Nonlinear Mechanics and Dynamics (NOMAD) Summer Research Institute - Kickoff Meeting
Abstract not provided.
Abstract not provided.
Abstract not provided.
Abstract not provided.
Abstract not provided.
Conference Proceedings of the Society for Experimental Mechanics Series
Contact in structures with mechanical interfaces has the ability to significantly influence the system dynamics, such that the energy dissipation and resonant frequencies vary as a function of the response amplitude. Finite element analysis is commonly used to study the physics of such problems, particularly when examining the local behavior at the interfaces. These high fidelity, nonlinear models are computationally expensive to run with time-stepping solvers due to their large mesh densities at the interface, and because of the high expense required to update the tangent operators. Hurty/Craig-Bampton substructuring and interface reduction techniques are commonly utilized to reduce computation time for jointed structures. In the past, these methods have only been applied to substructures rigidly attached to one another, resulting in a linear model. The present work explores the performance of a particular interface reduction technique (system-level characteristic constraint modes) on a nonlinear model with node-to-node contact for a benchmark structure consisting of two c-shape beams bolted together at each end.
Mechanical Systems and Signal Processing
The Hurty/Craig-Bampton method in structural dynamics represents the interior dynamics of each subcomponent in a substructured system with a truncated set of normal modes and retains all of the physical degrees of freedom at the substructure interfaces. This makes the assembly of substructures into a reduced-order system model relatively simple, but means that the reduced-order assembly will have as many interface degrees of freedom as the full model. When the full-model mesh is highly refined, and/or when the system is divided into many subcomponents, this can lead to an unacceptably large system of equations of motion. To overcome this, interface reduction methods aim to reduce the size of the Hurty/Craig-Bampton model by reducing the number of interface degrees of freedom. This research presents a survey of interface reduction methods for Hurty/Craig-Bampton models, and proposes improvements and generalizations to some of the methods. Some of these interface reductions operate on the assembled system-level matrices while others perform reduction locally by considering the uncoupled substructures. The advantages and disadvantages of these methods are highlighted and assessed through comparisons of results obtained from a variety of representative linear FE models.
Conference Proceedings of the Society for Experimental Mechanics Series
In computational structural dynamics problems, the ability to calibrate numerical models to physical test data often depends on determining the correct constraints within a structure with mechanical interfaces. These interfaces are defined as the locations within a built-up assembly where two or more disjointed structures are connected. In reality, the normal and tangential forces arising from friction and contact, respectively, are the only means of transferring loads between structures. In linear structural dynamics, a typical modeling approach is to linearize the interface using springs and dampers to connect the disjoint structures, then tune the coefficients to obtain sufficient accuracy between numerically predicted and experimentally measured results. This work explores the use of a numerical inverse method to predict the area of the contact patch located within a bolted interface by defining multi-point constraints. The presented model updating procedure assigns contact definitions (fully stuck, slipping, or no contact) in a finite element model of a jointed structure as a function of contact pressure computed from a nonlinear static analysis. The contact definitions are adjusted until the computed modes agree with experimental test data. The methodology is demonstrated on a C-shape beam system with two bolted interfaces, and the calibrated model predicts modal frequencies with <3% total error summed across the first six elastic modes.
Abstract not provided.
Abstract not provided.
The 2018 Nonlinear Mechanics and Dynamics (NOMAD) Research Institute was successfully held from June 18 to August 2, 2018. NOMAD brings together participants with diverse technical backgrounds to work in small teams to cultivate new ideas and approaches in engineering mechanics and dynamics research. NOMAD provides an opportunity for researchers -- especially early career researchers - to develop lasting collaborations that go beyond what can be established from the limited interactions at their institutions or at annual conferences. A total of 17 students came to Albuquerque, New Mexico to participate in the seven-week long program held at the Mechanical Engineering building on the University of New Mexico campus. The students collaborated on one of six research projects that were developed by various mentors from Sandia National Laboratories, University of New Mexico, and academic institutions. In addition to the research activities, the students attended weekly technical seminars, various tours, and socialized at various off-hour events including an Albuquerque Isotopes baseball game. At the end of the summer, the students gave a final technical presentation on their research findings. Many of the research discoveries made at NOMAD are published as proceedings at technical conferences and have direct alignment with the critical mission work performed at Sandia.
