The additive manufacture of compositionally graded Al/Cu parts by laser engineered net shaping (LENS) is demonstrated. The use of a blue light build laser enabled deposition on a Cu substrate. The thermal gradient and rapid solidification inherent to selective laser melting enabled mass transport of Cu up to 4 mm from a Cu substrate through a pure Al deposition, providing a means of producing gradients with finer step sizes than the printed layer thicknesses. Divorcing gradient continuity from layer or particle size makes LENS a potentially enabling technology for the manufacture of graded density impactors for ramp compression experiments. Printing graded structures with pure Al, however, was prevented by the growth of Al2Cu3 dendrites and acicular grains amid a matrix of Al2Cu. A combination of adding TiB2 grain refining powder and actively varying print layer composition suppressed the dendritic growth mode and produced an equiaxed microstructure in a compositionally graded part. Material phase was characterized for crystal structure and nanoindentation hardness to enable a discussion of phase evolution in the rapidly solidifying melt pool of a LENS print.
Density-functional theory (DFT) is used to identify phase-equilibria in multi-principal-element and high-entropy alloys (MPEAs/HEAs), including duplex-phase and eutectic microstructures. A combination of composition-dependent formation energy and electronic-structure-based ordering parameters were used to identify a transition from FCC to BCC favoring mixtures, and these predictions experimentally validated in the Al-Co-Cr-Cu-Fe-Ni system. A sharp crossover in lattice structure and dual-phase stability as a function of composition were predicted via DFT and validated experimentally. The impact of solidification kinetics and thermodynamic stability was explored experimentally using a range of techniques, from slow (castings) to rapid (laser remelting), which showed a decoupling of phase fraction from thermal history, i.e., phase fraction was found to be solidification rate-independent, enabling tuning of a multi-modal cell and grain size ranging from nanoscale through macroscale. Strength and ductility tradeoffs for select processing parameters were investigated via uniaxial tension and small-punch testing on specimens manufactured via powder-based additive manufacturing (directed-energy deposition). This work establishes a pathway for design and optimization of next-generation multiphase superalloys via tailoring of structural and chemical ordering in concentrated solid solutions.
Additive manufacturing has ushered in a new paradigm of bottom-up materials-by-design of spatially non-uniform materials. Functionally graded materials have locally tailored compositions to provide optimized global properties and performance. In this letter, we propose an opportunity for the application of graded magnetic materials as lens elements for charged particle optics. A Hiperco50/Hymu80 (FeCo-2 V/Fe-80Ni-5Mo) graded magnetic alloy was successfully additively manufactured via Laser Directed Energy Deposition with spatially varying magnetic properties. The compositional gradient is then applied using computational simulations to demonstrate how a tailored material can enhance the magnetic performance of a critical, image-forming component of a transmission electron microscope.
Directed energy deposition (DED) is an attractive additive manufacturing (AM) process for large structural components. The rapid solidification and layer-by-layer process associated with DED results in non-ideal microstructures, such as large grains with strong crystallographic textures. These non-ideal microstructures can lead to severe anisotropy in the mechanical properties. Despite these challenges, DED has been identified as a potential solution for the manufacturing of near net shape Ti-6Al-4V preforms, replacing lost casting and forging capabilities. Two popular wire-based directed energy deposition (W-DED) processes were considered for the manufacturing of Ti-6Al-4V with assessments on their respective metallurgical and mechanical properties, as compared to a conventionally processed material. The two W-DED processes explored were wire arc additive manufacturing (WAAM) and electron beam additive manufacturing (EBAM). High throughput inspection and tensile testing procedures were utilized to generate statistically relevant data sets related to each process and sample orientation. The 2 AM technologies produced material with remarkably different microstructures and mechanical properties. Results revealed key differences in strength and ductility for the two disparate processes which were found to be related to differences in the metallurgical properties.
Kustas, Andrew B.; Mann, James B.; Trumble, Kevin P.; Chandrasekar, Srinivasan
Soft magnetic Fe-Si alloys (electrical steels) possess exceptional functional properties such as high permeability, low coercivity, and low core loss, which generally improve with increasing Si content in the alloy. However, Fe-Si alloys containing > 3.5 wt% Si are also characterized by prohibitively low workability and poor ductility that have prevented their efficient commercial production in sheet form by rolling. This has limited their use for improving efficiency of motors and transformers. In this study, hybrid cutting-extrusion (HCE) is used as a single-step thermomechanical processing method to produce continuous Fe-Si alloy sheet with high Si compositions of 4 wt% to 6.5 wt%. HCE sheet is shown to have a homogeneous annealed grain structure and simple-shear crystallographic textures. By controlling the HCE deformation path, varied crystallographic shear textures are created in the sheet. Quasi-static magnetic properties of the HCE sheet are evaluated to decouple the effects of sheet texture and Si composition on resultant permeability and coercivity properties. The results suggest that HCE, with suitable process scaling, is a viable route for production of high-Si content electrical steel sheet for next-generation motors and transformers.
