Stangebye, Sandra S.; Lei, Changhui L.; Kinghorn, Aubri K.; robertson, ian m.; Kacher, Josh K.; Hattar, Khalid M.
We report the dynamics of the gold–silicon eutectic reaction in limited dimensions were studied using in situ transmission electron microscopy and scanning transmission electron microscopy heating experiments. The phase transformation, viewed in both plan-view and cross-section of the film, occurs through a complex combination of dislocation and grain boundary motion and diffusion of silicon along gold grain boundaries, which results in a dramatic change in the microstructure of the film. The conversion observed in cross-section shows that the eutectic mixture forms at the Au–Si interface and proceeds into the Au film at a discontinuous growth rate. This complex process can lead to a variety of microstructures depending on sample geometry, heating temperature, and the ratio of gold to silicon which was found to have the largest impact on the eutectic microstructure. The eutectic morphology varied from dendrites to hollow rectangular structures to Au–Si eutectic agglomerates with increasing silicon to gold ratio.
Pfeifer, Thomas W.; Tomko, John A.; Hoglund, Eric H.; Scott, Ethan A.; Hattar, Khalid M.; Huynh, Kenny H.; Liao, Michael L.; Goorsky, Mark G.; Hopkins, Patrick E.
The thermal properties of semiconductors following exposure to ion irradiation are of great interest for the cooling of electronic devices; however, gradients in composition and structure due to irradiation often make the measurement difficult. Furthermore, the nature of spatial variations in thermal resistances due to spatially varying ion irradiation damage is not well understood. In this work, we develop an advancement in the analysis of time-domain thermoreflectance to account for spatially varying thermal conductivity in a material resulting from a spatial distribution of defects. We then use this method to measure the near-surface (≲1 μm) thermal conductivity of silicon wafers irradiated with Kr+ ions, which has an approximate Gaussian distribution centered 260 nm into the sample. Our numerical analysis presented here allows for the spatial gradient of thermal conductivity to be extracted via what is fundamentally a volumetric measurement technique. We validate our findings via transmission electron microscopy, which is able to confirm the spatial variation of the sub-surface silicon structure, and provide additional insight into the local structure resulting from the effects of ion bombardment. Thermal measurements found the ion stopping region to have a nearly 50x reduction in thermal conductivity as compared to pristine silicon, while TEM showed the region was not fully amorphized. Our results suggest this drastic reduction in silicon thermal conductivity is primarily driven by structural defects in crystalline regions along with boundary scattering between amorphous and crystalline regions, with a negligible contribution being due to implanted krypton ions themselves.
IEEE Transactions on Device and Materials Reliability
Buddhanoy, Matchima B.; Sakib, Sadman S.; Surendranathan, Umeshwarnath S.; Wasiolek, Maryla W.; Hattar, Khalid M.; Ray, Biswajit R.
This paper describes a new non-charge-based data storing technique in NAND flash memory called watermark that encodes read-only data in the form of physical properties of flash memory cells. Unlike traditional charge-based data storing method in flash memory, the proposed technique is resistant to total ionizing dose (TID) effects. To evaluate its resistance to irradiation effects, we analyze data stored in several commercial single-level-cell (SLC) flash memory chips from different vendors and technology nodes. These chips are irradiated using a Co-60 gamma-ray source array for up to 100 krad(Si) at Sandia National Laboratories. Experimental evaluation performed on a flash chip from Samsung shows that the intrinsic bit error rate (BER) of watermark increases from 0.8% for TID = 0 krad(Si) to 1% for TID = 100 krad(Si). Conversely, the BER of charge-based data stored on the same chip increases from 0% at TID = 0 krad(Si) to 1.5% at TID = 100 krad(Si). Overall, the results imply that the proposed technique may potentially offer significant improvements in data integrity relative to traditional charge-based data storage for very high radiation (TID > 100 krad(Si)) environments. These gains in data integrity relative to the charge-based data storage are useful in radiation-prone environments, but they come at the cost of increased write times and higher BERs before irradiation.
