Exploding bridgewire (EBW) detonators are used to rapidly and reliably initiate energetic reactions by exploding a bridgewire via Joule heating. While the mechanisms of EBW detonators have been studied extensively in nominal conditions, comparatively few studies have addressed thermally damaged detonator operability. We present a mesoscale simulation study of thermal damage in a representative EBW detonator, using discrete element method (DEM) simulations that explicitly account for individual particles in the pressed explosive powder. We use a simplified model of melting, where solid spherical particles undergo uniform shrinking, and fluid dynamics are ignored. The subsequent settling of particles results in the formation of a gap between the solid powder and the bridgewire, which we study under different conditions. In particular, particle cohesion has a significant effect on gap formation and settling behavior, where sufficiently high cohesion leads to coalescence of particles into a free-standing pellet. This behavior is qualitatively compared to experimental visualization data, and simulations are shown to capture several key changes in pellet shape. We derive a minimum and maximum limit on gap formation during melting using simple geometric arguments. In the absence of cohesion, results agree with the maximum gap size. With increasing cohesion, the gap size decreases, eventually saturating at the minimum limit. We present results for different combinations of interparticle cohesion and detonator orientations with respect to gravity, demonstrating the complex behavior of these systems and the potential for DEM simulations to capture a range of scenarios.
Determining the thermal response of energetic materials at high densities can be difficult when pressure dependent reactions occur within the interior of the material. At high temperatures, reactive components such as hexahydro-l,3,5-tri-nitro-l,3,5-triazine (RDX), ammonium perchlorate (AP), and hydroxyl-terminated polybutadiene (HTPB) decompose and interact. The decomposition products accumulate near defects where internal pressure ultimately causes mechanical damage with closed pores transitioning into open pores. Gases are no longer confined locally; instead, they freely migrate between open pores and ultimately escape into the surrounding headspace or vent. Recently we have developed a universal cookoff model (UCM) coupled to a micromechanics pressurization (MMP) model to address pressure-dependent reactions that occur within the interior of explosives. Parameters for the UCM/MMP model are presented for an explosive and two propellants that contain similar portions of both aluminum (Al) and a binder. The explosive contains RDX and the propellants contain AP with no RDX. One of the propellants contains small amounts of curing catalysts and a burn modifier whereas the other propellant does not. We found that the cookoff behavior of the two propellants behave similarly leading and conclude that small amounts of catalysts or burn modifiers do not influence cookoff behavior appreciably. Kinetic parameters for the UCM/MMP models were obtained from the Sandia Instrumented Thermal Ignition (SITI) experiment. Validation is done with data from other laboratories.
Large rocket motors may violently explode when exposed to accidental fires. Even hot metal fragments from a nearby accident may penetrate the propellant and ultimately cause thermal ignition. A mechanistic understanding of heated propellants leading to thermal runaway is a major unsolved problem. Here we show that thermal ignition in propellants can be predicted using a universal cookoff model coupled to a micromechanics pressurization model. Our model predicts the time to thermal ignition in cookoff experiments with variable headspace volumes. We found that experiments with headspace volumes are more prone to deformation which distorts pores and causes increased permeability when the propellant expands into this headspace. Delayed ignition with larger headspace volume correlates with lower headspace pressures during decomposition. We found that our predictions matched experimental measurements best when the initial propellant was impermeable to gas flow rather than being permeable. Similar behavior is expected with other energetic materials with rubbery binders. Our model is validated using data from a separate laboratory. We also present an uncertainty analysis using Latin Hypercube Sampling (LHS) of thermal ignition caused by a steel fragment embedded in the propellant.
Hobbs, Michael L.; Britt, Phillip F.; Hobbs, David T.; Kaneshige, Michael; Minette, Michael; Mintz, Jessica; Pennebaker, Frank M.; Parker, Gary R.; Rosenberg, David; Schwantes, Jon; Williams, Audrey; Pierce, Robert
Hobbs, Michael L.; Britt, Phillip F.; Hobbs, David T.; Kaneshige, Michael; Minette, Michael; Mintz, Jessica; Pennebaker, Frank M.; Parker, Gary R.; Pierce, Robert; Rosenberg, David; Schwantes, Jon; Williams, Audrey
Precise wording is important in every field of study, including operational procedures. Confusion in the wording “organic” and “inorganic” may have contributed to substitution of an organic kitty litter for an inorganic adsorbent used to prepare nuclear waste for disposal at an underground salt repository. Adsorbents prevent liquids like nitric acid from causing corrosion within the waste drums. However, combination of organic material with nitric acid can cause heat- and gas-generating reactions resulting in thermal runaway, rapid pressurization, and drum rupture. In 2014, waste Drum 68660 containing nitric acid-soaked organic kitty litter exploded and released transuranic waste into the repository. The cause of the accident was never identified. Here we show that the root cause of Drum 68660 igniting was restriction of the drum vent resulting in accelerated nitric acid chemistry, thermal runaway, and radiation dispersal.
Operability thresholds that differentiate between functional RP-87 exploding bridge wire (EBW) detonators and nonfunctional RP-87 EBW detonators (duds) were determined by measuring the time delay between initiation and early wall movement (function time). The detonators were inserted into an externally heated hollow cylinder of aluminum and fired with current flow from a charged capacitor using an exploding bridge wire (EBW initiated). Functioning detonators responded like unheated pristine detonators when the function time was 4 μs or less. The operability thresholds of the detonators were characterized with a simple decomposition cookoff model calibrated using a modified version of the Sandia Instrumented Thermal Ignition (SITI) experiment. These thresholds are based on the calculated state of the PETN when the detonators fire. The operability threshold is proportional to the positive temperature difference (ΔT) between the maximum temperature within the PETN and the onset of decomposition (∼406 K). The temperature difference alone was not sufficient to define the operability threshold. The operability threshold was also proportional to the time that the PETN had been at elevated temperatures. That is, failure was proportional to both temperature and reaction rate. The reacted gas fraction is used in the current work for the reaction correlation. Melting of PETN also had a significant effect on the operability threshold. Detonator failure occurred when the maximum temperature exceeded the nominal melting point of PETN (414 K) for 45±5 s or more.
