A High-Altitude Electromagnetic Pulse (HEMP) is a potential threat to the power grid. HEMP can couple to transmission lines and cables, causing significant overvoltages which can be harmful to line connected equipment. The effects of overvoltages on various types of power systems components need to be understood. HEMP effects on trip coils were tested and presented in this report. A high voltage pulser was built to replicate the induced voltage waveform from a HEMP. The pulser was used to test breaker trip coils with increasing pulse magnitudes ranging from 20 kV to 80 kV. The State-of-Health of each trip coils was measured via mechanical operation and impedance measurements before and after each insult to identify any damage or degradation to the trip coils. Dielectric breakdown was observed at the conductor leads during testing, causing the HEMP insult to be diverted to the grounded casing. However, the dielectric breakdown did not cause interference with regular device operation.
Direct coupling of early-time high-altitude electromagnetic pulse (HEMP) to substation control cables is simulated for cable layouts based on surveys of seven electrical substations in the United States. An analytic transmission line modeling code is used to estimate worst-case coupled current at the terminations of cable segments in or near the control shack. Where applicable, an induced voltage due to cable shield grounding is also estimated. Various configurations are simulated, including cables with different elevations, lengths, radii, and terminations. Plots of the coupled HEMP effects are given, and general relationships between these effects and the substations geometric and material parameters are highlighted and discussed.
This report describes broadband measurements of transmission-scale transformers typical in the electric power grid. This work was performed as part of the EMP Resilient Grid LDRD project at Sandia National Laboratories to generate circuit models that can be used for high-altitude electromagnetic pulse (HEMP) coupling simulations and response predictions. The objective of the work was to obtain characterization data of substation yard equipment across a frequency range relevant to HEMP. Vector network analyzer measurements up to 100 MHz were performed on two power transformers at ABB-Hitachi and a single ITEC potential transformer. Custom cable breakouts were designed to interface with the transformer terminals and provide ground connections to the chassis at the base of the transformer bushings. The three-phase terminals of the power transformers were measured as a common mode impedance using a parallel resistive splitter, and the single-phase terminals of the potential transformer were measured directly. A vector fitting algorithm was used to empirically fit circuit models to the resulting two-port networks and input impedances of the measured objects. Simplified circuit representations of the input impedances were also generated to assess the degree of precision needed for high-altitude electromagnetic pulse response predictions, which were performed in Sandia's XYCE circuit simulator platform. HEMP coupling simulations using the transformer models showed significant reduction in the voltage peak and broadening in the pulse width seen at the power transformer compared to the traveling wave voltage. This indicated the importance of the load condition when defining the coupled insult in an electric power substation. Simplified circuit models showed a similar voltage at the transformer with a smoothed waveform. The presence of potential transformers in the simulation did not significantly change the simulated voltage at the power transformer. Single-port input impedance models were also developed to define load conditions when transfer characteristics were not necessary.
An electro-magnetic pulse (EMP) event can induce large currents and voltages on electrical conductors such as electrical power transmission lines which span many kilometers and the shorter lines typically tens of meters in length used to monitor equipment controlling the power grid. The exact current and voltage induced on a conductor depends on many factors, such as line height, diameter and length as well as ground conductivity and the location of the EMP event relative to the conductor. The current work focus on the line location and orientation relative to the EMP source. A statistical, Monte-Carlo approach is used in sampling the line configuration and then calculating the induced current and voltage. Thousands of EMP events are simulated on the region of the Earth where the EMP event can couple to a given above-ground conductor and the resulting current and voltage is then calculated on that conductor. Through the many simulations, one can assemble statistics on the insult including the peak value, rise time and pulse width.
Determining the effectiveness of surge and pulse protection devices in the United States power grid against effects of a High-Altitude Electromagnetic Pulse (HEMP) is crucial in determining the present state of grid resilience. Transient Voltage Surge Suppressors (TVSS) are used to protect loads in substations from transient overvoltages. Designed to mitigate the effects of lightning, their response to a HEMP event is unknown and was determined. TVSSs were tested in two unique configurations using a pulser that generates pulses in the tens of nanoseconds scale to determine their protective capability as well as to determine their self-resilience against HEMP pulses. Testing concluded that TVSS devices adequately protect against microsecond scale pulses like lightning but do not protect against pulses resembling HEMP events. It suggests that TVSS devices should not be relied upon to mitigate the effects of HEMP pulses.
