In this study we present a replication method to determine surface roughness and to identify surface features when a sample cannot be directly analyzed by conventional techniques. As a demonstration, this method was applied to an unused spent nuclear fuel dry storage canister to determine variation across different surface features. In this study, an initial material down-selection was performed to determine the best molding agent and determined that non-modified Polytek PlatSil23-75 provided the most accurate representation of the surface while providing good usability. Other materials that were considered include Polygel Brush-On 35 polyurethane rubber (with and without Pol-ease 2300 release agent), Polytek PlatSil73-25 silicone rubber (with and without PlatThix thickening agent and Pol-ease 2300 release agent), and Express STD vinylpolysiloxane impression putty. The ability of PlatSil73-25 to create an accurate surface replica was evaluated by creating surface molds of several locations on surface roughness standards representing ISO grade surfaces N3, N5, N7, and N8. Overall, the molds were able to accurately reproduce the expected roughness average (Ra) values, but systematically over-estimated the peak-valley maximum roughness (Rz) values. Using a 3D printed sample cell, several locations across the stainless steel spent nuclear fuel canister were sampled to determine the surface roughness. These measurements provided information regarding variability in normal surface roughness across the canister as well as a detailed evaluation on specific surface features (e.g., welds, grind marks, etc.). The results of these measurements can support development of dry storage canister ageing management programs, as surface roughness is an important factor for surface dust deposition and accumulation. This method can be applied more broadly to different surfaces beyond stainless steel to provide rapid, accurate surface replications for analytical evaluation by profilometry.
The formation of magnesium chloride-hydroxide salts (magnesium hydroxychlorides) has implications for many geochemical processes and technical applications. For this reason, a thermodynamic database for evaluating the Mg(OH)2–MgCl2–H2O ternary system from 0 °C–120 °C has been developed based on extensive experimental solubility data. Internally consistent sets of standard thermodynamic parameters (ΔGf°, ΔHf°, S°, and CP) were derived for several solid phases: 3 Mg(OH)2:MgCl2:8H2O, 9 Mg(OH)2:MgCl2:4H2O, 2 Mg(OH)2:MgCl2:4H2O, 2 Mg(OH)2:MgCl2: 2H2O(s), brucite (Mg(OH)2), bischofite (MgCl2:6H2O), and MgCl2:4H2O. First, estimated values for the thermodynamic parameters were derived using a component addition method. These parameters were combined with standard thermodynamic data for Mg2+(aq) consistent with CODATA (Cox et al., 1989) to generate temperature-dependent Gibbs energies for the dissolution reactions of the solid phases. These data, in combination with values for MgOH+(aq) updated to be consistent with Mg2+-CODATA, were used to compute equilibrium constants and incorporated into a Pitzer thermodynamic database for concentrated electrolyte solutions. Phase solubility diagrams were constructed as a function of temperature and magnesium chloride concentration for comparisons with available experimental data. To improve the fits to the experimental data, reaction equilibrium constants for the Mg-bearing mineral phases, the binary Pitzer parameters for the MgOH+ — Cl− interaction, and the temperature-dependent coefficients for those Pitzer parameters were constrained by experimental phase boundaries and to match phase solubilities. These parameter adjustments resulted in an updated set of standard thermodynamic data and associated temperature-dependent functions. The resulting database has direct applications to investigations of magnesia cement formation and leaching, chemical barrier interactions related to disposition of heat-generating nuclear waste, and evaluation of magnesium-rich salt and brine stabilities at elevated temperatures.
