The mechanical behavior of partial-penetration laser welds exhibits significant variability in engineering quantities such as strength and apparent ductility. Understanding the root cause of this variability is important when using such welds in engineering designs. In Part II of this work, we develop finite element simulations with geometry derived from micro-computed tomography (μCT) scans of partial-penetration 304L stainless steel laser welds that were analyzed in Part I. We use these models to study the effects of the welds’ small-scale geometry, including porosity and weld depth variability, on the structural performance metrics of weld ductility and strength under quasi-static tensile loading. We show that this small-scale geometry is the primary cause of the observed variability for these mechanical response quantities. Additionally, we explore the sensitivity of model results to the conversion of the μCT data to discretized model geometry using different segmentation algorithms, and to the effect of small-scale geometry simplifications for pore shape and weld root texture. The modeling approach outlined and results of this work may be applicable to other material systems with small-scale geometric features and defects, such as additively manufactured materials.
Background: Using a thin-walled tube torsion test to characterize a material’s shear response is a well-known technique; however, the thin walled specimen tends to buckle before reaching large shear deformation and failure. An alternative technique is the surface stress method (Nadai 1950; Wu et al. J Test Eval 20:396–402, 1992), which derives a shear stress-strain curve from the torque-angular displacement relationship of a solid cylindrical bar. The solid bar torsion test uniquely stabilizes the deformation which allows us to control and explore very large shear deformation up to failure. However, this method has rarely been considered in the literature, possibly due to the complexity of the analysis and experimental issues such as twist measurement and specimen uniformity. Objective: In this investigation, we develop a method to measure the large angular displacement in the solid bar torsion experiments to study the large shear deformation of two common engineering materials, Al6061-T6 and SS304L, which have distinctive hardening behaviors. Methods: Modern stereo-DIC methods were applied to make deformation measurements. The large angular displacement of the specimen posed challenges for the DIC analysis. An analysis method using multiple reference configurations and transformation of deformation gradient is developed to make the large shear deformation measurement successful. Results: We successfully applied the solid bar torsion experiment and the new analysis method to measure the large shear deformation of Al6061-T6 and SS304L till specimen failure. The engineering shear strains at failure are on the order of 2–3 for Al6061-T6 and 3–4 for SS304L. Shear stress-strain curves of Al6061-T6 and SS304L are also obtained. Conclusions: Solid bar torsion experiments coupled with 3D-DIC technique and the new analysis method of deformation gradient transformation enable measurement of very large shear deformation up to specimen failure.
Foam materials are extensively utilized in aerospace, military, and transportation applications to mitigate blast or shock impact. When foam materials are subjected to an external high-speed impact, shock, or blast loading, an elastic wave or shock wave will form and propagate through the thickness of the foam materials. In this study, silicone foam pads, which were confined laterally and pre-strained to different levels, were experimentally characterized and theoretically analyzed to understand their effects on wave propagation characteristics under impact loading. Depending on impact velocity, either an elastic strain wave or a shock wave would be generated in the silicone foam pad with different pre-strains. Above a certain impact velocity, a shock wave will be generated whereas, below this threshold impact velocity, an elastic strain wave will be generated. This threshold impact velocity depends on the pre-strain applied to the silicone foam pad. Equations are provided to estimate the wave propagation speed for either an elastic or a shock wave from the amount of pre-strain in the silicone foam pads and the impact velocity. These equations are expected to help improve silicone foam design and assembly processes for shock or blast mitigation applications.
Polymeric foams have been extensively used in shock isolation applications because of their superior shock or impact energy absorption capability. In order to meet the shock isolation requirements, the polymeric foams need to be experimentally characterized and numerically modeled in terms of material response under shock/impact loading and then evaluated with experimental, analytical, and/or numerical efforts. Measurement of the dynamic compressive stress-strain response of polymeric foams has become fundamental to the shock isolation performance. However, radial inertia has become a severe issue when characterizing soft materials. It is even much more complicated and difficult to address the radial inertia effect in soft polymeric foams. In this study, we developed an analytical method to calculate the additional stress induced by radial inertia in a polymeric foam specimen. The effect of changing profile of Poisson’s ratio during deformation on radial inertia was investigated. The analytical results were also compared with experimental results obtained from Kolsky compression bar tests on a silicone foam.