Sandia National Laboratories sponsored a three-year internally funded Laboratory Directed Research and Development (LDRD) effort to investigate the vulnerabilities and mitigations of a high-altitude electromagnetic pulse (HEMP) on the electric power grid. The research was focused on understanding the vulnerabilities and potential mitigations for components and systems at the high voltage transmission level. Results from the research included a broad array of subtopics, covered in twenty-three reports and papers, and which are highlighted in this executive summary report. These subtopics include high altitude electromagnetic pulse (HEMP) characterization, HEMP coupling analysis, system-wide effects, and mitigating technologies.
Electromagnetic pulse (EMP) coupling into electronic devices can be destructive to components potentially causing device malfunction or failure. A large electromagnetic field generated from the EMP can induce large voltages and currents in components. As such, the effects of EMP on different devices needs to be understood to elucidate the effect of EMP on potentially vulnerable systems. This report presents test results for small-scale residential DC to AC solar panel microinverters that were subjected to high voltage impulses and currents. The impulses were intended to emulate an EMP coupling event to the AC and DC sides of the microinverter. State-of-health measurements were conducted to characterize device performance before and after each test.
There are concerns about the effects of High-Altitude Electromagnetic Pulses (HEMP) on the electric power grid. Activities to date tested and analyzed vulnerability of digital protective relays (DPRs) used in power substations, but the effect of HEMP on the greater substation environment is not well known. This work establishes a method of testing the vulnerability of circuit breaker control and protective relay circuits to the radiated E1 pulse associated with HEMP based on coupling to the cables in a substation yard. Two DPRs from Schweitzer Engineering Laboratories, Inc. were independently tested. The test setup also included a typical cable in a substation yard with return plane to emulate the ground grid and other ground conductors near the yard cable, cabinetry housing the installed DPRs, station battery and battery charger, terminal block elements, and a breaker simulator to emulate a substation yard configuration. The DPRs were powered from the station battery and the transformer inputs energized with a three-phase source to maintain typical operating conditions during the tests. Vulnerability testing consisted of a conducted E1 pulse injected into the center of the yard cable of the DPR circuits. Current measurements on the yard cable and DPR inputs indicated significant attenuation of the conducted pulse arriving at the control house equipment from the emulated substation yard. This reduction was quantified with respect to the equivalent open-circuit voltage on the yard cable. No equipment damage or undesired operation occurred on the tested circuits for values below 180 kV, which is significantly higher than the anticipated coupling to a substation yard cable.
In a transmission line, we evaluate the coupling between a line and a tower above ground when the excitation is an El high-altitude electromagnetic pulse (HEMP). Our model focuses on capturing correctly the effect of the coupling on the peak of the HEMP induced current that propagates along the line. This assessment is necessary to accurately estimate the effect of the excitation on the systems and components of the power grid. This analysis is a step towards a quantitative evaluation of HEMP excitation on the power grid.
The electric power grid is one of the most critical infrastructures in the modern world, and the continued protection and resilience of this system from threats is of significant concern. One such set of threats is nanosecond-scale transient effects generated by high-altitude electromagnetic pulses, for which the effect on the power grid is still being studied. Lightning surge arresters serve as the current grid protection against fast transients but are designed and modeled for protection against lightning and switching transients. Surge arrester response to faster transients is not well known. This work defines a scalable metal-oxide surge arrester model with specific consideration to frequencies attributed to fast transient overvoltages from electromagnetic pulses. Measurements using vector network analyzer sweeps at low and high bias as well as high-voltage I-V curve traces are presented to define arrester behavior and to parameterize it from measurement data. The proposed model is compared to the standard IEEE model for lightning arresters in this paper. Furthermore, model parameters are defined by scalable terms to be easily implemented for transmission-level devices. The scalable model enables enhanced assessment of protection levels and grid susceptibility against fast transients.
High-altitude electromagnetic pulses pose an unknown risk to the electric power grid, and the vulnerabilities will continue to arise as the structure and needs of the grid change. This is especially true with the increasing prevalence of renewable energy sources. This work investigates the vulnerability of photovoltaic modules to E1-like radiated environments with maximum field levels exceeding 100 kV/m. State of health checks via I-V curve trace measurements and physical inspection indicated no readily observable damage or degradation of the module behavior after multiple field exposures. Any variation in I-V curve data was attributable to ambient conditions at the time of measurement and was reflected in similar measurements of the experimental control. Follow-up measurements with a calibrated light source showed that all modules aligned with the experimental control and exceeding the manufacturer ratings for fill factor and efficiency, implying that no damage was incurred from field exposure. Coupled current measurements were also performed over the course of testing, showing a damped sine response in common mode and double exponential response in differential mode. The responses were observed to scale with incident field and were dependent on the module orientation.
