Leguizamon, Samuel C.; Foster, Jeffrey C.; Greenlee, Andrew J.; Weitekamp, Raymond A.
Since the earliest investigations of olefin metathesis catalysis, light has been the choice for controlling the catalyst activity on demand. From the perspective of energy efficiency, temporal and spatial control, and selectivity, photochemistry is not only an attractive alternative to traditional thermal manufacturing techniques but also arguably a superior manifold for advanced applications like additive manufacturing (AM). In the last three decades, pioneering work in the field of ring-opening metathesis polymerization (ROMP) has broadened the scope of material properties achievable through AM, particularly using light as both an activating and deactivating stimulus. In this Perspective, we explore trends in photocontrolled ROMP systems with an emphasis on approaches to photoinduced activation and deactivation of metathesis catalysts. Recent work has yielded a myriad of commercial and synthetically accessible photosensitive catalyst systems, although comparatively little attention has been paid to achieving precise control over polymer morphology using light. Metal-free, photophysical, and living ROMP systems have also been relatively underexplored. To take fuller advantage of both the thermomechanical properties of ROMP polymers and the operational simplicity of photocontrol, clear directions for the field are to improve the reversibility of activation and deactivation strategies as well as to further develop photocontrolled approaches to tuning cross-link density and polymer tacticity.
The effective management of plastic waste streams to prevent plastic land and water pollution is a growing problem that is also one of the most important challenges in polymer science today. Polymer materials that are stable over their lifetime and can also be cheaply recycled or repurposed as desired could more easily be diverted from waste streams. However, this is difficult for most commodity plastics. It is especially difficult to conceive this with intractable, cross-linked polymers such as rubbers. In this work, we explore the utility of microencapsulated Grubbs’ catalysts for the in-situ depolymerization and reprocessing of polybutadiene (PB) rubber. Second-generation Hoveyda-Grubbs catalyst (HG2) contained within glassy thermoplastic microspheres can be dispersed in PB rubber below the microsphere’s glass transition temperature (Tg) without adverse depolymerization, evidenced by rubber with and without these microspheres obtaining similar shear storage moduli of ≈16 and ≈28 kPa, respectively. The thermoplastic’s Tg can be used to tune the depolymerization temperature, via release of HG2 into the rubber matrix. For example, using poly(lactic acid) (PLA) vs polysulfone results in an 85 and 162 °C depolymerization temperature, respectively. Liquefaction of rubber to a mixture of small molecules and oligomers is demonstrated using a 0.01 mol % catalyst loading using PLA as the encapsulant. At that same catalyst loading, depolymerization occurs to a greater extent in comparison to two ex-situ approaches, including a conventional solvent-assisted method, where it occurs at roughly twice the extent at each given catalyst loading. In addition, depolymerization of the microsphere-loaded rubbers was demonstrated for samples stored under nitrogen for 23 days. Lastly, we show that the depolymerized products can be reprocessed back into solid rubber with a shear storage modulus of ≈32 kPa. Thus, we envision that this approach could be used to recycle and reuse cross-linked rubbers at the end of their product lifetime.
Frontal polymerization involves the propagation of a thermally driven polymerization wave through a monomer solution to rapidly generate high-performance polymeric materials with little energy input. The balance between latent catalyst activation and sufficient reactivity to sustain a front can be difficult to achieve and often results in systems with poor storage lives. This is of particular concern for frontal ring-opening metathesis polymerization (FROMP) where gelation occurs within a single day of resin preparation due to the highly reactive nature of Grubbs-type catalysts. In this report we demonstrate the use of encapsulated catalysts to provide remarkable latency to frontal polymerization systems, specifically using the highly active dicyclopentadiene monomer system. Negligible differences were observed in the frontal velocities or thermomechanical properties of the resulting polymeric materials. FROMP systems with encapsulated catalyst particles are shown with storage lives exceeding 12 months and front rates that increase over a well-characterized 2 month period. Moreover, the modularity of this encapsulation method is demonstrated by encapsulating a platinum catalyst for the frontal polymerization of silicones by using hydrosilylation chemistry.
Recent studies on off-stoichiometric thermosets reveal unique viscoelastic behavior derived from increased free volume and physical interactions between chain ends. To understand structural characteristics arising from cure and its effect on properties, we developed a Monte Carlo model based on step-growth polymerization. Our model accurately predicted structure-property trends for a two-component system of EPON 828 (EPON) and ethylenediamine. A second epoxy monomer, D.E.R. 732 (DER), was investigated to modulate Tg. Binary mixtures of EPON and DER in off-stoichiometric, amine-rich formulations resulted in nonlinear evolution of thermomechanical properties with respect to initial formulation stoichiometry. Modifying our model with kinetic parameters allowing for differential epoxide/amine reaction kinetics only partially accounted for trends in Tg, suggesting that spatiotemporal contributions─not captured by our model─were significant determinants of material properties compared to polymer architecture for three-component systems. These findings underpin the importance of spatial awareness in modeling to inform the development of dynamic thermosets.