Abstract not provided.
Abstract not provided.
Abstract not provided.
Abstract not provided.
Abstract not provided.
A reduced order modeling capability has been developed to reduce the computational burden associated with time-domain solutions of structural dynamic models with linear viscoelastic materials. The discretized equations-of-motion produce convolution integrals resulting in a linear system with nonviscous damping forces. The challenge associated with the reduction of nonviscously damped, linear systems is the selection and computation of the appropriate modal basis to perform modal projection. The system produces a nonlinear eigenvalue problem that is challenging to solve and requires use of specialized algorithms not readily available in commercial finite element packages. This SAND report summarizes the LDRD discoveries of a reduction scheme developed for monolithic finite element models and provides preliminary investigations to extensions of the method using component mode synthesis. In addition, this report provides a background overview of structural dynamic modeling of structures with linear viscoelastic materials, and provides an overview of a new code capability in Sierra Structural Dynamics to output the system level matrices computed on multiple processors.
Abstract not provided.
Abstract not provided.
The 2017 Nonlinear Mechanics and Dynamics (NOMAD) Research Institute was successfully held from June 19 to July 28, 2017. NOMAD seeks to bring together participants with diverse technical backgrounds to work in small teams to utilize an interactive approach to cultivate new ideas and approaches in engineering . NOMAD provides an opportunity for researchers - especially early career researchers - to develop lasting collaborations that go beyond what can be established from the limited interactions at their institutions or at annual conferences. A total of 17 students from around the world came to Albuquerque, New Mexico to participate in the six - week long program held at the University of New Mexico campus. The students collaborated on one of six research projects that were developed by various mentors from Sandia National Laboratories, academia, and other government laboratories. In addition to the research activities, the students attended weekly technical seminars, toured the National Museum of Nuclear Science & History, and socialized at various off - hour events including an Albuquerque Isotopes baseball game. At the end of the summer, the students gave a final technical presentation o n their research findings that was broadcast via Skype. Many of the research discoveries made at NOMAD are published as proceedings at technical conference s and have direct alignment with the critical mission work performed at Sandia.
Abstract not provided.
Proceedings of ISMA 2018 - International Conference on Noise and Vibration Engineering and USD 2018 - International Conference on Uncertainty in Structural Dynamics
Structural dynamic models of mechanical, aerospace, and civil structures often involve connections of multiple subcomponents with rivets, bolts, press fits, or other joining processes. Recent model order reduction advances have been made for jointed structures using appropriately defined whole joint models in combination with linear substructuring techniques. A whole joint model condenses the interface nodes onto a single node with multi-point constraints resulting in drastic increases in computational speeds to predict transient responses. One drawback to this strategy is that the whole joint models are empirical and require calibration with test or high-fidelity model data. A new framework is proposed to calibrate whole joint models by computing global responses from high-fidelity finite element models and utilizing global optimization to determine the optimal joint parameters. The method matches the amplitude dependent damping and natural frequencies predicted for each vibration mode using quasi-static modal analysis.
Proceedings of ISMA 2018 - International Conference on Noise and Vibration Engineering and USD 2018 - International Conference on Uncertainty in Structural Dynamics
Structural dynamic models of mechanical, aerospace, and civil structures often involve connections of multiple subcomponents with rivets, bolts, press fits, or other joining processes. Recent model order reduction advances have been made for jointed structures using appropriately defined whole joint models in combination with linear substructuring techniques. A whole joint model condenses the interface nodes onto a single node with multi-point constraints resulting in drastic increases in computational speeds to predict transient responses. One drawback to this strategy is that the whole joint models are empirical and require calibration with test or high-fidelity model data. A new framework is proposed to calibrate whole joint models by computing global responses from high-fidelity finite element models and utilizing global optimization to determine the optimal joint parameters. The method matches the amplitude dependent damping and natural frequencies predicted for each vibration mode using quasi-static modal analysis.