This report documents the results of a long-term (5.79 year) exposure of 4-point bend corrosion test samples in the inlet and outlet vents of four spent nuclear fuel dry storage systems at the Maine Yankee Independent Spent Fuel Storage Installation. The goal of the test was to evaluate the corrosiveness of salt aerosols in a realistic near-marine environment, providing a data set for improved understanding of stress corrosion cracking of spent nuclear fuel dry storage canisters. Examination of the samples after extraction showed minor corrosion was present, mostly on rough-ground surfaces. However, dye penetrant testing showed that no SCC cracks were present. Dust collected on coupons co-located with the corrosion specimens was analyzed by scanning electron microscopy and leached to determine the soluble salts present. The dust was mostly organic material (pollen and stellate trichomes), with lesser detrital mineral grains. Salts present were a mix of sea-salts and continental salts, with chloride dominating the anions, but significant amounts of nitrate were also present. Both corrosion samples and dust samples showed evidence of wetting, indicating entry of water into the vents. The results of this field test suggest that the environment at Maine Yankee is not highly aggressive, although extrapolation from the periodically wetted vent samples to the hot, dry, canister surface may be difficult. No stress corrosion cracks were observed, but minor corrosion was present despite high nitrate concentrations in the salts. These observations may help address the ongoing question of the importance of nitrate in suppressing corrosion and SCC.
Work evaluating spent nuclear fuel (SNF) dry storage canister surface environments and canister corrosion progressed significantly in FY23, with the goal of developing a scientific understanding of the processes controlling initiation and growth of stress corrosion cracking (SCC) cracks in stainless steel canisters in relevant storage environments. The results of the work performed at Sandia National Laboratories (SNL) will guide future work and will contribute to the development of better tools for predicting potential canister penetration by SCC.
This report summarizes the activities performed by Sandia National Laboratories in FY23 to identify and test coating materials for the prevention, mitigation, and/or repair of potential chloride-induced stress corrosion cracking in spent nuclear fuel dry storage canisters. This work continues efforts by Sandia National Laboratories that are summarized in previous reports from FY20 through FY22 on the same topic. In FY23, Sandia National Laboratories, in collaboration with five industry partners through a memorandum of understanding, evaluated the physical, mechanical, and corrosion-resistance properties of eight different coating systems. The evaluation included thermal and radiation environments relevant to various time periods of storage for spent nuclear fuel canisters. The coating systems include polymeric (polyetherketoneketone, modified polyimide/polyurea, modified phenolic resin, epoxy), organic/inorganic ceramic hybrids (silane-based polyurethane hybrid and a quasi-ceramic sol-gel polyurethane hybrid), and coatings utilizing a Zn-rich primer applied to stainless steel coupons. The results and implications of these tests are summarized in this report. These analyses will be used to identify the most effective coatings for potential use on spent nuclear fuel dry storage canisters and to identify specific needs for further optimization of coating technologies for application on spent nuclear fuel canisters.
This report describes the results of preliminary testing of aerosol monitoring equipment that will be used to continuously monitor the aerosol source term for the multi-year Canister Deposition Field Demonstration (CDFD). These data are required inputs for the development and validation of models for the deposition of dust and potentially corrosive salts on the surface of spent nuclear fuel (SNF) dry storage canisters. Surface salt loads correlate with the extent of corrosion damage on a metal surface, and potentially to the likelihood and timing of initiation of stress corrosion cracks. Aerosols will be monitored at the CDFD site using three instruments. A Dekati® ELPI+ cascade impactor will be used for real-time monitoring of aerosol particle sizes. It will also collect dust in 14 size bins on impactor targets that can be chemically analyzed to determine the soluble salts present as a function of particle size. However, this instrument can only measure dried aerosols, with a diameter of <10 µm. The second instrument is a Topas laser particle size spectrometer, which provides real-time monitoring of aerosol particle sizes up to ~40 µm in size. It monitors both the ambient (potentially deliquesced) aerosol particle size distributions required for the dust deposition models and the distributions of the equivalent dried particles, allowing correlation with the Dekati® data. However, it does not discriminate between inert dust particles and salt aerosols, and it does not retain samples of the different particle sizes for later analysis. The third instrument that will monitor aerosols at the CDFD site is a Clean Air Status and Trends Network (CASTNET) tower, which uses a multiple canister system to collect weekly samples for analysis to total suspended aerosol particle compositions and atmospheric gas concentrations. This status report describes work in FY23 to develop the capabilities for using these tools. In two training exercises, the cascade impactor and laser particle sizer were deployed in two different testing environments, one indoor and one outdoor. For the cascade impactor, the tests provided opportunities for the operators to familiarize themselves with impactor substrate preparation, and post-test sample removal and analysis. For the laser particle sizer, the tests were used to evaluate different instrument parameters, to determine the most appropriate settings for capturing transient events. Data and samples were collected for weeks to months for each test, and the results are presented here. In addition to the preliminary testing, contracts were developed with WSP Analytical Labs for sample preparation and analysis of the cascade impactor samples. The impactor tower from outdoor test was delivered to WSP and used to train the staff there in disassembly, sample extraction, sample analysis, and tower reassembly with new target substrates. These are tasks that WSP will be performing routinely for the CDFD project. The CASTNET system cannot be purchased or tested until an actual site has been selected for the CDFD test. Work for this FY has been restricted to preparation of contracts for purchasing the CASTNET tower, and for sample analysis, once the tower is in operation.