Recent progress in photoinitiated ring-opening metathesis polymerization (photoROMP) has enabled the lithographic production of patterned films from olefinic resins. Recently, we reported the use of a latent ruthenium catalyst (HeatMet) in combination with a photosensitizer (2-isopropylthioxanthone) to rapidly photopolymerize dicyclopentadiene (DCPD) formulations upon irradiation with UV light. While this prior work was limited in terms of catalyst and photosensitizer scope, a variety of alternative catalysts and photosensitizers are commercially available that could allow for tuning of thermomechanical properties, potlifes, activation rates, and irradiation wavelengths. Herein, 14 catalysts and 8 photosensitizers are surveyed for the photoROMP of DCPD and the structure-activity relationships of the catalysts examined. Properties relevant to stereolithography additive manufacturing (SLA AM)-potlife, irradiation dose required to gel, conversion-are characterized to develop catalyst and photosensitizer libraries to inform development of SLA AM resin systems. Two optimized catalyst/photosensitizer systems are demonstrated in the rapid SLA printing of complex, multidimensional pDCPD structures with microscale features under ambient conditions.
Solid state nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) spectroscopy and small-to wide-angle X-ray scattering (SWAXS) methods were used to characterize the heterogeneous dynamics and polymer domain structure in rubber modified thermoset materials containing the diglycidyl ether of bisphenol A (DGEBA) epoxy resin and a mixture of Jeffamine reactive rubber and 4,4-diaminodicyclohexylmethane (PACM) amine curing agent. The polymer chain dynamics and morphologies as a function of the PACM/Jeffamine ratio were determined. Using dipolar-filtered NMR experiments, the resulting networks are shown to be composed of mobile and rigid regions that are separated on nanometer length scales, along with a dynamically immobilized interface region. Proton NMR spin diffusion experiments measured the dimensions of the mobile phase to range between 9 and 66 nm and varied with the relative PACM concentration. Solid state 13C magic angle spinning NMR experiments show that the highly mobile phase is composed entirely of the dynamically flexible polyether chains of the Jeffamine rubber, the immobilized interface region is a mixture of DGEBA, PACM, and the Jeffamine rubber, with the PACM cross-linked to DGEBA predominantly residing in the rigid phase. The SWAXS results showed compositional nanophase separation spanning the 11–77 nm range. These measurements of the nanoscale compositional and dynamic heterogeneity provide molecular level insight into the very broad and controllable glass transition temperature distributions observed for these highly cross-linked polymer networks.
Once limited to chain-growth polymerizations, fine control over polymerization-induced phase separation (PIPS) has recently been demonstrated in rubber-toughened thermoset materials formed through step-growth polymerizations. The domain length scales of these thermoset materials can be elegantly tuned by utilizing a binary mixture of curing agents (CAs) that individually yield disparate morphologies. Importantly, varying the composition of the binary mixture affects characteristics of the materials such as glass transition temperature and tensile behavior. Here, we establish a full phase diagram of PIPS in a rubber-toughened epoxy system tuned by a binary CA mixture to provide a robust framework of phase behaviour. X-Ray scattering in situ and post-PIPS is employed to elucidate the PIPS mechanism whereby an initial polymerization-induced compositional fluctuation causes nanoscale phase separation of rubber and epoxy components prior to local chain crosslinking and potential macrophase separation. We further demonstrate the universality of this approach by alternatively employing binary epoxy or binary rubber mixtures to achieve broad variations in morphology and glass transitions.
The development of chemistry is reported to implement selective dual-wavelength olefin metathesis polymerization for continuous additive manufacturing (AM). A resin formulation based on dicyclopentadiene is produced using a latent olefin metathesis catalyst, various photosensitizers (PSs) and photobase generators (PBGs) to achieve efficient initiation at one wavelength (e.g., blue light) and fast catalyst decomposition and polymerization deactivation at a second (e.g., UV-light). This process enables 2D stereolithographic (SLA) printing, either using photomasks or patterned, collimated light. Importantly, the same process is readily adapted for 3D continuous AM, with printing rates of 36 mm h–1 for patterned light and up to 180 mm h–1 using un-patterned, high intensity light.
Polymerization-induced phase separation enables fine control over thermoset network morphologies, yielding heterogeneous structures with domain sizes tunable over 1-100 nm. However, the controlled chain-growth polymerization techniques exclusively employed to regulate the morphology at these length scales are unsuitable for a majority of thermoset materials typically formed through step-growth mechanisms. By varying the composition of a binary curing agent mixture in a classic rubber-toughened epoxy thermoset, where the two curing agents are selected based on disparate compatibility with the rubber, we demonstrate facile tunability over morphology through a single compositional parameter. Indeed, this method yields morphologies spanning the nano-scale to the macro-scale, controlled by the relative reactivities and thermodynamic compatibility of the network components. We further demonstrate a profound connection between chain dynamics and microstructure in these materials, with the tunable morphology enabling exquisite variations in glass transition. In addition, previously unattainable control over tensile mechanical properties is realized, including atypical increase of elongation at failure while maintaining the modulus and ultimate strength.