This research proposes a sensitivity-based framework for selecting the optimal prescribed loading path for a biaxial cruciform specimen. Optimality here is determined by the direction and magnitude of the prescribed displacement that minimizes the influence of random noise on the material model parameter identification. Using simulated experimental data based on finite element simulation, in this work, we identify the material model parameters of a Ludwik hardening model and plane stress implementation of the Hill-48 yield criterion using finite element model updating (FEMU). Our analysis reveals that the identification (or estimator) uncertainty of model parameters depends on the displacement boundary conditions (i.e., loading sequence) and the ground-truth value of the individual parameters. Optimal experimental design (OED) criteria based on the Fisher information matrix were investigated to mitigate indecision in the choice of optimal load path when the identification uncertainty of different material model parameters optimized at different load paths. The determinant of the Fisher information matrix was chosen here as the more useful metric due to its ability to capture uncertainty of the most influential material model parameters. The proposed framework demonstrates potential for real-time automated load step selection using scalar criteria derived prior to mechanical loading. The framework can be generalized to other geometries, boundary conditions and material models, allowing this procedure to be utilized for different experimental configurations and materials.
Material Testing 2.0 (MT2.0) is a paradigm that advocates for the use of rich, full-field data, such as from digital image correlation and infrared thermography, for material identification. By employing heterogeneous, multi-axial data in conjunction with sophisticated inverse calibration techniques such as finite element model updating and the virtual fields method, MT2.0 aims to reduce the number of specimens needed for material identification and to increase confidence in the calibration results. To support continued development, improvement, and validation of such inverse methods—specifically for rate-dependent, temperature-dependent, and anisotropic metal plasticity models—we provide here a thorough experimental data set for 304L stainless steel sheet metal. The data set includes full-field displacement, strain, and temperature data for seven unique specimen geometries tested at different strain rates and in different material orientations. Commensurate extensometer strain data from tensile dog bones is provided as well for comparison. We believe this complete data set will be a valuable contribution to the experimental and computational mechanics communities, supporting continued advances in material identification methods.
X-rays can provide images when an object is visibly obstructed, allowing for motion measurements via x-ray digital image correlation (DIC). However, x-ray images are path-integrated and contain data for all objects between the source and detector. If multiple objects are present in the x-ray path, conventional DIC algorithms may fail to correlate the x-ray images. A new DIC algorithm called path-integrated (PI)-DIC addresses this issue by reformulating the matching criterion for DIC to account for multiple, independently-moving objects. PI-DIC requires a set of reference x-ray images of each independent object. However, due to experimental constraints, such reference images might not be obtainable from the experiment. This work focuses on the reliability of synthetically-generated reference images, in such cases. A simplified exemplar is used for demonstration purposes, consisting of two aluminum plates with tantalum x-ray DIC patterns undergoing independent rigid translations. Synthetic reference images based on the “as-designed” DIC patterns were generated. However, PI-DIC with the synthetic images suffered some biases due to manufacturing defects of the patterns. A systematic study of seven identified defect types found that an incorrect feature diameter was the most influential defect. Synthetic images were re-generated with the corrected feature diameter, and PI-DIC errors were improved by a factor of 3-4. Final biases ranged from 0.00-0.04 px, and standard uncertainties ranged from 0.06-0.11 px. In conclusion, PI-DIC accurately measured the independent displacement of two plates from a single series of path-integrated x-ray images using synthetically-generated reference images, and the methods and conclusions derived here can be extended to more generalized cases involving stereo PI-DIC for arbitrary specimen geometry and motion. This work thus extends the application space of x-ray imaging for full-field DIC measurements of multiple surfaces or objects in extreme environments where optical DIC is not possible.