There is a need to understand materials exposed to overlapping extreme environments such as high temperature, radiation, or mechanical stress. When these stressors are combined there may be synergistic effects that enable unique microstructural evolution mechanisms to activate. Understanding of these mechanisms is necessary for the input and refinement of predictive models and critical for engineering of next generation materials. The basic physics and underlying mechanisms require advanced tools to be investigated. The in situ ion irradiation transmission electron microscope (I³TEM) is designed to explore these principles. To quantitatively probe the complex dynamic interactions in materials, careful preparation of samples and consideration of experimental design is required. Particular handling or preparation of samples can easily introduce damage or features that obfuscate the measurements. There is no one correct way to prepare a sample; however, many mistakes can be made. The most common errors and things to consider are highlighted within. The I³TEM has many adjustable variables and a large potential experimental space, therefore it is best to design experiments with a specific scientific question or questions in mind. Experiments have been performed on large number of sample geometries, material classes, and with many irradiation conditions. The following are a subset of examples that demonstrate unique in situ capabilities utilizing the I3TEM. Au nanoparticles prepared by drop casting have been used to investigate the effects of single ion strikes. Au thin films have been used in studies on the effects of multibeam irradiation on microstructure evolution. Zr films have been exposed to irradiation and mechanical tension to examine creep. Ag nanopillars were subjected to simultaneous high temperature, mechanical compression, and ion irradiation to study irradiation induced creep as well. These results impact fields including: structural materials, nuclear energy, energy storage, catalysis, and microelectronics in space environments.
Metals subjected to irradiation environments undergo microstructural evolution and concomitant degradation, yet the nanoscale mechanisms for such evolution remain elusive. Here, we combine in situ heavy ion irradiation, atomic resolution microscopy, and atomistic simulation to elucidate how radiation damage and interfacial defects interplay to control grain boundary (GB) motion. While classical notions of boundary evolution under irradiation rest on simple ideas of curvature-driven motion, the reality is far more complex. Focusing on an ion-irradiated Pt Σ3 GB, we show how this boundary evolves by the motion of 120° facet junctions separating nanoscale {112} facets. Our analysis considers the short- and mid-range ion interactions, which roughen the facets and induce local motion, and longer-range interactions associated with interfacial disconnections, which accommodate the intergranular misorientation. We suggest how climb of these disconnections could drive coordinated facet junction motion. These findings emphasize that both local and longer-range, collective interactions are important to understanding irradiation-induced interfacial evolution.
High‐Entropy Alloys (HEAs) are proposed as materials for a variety of extreme environments, including both fission and fusion radiation applications. To withstand these harsh environments, materials processing must be tailored to their given application, now achieved through additive manufacturing processes. However, radiation application opportunities remain limited due to an incomplete understanding of the effects of irradiation on HEA performance. In this letter, we investigate the response of additively manufactured refractory high‐entropy alloys (RHEAs) to helium (He) ion bombardment. Through analytical microscopy studies, we show the interplay between the alloy composition and the He bubble size and density to demonstrate how increasing the compositional complexity can limit the He bubble effects, but care must be taken in selecting the appropriate constituent elements.
We report the joining process for oxide dispersion strengthened (ODS) alloys remains a key challenge facing the nuclear community. The microstructure and mechanical properties were characterized in the base material and friction stir welded ODS MA956 irradiated with 5 MeV Fe2+ ions from 400 to 500°C up to 25 dpa. Nanoindentation was performed to assess changes in hardness and yield stress, and the dispersed barrier hardening (DBH) model was applied to described results. A combination of scanning transmission electron microscopy (STEM) and atom probe tomography (APT) were used to assess evolution of the microstructure including dispersoids, network dislocations and dislocation loops, nanoclusters, and solid solution concentrations. Overall, softening was observed as a result of increased dose, which was exacerbated at 500°C. The formation and coarsening of new dispersoids was noted while nanoclusters tended to dissolve in the base material, and were not observed in the stir zone. Solute nanocluster evolution was identified as a primary driver of the changes in mechanical properties.