Mann, James B.; Mohanty, Debapriya P.; Kustas, Andrew B.; Stiven Puentes Rodriguez, B.; Issahaq, Mohammed N.; Udupa, Anirudh; Sugihara, Tatsuya; Trumble, Kevin P.; M'Saoubi, Rachid; Chandrasekar, Srinivasan
Machining-based deformation processing is used to produce metal foil and flat wire (strip) with suitable properties and quality for electrical power and renewable energy applications. In contrast to conventional multistage rolling, the strip is produced in a single-step and with much less process energy. Examples are presented from metal systems of varied workability, and strip product scale in terms of size and production rate. By utilizing the large-strain deformation intrinsic to cutting, bulk strip with ultrafine-grained microstructure, and crystallographic shear-texture favourable for formability, are achieved. Implications for production of commercial strip for electric motor applications and battery electrodes are discussed.
Saville, Alec I.; Benzing, Jake T.; Vogel, Sven C.; Buckner, Jessica L.; Donohoue, Collin; Kustas, Andrew B.; Creuziger, Adam; Clarke, Kester D.; Clarke, Amy J.
Metallic additive manufacturing (AM) provides a customizable and tailorable manufacturing process for new engineering designs and technologies. The greatest challenge currently facing metallic AM is maintaining control of microstructural evolution during solidification and any solid state phase transformations during the build process. Ti-6Al-4V has been extensively surveyed in this regard, with the potential solid state and solidification microstructures explored at length. This work evaluates the applicability of previously determined crystallographic markers of microstructural condition observed in electron beam melting powder bed fusion (PBF-EB) builds of Ti-6Al-4V in a directed energy deposition (DED) build process. The aim of this effort is to elucidate whether or not these specific crystallographic textures are useful tools for indicating microstructural conditions in AM variants beyond PBF-EB. Parent β-Ti grain size was determined to be directly related to α-Ti textures in the DED build process, and the solid state microstructural condition could be inferred from the intensity of specific α-Ti orientations. Qualitative trends on the as-solidified β-Ti grain size were also determined to be related to the presence of a fiber texture, and proposed as a marker for as-solidified grain size in any cubic metal melted by AM. Analysis of the DED Ti-6Al-4V build also demonstrated a near complete fracture of the build volume, suspected to originate from accumulated thermal stresses in the solid state. Crack propagation was found to only appreciably occur in regions of slow cooling with large α+β colonies. Schmid factors for the basal and prismatic α-Ti systems explained the observed crack pathway, including slower bifurcation in colonies with lower Schmid factors of both slip systems. Colony morphologies and localized equiaxed β-Ti solidification were also found to originate from build pauses during production and uneven heating of the build edges during deposition. Tailoring of DED Ti-6Al-4V microstructures with the insight gained here is proposed, along with cautionary insight on preventing unplanned build pauses to maintain an informed and controlled thermal environment for microstructural control.
In this study, we experimentally investigate the high stain rate and spall behavior of Cantor high-entropy alloy (HEA), CoCrFeMnNi. First, the Hugoniot equations of state (EOS) for the samples are determined using laser-driven CoCrFeMnNi flyers launched into known Lithium Fluoride (LiF) windows. Photon Doppler Velocimetry (PDV) recordings of the velocity profiles find the EOS coefficients using an impedance mismatch technique. Following this set of measurements, laser-driven aluminum flyer plates are accelerated to velocities of 0.5–1.0 km/s using a high-energy pulse laser. Upon impact with CoCrFeMnNi samples, the shock response is found through PDV measurements of the free surface velocities. From this second set of measurements, the spall strength of the alloy is found for pressures up to 5 GPa and strain rates in excess of 106 s−1. Further analysis of the failure mechanisms behind the spallation is conducted using fractography revealing the occurrence of ductile fracture at voids presumed to be caused by chromium oxide deposits created during the manufacturing process.