Accurate material characterization and model calibration are pivotal for simulations used for high-consequence engineering decisions. Current characterization and calibration methods (1) use simplified test specimen geometries and global data, (2) cannot guarantee that sufficient characterization data is collected for a specific model of interest, (3) provide only mean parameter values with no uncertainty quantification, and (4) are sequential, inflexible, and time-consuming. This work developed a new paradigm—coined Interlaced Characterization and Calibration (ICC)—which drives forward the state-of-the-art in model calibration by bringing together recent advancements into one improved workflow. The ICC paradigm (1) employs tools to efficiently use full-field data to calibrate high-fidelity material models, (2) aligns the data needed with the data collected by adopting an optimal experimental design protocol, (3) provides uncertainty metrics on the calibrated model parameters, and (4) incorporates these advances into a quasi real-time feedback loop. The ICC framework was validated synthetically with both low-fidelity and high-fidelity simulations paired with several different elastoplastic material models, and was also demonstrated experimentally with an aluminum 6061 cruciform exemplar specimen. Results showed that the ICC framework—in which Bayesian optimal experimental design actively guided the experiment— resulted in calibrations with similar or better accuracy than predetermined experiments based on subject matter expertise. Moreover, the ICC framework produced a complete model calibration— with quantified uncertainties on model parameters—in 1 week, a 5 - 10× increase in efficiency over traditional approaches. Thus, the ICC paradigm improves both the calibration process and quality, by (1) improving efficiency, which increases agility of solid mechanics modeling and enables utilization of computational simulation (CompSim) at earlier stages of the design cycle and (2) providing quantified, and in some cases reduced, parameter uncertainties, which increases confidence in model predictions and supports credible decision making.
Understanding temperature-dependent material decomposition and structural deformation induced by combined thermal-mechanical environments is critical for safety qualification of hardware under accident scenarios. Seeing in with X-rays elucidated the physics necessary to develop X-ray strain and thermometry diagnostics for use in optically opaque environments. Two parallel thermometry schemes were explored: X-ray fluorescence and X-ray diffraction of inorganic doped ceramics– colloquially known as thermographic phosphors. Two parallel surface strain techniques–Path-Integrated Digital Image Correlation and Frequency Multiplexed Digital Image Correlation–were demonstrated. Finally, preliminary demonstration of time-resolved digital volume correlation was performed by taking advantage of limited view reconstruction techniques. Additionally, research into blended ceramic-metal coatings was critical to generating intrinsic thermographic patterns for the future combination of X-ray strain and thermometry measurements.
A computational model of aluminum melting is proposed which captures both the thermal fluid-solid phase transition and the mechanical effects of oxidation. The model hybridizes ideas from smoothed particle hydrodynamics and bonded particle models to simulate both hydrodynamic flows and solid elasticity. Oxidation is represented by dynamically adding and deleting spring-like bonds between surface fluid particles to represent the formation and rupture of the oxide skin. Various complex systems are simulated to demonstrate the adaptability of the method and to illustrate the significant impact of skin properties on material flow. As a result, initial comparison to experiments of a melting aluminum cantilever highlights that the computational model can reproduce key qualitative features of aluminum relocation.
In this study, x-ray imaging addresses many challenges with visible light imaging in extreme environments, where optical diagnostics such as digital image correlation (DIC) and particle image velocimetry (PIV) suffer biases from index of refraction changes and/or cannot penetrate visibly occluded objects. However, conservation of intensity—the fundamental principle of optical image correlation algorithms—may be violated if ancillary components in the X-ray path besides the surface or fluid of interest move during the test. The test series treated in this work sought to characterize the safe use of fiber-epoxy composites in aerospace and aviation industries during fire accident scenarios. Stereo X-ray DIC was employed to measure test unit deformation in an extreme thermal environment involving a visibly occluded test unit, incident surface heating to temperatures above 600°C, and flames and soot from combusting epoxy decomposition gasses. The objective of the current work is to evaluate two solutions to resolve the violation of conservation of intensity that resulted from both the test unit and the thermal chamber deforming during the test. The first solution recovered conservation of intensity by pre-processing the path-integrated X-ray images to isolate the DIC pattern of the test unit from the thermal chamber components. These images were then correlated with standard, optical DIC software. The second solution, called Path-Integrated Digital Image Correlation (PI-DIC), modified the fundamental matching criterion of DIC to account for multiple, independently-moving components contributing to the final image intensity. The PI-DIC algorithm was extended from a 2D framework to a stereo framework and implemented in a custom DIC software. Both solutions accurately measured the cylindrical shape of the undeformed test unit, recovering radii values of R = 76.20±0.12 mm compared to the theoretical radius of Rtheor = 76.20 mm. During the test, the test unit bulged asymmetrically as decomposition gasses pressurized the interior and eventually burned in a localized jet. Both solutions measured the heterogeneous radius of this bulge, which reached a maximum of approximately R = 91 mm, with a discrepancy of 2–3% between the two solutions. Two solutions that resolve the violation of conservation of intensity for path-integrated X-ray images were developed. Both were successfully employed in a stereo X-ray DIC configuration to measure deformation of an aluminum-skinned, fiber-epoxy composite test unit in a fire accident scenario.