Abstract not provided.
An assessment of two methodologies used at Sandia National Laboratories to model mechanical interfaces is performed on the Ministack finite element model. One method uses solid mechanics models to model contacting surfaces with Coulomb frictional contact to capture the physics. The other, termed the structural dynamics reduced order model, models the interface with a simplified whole joint model using four-parameter Iwan elements. The solid mechanics model resolves local kinematics at the interface while the simplified structural dynamics model is significantly faster to simulate. One of the current challenges to using the whole joint model is that it requires calibration to data. A novel approach is developed to calibrate the reduced structural dynamics model using data from the solid mechanics model to match the global dynamics of the system. This is achieved by calibrating to amplitude dependent frequency and damping of the system modes, which are estimated using three different approaches.
Abstract not provided.
Abstract not provided.
Mechanical Systems and Signal Processing
The ability to model nonlinear structures subject to random excitation is of key importance in designing hypersonic aircraft and other advanced aerospace vehicles. When a structure is linear, superposition can be used to construct its response to a known spectrum in terms of its linear modes. Superposition does not hold for a nonlinear system, but several works have shown that a system's dynamics can still be understood qualitatively in terms of its nonlinear normal modes (NNMs). This work investigates the connection between a structure's undamped nonlinear normal modes and the spectrum of its response to high amplitude random forcing. Two examples are investigated: a spring-mass system and a clamped-clamped beam modeled within a geometrically nonlinear finite element package. In both cases, an intimate connection is observed between the smeared peaks in the response spectrum and the frequency-energy dependence of the nonlinear normal modes. In order to understand the role of coupling between the underlying linear modes, reduced order models with and without modal coupling terms are used to separate the effect of each NNM's backbone from the nonlinear couplings that give rise to internal resonances. In the cases shown here, uncoupled, single-degree-of-freedom nonlinear models are found to predict major features in the response with reasonable accuracy; a highly inexpensive approximation such as this could be useful in design and optimization studies. More importantly, the results show that a reduced order model can be expected to give accurate results only if it is also capable of accurately predicting the frequency-energy dependence of the nonlinear modes that are excited.
Abstract not provided.
Conference Proceedings of the Society for Experimental Mechanics Series
Thin beams and panels subjected to large loadings will behave nonlinearly due to membrane stretch effects as they approach deflections on the order of their thickness; this behavior can be efficiently and accurately modeled using nonlinear reduced order models based on the structure’s linear normal modes. However, the complexity of such reduced order models grows cubically with the number of linear modes in the basis set, making complicated geometries prohibitively expensive to compute. Component mode synthesis techniques may be used to reduce this cost by assembling a set of smaller nonlinear subcomponent models, each of which can be more quickly computed than a nonlinear model of the entire structure. Since geometric nonlinearity is heavily dependent on each structure’s boundary conditions, however, subcomponents of an assembly which are constrained only at their interfaces – such as panels mounted to an underlying frame – prove difficult to treat using existing nonlinear modeling techniques. This work uses Craig-Bampton dynamic substructuring combined with characteristic constraint modes for interface reduction to examine the challenges associated with panel and frame assemblies, with a simple example motivating a discussion of current solutions and future challenges.
