Adsorption of noble gas fission products onto naturally occurring minerals is of interest for its potential to retain or retard emissions from nuclear fuel reprocessing operations or underground nuclear explosions. However, experimental studies of trace noble gas adsorption in the presence of air and water have largely focused on synthetic materials, such as activated carbon or metal-organic frameworks. Here, adsorption of Kr and Xe onto the naturally occurring zeolitic mineral clinoptilolite is studied in the presence of nitrogen and water. By varying the composition of the gas phase and monitoring the change in the combined adsorbate mass, the adsorbed concentration of noble gas is calculated gravimetrically. For dry clinoptilolite, the concentration of adsorbed Kr and Xe is linearly correlated with noble gas pressure and Henry's Law appears satisfactory, despite the presence of nitrogen at atmospheric pressures. However, the presence of water significantly reduces the adsorbed concentration of both Kr and Xe, which is typical in nanoporous sorbents. Here, an empirical bivariate model is presented, combining the Henry's Law adsorption model for a dry adsorbent with the exponential reduction in the presence of water, as reported by Lungu and Underhill in 1999. This model provides a means to estimate the adsorbate concentration at the trace partial pressures and higher water contents relevant to field-scale modeling of fission gas transport through the vadose zone.
Geogenic Helium-4 (4He) in-situ increases locally in regions of large deformation generated naturally or anthropogenically. This gas release by deformation is a potential geochemical precursor signal for subsurface deformation. To evaluate the applicability of 4He degassing for correlating deformation in different lithologies, we conducted high force crush tests, up to 97,800 N axial load, to assess the total 4He released during fragmentation of the rocks. We observed that the highest 4He released occurred in the sedimentary rocks and that release correlated strongly with lithologic age and U/Th content. Microstructural changes of the pre- and post-test rocks indicate that the degree of grain size reduction relates directly to the total 4He released during crushing. The range of in-place 4He was calculated based XRF measurements of uranium and thorium in each lithology, with the results indicating that the majority of the trapped 4He was not released. However, the 4He released by deformation depended upon how the each rock deformed during deformation and the degree of grain size reduction. We postulate that 4He precursor signals can be used to understand subsurface deformation only if geomechanical and geochemical conditions for 4He enrichment in a lithology are met.
The Spent Fuel & Waste Science and Technology (SFWST) Campaign of the Office of Spent Fuel & Waste Disposition of U.S. Department of Energy Office of Nuclear Energy (DOE-NE) is conducting research and development on geologic disposal of spent nuclear fuel (SNF) and high-level nuclear waste (HLW). This report describes fiscal year 2024 accomplishments in the Geologic Disposal Safety Assessment (GDSA) PFLOTRAN Development work package, which is charged with developing subsurface simulation software for postclosure performance assessment of deep geologic disposal of SNF and HLW.
This report summarizes fiscal year 2024 (FY24) activities centered around a series of field tests in bedded salt at the Waste Isolation Pilot Plant (WIPP) funded by the Office of Spent Fuel and Waste Science and Technology in the Spent Fuel and Waste Disposition (SFWD) program of the US Department of Energy’s Office of Nuclear Energy (DOE-NE). High-level Purpose of Experiments: The Brine Availability Test in Salt (BATS) field tests are revealing both brine occurrence (i.e., where, and how much) and brine migration (i.e., how easily it moves) in the excavation damaged zone (EDZ). This understanding is foundational to develop a safety case for a future heat-generating waste repository in salt, and to starting up a generic repository program in salt to buy down risk. BATS seeks to predict how much brine can flow into both ambient and heated excavations (e.g., boreholes or rooms) in salt. This work is educating and empowering new repository scientists on two fronts: “design and execution of field tests” and “prediction and modeling of coupled processes.” DOE-NE capabilities in salt have grown and been tested through international modeling and benchmarking exercises (e.g., DECOVALEX, RANGERS, KOMPASS, and MEASURES; see Mills et al., 2024). The hands-on expertise we are building is a necessary step towards large-scale disposal demonstrations and eventual implementation.
The goal of this project is to investigate the molecular interactions of H2 with earth materials (EMs) that may potentially affect economics and safety of H2 geological storage (HGS). We investigated (1) the H2 intercalation into interlayers of phyllosilicates, (2) the competitive adsorption of H2/CH4 onto porous materials, and (3) solubility of H2 in interfacial and confined hydrocarbons. Our results indicate that (i) H2 intercalation into hydrated interlayers is thermodynamically unfavorable and H2 solubility in hydrated clay interlayers is in the same order of magnitude as that in bulk water, (ii) CH4 outcompetes H2 in adsorption onto kerogen, due to stronger CH4-kerogen interactions than H2-kerogen interactions, (iii) H2 tends to dissolve more in oil than in water, and the introduction of CO2 as a cushion gas reduces H2 partitioning near the kaolinite surfaces. The outcomes provide foundational knowledge for preparing the USA for future storage site selection and storage system design, supporting DOE missions in clean and secured energy.