Transforming polymorphs, melting, and boiling are physical processes that can accelerate decomposition rates during cookoff of PETN and make measurements difficult. For example, splashing liquids from large bubbles filled with decomposition products clog pressure tubing in sealed experiments. Boil over can also extinguish thermal excursions in vented experiments making ignition difficult. For better measurements, we have modified the Sandia Instrumented Thermal Ignition (SITI) experiment to obtain better sealed and vented cookoff data for PETN by reducing the sample size and including additional gas space to prevent clogged tubing and boil over. Ignition times were not affected by 1) increasing the gas space by a factor of 3 in sealed SITI experiments or by 2) venting the decomposition gasses. That is, thermal ignition of PETN is not pressure dependent and the rate-limiting step during PETN decomposition likely occurs in the condensed phase. A simple decomposition model was calibrated using these observations and includes rate acceleration caused by melting and boiling. The model is used to predict internal temperatures, pressurization, and thermal ignition in a wide variety of experiments. The model is also used with SITI data to estimate the previously unreported latent enthalpy (5 J/g) associated with the α (PETN-I) to β (PETN-II) polymorphic phase transformation of PETN.
Cookoff experiments of powdered and pressed TATB-based plastic bonded explosives (PBXs) have been modeled using a pressure-dependent universal cookoff model (UCM) in combination with a micromechanics pressurization (MMP) model described in a companion paper. The MMP model is based on the accumulation of decomposition gases at nucleation sites that load the surrounding TATB crystals and binder. This is the first cookoff model to use an analytical mechanics solution for compressibility and thermal expansion to describe internal pressurization caused by both temperature and decomposition occurring within closed-pore explosives. This approach produces more accurate predictions of ignition time and pressurization within high-density explosives than simple equation-of-state models. The current paper gives details of the reaction chemistry, model parameters, predicted uncertainty, and validation using experiments from multiple laboratories with errors less than 6 %. The UCM/MMP model framework gives more accurate thermal ignition predictions for high density explosives that are initially impermeable to decomposition gases.
We have completed a series of both vented and sealed cookoff experiments of black powder and smokeless powder in our Sandia Instrumented Thermal Ignition (SITI) apparatus at bulk densities of 1078 and 729 kg/m3, respectively. The confining aluminum cylinder was ramped from room temperature to a set point temperature and then held at the setpoint temperature until ignition. The setpoint temperatures varied between 495 to 523 K for the black powder and 401 to 412 K for the more sensitive smokeless powder. The vented experiments show a significant delay in thermal ignition, indicating that the ignition is dependent on pressure. Post experimental debris shows greater violence for our smokeless powder experiments than our black powder experiments. A simplified universal cookoff model (UCM) was calibrated using the black powder and smokeless powder SITI data and used to predict pressurization and thermal ignition. The current work presents the first calibration of the UCM with a double base propellant. This work also presents the first pressure-dependent cookoff model for black powder and smokeless powder.
In the present study, commercially available detonators with pentaerythritol tetranitrate (PETN) were subjected to elevated temperatures. The detonators were thermally ignited over a range of heating rates to measure ignition delay time and assess detonator violence. The violence of the detonator was quantified by measuring the velocity of the detonator closure disc (or "flyer"). The maximum flyer velocity of a thermally ignited detonator was comparable in magnitude to that obtained by initiating a room temperature pristine detonator with an exploding bridge wire (under the same confinement); however, the high flyer velocity was not an indication of deflagration to detonation transition (DDT) in the thermally ignited detonator. The detonator responded more violently than a thermally ignited detonator when initiated at 95% of the ignition delay time. Inoperability thresholds were also measured by varying the detonator temperature and the threshold was found to be sensitive at detonator temperatures below the melting point of PETN.
We have completed a series of vented and sealed cookoff experiments of the ε-polymorph of CL-20 in our Sandia Instrumented Thermal Ignition (SITI) apparatus using both powder and pressed pellets at nominal densities of 313 ± 8 kg/m3 and 1030 ± 4 kg/m3, respectively. The boundary temperature of our aluminum confinement cylinder was ramped in 10 minutes from room temperature to a prescribed set-point temperature ranging between 448 nd 468 K and held at the set-point temperature until ignition. A universal cookoff model (UCM) has been calibrated using the ε-CL-20 SITI data to predict pressurization and thermal ignition of ε-CL-20. The ignition model was validated by using one-dimensional time-to-explosion (ODTX) ignition data from a different laboratory. We found that a thirtyfold increase in the reaction rates due to liquefaction at 520 K could explain the high temperature ODTX cookoff data. The model gives a plausible explanation of why melting is important in fast cookoff events involving CL-20. Our model also gives support to 520 K as the liquefaction point of CL-20, which has different values in the literature.
On June 30, 2020, a 0.87 gram PETN charge being pressed in the Rapid Prototyping Facility (RPF), unexpectedly initiated, resulting in destruction of the pressing fixture but no injuries or facility damage. In response, the Safety Review Board (SRB) met on Aug. 13, 2020 and Oct. 1, 2020 to review information collected following the incident, consider likely direct causes, and form recommendations.