AIAA Journal
Substructuring methods have been widely used in structural dynamics to divide large, complicated finite element models into smaller substructures. For linear systems, many methods have been developed to reduce the subcomponents down to a low-order set of equations using a special set of component modes, and these are then assembled to approximate the dynamics of a large-scale model. In this paper, a substructuring approach is developed for coupling geometrically nonlinear structures, where each subcomponent is drastically reduced to a low-order set of nonlinear equations using a truncated set of fixed-interface and characteristic constraint modes. The method used to extract the coefficients of the nonlinear reduced-order model is nonintrusive, in that it does not require any modification to the commercial finite element code but computes the reduced-order model from the results of several nonlinear static analyses. The nonlinear reduced-order models are then assembled to approximate the nonlinear differential equations of the global assembly. The method is demonstrated on the coupling of two geometrically nonlinear plates with simple supports at all edges. The plates are joined at a continuous interface through the rotational degrees of freedom, and the nonlinear normal modes of the assembled equations are computed to validate the models. The proposed substructuring approach reduces a 12,861-degree-of-freedom model down to only 23 degrees of freedom while still accurately reproducing the nonlinear normal modes.
Abstract not provided.
Conference Proceedings of the Society for Experimental Mechanics Series
The Craig-Bampton approach for component mode synthesis in structural dynamics has been widely used to reduce the order of large, detailed finite element models made from linear elastic materials. This methodology separates the full order model into smaller subcomponents and reduces the equations of motion with a truncated set of fixed-interface modes and static constraint modes. A drawback of this approach is that the model has one constraint mode for every interface degree-of-freedom, which may result in a large and prohibitively costly superelement. Previous work has addressed this issue via characteristic constraint modes, which reduces the number of interface degrees-of-freedom by performing a secondary modal analysis on the interface partition. The current work extends the Craig-Bampton approach with interface reduction to include subcomponents with linear viscoelastic materials modeled using a Prony series. For substructures containing materials such as foams or polymers, the viscoelastic constitutive law more accurately represents the material energy dissipation compared to traditional viscous or modal damping. The new approach will be demonstrated on the assembly of two composite plates with fixed boundary conditions along one edge.
Conference Proceedings of the Society for Experimental Mechanics Series
Nonlinear joints and interfaces modeled with a discrete four-parameter Iwan element are defined by parameters that are often unknown a priori or require calibration to get better agreement with test data. While this constitutive model has been validated experimentally, its drawback lies in the difficulty of identifying the correct coefficients. This work proposes a parameter estimation approach using a genetic algorithm to minimize the residual between experimental and model data. Global optimization schemes have the ability to find global minima/maxima of a broad parameter space but require a very large number of function evaluations. This research focuses on decreasing the computational cost of the optimization scheme by developing a simplified model of the structure of interest and defining the objective function with amplitude dependent frequencies and damping ratios. A recently developed quasi-static modal analysis technique is used to determine these amplitude dependent properties of the model at a significantly reduced cost in comparison to solutions obtained with numerical time integration. This technique is demonstrated on a structure termed the Ministack which contains a foam-to-metal interface held together with a press fit joint.
Proceedings of the ASME Design Engineering Technical Conference
Structural dynamics models with localized nonlinearities can be reduced using Hurty/Craig-Bampton component mode synthesis methods. The interior degrees-of-freedom of the linear subcomponents are reduced with a set of dynamic fixedinterface modes while the static constraint modes preserve the physical coordinates at which the nonlinear restoring forces are applied. For finite element models with a highly refined mesh at the boundary, a secondary modal analysis can be performed to reduce the interface down to a truncated set of local-level characteristic constraint modes. In this research, the cost savings and accuracy of the interface reduction technique are evaluated on a simple example problem involving two elastic blocks coming into contact.
Proceedings of the ASME Design Engineering Technical Conference
Structural dynamics models with localized nonlinearities can be reduced using Hurty/Craig-Bampton component mode synthesis methods. The interior degrees-of-freedom of the linear subcomponents are reduced with a set of dynamic fixedinterface modes while the static constraint modes preserve the physical coordinates at which the nonlinear restoring forces are applied. For finite element models with a highly refined mesh at the boundary, a secondary modal analysis can be performed to reduce the interface down to a truncated set of local-level characteristic constraint modes. In this research, the cost savings and accuracy of the interface reduction technique are evaluated on a simple example problem involving two elastic blocks coming into contact.