Geogenic gases often reside in intergranular pore space, fluid inclusions, and within mineral grains. In particular, helium-4 (4He) is generated by alpha decay of uranium and thorium in rocks. The emitted 4He nuclei can be trapped in the rock matrix or in fluid inclusions. Recent work has shown that releases of helium occur during plastic deformation of crustal rocks above atmospheric concentrations that are detectable in the field. However, it is unclear how rock type and deformation modalities affect the cumulative gas released. This work seeks to address how different deformation modalities observed in several rock types affect release of helium. Axial compression tests with granite, rhyolite, tuff, dolostone, and sandstone - under vacuum conditions - were conducted to measure the transient release of helium from each sample during crushing. It was found that, when crushed up to 97500 N, each rock type released helium at a rate quantifiable using a helium mass spectrometer leak detector. For plutonic rock like granite, helium flow rate spikes with the application of force as the samples elastically deform until fracture, then decays slowly until grain breakdown comminution begins to occur. Both the rhyolite and tuff do not experience such large spikes in helium flow rate, with the rhyolites fracturing at much lower force and the tuffs compacting instead of fracturing due to their high porosity. Both rhyolite and tuff instead experience a lesser but steady helium release as they are crushed. The cumulative helium release for the volcanic tuffs varies as much as two orders of magnitude but is fairly consistent for the denser rhyolite and granite tested. The results indicate that there is a large degassing of helium as rocks are elastically and inelastically deformed prior to fracturing. For more porous and less brittle rocks, the cumulative release will depend more on the degree of deformation applied. These results are compared with known U/Th radioisotopes in the rocks to relate the trapped helium as either produced in the rock or from secondary migration of 4He.
Geogenic gases often reside in intergranular pore space, fluid inclusions, and within mineral grains. In particular, helium-4 (4He) is generated by alpha decay of uranium and thorium in rocks. The emitted 4He nuclei can be trapped in the rock matrix or in fluid inclusions. Recent work has shown that releases of helium occur during plastic deformation of crustal rocks above atmospheric concentrations that are detectable in the field. However, it is unclear how rock type and deformation modalities affect the cumulative gas released. This work seeks to address how different deformation modalities observed in several rock types affect release of helium. Axial compression tests with granite, rhyolite, tuff, dolostone, and sandstone - under vacuum conditions - were conducted to measure the transient release of helium from each sample during crushing. It was found that, when crushed up to 97500 N, each rock type released helium at a rate quantifiable using a helium mass spectrometer leak detector. For plutonic rock like granite, helium flow rate spikes with the application of force as the samples elastically deform until fracture, then decays slowly until grain breakdown comminution begins to occur. Both the rhyolite and tuff do not experience such large spikes in helium flow rate, with the rhyolites fracturing at much lower force and the tuffs compacting instead of fracturing due to their high porosity. Both rhyolite and tuff instead experience a lesser but steady helium release as they are crushed. The cumulative helium release for the volcanic tuffs varies as much as two orders of magnitude but is fairly consistent for the denser rhyolite and granite tested. The results indicate that there is a large degassing of helium as rocks are elastically and inelastically deformed prior to fracturing. For more porous and less brittle rocks, the cumulative release will depend more on the degree of deformation applied. These results are compared with known U/Th radioisotopes in the rocks to relate the trapped helium as either produced in the rock or from secondary migration of 4He.
The heat generated by high-level radioactive waste can pose numerical and physical challenges to subsurface flow and transport simulators if the liquid water content in a region near the waste package approaches residual saturation due to evaporation. Here, residual saturation is the fraction of the pore space occupied by liquid water when the hydraulic connectivity through a porous medium is lost, preventing the flow of liquid water. While conventional capillary pressure models represent residual saturation using asymptotically large values of capillary pressure, here, residual saturation is effectively modeled as a tortuosity effect alone. Treating the residual fluid as primarily dead-end pores and adsorbed films, relative permeability is independent of capillary pressure below residual saturation. To test this approach, PFLOTRAN is then used to simulate thermal-hydrological conditions resulting from direct disposal of a dual-purpose canister in unsaturated alluvium using both conventional asymptotic and revised, smooth models. Importantly, while the two models have comparable results over 100 000 years, the number of flow steps required is reduced by approximately 94%.