Measured salt compositions in dust collected over roughly the last decade from surfaces of in-service stainless-steel alloys at four locations around the United States are presented, along with the predicted brine compositions that would result from deliquescence of these salts. The salt compositions vary greatly from ASTM seawater and from laboratory salts (i.e., NaCl or MgCl2) commonly used on corrosion testing. The salts contained relatively high amounts of sulfates and nitrates, evolved to basic pH values, and exhibited deliquescence relative humidity values (RH) higher than seawater. Additionally, inert dust in components were quantified and considerations for laboratory testing are presented. The observed dust compositions are discussed in terms of the potential corrosion behavior and are compared to commonly used accelerated testing protocols. Finally, ambient weather conditions and their influence on diurnal fluctuations in temperature (T) and RH on heated metal surfaces are evaluated and a relevant diurnal cycle for laboratory testing a heated surface has been developed. Suggestions for future accelerated tests are proposed that include exploration of the effects of inert dust particles on atmospheric corrosion, chemistry considerations, and realistic diurnal fluctuations in T and RH. Understanding mechanisms in both realistic and accelerated environments will allow development of a corrosion factor (i.e., scaling factor) for the extrapolation of laboratory-scale test results to real world applications.
This report describes the results of a field demonstration of the proposed surface sampling techniques and plan for the multi-year Canister Deposition Field Demonstration (CDFD). The CDFD will evaluate salt deposition rates on three commercial 32PTH2 NUHOMS welded stainless steel storage canisters in Advanced Horizontal Storage Modules. Exposure testing is planned for up to 10 years and will incorporate periodic surface sampling campaigns. The goal of the planned dust sampling and analysis is to determine important environmental parameters that impact the potential occurrence of stress corrosion cracking on spent nuclear fuel (SNF) dry storage canisters. Specifically, measured dust deposition rates and deposited particle sizes will improve parameterization of dust deposition models employed to predict the potential occurrence and timing of stress corrosion cracks on the stainless steel SNF canisters. Previously, a preliminary sampling plan was developed, identifying possible sampling locations on the canister surfaces and sampling intervals; possible sampling methods were also described. Building from previous work, this report documents hand sampling from a spent nuclear fuel canister on a transfer skid mockup designed by Sandia National Laboratories. The sampling took place from a boom lift and salts were collected from mounted sample plates. The results of these efforts are presented in this report and compared to previous laboratory-controlled tests. The information obtained from the CDFD will be critical for ongoing efforts to develop a detailed understanding of the potential for stress corrosion cracking of SNF dry storage canisters.