High-altitude electromagnetic pulses pose an unknown risk to the electric power grid, and the vulnerabilities will continue to arise as the structure and needs of the grid change. This is especially true with the increasing prevalence of renewable energy sources. This work investigates the vulnerability of photovoltaic modules to E1-like radiated environments with maximum field levels exceeding 100 kV/m. State of health checks via I-V curve trace measurements and physical inspection indicated no readily observable damage or degradation of the module behavior after multiple field exposures. Any variation in I-V curve data was attributable to ambient conditions at the time of measurement and was reflected in similar measurements of the experimental control. Follow-up measurements with a calibrated light source showed that all modules aligned with the experimental control and exceeding the manufacturer ratings for fill factor and efficiency, implying that no damage was incurred from field exposure. Coupled current measurements were also performed over the course of testing, showing a damped sine response in common mode and double exponential response in differential mode. The responses were observed to scale with incident field and were dependent on the module orientation.
Impacts of a high-altitude electromagnetic pulse (HEMP) on the power grid are a growing concern due to the increased reliance on the power grid. A critical area of research is quantifying power system equipment response to HEMP since this is not known in general. Substation site surveys were performed at seven high voltage substations across the United States to gather substation layout and construction details pertinent to HEMP coupling calculations and component vulnerability assessments. The primary objective for the survey was to gather information on cable layouts and cable construction within substations. Additional information was also gathered on equipment present within the substations and control house layouts. This report provides information gathered from the substation surveys.
This report details the test setup, process, and results for radiated susceptibility testing of multicrystalline silicon photovoltaic (PV) modules as part of the EMP-Resilient Electric Grid Grand Challenge Laboratory Directed Research and Development (LDRD) project at Sandia National Laboratories. Testing was conducted over October 10-17, 2019, where 8 photovoltaic modules were exposed to E1 transient pulses with peak field levels up to 100 kV/m. Modules were terminated in a resistive load representing connected components. State of health testing conducted via I-V curve tracing of the photovoltaic modules showed no observable loss of device function due to large electric field transients. Differential mode currents were measured on the order of 10's of amps for up to a microsecond following the radiated field pulse. Common mode currents took the form of a damped sinusoid with a maximum peak of 10's to 100's of amps with a resonance near 60 MHz.
Radiated power calculation approaches for practical scenarios of incomplete high- density interface characterization information and incomplete incident power information are presented. The suggested approaches build upon a method that characterizes power losses through the definition of power loss constant matrices. Potential radiated power estimates include using total power loss information, partial radiated power loss information, worst case analysis, and statistical bounding analysis. A method is also proposed to calculate radiated power when incident power information is not fully known for non-periodic signals at the interface. Incident data signals are modeled from a two-state Markov chain where bit state probabilities are derived. The total spectrum for windowed signals is postulated as the superposition of spectra from individual pulses in a data sequence. Statistical bounding methods are proposed as a basis for the radiated power calculation due to the statistical calculation complexity to find a radiated power probability density function.
In this study, we characterized and quantified the behavior of Sandia National Laboratories' electromagnetic reverberation chamber owned by department 1353. The primary purpose of the chamber is to measure the response of a test object to electromagnetic stimuli. The primary chamber application is qualification of nuclear weapons systems and components for the nuclear weapon qualification programs. National Nuclear Security Administration (NNSA) requires a comprehensive understanding of any measurement used to qualify a nuclear weapon. Understanding includes the accuracy of every measurement used to qualify the weapon. Knowing the uncertainty of any measurement gives the information needed to estimate boundaries and tolerances of the measurement. By proper application of these measurement tolerances, weapon qualification programs can comply with uncertainty requirements. This document reports our findings. Weapons Systems Engineering Assessment Technology (WSEAT) commissioned this effort to provide support to Nuclear Weapons qualification in accordance with Realize Product Sub System (RPSS). Motivation for this effort stems from four qualification programs: B61 LEP, W88 ALT370, W80-4 LEP, and the Mk21 fuze program.