This report summarizes the fiscal year 2023 (FY23) status of the second phase of a series of borehole heater tests in salt at the Waste Isolation Pilot Plant (WIPP) funded by the Disposal Research and Development (R&D) program of the Spent Fuel & Waste Science and Technology (SFWST) office at the US Department of Energy’s Office of Nuclear Energy’s (DOE-NE) Office in the Spent Fuel and Waste Disposition (SFWD) program.
An analytical expression is derived for the thermal response observed during spontaneous imbibition of water into a dry core of zeolitic tuff. Sample tortuosity, thermal conductivity, and thermal source strength are estimated from fitting an analytical solution to temperature observations during a single laboratory test. The closed-form analytical solution is derived using Green's functions for heat conduction in the limit of “slow” water movement; that is, when advection of thermal energy with the wetting front is negligible. The solution has four free fitting parameters and is efficient for parameter estimation. Laboratory imbibition data used to constrain the model include a time series of the mass of water imbibed, visual location of the wetting front through time, and temperature time series at six locations. The thermal front reached the end of the core hours before the visible wetting front. Thus, the predominant form of heating during imbibition in this zeolitic tuff is due to vapor adsorption in dry zeolitic rock ahead of the wetting front. The separation of the wetting front and thermal front in this zeolitic tuff is significant, compared to wetting front behavior of most materials reported in the literature. This work is the first interpretation of a thermal imbibition response to estimate transport (tortuosity) and thermal properties (including thermal conductivity) from a single laboratory test.
Strong gas-mineral interactions or slow adsorption kinetics require a molecular-level understanding of both adsorption and diffusion for these interactions to be properly described in transport models. In this combined molecular simulation and experimental study, noble gas adsorption and mobility is investigated in two naturally abundant zeolites whose pores are similar in size (clinoptilolite) and greater than (mordenite) the gas diameters. Simulated adsorption isotherms obtained from grand canonical Monte Carlo simulations indicate that both zeolites can accommodate even the largest gas (Rn). However, gas mobility in clinoptilolite is significantly hindered at pore-limiting window sites, as seen from molecular dynamics simulations in both bulk and slab zeolite models. Experimental gas adsorption isotherms for clinoptilolite confirm the presence of a kinetic barrier to Xe uptake, resulting in the unusual property of reverse Kr/Xe selectivity. Finally, a kinetic model is used to fit the simulated gas loading profiles, allowing a comparison of trends in gas diffusivity in the zeolite pores.
A natural clinoptilolite sample near the Nevada National Security Site was obtained to study adsorption and retardation on gas transport. Of interest is understanding the competition for adsorption sites that may reduce tracer gas adsorption relative to single-component measurements, which may be affected by the multi-scale pore structure of clinoptilolite. Clinoptilolite has three distinct domains of pore size distributions ranging from nanometers to micrometers: micropores with 0.4–0.7 nm diameters, measured on powders by CO2 adsorption at 273 K, representing the zeolite cages; mesopores with 4–200 nm diameters, observed using liquid nitrogen adsorption at 77 K; and macropores with 300–1000 nm diameters, measured by mercury injection on rock chips (~ 100 mesh), likely representing the microfractures. These pore size distributions are consistent with X-ray computed tomography (CT) and focused ion beam scanning electron microscope (FIB-SEM) images, which are used to construct the three-dimensional (3D) pore network to be used in future gas transport modeling. To quantify tracer gas adsorption in this multi-scale pore structure and multicomponent gas species environment, natural zeolite samples initially in equilibrium in air were exposed to a mixture of tracer gases. As the tracer gases diffuse and adsorb in the sample, the remaining tracer gases outside the sample fractionate. Using a quadrupole mass spectrometer to quantify this fractionation, the degree of adsorption of tracer gases in the multicomponent gas environment and multi-scale pore structure is assessed. The major finding is that Kr reaches equilibrium much faster than Xe in the presence of ambient air, which leads to more Kr uptake than Xe over limited exposure periods. When the clinoptilolite chips were exposed to humid air, the adsorption capability decreases significantly for both Xe and Kr with relative humidity (RH) as low as 3%. Both Xe and Kr reaches equilibrium faster at higher RH. The different, unexpected, adsorption behavior for Xe and Kr is due to their kinetic diameters similar to the micropores in clinoptilolite which makes it harder for Xe to access compared to Kr.