Calcite (CaCO3) composition and properties are defined by the chemical environment in which CaCO3 forms. However, a complete understanding of the relationship between aqueous chemistry during calcite precipitation and resulting chemical and physical CaCO3 properties remains elusive; therefore, we present an investigation into the coupled effects of divalent cations Sr2+ and Mg2+ on CaCO3 precipitation and subsequent crystal growth. Through chemical analysis of the aqueous phases and microscopy of the resulting calcite phases in compliment with density functional theory calculations, we elucidate the relationship between crystal growth and the resulting composition (elemental and isotopic) of calcite. The results of this experimental and modeling work suggest that Mg2+ and Sr2+ have cation-specific impacts that inhibit calcite crystal growth, including: (1) Sr2+ incorporates more readily into calcite than Mg2+ (DSr > DMg), and increasing [Sr2+]t or [Mg2+]t increases DSr; (2) the inclusion of Mg2+ into structure leads to a reduction in the calcite unit cell volume, whereas Sr2+ leads to an expansion; (3) the inclusion of both Mg2+ and Sr2+ results in a distribution of unit cell impacts based on the relative positions of the Sr2+ and Mg2+ in the lattice. These experiments were conducted at saturation indices of CaCO3 of ~4.1, favoring rapid precipitation. This rapid precipitation resulted in observed Sr isotope fractionation confirming Sr isotopic fractionation is dependent upon the precipitation rate. We further note that the precipitation and growth of calcite favors the incorporation of the lighter 86Sr isotope over the heavier 87Sr isotope, regardless of the initial solution conditions, and the degree of fractionation increases with DSr. In sum, these results demonstrate the impact of solution environment to influence the incorporation behavior and crystal growth behavior of calcite. These factors are important to understand in order to effectively use geochemical signatures resulting from calcite precipitation or dissolution to gain specific information.
High-level purpose of this work: This report summarizes work carried out by Sandia National Laboratories (SNL) in the fiscal year 2022 (FY22) to evaluate the potential occurrence of stress corrosion cracking (SCC) on spent nuclear fuel (SNF) dry storage canisters. The U.S. currently lacks a repository for permanent disposal of SNF; thus, dry storage systems will be in use for much longer time periods than originally intended. Gap analyses by the US Department of Energy (DOE), the Nuclear Regulatory Commission (NRC), the Nuclear Waste Technical Review Board (NWTRB), and the Electric Power Research Institute (EPRI) have all determined that an improved understanding of the occurrence and risk of canister SCC is critical to demonstrating the safety of long-term dry storage. Should canister penetration by SCC occur, the containment boundary represented by the canister would be breached. A loss of the inert environment (helium) within the canister could occur and intrusion of air and moisture could react with and damage the fuel within the canister. For this reason, the DOE is funding an effort to evaluate the potential occurrence and consequences of dry storage canister SCC and to develop prevention, mitigation, and repair technologies for this degradation mechanism.
This report summarizes the activities performed by Sandia National Laboratories in FY22 to identify and test coating materials for the prevention, mitigation, and/or repair of potential chloride-induced stress corrosion cracking in spent nuclear fuel dry storage canisters. This work continues efforts by Sandia National Laboratories that are summarized in previous reports in FY20 and FY21 on the same topic. The previous work detailed the specific coating properties desired for application and implementation to spent nuclear fuel canisters (FY20) and identified several potential coatings for evaluation (FY21). In FY22, Sandia National Laboratories, in collaboration with four industry partners through a Memorandum of Understanding, started evaluating the physical, mechanical, and corrosion-resistance properties of 6 different coating systems (11 total coating variants) to develop a baseline understanding of the viability of each coating type for use to prevent, mitigate, and/or repair potential stress corrosion on cracking on spent nuclear fuel canisters. This collaborative R&D program leverages the analytical and laboratory capabilities at Sandia National Laboratories and the material design and synthesis capabilities of the industry collaborators. The coating systems include organic (polyetherketoneketone, modified polyimide/polyurea, modified phenolic resin), organic/inorganic ceramic hybrids (silane-based polyurethane hybrid and a quasi-ceramic sol-gel polyurethane hybrid), and hybrid systems in conjuncture with a Zn-rich primer. These coatings were applied to stainless steel coupons (the same coupons were supplied to all vendors by SNL for direct comparison) and have undergone several physical, mechanical, and electrochemical tests. The results and implications of these tests are summarized in this report. These analyses will be used to identify the most effective coatings for potential use on spent nuclear fuel dry storage canisters, and also to identify specific needs for further optimization of coating technologies for their application on spent nuclear fuel canisters. In FY22, Sandia National Laboratories performed baseline testing and atmospheric exposure tests of the coating samples supplied by the vendors in accordance with the scope of work defined in the Memorandum of Understanding. In FY23, Sandia National Laboratories will continue evaluating coating performance with a focus on thermal and radiolytic stability.