Abstract not provided.
Abstract not provided.
Abstract not provided.
Abstract not provided.
Abstract not provided.
Abstract not provided.
Abstract not provided.
Abstract not provided.
Abstract not provided.
Conference Proceedings of the Society for Experimental Mechanics Series
Motivated by the current demands in high-performance structural analysis, and by a desire to better model systems with localized nonlinearities, analysts have developed a number of different approaches for modelling and simulating the dynamics of a bolted-joint structure. However, the types of conditions that make one approach more effective than the others remains poorly understood due to the fact that these approaches are developed from fundamentally and phenomenologically different concepts. To better grasp their similarities and differences, this research presents a numerical round robin that assesses how well three different approaches predict and simulate a mechanical joint. These approaches are applied to analyze a system comprised of two linear beam structures with a bolted joint interface, and their strengths and shortcomings are assessed in order to determine the optimal conditions for their use.
Conference Proceedings of the Society for Experimental Mechanics Series
Broadband impact excitation in structural dynamics is a common technique used to detect and characterize nonlinearities in mechanical systems since it excites many frequencies of a structure at once. Non-stationary time signals from transient ring-down measurements require time-frequency analysis tools to observe variations in frequency and energy dissipation as the response evolves. This work uses the short-time Fourier transform to estimate the instantaneous parameters from measured or simulated data. By combining the discrete Fourier transform with an expanding or contracting window function that moves along the time axis, the resulting spectra are used to estimate the instantaneous frequencies, damping ratios and complex Fourier coefficients. This method is demonstrated on a multi-degree-of-freedom beam with a cubic spring attachment. The amplitude-frequency dependence in the damped response is compared to the undamped nonlinear normal modes. A second example shows the results from experimental ring-down measurements taken on a beam with a lap joint, revealing how the mechanical interface introduces nonlinear frequency and damping parameters.
Conference Proceedings of the Society for Experimental Mechanics Series
Experimental dynamic substructuring is a means whereby a mathematical model for a substructure can be obtained experimentally and then coupled to a model for the rest of the assembly to predict the response. Recently, various methods have been proposed that use a transmission simulator to overcome sensitivity to measurement errors and to exercise the interface between the substructures; including the Craig-Bampton, Dual Craig-Bampton, and Craig-Mayes methods. This work compares the advantages and disadvantages of these reduced order modeling strategies for two dynamic substructuring problems. The methods are first used on an analytical beam model to validate the methodologies. Then they are used to obtain an experimental model for structure consisting of a cylinder with several components inside connected to the outside case by foam with uncertain properties. This represents an exceedingly difficult structure to model and so experimental substructuring could be an attractive way to obtain a model of the system.
Conference Proceedings of the Society for Experimental Mechanics Series
The physical mechanisms of energy dissipation in foam to metal interfaces must be understood in order to develop predictive models of systems with foam packaging common to many aerospace and aeronautical applications. Experimental data was obtained from hardware termed “Ministack”, which has large, unbonded interfaces held under compressive preload. This setup has a solid aluminum mass placed into two foam cups which are then inserted into an aluminum can and fastened with a known preload. Ministack was tested on a shaker using upward sine sweep base acceleration excitations to estimate the linearized natural frequency and energy dissipation of the first axial mode. The experimental system was disassembled and reassembled before each series of tests in order to observe the effects of the assembly to assembly variability on the dynamics. There are some important findings in the measured data: there is significant assembly to assembly variability, the order in which the sine sweeps are performed influence the dynamic response, and the system exhibits nontrivial damping and stiffness nonlinearities that must be accounted for in modeling efforts. A Craig-Bampton model connected with a four-parameter Iwan element and piecewise linear springs is developed and calibrated using test data with the intention of capturing the nonlinear energy dissipation and loss of stiffness observed in experiment.
Abstract not provided.
Abstract not provided.