Understanding of structural and morphological evolution in nanomaterials is critical in tailoring their functionality for applications such as energy conversion and storage. Here, we examine irradiation effects on the morphology and structure of amorphous TiO2 nanotubes in comparison with their crystalline counterpart, anatase TiO2 nanotubes, using high-resolution transmission electron microscopy (TEM), in situ ion irradiation TEM, and molecular dynamics (MD) simulations. Anatase TiO2 nanotubes exhibit morphological and structural stability under irradiation due to their high concentration of grain boundaries and surfaces as defect sinks. On the other hand, amorphous TiO2 nanotubes undergo irradiation-induced crystallization, with some tubes remaining only partially crystallized. The partially crystalline tubes bend due to internal stresses associated with densification during crystallization as suggested by MD calculations. These results present a novel irradiation-based pathway for potentially tuning structure and morphology of energy storage materials. Graphical abstract: [Figure not available: see fulltext.]
This article evaluates the data retention characteristics of irradiated multilevel-cell (MLC) 3-D NAND flash memories. We irradiated the memory chips by a Co-60 gamma-ray source for up to 50 krad(Si) and then wrote a random data pattern on the irradiated chips to find their retention characteristics. The experimental results show that the data retention property of the irradiated chips is significantly degraded when compared to the un-irradiated ones. We evaluated two independent strategies to improve the data retention characteristics of the irradiated chips. The first method involves high-temperature annealing of the irradiated chips, while the second method suggests preprogramming the memory modules before deploying them into radiation-prone environments.
Surendranathan, Umeshwarnath; Wasiolek, Maryla; Hattar, Khalid M.; Fleetwood, Daniel M.; Ray, Biswajit
This article analyzes the total ionizing dose (TID) effects on noise characteristics of commercial multi-level-cell (MLC) 3-D NAND memory technology during the read operation. The chips were exposed to a Co-60 gamma-ray source for up to 100 krad(Si) of TID. We find that the number of noisy cells in the irradiated chip increases with TID. Bit-flip noise was more dominant for cells in an erased state during irradiation compared to programmed cells.
In this article, we provide an analytical model for the total ionizing dose (TID) effects on the bit error statistics of commercial flash memory chips. We have validated the model with experimental data collected by irradiating several commercial NAND flash memory chips from different technology nodes. We find that our analytical model can project bit errors at higher TID values [20 krad (Si)] from measured data at lower TID values [<1 krad (Si)]. Based on our model and the measured data, we have formulated basic design rules for using a commercial flash memory chip as a dosimeter. We discuss the impact of NAND chip-to-chip variability, noise margin, and the intrinsic errors on the dosimeter design using detailed experimentation.
Kiani, Mehrdad T.; Gan, Lucia T.; Traylor, Rachel; Yang, Rui; Barr, Christopher M.; Hattar, Khalid M.; Fan, Jonathan A.; Wendy Gu, X.
Grain boundaries have complex structural features that influence strength, ductility and fracture in metals and alloys. Grain boundary misorientation angle has been identified as a key parameter that controls their mechanical behavior, but the effect of misorientation angle has been challenging to isolate in polycrystalline materials. Here, we describe the use of bicrystal Au thin films made using a rapid melt growth process to study deformation at a single grain boundary. Tensile testing is performed on bicrystals with different misorientation angles using in situ TEM, as well as on a single crystalline sample. Plastic deformation is initiated through dislocation nucleation from free surfaces. Grain boundary sliding is not observed, and failure occurs away from the grain boundary through plastic collapse in all cases. The failure behavior in these nanoscale bicrystals does not appear to depend on the misorientation angle or grain boundary energy but instead has a more complex dependence on sample surface structure and dislocation activity.