Hyperelastic foams have excellent impact energy absorption capability and can experience full recovery following impact loading. Consequently, hyperelastic foams are selected for different applications as shock isolators. Obtaining accurate intrinsic dynamic compressive properties of the hyperelastic foams has become a crucial step in shock isolation design and evaluation. Radial inertia is a key issue in dynamic characterization of soft materials. Radial inertia induced stress in the sample is generally caused by axial acceleration and large deformation applied to a soft specimen. In this study, Poisson's ratio of a typical hyperelastic foam-silicone foam-was experimentally characterized under high strain rate loading and was observed to drastically change across the densification process. A transition in the Poisson's ratio of the silicone foam specimen during dynamic compression generated radial inertia which consequently resulted in additional axial stress in the silicone foam sample. A new analytical method was developed to address the Poisson's ratio-induced radial inertia effects for hyperelastic foams during high rate compression.
This report describes the mechanical characterization of six types of woven composites that Sandia National Laboratories are interested in. These six composites have various combinations of two types of fibers (Carbon-IM7 and Glass-S2) and three types of resins (UF-3362, TC275-1, TC350-1). In this work, two sets of experiments were conducted: quasi-static loading with displacement rate of 2 mm/min (1.3x10^(-3) in/s) and high rate loading with displacement of 5.08 m/s (200 in/s). Quasi-static experiments were performed at three loading orientations of 0°, 45°, 90° for all the six composites to fully characterize their mechanical properties. The elastic properties Young's modulus and Poisson's ratio, as well as ultimate stress and strain were obtained from the quasi-static experiments. The high strain rate experiments were performed only on glass fiber composites along 0° angle of loading. The high rate experiments were mainly to study how the strain rate affects the ultimate stress of the glass-fiber composites with different resins.
Experiments were performed to characterize the mechanical response of a 15 pcf flexible polyurethane foam to large deformation at different strain rates and temperatures. Results from these experiments indicated that at room temperature, flexible polyurethane foams exhibit significant nonlinear elastic deformation and nearly return to their original undeformed shape when unloaded. However, when these foams are cooled to temperatures below their glass transition temperature of approximately -35 o C, they behave like rigid polyurethane foams and exhibit significant permanent deformation when compressed. Thus, a new model which captures this dramatic change in behavior with temperature was developed and implemented into SIERRA with the name Flex_Foam to describe the mechanical response of both flexible and rigid foams to large deformation at a variety of temperatures and strain rates. This report includes a description of recent experiments. Next, development of the Flex Foam model for flexible polyurethane and other flexible foams is described. Selection of material parameters are discussed and finite element simulations with the new Flex Foam model are compared with experimental results to show behavior that can be captured with this new model.
Laser Engineered Net Shaping (LENS) and Powder Bed Fusion (PBF) are 3-D additive manufacturing (AM) processes. They are capable of printing metal parts with complex geometries and dimensions effectively. Studies have shown that AM processes create metals with distinctive microstructure features and material properties, which are highly dependent on the processing parameters. The mechanical properties of an AM material may appear to be similar to the corresponding wrought material in some way. This investigation focuses on the relationships among AM process, microstructure features, and material properties. The study involves several AM SS316L components made from 3D LENS and PBF printing. Specimens were taken from different locations and orientations of AM components to obtain the associated tensile properties, including yield, strength, and ductility, and to conduct microstructure analyses.
We investigate the process-structure-property relationships for 316L stainless steel prototyping utilizing 3-D laser engineered net shaping (LENS), a commercial direct energy deposition additive manufacturing process. The study concluded that the resultant physical metallurgy of 3-D LENS 316L prototypes is dictated by the interactive metallurgical reactions, during instantaneous powder feeding/melting, molten metal flow and liquid metal solidification. The study also showed 3-D LENS manufacturing is capable of building high strength and ductile 316L prototypes due to its fine cellular spacing from fast solidification cooling, and the well-fused epitaxial interfaces at metal flow trails and interpass boundaries. However, without further LENS process control and optimization, the deposits are vulnerable to localized hardness variation attributed to heterogeneous microstructure, i.e., the interpass heat-affected zone (HAZ) from repetitive thermal heating during successive layer depositions. Most significantly, the current deposits exhibit anisotropic tensile behavior, i.e., lower strain and/or premature interpass delamination parallel to build direction (axial). This anisotropic behavior is attributed to the presence of interpass HAZ, which coexists with flying feedstock inclusions and porosity from incomplete molten metal fusion. The current observations and findings contribute to the scientific basis for future process control and optimization necessary for material property control and defect mitigation.