Computational simulation is increasingly relied upon for high/consequence engineering decisions, which necessitates a high confidence in the calibration of and predictions from complex material models. However, the calibration and validation of material models is often a discrete, multi-stage process that is decoupled from material characterization activities, which means the data collected does not always align with the data that is needed. To address this issue, an integrated workflow for delivering an enhanced characterization and calibration procedure—Interlaced Characterization and Calibration (ICC)—is introduced and demonstrated. Further, this framework leverages Bayesian optimal experimental design (BOED), which creates a line of communication between model calibration needs and data collection capabilities in order to optimize the information content gathered from the experiments for model calibration. Eventually, the ICC framework will be used in quasi real-time to actively control experiments of complex specimens for the calibration of a high-fidelity material model. This work presents the critical first piece of algorithm development and a demonstration in determining the optimal load path of a cruciform specimen with simulated data. Calibration results, obtained via Bayesian inference, from the integrated ICC approach are compared to calibrations performed by choosing the load path a priori based on human intuition, as is traditionally done. The calibration results are communicated through parameter uncertainties which are propagated to the model output space (i.e. stress–strain). In these exemplar problems, data generated within the ICC framework resulted in calibrated model parameters with reduced measures of uncertainty compared to the traditional approaches.
Full-field, multi-measurand diagnostics provide rich validation data necessary to improve the product life cycle time of nuclear safety components. Thermophosphor digital image correlation (TP+DIC) is a method of simultaneously measuring strain and temperature fields using patterned phosphor coatings deposited with aerosol deposition (AD). While TP+DIC produces a functional diagnostic, the coating’s reproducibility and the effect of the patterned features on the inferred temperature remains uncharacterized. This NSR&D project provided the opportunity to study two areas: 1) the tunability and repeatability of aerosol deposition and 2) the robustness of aerosol deposition phosphor on deforming substrates. The first area explores the process-property relationship of parameters elucidating the significance of each on the coating. The second area explores the relationship between the features’ characteristics (namely thickness) and the phosphor emission and inferred temperature. Together, the results will lead to the improved accuracy and functionality of TP+DIC for qualification testing of nuclear safety components.
Ultimately, our experiment measures two quantities on an aluminum bar: motion (which modeling must predict) and temperature (which sets thermal boundary conditions). For motion, stereo DIC is a technique to use imaging data to provide displacements relative to a reference image down to 1/100th of a pixel. We use a calibrated infrared imaging method for accurate temperature measurements. We will be capturing simultaneous data and then registering temperature data in space to the same coordinate system as the displacement data. While we will later show that our experiments are repeatable, indicating that separate experiments for motion and temperature would provide similar data, the simultaneous and registered data removes test to test variability as a source of uncertainty for model calibration and reduces the number of time-consuming tests that must be performed.
Recent work on the development of integrated thermographic phosphors and digital image correlation (TP+DIC) for combined thermal–mechanical measurements has revealed the need for a flexible, stretchable phosphor coating for metal surfaces. Herein, we coat stainless steel substrates with a polymer-based phosphor ink in a DIC speckle pattern and demonstrate that the ink remains well bonded under substrate deformation. In contrast, a binderless phosphor DIC coating produced via aerosol deposition (AD) partially debonded from the substrate. DIC calculations reveal that the strain on the ink coating matches the strain on the substrate within 4% error at the highest substrate loads (0.05 mm/mm applied substrate strain), while the strain on the AD coating remains near 0 mm/mm as the substrate deforms. Spectrally resolved emission from the phosphor is measured through the transparent binder throughout testing, and the ratio method is used to infer temperature with an uncertainty of 1.7 °C. This phosphor ink coating will allow for accurate, non-contact strain and temperature measurements of a deforming surface.