High‐Entropy Alloys (HEAs) are proposed as materials for a variety of extreme environments, including both fission and fusion radiation applications. To withstand these harsh environments, materials processing must be tailored to their given application, now achieved through additive manufacturing processes. However, radiation application opportunities remain limited due to an incomplete understanding of the effects of irradiation on HEA performance. In this letter, we investigate the response of additively manufactured refractory high‐entropy alloys (RHEAs) to helium (He) ion bombardment. Through analytical microscopy studies, we show the interplay between the alloy composition and the He bubble size and density to demonstrate how increasing the compositional complexity can limit the He bubble effects, but care must be taken in selecting the appropriate constituent elements.
Soft-magnetic alloys exhibit exceptional functional properties that are beneficial for a variety of electromagnetic applications. These alloys are conventionally manufactured into sheet or bar forms using well-established insgot metallurgy practices that involve hot- and cold-working steps. However, recent developments in process metallurgy have unlocked opportunities to directly produce bulk soft-magnetic alloys with improved, and often tailorable, structure–property relationships that are unachievable conventionally. The emergence of unconventional manufacturing routes for soft-magnetic alloys is largely motivated by the need to improve the energy efficiency of electromagnetic devices. In this review, literature that details emerging manufacturing approaches for soft-magnetic alloys is overviewed. This review covers (1) severe plastic deformation, (2) recent advances in melt spinning, (3) powder-based methods, and (4) additive manufacturing. These methods are discussed in comparison with conventional rolling and bar processing. Perspectives and recommended future research directions are also discussed.
Refractory complex concentrated alloys are an emerging class of materials that attracts attention due to their stability and performance at high temperatures. In this study, we investigate the variations in the mechanical and thermal properties across a broad compositional space for the refractory MoNbTaTi quaternary using high-throughput ab-initio calculations and experimental characterization. For all the properties surveyed, we note a good agreement between our modeling predictions and the experimentally measured values. We reveal the particular role of molybdenum (Mo) to achieve high strength when in high concentration. We trace the origin of this phenomenon to a shift from metallic to covalent bonding when the Mo content is increased. Additionally, a mechanistic, dislocation-based description of the yield strength further explains such high strength due to a combination of high bulk and shear moduli, accompanied by the relatively small size of the Mo atom compared to the other atoms in the alloy. Our analysis of the thermodynamics properties shows that regardless of the composition, this class of quaternary alloys shows good stability and low sensitivity to temperature. Taken together, these results pave the way for the design of new high-performance refractory alloys beyond the equimolar composition found in high-entropy alloys.
Bai, Xiaolong; Kustas, Andrew B.; Mann, James B.; Chandrasekar, Srinivasan; Trumble, Kevin P.
Shear-based deformation processing by hybrid cutting-extrusion and free machining are used to make continuous strip, of thickness up to one millimeter, from low-workability AA6013-T6 in a single deformation step. The intense shear can impose effective strains as large as 2 in the strip without pre-heating of the workpiece. The creation of strip in a single step is facilitated by three factors inherent to the cutting deformation zone: highly confined shear deformation, in situ plastic deformation-induced heating and high hydrostatic pressure. The hybrid cutting-extrusion, which employs a second die located across from the primary cutting tool to constrain the chip geometry, is found to produce strip with smooth surfaces (Sa < 0.4 μm) that is similar to cold-rolled strip. The strips show an elongated grain microstructure that is inclined to the strip surfaces – a shear texture – that is quite different from rolled sheet. Furthermore, this shear texture (inclination) angle is determined by the deformation path. Through control of the deformation parameters such as strain and temperature, a range of microstructures and strengths could be achieved in the strip. When the cutting-based deformation was done at room temperature, without workpiece pre-heating, the starting T6 material was further strengthened by as much as 30% in a single step. In elevated-temperature cutting-extrusion, dynamic recrystallization was observed, resulting in a refined grain size in the strip. Implications for deformation processing of age-hardenable Al alloys into sheet form, and microstructure control therein, are discussed.
Laser beam directed energy deposition has become an increasingly popular advanced manufacturing technique for materials discovery as a result of the in situ alloying capability. In this study, we leverage an additive manufacturing enabled high throughput materials discovery approach to explore the composition space of a graded Wx(CoCrFeMnNi)100−x sample spanning 0 ≤ x ≤ 21 at%. In addition to microstructural and mechanical characterization, synchrotron high speed x-ray computer aided tomography was conducted on a W20(CoCrFeMnNi)80 composition to visualize melting dynamics, powder-laser interactions, and remelting effects of previously consolidated material. Results reveal the formation of the Fe7W6 intermetallic phase at W concentrations> 6 at%, despite the high configurational entropy. Unincorporated W particles also occurred at W concentrations> 10 at% accompanied by a dissolution band of Fe7W6 at the W/matrix interface and hardness values greater than 400 HV. The primary strengthening mechanism is attributed to the reinforcement of the Fe7W6 and W phases as a metal matrix composite. The in situ high speed x-ray imaging during remelting showed that an additional laser pass did not promote further mixing of the Fe7W6 or W phases suggesting that, despite the dissolution of the W into the Fe7W6 phase being thermodynamically favored, it is kinetically limited by the thickness/diffusivity of the intermetallic phase, and the rapid solidification of the laser-based process.