In June of 2022, dust samples were collected from the surface of an in-service spent nuclear fuel dry storage canister during an inspection at an Independent Spent Fuel Storage Installation. The site is anonymous but is a near-marine or brackish water east coast location referred to here as "Site C". The purpose of the sampling was to assess the composition and abundance of the soluble salts present on the canister surface, information that provides a metric for potential corrosion risks. Following collection, the samples were delivered to Sandia National Laboratories for analysis. At Sandia, the soluble salts were leached from the dust and quantified by ion chromatography. In addition, subsamples of the dust were taken for scanning electron microscopy to determine the particle sizes, morphology, and mineralogy of the dust and salts. The results of those analyses are presented in this report.
Thermodynamic modeling has been used to predict chemical compositions of brines formed by the deliquescence of sea salt aerosols. Representative brines have been mixed, and physical and chemical properties have been measured over a range of temperatures. Brine properties are discussed in terms of atmospheric corrosion of austenitic stainless steel, using spent nuclear fuel dry storage canisters as an example. After initial loading with spent fuel, during dry storage, the canisters cool over time, leading to increased surface relative humidities and evolving brine chemistries and properties. These parameters affect corrosion kinetics and damage distributions, and may offer important constraints on the expected timing, rate, and long-term impacts of canister corrosion.
This report describes the proposed surface sampling techniques and plan for the multi-year Canister Deposition Field Demonstration (CDFD). The CDFD is primarily a dust deposition test that will use three commercial 32PTH2 NUHOMS welded stainless steel storage canisters in Advanced Horizontal Storage Modules, with planned exposure testing for up to 10 years at an operating ISFSI site. One canister will be left at ambient condition, unheated; the other two will have heaters to achieve canister surface temperatures that match, to the degree possible, spent nuclear fuel (SNF) loaded canisters with heat loads of 10 kW and 40 kW. Surface sampling campaigns for dust analysis will take place on a yearly or bi-yearly basis. The goal of the planned dust sampling and analysis is to determine important environmental parameters that impact the potential occurrence of stress corrosion cracking on SNF dry storage canisters. Specifically, measured dust deposition rates and deposited particle sizes will improve parameterization of dust deposition models employed to predict the potential occurrence and timing of stress corrosion cracks on the stainless steel SNF canisters. The size, morphology, and composition of the deposited dust and salt particles will be quantified, as well as the soluble salt load per unit area and the rate of deposition, as a function of canister surface temperature, location, time, and orientation. Previously, a preliminary sampling plan was developed, identifying possible sampling locations on the canister surfaces and sampling intervals; possible sampling methods were also described. Further development of the sampling plan has commenced through three different tasks. First, canister surface roughness, a potentially important parameter for air flow and dust deposition, was characterized at several locations on one of the test canisters. Second, corrosion testing to evaluate the potential lifetime and aging of thermocouple wires, spot welds, and attachments was initiated. Third, hand sampling protocols were developed, and initial testing was carried out. The results of those efforts are presented in this report. The information obtained from the CDFD will be critical for ongoing efforts to develop a detailed understanding of the potential for stress corrosion cracking of SNF dry storage canisters.