for LV networks often use highly sensitive reverse current trip settings to detect faults in the medium-voltage system. As a result, interconnecting even low levels of distributed energy resources (DERs) can impact the reliability of the protection system and cause nuisance tripping. This work analyzes the possibility of modifying the reverse current relay trip settings to increase the DER hosting capacity of LV networks without impacting fault detection performance. The results suggest that adjusting relay settings can significantly increase DER hosting capacity on LV networks without adverse effects, and that existing guidance on connecting DERs to secondary networks, such as that contained in IEEE Std 1547-2018, could potentially be modified to allow higher DER deployment levels.
Due to their increased levels of reliability, meshed low-voltage (LV) grid and spot networks are common topologies for supplying power to dense urban areas and critical customers. Protection schemes for LV networks often use highly sensitive reverse current trip settings to detect faults in the medium-voltage system. As a result, interconnecting even low levels of distributed energy resources (DERs) can impact the reliability of the protection system and cause nuisance tripping. This work analyzes the possibility of modifying the reverse current relay trip settings to increase the DER hosting capacity of LV networks without impacting fault detection performance. The results suggest that adjusting relay settings can significantly increase DER hosting capacity on LV networks without adverse effects, and that existing guidance on connecting DERs to secondary networks, such as that contained in IEEE Std 1547-2018, could potentially be modified to allow higher DER deployment levels.
The wide variety of inverter control settings for solar photovoltaics (PV) causes the accurate knowledge of these settings to be difficult to obtain in practice. This paper addresses the problem of determining inverter reactive power control settings from net load advanced metering infrastructure (AMI) data. The estimation is first cast as fitting parameterized control curves. We argue for an intuitive and practical approach to preprocess the AMI data, which exposes the setting to be extracted. We then develop a more general approach with a data-driven reactive power disaggregation algorithm, reframing the problem as a maximum likelihood estimation for the native load reactive power. These methods form the first approach for reconstructing reactive power control settings of solar PV inverters from net load data. The constrained curve fitting algorithm is tested on 701 loads with behind-the-meter (BTM) PV systems with identical control settings. The settings are accurately reconstructed with mean absolute percentage errors between 0.425% and 2.870%. The disaggregation-based approach is then tested on 451 loads with variable BTM PV control settings. Different configurations of this algorithm reconstruct the PV inverter reactive power timeseries with root mean squared errors between 0.173 and 0.198 kVAR.
Reno, Matthew J.; Blakely, Logan; Trevizan, Rodrigo D.; Pena, Bethany; Lave, Matt; Azzolini, Joseph A.; Yusuf, Jubair; Jones, Christian B.; Furlani Bastos, Alvaro; Chalamala, Rohit; Korkali, Mert; Sun, Chih-Che; Donadee, Jonathan; Stewart, Emma M.; Donde, Vaibhav; Peppanen, Jouni; Hernandez, Miguel; Deboever, Jeremiah; Rocha, Celso; Rylander, Matthew; Siratarnsophon, Piyapath; Grijalva, Santiago; Talkington, Samuel; Mason, Karl; Vejdan, Sadegh; Khan, Ahmad U.; Mbeleg, Jordan S.; Ashok, Kavya; Divan, Deepak; Li, Feng; Therrien, Francis; Jacques, Patrick; Rao, Vittal; Francis, Cody; Zaragoza, Nicholas; Nordy, David; Glass, Jim; Holman, Derek; Mannon, Tim; Pinney, David
This report summarizes the work performed under a project funded by U.S. DOE Solar Energy Technologies Office (SETO), including some updates from the previous report SAND2022-0215, to use grid edge measurements to calibrate distribution system models for improved planning and grid integration of solar PV. Several physics-based data-driven algorithms are developed to identify inaccuracies in models and to bring increased visibility into distribution system planning. This includes phase identification, secondary system topology and parameter estimation, meter-to-transformer pairing, medium-voltage reconfiguration detection, determination of regulator and capacitor settings, PV system detection, PV parameter and setting estimation, PV dynamic models, and improved load modeling. Each of the algorithms is tested using simulation data and demonstrated on real feeders with our utility partners. The final algorithms demonstrate the potential for future planning and operations of the electric power grid to be more automated and data-driven, with more granularity, higher accuracy, and more comprehensive visibility into the system.