The mechanical performance of an Fe-Co intermetallic alloy processed by laser powder bed fusion (L-PBF) and laser directed energy deposition (L-DED) additive manufacturing is compared. L-PBF material was characterized by high strength (500–550 MPa) and high ductility (35%) in tension, corresponding to a ~250% increase in strength and an order-of-magnitude improvement in ductility relative to conventional material. Conversely, L-DED material exhibited similarly poor tensile properties to the conventional wrought alloy, with low strength (200–300 MPa) and low ductility (0–2.7%). The disparity in properties between L-PBF and L-DED material is discussed in the context of the fundamental differences between manufacturing methods.
In this work, scratch and nanoindentation testing was used to determine hardness, fracture toughness, strain rate sensitivity, and activation volumes on additively manufactured graded and uniform Ni-Nb bulk specimens. Characterization showed the presence of a two phase system consisting of Ni3Nb and Ni6Nb7 intermetallics. Intermetallics were multimodal in nature, having grain and cell sizes spanning from a few nanometers to 10s of micrometers. The unique microstructure resulted in impressively high hardness, up to 20 GPa in the case of the compositionally graded sample. AM methods with surface deformation techniques are a useful way to rapidly probe material properties and alloy composition space.
In this work, scratch and nanoindentation testing was used to determine hardness, fracture toughness, strain rate sensitivity, and activation volumes on additively manufactured graded and uniform Ni-Nb bulk specimens. Characterization showed the presence of a two phase system consisting of Ni3Nb and Ni6Nb7 intermetallics. Intermetallics were multimodal in nature, having grain and cell sizes spanning from a few nanometers to 10s of micrometers. The unique microstructure resulted in impressively high hardness, up to 20 GPa in the case of the compositionally graded sample. AM methods with surface deformation techniques are a useful way to rapidly probe material properties and alloy composition space.
We present evidence of inverse Hall-Petch behavior for a single-phase high entropy alloy (CoCrFeMnNi) in ultra-high vacuum and show that it is associated with low friction coefficients (~0.3). Grain size measurements by STEM validate a recently proposed dynamic amorphization model that accurately predicts grain size-dependent shear strength in the inverse Hall-Petch regime. Wear rates in the initially soft (coarse grained) material were shown to be remarkably low (~10–6 mm3/N-m), the lowest for any HEA tested in an inert environment where oxidation and the formation of mixed metal-oxide films is mitigated. The combined high wear resistance and low friction are linked to the formation of an ultra-nanocrystalline near-surface layer. The dynamic amorphization model was also used to predict an average high angle grain boundary energy (0.87 J/m2). This value was used to explain cavitation-induced nanoporosity found in the highly deformed surface layer, a phenomenon that has been linked to superplasticity.
The potential advantages of AM (e.g. weight reduction, novel geometries) are well understood within a systems context. However, adoption of AM at the system level has been slow due to the relative uncertainty in the final material properties, which leaves capabilities and/or performance gains unrealized. Utilizing remelt strategies it may be possible to expand the available process window to provide densities and microstructures beyond what is capable with standard scan strategies. This work explored remelting strategies for 316L stainless steel to tailor grain size and increase density. Twelve scan strategies were explored experimentally and computationally to understand the limitations of remelt strategies and the robustness of the current simulation package. Results show tailoring of grain size, density, and texture is achievable through remelting and several key lessons learned were made to improve the texture evaluation through simulation.
Additive Manufacturing (AM) presents unprecedented opportunities to enable design freedom in parts that are unachievable via conventional manufacturing. However, AM-processed components generally lack the necessary performance metrics for widespread commercial adoption. We present a novel AM processing and design approach using removable heat sink artifacts to tailor the mechanical properties of traditionally low strength and low ductility alloys. The design approach is demonstrated with the Fe-50 at.% Co alloy, as a model material of interest for electromagnetic applications. AM-processed components exhibited unprecedented performance, with a 300 % increase in strength and an order-of-magnitude improvement in ductility relative to conventional wrought material. These results are discussed in the context of product performance, production yield, and manufacturing implications toward enabling the design and processing of high-performance, next-generation components, and alloys.
