Publications Details

Preliminary Results of the 3D-shape Round-Robin

Montecchi, Marco; Benedetti, Arcangelo; Cara, Guiseppe; Torres, Francisco; Bern, Gregor; Roger, Marc; Lupfert, Eckhard; Kesseli, Devon; Zhu, Guangdong; Smith, Braden J.; Brost, Randolph

In the framework of SFERA-III WP10 Task3, ENEA has organized the 3D-shape round-robin (RR); the purpose is to compare the main geometrical parameters of 3D shape measurement of parabolic-trough (PT) reflective panels evaluated with the instruments adopted by each participant among: ENEA, DLR, F-ISE, NREL, and SANDIA. The last two institutions are outside of the EU, but benefited from the Transnational Access institute to visit several European laboratories, including the ENEA Casaccia research center where they accomplished some measurements with a portable experimental set-up. RR is based on the inter-laboratory circulation of 3 inner plus 3 outer PT panels. The start of the RR was delayed by the covid pandemic, then the circulation of the specimen-set and their measurement took more than one year. At the time of drafting this deliverable at the end of SFERA-III project, NREL has not yet completed the analysis of the measurements, making available only the deviations of the slopes. Therefore here will be reported only the preliminary results. The full comparison will be published as soon as possible, maybe in the open access venue Open Research Europe.