Several open-cell flexible foams, including aged polyurethane foams, were mechanically characterized over a temperature range of 40 to 20 °C. Quasi-static compression was performed to obtain the stress-strain behavior of the foams. The stress-strain relation is nonlinear, but typically there is a small range of linear behavior initially. Compressive cyclic loading at different amplitudes and frequencies of interest (20–60 Hz) were applied to measure foam’s hysteresis properties, i.e. stiffness and energy dissipation. The cyclic characterization includes foams with different amount of pre-strains, some are beyond the initial linear range as occurred in many applications.
Flexible open celled foams are commonly used for energy absorption in packaging. Over time polymers can suffer from aging by becoming stiffer and more brittle. This change in stiffness can affect the foam’s performance in a low velocity impact event. In this study, the compressive properties of new open-cell flexible polyurethane foam were compared to those obtained from aged open-cell polyurethane foam that had been in service for approximately 25 years. The foams tested had densities of 10 and 15 pcf. These low density foams provided a significant challenge to machine cylindrical compression specimens that were 1 “in height and 1” in diameter. Details of the machining process are discussed. The compressive properties obtained for both aged and new foams included testing at various strain rates (0.05. 0.10, 5 s-1) and temperatures (-54, RT, 74 °C). Results show that aging of flexible polyurethane foam does not have much of an effect on its compressive properties.
Flexible open celled foams are commonly used for energy absorption in packaging. Over time polymers can suffer from aging by becoming stiffer and more brittle. This change in stiffness can affect the foam’s performance in a low velocity impact event. In this study, the compressive properties of new open-cell flexible polyurethane foam were compared to those obtained from aged open-cell polyurethane foam that had been in service for approximately 25 years. The foams tested had densities of 10 and 15 pcf. These low density foams provided a significant challenge to machine cylindrical compression specimens that were 1 “in height and 1” in diameter. Details of the machining process are discussed. The compressive properties obtained for both aged and new foams included testing at various strain rates (0.05. 0.10, 5 s-1) and temperatures (-54, RT, 74 °C). Results show that aging of flexible polyurethane foam does not have much of an effect on its compressive properties.
As an optimum energy-absorbing material system, polymeric foams are needed to dissipate the kinetic energy of an impact, while maintaining the impact force transferred to the protected object at a low level. Therefore, it is crucial to accurately characterize the load bearing and energy dissipation performance of foams at high strain rate loading conditions. There are certain challenges faced in the accurate measurement of the deformation response of foams due to their low mechanical impedance. In the present work, a non-parametric method is successfully implemented to enable the accurate assessment of the compressive constitutive response of rigid polymeric foams subjected to impact loading conditions. The method is based on stereovision high speed photography in conjunction with 3D digital image correlation, and allows for accurate evaluation of inertia stresses developed within the specimen during deformation time. Full-field distributions of stress, strain and strain rate are used to extract the local constitutive response of the material at any given location along the specimen axis. In addition, the effective energy absorbed by the material is calculated. Finally, results obtained from the proposed non-parametric analysis are compared with data obtained from conventional test procedures.
Lu, Wei-Yang L.; Koohbor, Behrad; Kidane, Addis; Sutton, Michael A.
Dynamic stress-strain response of rigid closed-cell polymeric foams is investigated in this work by subjecting high toughness polyurethane foam specimens to direct impact with different projectile velocities and quantifying their deformation response with high speed stereo-photography together with 3D digital image correlation. The measured transient displacement field developed in the specimens during high stain rate loading is used to calculate the transient axial acceleration field throughout the specimen. A simple mathematical formulation based on conservation of mass is also proposed to determine the local change of density in the specimen during deformation. By obtaining the full-field acceleration and density distributions, the inertia stresses at each point in the specimen are determined through a non-parametric analysis and superimposed on the stress magnitudes measured at specimen ends to obtain the full-field stress distribution. The process outlined above overcomes a major challenge in high strain rate experiments with low impedance polymeric foam specimens, i.e. the delayed equilibrium conditions can be quantified.