The Fusion Energy Sciences office supported “A Pilot Program for Research Traineeships to Broaden and Diversify Fusion Energy Sciences” at Sandia National Laboratories during the summer of 2021. This pilot project was motivated in part by the Fusion Energy Sciences Advisory Committee report observation that “The multidisciplinary workforce needed for fusion energy and plasma science requires that the community commit to the creation and maintenance of a healthy climate of diversity, equity, and inclusion, which will benefit the community as a whole and the mission of FES”. The pilot project was designed to work with North Carolina A&T (NCAT) University and leverage SNL efforts in FES to engage underrepresented students in developing and accessing advanced material solutions for plasma facing components in fusion systems. The intent was to create an environment conducive to the development of a sense of belonging amongst participants, foster a strong sense of physics identity among the participants, and provide financial support to enable students to advance academically while earning money. The purpose of this assessment is to review what worked well and lessons that can be learned. We reviewed implementation and execution of the pilot, describe successes and areas for improvement and propose a no-cost extension of the pilot project to apply these lessons and continue engagement activities in the summer of 2022.
Daly, Luke; Lee, Martin R.; Hallis, Lydia J.; Ishii, Hope A.; Bradley, John P.; Bland, Phillip A.; Saxey, David W.; Fougerouse, Denis; Rickard, William D.A.; Forman, Lucy V.; Timms, Nicholas E.; Jourdan, Fred; Reddy, Steven M.; Salge, Tobias; Quadir, Zakaria; Christou, Evangelos; Cox, Morgan A.; Aguiar, Jeffrey A.; Hattar, Khalid M.; Monterrosa, Anthony; Keller, Lindsay P.; Christoffersen, Roy; Dukes, Catherine A.; Loeffler, Mark J.; Thompson, Michelle S.
The isotopic composition of water in Earth’s oceans is challenging to recreate using a plausible mixture of known extraterrestrial sources such as asteroids—an additional isotopically light reservoir is required. The Sun’s solar wind could provide an answer to balance Earth’s water budget. We used atom probe tomography to directly observe an average ~1 mol% enrichment in water and hydroxyls in the solar-wind-irradiated rim of an olivine grain from the S-type asteroid Itokawa. We also experimentally confirm that H+ irradiation of silicate mineral surfaces produces water molecules. These results suggest that the Itokawa regolith could contain ~20 l m−3 of solar-wind-derived water and that such water reservoirs are probably ubiquitous on airless worlds throughout our Galaxy. The production of this isotopically light water reservoir by solar wind implantation into fine-grained silicates may have been a particularly important process in the early Solar System, potentially providing a means to recreate Earth’s current water isotope ratios.
Wang, Fei; Yan, Xueliang; Chen, Xin; Snyder, Nathan; Nastasi, Michael; Hattar, Khalid M.; Cui, Bai
The solid-state joining of oxide-dispersion-strengthened (ODS) austenitic steels was achieved using a pulsed electric current joining (PECJ) process. Microstructures of the austenitic grain structures and oxide dispersions in the joint areas were characterized using electron microscopy. Negligible grain growth was observed in austenitic grain structures, while slight coarsening of oxide dispersions occurred at a short holding time. The mechanisms of the PECJ process may involve three steps that occur simultaneously, including the sintering of mechanical alloying powders in the bonding layer, formation of oxide dispersions, and bonding of the mechanical alloying powders with the base alloy. The high hardness and irradiation resistance of ODS alloys were retained in the joint areas. This research revealed the fundamental mechanisms during the PECJ process, which is beneficial for its potential applications during the advanced manufacturing of ODS alloys.
Dennett, Cody A.; Dacus, Benjamin R.; Barr, Christopher M.; Clark, Trevor; Bei, Hongbin; Zhang, Yanwen; Short, Michael P.; Hattar, Khalid M.
