Experiments offer incredible value to science, but results must always come with an uncertainty quantification to be meaningful. This requires grappling with sources of uncertainty and how to reduce them. In wind energy, field experiments are sometimes conducted with a control and treatment. In this scenario uncertainty due to bias errors can often be neglected as they impact both control and treatment approximately equally. However, uncertainty due to random errors propagates such that the uncertainty in the difference between the control and treatment is always larger than the random uncertainty in the individual measurements if the sources are uncorrelated. As random uncertainties are usually reduced with additional measurements, there is a need to know the minimum duration of an experiment required to reach acceptable levels of uncertainty. We present a general method to simulate a proposed experiment, calculate uncertainties, and determine both the measurement duration and the experiment duration required to produce statistically significant and converged results. The method is then demonstrated as a case study with a virtual experiment that uses real-world wind resource data and several simulated tip extensions to parameterize results by the expected difference in power. With the method demonstrated herein, experiments can be better planned by accounting for specific details such as controller switching schedules, wind statistics, and postprocess binning procedures such that their impacts on uncertainty can be predicted and the measurement duration needed to achieve statistically significant and converged results can be determined before the experiment.
This paper provides a summary of planning work for experiments that will be necessary to address the long-term model validation needs required to meet offshore wind energy deployment goals. Conceptual experiments are identified and laid out in a validation hierarchy for both wind turbine and wind plant applications. Instrumentation needs that will be required for the offshore validation experiments to be impactful are then listed. The document concludes with a nominal vision for how these experiments can be accomplished.
Multiple rotors on single structures have long been proposed to increase wind turbine energy capture with no increase in rotor size, but at the cost of additional mechanical complexity in the yaw and tower designs. Standard turbines on their own very-closely-spaced towers avoid these disadvantages but create a significant disadvantage; for some wind directions the wake turbulence of a rotor enters the swept area of a very close downwind rotor causing low output, fatigue stress, and changes in wake recovery. Knowing how the performance of pairs of closely spaced rotors varies with wind direction is essential to design a layout that maximizes the useful directions and minimizes the losses and stress at other directions. In the current work, the high-fidelity large-eddy simulation (LES) code Exa-Wind/Nalu-Wind is used to simulate the wake interactions from paired-rotor configurations in a neutrally stratified atmospheric boundary layer to investigate performance and feasibility. Each rotor pair consists of two Vestas V27 turbines with hub-to-hub separation distances of 1.5 rotor diameters. The on-design wind direction results are consistent with previous literature. For an off-design wind direction of 26.6°, results indicate little change in power and far-wake recovery relative to the on-design case. At a direction of 45.0°, significant rotor-wake interactions produce an increase in power but also in far-wake velocity deficit and turbulence intensity. A severely off-design case is also considered.
A large-scale numerical computation of five wind farms was performed as a part of the American WAKE experimeNt (AWAKEN). This high-fidelity computation used the ExaWind/AMR-Wind LES solver to simulate a 100 km × 100 km domain containing 541 turbines under unstable atmospheric conditions matching previous measurements. The turbines were represented by Joukowski and OpenFAST coupled actuator disk models. Results of this qualitative comparison illustrate the interactions of wind farms with large-scale ABL structures in the flow, as well as the extent of downstream wake penetration in the flow and blockage effects around wind farms.
Multiple rotors on single structures have long been proposed to increase wind turbine energy capture with no increase in rotor size, but at the cost of additional mechanical complexity in the yaw and tower designs. Standard turbines on their own very-closely-spaced towers avoid these disadvantages but create a significant disadvantage; for some wind directions the wake turbulence of a rotor enters the swept area of a very close downwind rotor causing low output, fatigue stress, and changes in wake recovery. Knowing how the performance of pairs of closely spaced rotors varies with wind direction is essential to design a layout that maximizes the useful directions and minimizes the losses and stress at other directions. In the current work, the high-fidelity large-eddy simulation (LES) code Exa-Wind/Nalu-Wind is used to simulate the wake interactions from paired-rotor configurations in a neutrally stratified atmospheric boundary layer to investigate performance and feasibility. Each rotor pair consists of two Vestas V27 turbines with hub-to-hub separation distances of 1.5 rotor diameters. The on-design wind direction results are consistent with previous literature. For an off-design wind direction of 26.6°, results indicate little change in power and far-wake recovery relative to the on-design case. At a direction of 45.0°, significant rotor-wake interactions produce an increase in power but also in far-wake velocity deficit and turbulence intensity. A severely off-design case is also considered.