Experiments were performed to characterize the mechanical response of several different rigid polyurethane foams to large deformation. In these experiments, the effects of load path, loading rate, and temperature were investigated. Results from these experiments indicated that rigid polyurethane foams exhibit significant damage, volumetric and deviatoric plasticity when they are compressed. Rigid polyurethane foams were also found to be extremely strain-rate and temperature dependent. These foams are also rather brittle and crack when loaded to small strains in tension or to larger strains in compression. Thus, a phenomenological Unified Creep Plasticity Damage (UCPD) model was developed to describe the mechanical response of these foams to large deformation at a variety of temperatures and strain rates. This paper includes a description of recent experiments and experimental findings. Next, development of a UCPD model for rigid, polyurethane foams is described. Finite element simulations with the new UCPD model are compared with experimental results to show behavior that can be captured with this model.
Experiments were performed to characterize the mechanical response of several different rigid polyurethane foams to large deformation. In these experiments, the effects of load path, loading rate, and temperature were investigated. Results from these experiments indicated that rigid polyurethane foams exhibit significant damage, volumetric and deviatoric plasticity when they are compressed. Rigid polyurethane foams were also found to be extremely strain-rate and temperature dependent. These foams are also rather brittle and crack when loaded to small strains in tension or to larger strains in compression. Thus, a phenomenological Unified Creep Plasticity Damage (UCPD) model was developed to describe the mechanical response of these foams to large deformation at a variety of temperatures and strain rates. This paper includes a description of recent experiments and experimental findings. Next, development of a UCPD model for rigid, polyurethane foams is described. Finite element simulations with the new UCPD model are compared with experimental results to show behavior that can be captured with this model.
A Hopkinson bar was employed to conduct transverse impact testing of twisted Kevlar KM2 fiber yarns at the same impact speed. The speed of Euler transverse wave generated by the impact was measured utilizing a high speed digital camera. The study included fiber yarns twisted by different amounts. The Euler transverse wave speed was observed to increase with increasing amount of twist of the fiber yarn, within the range of this investigation. The higher transverse wave speeds in the more twisted fiber yarns indicate better ballistic performance in soft body armors for personal protection.
Koohbor, Behrad; Mallon, Silas; Kidane, Addis; Lu, Wei-Yang L.
The present work aims to investigate the bulk deformation and failure response of closed-cell Polymeric Methylene Diphenyl Diisocyanate (PMDI) foams subjected to dynamic impact loading. First, foam specimens of different initial densities are examined and characterized in quasi-static loading conditions, where the deformation behavior of the samples is quantified in terms of the compressive elastic modulus and effective plastic Poisson's ratio. Then, the deformation response of the foam specimens subjected to direct impact loading is examined by taking into account the effects of material compressibility and inertia stresses developed during deformation, using high speed imaging in conjunction with 3D digital image correlation. The stress-strain response and the energy absorption as a function of strain rate and initial density are presented and the bulk failure mechanisms are discussed. It is observed that the initial density of the foam and the applied strain rates have a substantial influence on the strength, bulk failure mechanism and the energy dissipation characteristics of the foam specimens.
This report details a work in progress. We have attempted to calibrate and validate a Von Mises plasticity model with the Johnson-Cook failure criterion ( Johnson & Cook , 1985 ) against a set of experiments on various specimens of Al 6061-T651. As will be shown, the effort was not successful, despite considerable attention to detail. When the model was com- pared against axial-torsion experiments on tubes, it over predicted failure by 3 x in tension, and never predicted failure in torsion, even when the tube was twisted by 4 x further than the experiment. While this result is unfortunate, it is not surprising. Ductile failure is not well understood. In future work, we will explore whether more sophisticated material mod- els of plasticity and failure will improve the predictions. Selecting the appropriate advanced material model and interpreting the results of said model are not trivial exercises, so it is worthwhile to fully investigate the behavior of a simple plasticity model before moving on to an anisotropic yield surface or a similarly complicated model.