Coupling multiphase flow with energy transport due to high temperature heat sources introduces significant new challenges since boiling and condensation processes can lead to dry-out conditions with subsequent re-wetting. The transition between two-phase and single-phase behavior can require changes to the primary dependent variables adding discontinuities as well as extending constitutive nonlinear relations to extreme physical conditions. Practical simulations of large-scale engineered domains lead to Jacobian systems with a very large number of unknowns that must be solved efficiently using iterative methods in parallel on high-performance computers. Performance assessment of potential nuclear repositories, carbon sequestration sites and geothermal reservoirs can require numerous Monte-Carlo simulations to explore uncertainty in material properties, boundary conditions, and failure scenarios. Due to the numerical challenges, standard NR iteration may not converge over the range of required simulations and require more sophisticated optimization method like trust-region. We use the open-source simulator PFLOTRAN for the important practical problem of the safety assessment of future nuclear waste repositories in the U.S. DOE geologic disposal safety assessment Framework. The simulator applies the PETSc parallel framework and a backward Euler, finite volume discretization. We demonstrate failure of the conventional NR method and the success of trust-region modifications to Newton's method for a series of test problems of increasing complexity. Trust-region methods essentially modify the Newton step size and direction under some circumstances where the standard NR iteration can cause the solution to diverge or oscillate. We show how the Newton Trust-Region method can be adapted for Primary Variable Switching (PVS) when the multiphase state changes due to boiling or condensation. The simulations with high-temperature heat sources which led to extreme nonlinear processes with many state changes in the domain did not converge with NR, but they do complete successfully with the trust-region methods modified for PVS. This implementation effectively decreased weeks of simulation time needing manual adjustments to complete a simulation down to a day. Furthermore, we show the strong scalability of the methods on a single node and multiple nodes in an HPC cluster.
Tracer gases, whether they are chemical or isotopic in nature, are useful tools in examining the flow and transport of gaseous or volatile species in the underground. One application is using detection of short-lived argon and xenon radionuclides to monitor for underground nuclear explosions. However, even chemically inert species, such as the noble gases, have bene observed to exhibit non-conservative behavior when flowing through porous media containing certain materials, such as zeolites, due to gas adsorption processes. This report details the model developed, implemented, and tested in the open source and massively parallel subsurface flow and transport simulator PFLOTRAN for future use in modeling the transport of adsorbing tracer gases.
The Spent Fuel & Waste Science and Technology (SFWST) Campaign of the U.S. Department of Energy (DOE) Office of Nuclear Energy (NE), Office of Spent Fuel & Waste Disposition (SFWD) is conducting research and development (R&D) on geologic disposal of spent nuclear fuel (SNF) and high-level nuclear waste (HLW). A high priority for SFWST disposal R&D is to develop a disposal system modeling and analysis capability for evaluating disposal system performance for nuclear waste in geologic media. This report describes fiscal year (FY) 2022 accomplishments by the PFLOTRAN Development group of the SFWST Campaign. The mission of this group is to develop a geologic disposal system modeling capability for nuclear waste that can be used to probabilistically assess the performance of generic disposal concepts. In FY 2022, the PFLOTRAN development team made several advancements to our software infrastructure, code performance, and process modeling capabilities.
Estimation of two-phase fluid flow properties is important to understand and predict water and gas movement through the vadose zone for agricultural, hydrogeological, and engineering applications, such as containment transport and/or containment of gases in the subsurface. To estimate rock fluid flow properties and subsequently predict physically realistic processes such as patterns and timing of water, gas, and energy (e.g., heat) movement in the subsurface, laboratory spontaneous water imbibition with simultaneous temperature measurement and numerical modeling methods are presented in the FY22 progress report. A multiple-overlapping-continua conceptual model is used to explain and predict observed complex multi-phenomenological laboratory test behavior during spontaneous imbibition experiments. This report primarily addresses two complexities that arise during the experiments: 1) capturing the late-time behavior of spontaneous imbibition tests with dual porosity; and 2) understanding the thermal perturbation observed at or ahead of the imbibing wetting front, which are associated with adsorption of water in initially dry samples. We use numerical approaches to explore some of these issues, but also lay out a plan for further laboratory experimentation and modeling to best understand and leverage these unique observations.
Two-phase fluid flow properties underlie quantitative prediction of water and gas movement, but constraining these properties typically requires multiple time-consuming laboratory methods. The estimation of two-phase flow properties (van Genuchten parameters, porosity, and intrinsic permeability) is illustrated in cores of vitric nonwelded volcanic tuff using Bayesian parameter estimation that fits numerical models to observations from spontaneous imbibition experiments. The uniqueness and correlation of the estimated parameters is explored using different modeling assumptions and subsets of the observed data. The resulting estimation process is sensitive to both moisture retention and relative permeability functions, thereby offering a comprehensive method for constraining both functions. The data collected during this relatively simple laboratory experiment, used in conjunction with a numerical model and a global optimizer, result in a viable approach for augmenting more traditional capillary pressure data obtained from hanging water column, membrane plate extractor, or mercury intrusion methods. This method may be useful when imbibition rather than drainage parameters are sought, when larger samples (e.g., including heterogeneity or fractures) need to be tested that cannot be accommodated in more traditional methods, or when in educational laboratory settings.