This paper describes the methodology of designing a replacement blade tip and winglet for a wind turbine blade to demonstrate the potential of additive-manufacturing for wind energy. The team will later field-demonstrate this additive-manufactured, system-integrated tip (AMSIT) on a wind turbine. The blade tip aims to reduce the cost of wind energy by improving aerodynamic performance and reliability, while reducing transportation costs. This paper focuses on the design and modeling of a winglet for increased power production while maintaining acceptable structural loads of the original Vestas V27 blade design. A free-wake vortex model, WindDVE, was used for the winglet design analysis. A summary of the aerodynamic design process is presented along with a case study of a specific design.
The leading edge erosion of wind turbine blades is a common issue that can have a range of implications for the operation and maintenance of the turbine. A variety of methods have attempted to determine the severity of erosion damage, applied in different academic, testing and in-situ settings. This paper describes the current state of the art in categorization, and the individual drivers in assessment. From this foundation, the IEA Wind Task 46 WP3 group collated key considerations from the process of categorizing erosion damage and a proposed erosion classification system was put forward. Trial assessments were performed using the initial system, which led to adjustments to the original proposition. The refined system defines discrete severity levels that concern the wind turbine blade: (1) Visual Condition (concerning blades with/without leading edge protection); (2) Mass Loss; (3) Aerodynamic Performance; and (4) Structural Integrity. The classification system presented is not intended to be a fixed entity. The Task 46 group has already identified specific challenges and opportunities that are applicable to individual use and the overall wind energy industry. The intention is for the system to evolve as improvements are identified, technology improves, and work progresses through other Task 46 activities. Several considerations and recommendations are discussed that could be applicable for future implementation of the system.
Advances in wind-plant control have often focused on more effectively balancing power between neighboring turbines. Wake steering is one such method that provides control-based improvements in a quasi-static way, but this does little to fundamentally change the wake recovery process, and thus, it has limited potential. This study investigates use of another control paradigm known as dynamic wake control (DWC) to excite the mutual inductance instability between adjacent tip-vortex structures, thereby accelerating the breakdown of the structures. The current work carries this approach beyond the hypothetical by applying the excitation via turbine control vectors that already exist on all modern wind turbines: blade pitch and rotor speed control. The investigation leverages a free-vortex wake method (FVWM) that allows a thorough exploration of relevant frequencies and amplitudes of harmonic forcing for each control vector (as well as the phase difference between the vectors for a tandem configuration) while still capturing the essential tip-vortex dynamics. The FVWM output feeds into a Fourier stability analysis working to pinpoint candidate DWC strategies suggesting fastest wake recovery. Near-wake length reductions of >80% are demonstrated, although without considering inflow turbulence. Analysis is provided to interpret these predictions considering the presence of turbulence in a real atmospheric inflow.
The complexity and associated uncertainties involved with atmospheric-turbine-wake interactions produce challenges for accurate wind farm predictions of generator power and other important quantities of interest (QoIs), even with state-of-the-art high-fidelity atmospheric and turbine models. A comprehensive computational study was undertaken with consideration of simulation methodology, parameter selection, and mesh refinement on atmospheric, turbine, and wake QoIs to identify capability gaps in the validation process. For neutral atmospheric boundary layer conditions, the massively parallel large eddy simulation (LES) code Nalu-Wind was used to produce high-fidelity computations for experimental validation using high-quality meteorological, turbine, and wake measurement data collected at the Department of Energy/Sandia National Laboratories Scaled Wind Farm Technology (SWiFT) facility located at Texas Tech University's National Wind Institute. The wake analysis showed the simulated lidar model implemented in Nalu-Wind was successful at capturing wake profile trends observed in the experimental lidar data.
Develop, verify, and document model capabilities sufficient for comparing field wake measurements from SWiFT with synthetic lidar wake measurements from Nalu-Wind (hereafter referred to as `Nalu').