Defects and microstructural features spanning the atomic level to the microscale play deterministic roles in the expressed properties of materials. Yet studies of material evolution in response to environmental stimuli most often correlate resulting performance with one dominant microstructural feature only. Here, the dynamic evolution of swelling in a series of Ni-based concentrated solid solution alloys under high-temperature irradiation exposure is observed using continuous, in situ measurements of thermoelastic properties in bulk specimens. Unlike traditional evaluation techniques which account only for volumetric porosity identified using electron microscopy, direct property evaluation provides an integrated response across all defect length scales. In particular, the evolution in elastic properties during swelling is found to depend significantly on the entire size spectrum of defects, from the nano- to meso-scales, some of which are not resolvable in imaging. Observed changes in thermal transport properties depend sensitively on the partitioning of electronic and lattice thermal conductivity. This emerging class of in situ experiments, which directly measure integrated performance in relevant conditions, provides unique insight into material dynamics otherwise unavailable using traditional methods.
A synthesis process is presented for experimentally simulating modifications in cosmic dust grains using sequential ion implantations or irradiations followed by thermal annealing. Cosmic silicate dust analogues were prepared via implantation of 20–80 keV Fe−, Mg−, and O− ions into commercially available p-type silicon (100) wafers. The as-implanted analogues are amorphous with a Mg/(Fe + Mg) ratio of 0.5 tailored to match theoretical abundances in circumstellar dusts. Before the ion implantations were performed, Monte-Carlo-based ion-solid interaction codes were used to model the dynamic redistribution of the implanted atoms in the silicon substrate. 600 keV helium ion irradiation was performed on one of the samples before thermal annealing. Two samples were thermally annealed at a temperature appropriate for an M-class stellar wind, 1000 K, for 8.3 h in a vacuum chamber with a pressure of 1 × 10−7 torr. The elemental depth profiles were extracted utilizing Rutherford Backscattering Spectrometry (RBS) in the samples before and after thermal annealing. X-ray diffraction (XRD) analysis was employed for the identification of various phases in crystalline minerals in the annealed analogues. Transmission electron microscopy (TEM) analysis was utilized to identify specific crystal structures. RBS analysis shows redistribution of the implanted Fe, Mg, and O after thermal annealing due to incorporation into the crystal structures for each sample type. XRD patterns along with TEM analysis showed nanocrystalline Mg and Fe oxides with possible incorporation of additional silicate minerals.
Stainless steel TPBAR components undergo neutron radiation-induced segregation and dislocation loop formation. Comparison experiments with ion beams accelerate the damage, and visualize the damage process with in-situ microscopy. In-situ Au irradiation causes defect formation, but no elemental segregation.
Jawaharram, Gowtham S.; Barr, Christopher M.; Hattar, Khalid M.; Dillon, Shen J.
A series of nanopillar compression tests were performed on tungsten as a function of temperature using in situ transmission electron microscopy with localized laser heating. Surface oxidation was observed to form on the pillars and grow in thickness with increasing temperature. Deformation between 850◦C and 1120◦C is facilitated by long-range diffusional transport from the tungsten pillar onto adjacent regions of the Y2O3-stabilized ZrO2 indenter. The constraint imposed by the surface oxidation is hypothesized to underly this mechanism for localized plasticity, which is generally the so-called whisker growth mechanism. The results are discussed in context of the tungsten fuzz growth mechanism in He plasma-facing environments. The two processes exhibit similar morphological features and the conditions under which fuzz evolves appear to satisfy the conditions necessary to induce whisker growth.
Zhang, Xiang; Wang, Fei; Yan, Xueliang; Li, Xing Z.; Hattar, Khalid M.; Cui, Bai
A nanostructured oxide-dispersion-strengthened (ODS) CoCrFeMnNi high-entropy alloy (HEA) is synthesized by a powder metallurgy process. The thermal stability, including the grain size and crystal structure of the HEA matrix and oxide dispersions, is carefully investigated by X-ray diffraction (XRD) and electron microscopy characterizations after annealing at 900 °C. The limited grain growth may be attributed to Zener pinning of yttria dispersions that impede the grain boundary mobility and diffusivity. The high hardness is caused by both the fine grain size and yttria dispersions, which are also retained after annealing at 900 °C. Herein, it is implied that the combination of ODS and HEA concepts may provide a new design strategy for the development of thermally stable nanostructured alloys for extreme environments.