Foam materials are used to protect sensitive components from impact loading. In order to predict and simulate the foam performance under various loading conditions, a validated foam model is needed and the mechanical properties of foams need to be characterized. Uniaxial compression and tension tests were conducted for different densities of foams under various temperatures and loading rates. Crush stress, tensile strength, and elastic modulus were obtained. A newly developed confined compression experiment provided data for investigating the foam flow direction. A biaxial tension experiment was also developed to explore the damage surface of a rigid polyurethane foam.
Recent experimental investigations show that most models are not able to capture the ductile behavior of metal alloys in the entire triaxiality range, especially at low triaxiality. Modelers are moving beyond stress triaxiality as the dominant indicator of material failure and developing constitutive models that incorporate shear into the evolution of the failure model. Available data that cover low triaxiality range are rare and a series of critical experiments is needed. Here, experiments of smooth thin as well as notched tubular specimens of Al6061-T651 under combined tension-torsion loading were conducted. This provides a very basic set of data for phenomenological models. A full-field deformation technique, digital image correlation (DIC), was applied to these tests to allow measurement of the field deformation, including the notched area. The microstructural features of the tested specimens were characterized to better understand the different failure mechanisms which led to ductility variation in the aluminum alloy.
This report summarizes computational efforts to model interfacial fracture using cohesive zone models in the SIERRA/SolidMechanics (SIERRA/SM) finite element code. Cohesive surface elements were used to model crack initiation and propagation along predefined paths. Mesh convergence was observed with SIERRA/SM for numerous geometries. As the funding for this project came from the Advanced Simulation and Computing Verification and Validation (ASC V&V) focus area, considerable effort was spent performing verification and validation. Code verification was performed to compare code predictions to analytical solutions for simple three-element simulations as well as a higher-fidelity simulation of a double-cantilever beam. Parameter identification was conducted with Dakota using experimental results on asymmetric double-cantilever beam (ADCB) and end-notched-flexure (ENF) experiments conducted under Campaign-6 funding. Discretization convergence studies were also performed with respect to mesh size and time step and an optimization study was completed for mode II delamination using the ENF geometry. Throughout this verification process, numerous SIERRA/SM bugs were found and reported, all of which have been fixed, leading to over a 10-fold increase in convergence rates. Finally, mixed-mode flexure experiments were performed for validation. One of the unexplained issues encountered was material property variability for ostensibly the same composite material. Since the variability is not fully understood, it is difficult to accurately assess uncertainty when performing predictions.
This report contains the one-year feasibility study for our three-year LDRD proposal that is aimed to develop an experimental technique to measure the 3D deformation fields inside a material body. In this feasibility study, we first apply Digital Volume Correlation (DVC) algorithm to pre-existing in-situ Xray Computed Tomography (XCT) image sets with pure rigid body translation. The calculated displacement field has very large random errors and low precision that are unacceptable. Then we enhance these tomography images by setting threshold of the intensity of each slice. DVC algorithm is able to obtain accurate deformation fields from these enhanced image sets and the deformation fields are consistent with the global mechanical loading that is applied to the specimen. Through this study, we prove that the internal markers inside the pre-existing tomography images of aluminum alloy can be enhanced and are suitable for DVC to calculate the deformation field throughout the material body.
This paper compares measurements made by Raman and infrared thermometry on a SOI (silicon on insulator) bent-beam thermal microactuator. Both techniques are noncontact and used to experimentally measure temperatures along the legs and on the shuttle of the thermal microactuators. Raman thermometry offers micron spatial resolution and measurement uncertainties of {+-}10 K; however, typical data collection times are a minute per location leading to measurement times on the order of hours for a complete temperature profile. Infrared thermometry obtains a full-field measurement so the data collection time is much shorter; however, the spatial resolution is lower and calibrating the system for quantitative measurements is challenging. By obtaining thermal profiles on the same SOI thermal microactuator, the relative strengths and weaknesses of the two techniques are assessed.