Conservation voltage reduction (CVR) is a common technique used by utilities to strategically reduce demand during peak periods. As penetration levels of distributed generation (DG) continue to rise and advanced inverter capabilities become more common, it is unclear how the effectiveness of CVR will be impacted and how CVR interacts with advanced inverter functions. In this work, we investigated the mutual impacts of CVR and DG from photovoltaic (PV) systems (with and without autonomous Volt-VAR enabled). The analysis was conducted on an actual utility dataset, including a feeder model, measurement data from smart meters and intelligent reclosers, and metadata for more than 30 CVR events triggered by the utility over the year. The installed capacity of the modeled PV systems represented 66% of peak load, but reached instantaneous penetrations reached up to 2.5x the load consumption over the year. While the objectives of CVR and autonomous Volt-VAR are opposed to one another, this study found that their interactions were mostly inconsequential since the CVR events occurred when total PV output was low.
Distributed generation (DG) sources like photovoltaic (PV) systems with advanced inverters are able to perform grid-support functions, like autonomous Volt-VAR that attempts to mitigate voltage issues by injecting or consuming reactive power. However, the Volt-VAR function operates with VAR priority, meaning real power may be curtailed to provide additional reactive power support. Since some locations on the grid may be more prone to higher voltages than others, PV systems installed at those locations may be forced to curtail more power, adversely impacting the value of that PV system. Adaptive Volt-VAR (AVV) could be implemented as an alternative, whereby the Volt-VAR reference voltage changes over time, but this functionality has not been well-explored in the literature. In this work, the potential benefits and grid impacts of AVV were investigated using yearlong quasi-static time-series (QSTS) simulations. After testing a variety of allowable AVV settings, we found that even with aggressive settings AVV resulted in <0.01% real power curtailment and significantly reduced the reactive power support required from the PV inverter compared to conventional Volt-VAR but did not provide much mitigation for extreme voltage conditions. The reactive power support provided by AVV was injected to oppose large deviations in voltage (in either direction), indicating that it could be useful for other applications like reducing voltage flicker or minimizing interactions with other voltage regulating devices.
The increasing availability of advanced metering infrastructure (AMI) data has led to significant improvements in load modeling accuracy. However, since many AMI devices were installed to facilitate billing practices, few utilities record or store reactive power demand measurements from their AMI. When reactive power measurements are unavailable, simplifying assumptions are often applied for load modeling purposes, such as applying constant power factors to the loads. The objective of this work is to quantify the impact that reactive power load modeling practices can have on distribution system analysis, with a particular focus on evaluating the behaviors of distributed photovoltaic (PV) systems with advanced inverter capabilities. Quasi-static time-series simulations were conducted after applying a variety of reactive power load modeling approaches, and the results were compared to a baseline scenario in which real and reactive power measurements were available at all customer locations on the circuit. Overall, it was observed that applying constant power factors to loads can lead to significant errors when evaluating customer voltage profiles, but that performing per-phase time-series reactive power allocation can be utilized to reduce these errors by about 6x, on average, resulting in more accurate evaluations of advanced inverter functions.
The proper coordination of power system protective devices is essential for maintaining grid safety and reliability but requires precise knowledge of fault current contributions from generators like solar photovoltaic (PV) systems. PV inverter fault response is known to change with atmospheric conditions, grid conditions, and inverter control settings, but this time-varying behavior may not be fully captured by conventional static fault studies that are used to evaluate protection constraints in PV hosting capacity analyses. To address this knowledge gap, hosting capacity protection constraints were evaluated on a simplified test circuit using both a time-series fault analysis and a conventional static fault study approach. A PV fault contribution model was developed and utilized in the test circuit after being validated by hardware experiments under various irradiances, fault voltages, and advanced inverter control settings. While the results were comparable for certain protection constraints, the time-series fault study identified additional impacts that would not have been captured with the conventional static approach. Overall, while conducting full time-series fault studies may become prohibitively burdensome, these findings indicate that existing fault study practices may be improved by including additional test scenarios to better capture the time-varying impacts of PV on hosting capacity protection constraints.