Refractory High Entropy Alloys (RHEAs) and Refractory Complex Concentrated Alloys (RCCAs) are high-temperature structural alloys ideally suited for use in harsh environments. While these alloys have shown promising structural properties at high temperatures that exceed the practical limits of conventional alloys, such as Ni-based superalloys, exploration of the complex phase-space of these materials remains a significant challenge. We report on a high-throughput alloy processing and characterization methodology, leveraging laser-based metal additive manufacturing (AM) and mechanical testing techniques, to enable rapid exploration of RHEAs/RCCAs. We utilized in situ alloying and compositional grading, unique to AM processing, to rapidly-produce RHEAs/RCCAs using readily available and inexpensive commercial elemental powders. We demonstrate this approach with the MoNbTaW alloy system, as a model material known for having exceptionally high strength at elevated temperature when processed using conventional methods (e.g., casting). Microstructure analysis, chemical composition, and strain rate dependent hardness of AM-processed material are presented and discussed in the context of understanding the structure-properties relationships of RHEAs/RCCAs.
Soft ferromagnetic alloys are often utilized in electromagnetic applications due to their desirable magnetic properties. In support of these applications, the ferromagnetic alloys are also required to bear mechanical load under various loading and environmental conditions. In this study, a Fe–49Co–2V alloy was dynamically characterized in tension with a Kolsky tension bar and a Drop–Hopkinson bar at various strain rates and temperatures. Dynamic tensile stress–strain curves of the Fe–49Co–2V alloy were obtained at strain rates ranging from 40 to 230 s−1 and temperatures from − 100 to 100 °C. All dynamic tensile stress–strain curves exhibited an initial linear elastic response to an upper yield followed by Lüders band response and then a nearly linear work-hardening behavior. The yield strength of this material was found to be sensitive to both strain rate and temperature, whereas the hardening rate was independent of strain rate or temperature. The Fe–49Co–2V alloy exhibited a feature of brittle fracture in tension under dynamic loading with no necking being observed.
Equal channel angular extrusion (ECAE) of 49Fe-49Co-2V, also known as Hiperco® 50A or Permendur-2V, greatly improves the strength and ductility of this alloy, while sacrificing soft magnetic performance. In this work, ECAE Hiperco specimens were subjected to post-ECAE annealing in order to improve soft magnetic properties. The microstructure, mechanical properties, and magnetic performance are summarized in this study. Annealing begins above 650°C and a steep decline in yield strength is observed for heat treatments between 700 and 840°C due to grain growth and the Hall-Petch effect, although some strength benefit is still observed in fully annealed ECAE material compared to conventionally processed bar. Soft magnetic properties were assessed through B-H hysteresis curves from which coercivity (Hc) values were extracted. Hc decreases rapidly with annealing above 650°C as well, i.e. improved soft magnetic behavior. The observed trend is attributed to annealing and grain growth in this temperature regime, which facilitates magnetic domain wall movement. The coercivity vs. grain size results generally follow the trend predicted in the literature. The magnetic behavior of annealed ECAE material compares favorably to conventional bar, possibly due to mild crystallographic texturing which enhances properties in the post-ECAE annealed material. Overall, this study highlights a definitive tradeoff between mechanical and magnetic properties brought about by post-ECAE annealing and grain growth.
Exposure testing was performed on CoCrFeMnNi equiatomic high entropy alloy (HEA) produced via directed energy deposition additive manufacturing in NaNO3-KNO3 (60-40 wt%) molten salt at 500 °C for 50 h to evaluate the corrosion performance and oxide film chemistry of the HEA. Potentiodynamic electrochemical corrosion testing, scanning electron microscopy, focused ion beam milling coupled with energy dispersive spectroscopy, Raman spectroscopy, X-ray diffraction, X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy, and inductively coupled plasma optical emission spectroscopy were used to analyze the corrosion behavior and chemistry of the HEA/nitrate molten salt system. The CoCrFeMnNi HEA exhibited a higher passive current density during potentiodynamic polarization testing than steel alloys SS316L and 4130 and the high-Ni alloy 800 H in identical conditions. The oxide film was primarily composed of a (Mn,Co,Ni)Fe2O4 spinel with a vertical plate-like morphology at the surface. Cr and Ni were found to be totally depleted at the outer surface of the oxide and dissolved in high concentrations in the molten salt. While Cr was expected to dissolve into the molten salt, the high concentration of dissolved Ni has not been observed with traditional alloys, suggesting that Ni is less stable in the spinel when Mn and Co are present.