In order to determine a material's hydrogen storage potential, capacity measurements must be robust, reproducible, and accurate. Commonly, research reports focus on the gravimetric capacity, and often times the volumetric capacity is not reported. Determining volumetric capacities is not as straight-forward, especially for amorphous materials. This is the first study to compare measurement reproducibility across laboratories for excess and total volumetric hydrogen sorption capacities based on the packing volume. The use of consistent measurement protocols, common analysis, and figure of merits for reporting data in this study, enable the comparison of the results for two different materials. Importantly, the results show good agreement for excess gravimetric capacities amongst the laboratories. Irreproducibility for excess and total volumetric capacities is attributed to real differences in the measured packing volume of the material.
Here in this article, the capabilities of soft and hard X-ray techniques, including X-ray absorption (XAS), soft X-ray emission spectroscopy (XES), resonant inelastic soft X-ray scattering (RIXS), X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy (XPS), and X-ray diffraction (XRD), and their application to solid-state hydrogen storage materials are presented. These characterization tools are indispensable for interrogating hydrogen storage materials at the relevant length scales of fundamental interest, which range from the micron scale to nanometer dimensions.Since nanostructuring is now well established as an avenue to improve the thermodynamics and kinetics of hydrogen release and uptake, due to properties such as reduced mean free paths of transport and increased surface-to-volume ratio, it becomes of critical importance to explicitly identify structure-property relationships on the nanometer scale. X-ray diffraction and spectroscopy are effective tools for probing size-, shape-, and structure-dependent material properties at the nanoscale. This article also discusses the recent development of in-situ soft X-ray spectroscopy cells, which enable investigation of critical solid/liquid or solid/gas interfaces under more practical conditions. These unique tools are providing a window into the thermodynamics and kinetics of hydrogenation and dehydrogenation reactions and informing a quantitative understanding of the fundamental energetics of hydrogen storage processes at the microscopic level. In particular, in-situ soft X-ray spectroscopies can be utilized to probe the formation of intermediate species, byproducts, as well as the changes in morphology and effect of additives, which all can greatly affect the hydrogen storage capacity, kinetics, thermodynamics, and reversibility.A few examples using soft X-ray spectroscopies to study these materials are discussed to demonstrate how these powerful characterization tools could be helpful to further understand the hydrogen storage systems.
Solid-state metal hydrides are prime candidates to replace compressed hydrogen for fuel cell vehicles due to their high volumetric capacities. Sodium aluminum hydride has long been studied as an archetype for higher-capacity metal hydrides, with improved reversibility demonstrated through the addition of titanium catalysts; however, atomistic mechanisms for surface processes, including hydrogen desorption, are still uncertain. Here, operando and ex situ measurements from a suite of diagnostic tools probing multiple length scales are combined with ab initio simulations to provide a detailed and unbiased view of the evolution of the surface chemistry during hydrogen release. In contrast to some previously proposed mechanisms, the titanium dopant does not directly facilitate desorption at the surface. Instead, oxidized surface species, even on well-protected NaAlH 4 samples, evolve during dehydrogenation to form surface hydroxides with differing levels of hydrogen saturation. Additionally, the presence of these oxidized species leads to considerably lower computed barriers for H 2 formation compared to pristine hydride surfaces, suggesting that oxygen may actively participate in hydrogen release, rather than merely inhibiting diffusion as is commonly presumed. These results demonstrate how close experiment-theory feedback can elucidate mechanistic understanding of complex metal hydride chemistry and potentially impactful roles of unavoidable surface impurities.
Solid-state metal hydrides are prime candidates to replace compressed hydrogen for fuel cell vehicles due to their high volumetric capacities. Sodium aluminum hydride has long been studied as an archetype for higher-capacity metal hydrides, with improved reversibility demonstrated through the addition of titanium catalysts; however, atomistic mechanisms for surface processes, including hydrogen desorption, are still uncertain. Here in this paper, operando and ex situ measurements from a suite of diagnostic tools probing multiple length scales are combined with ab initio simulations to provide a detailed and unbiased view of the evolution of the surface chemistry during hydrogen release. In contrast to some previously proposed mechanisms, the titanium dopant does not directly facilitate desorption at the surface. Instead, oxidized surface species, even on well-protected NaAlH4 samples, evolve during dehydrogenation to form surface hydroxides with differing levels of hydrogen saturation. Additionally, the presence of these oxidized species leads to considerably lower computed barriers for H2 formation compared to pristine hydride surfaces, suggesting that oxygen may actively participate in hydrogen release, rather than merely inhibiting diffusion as is commonly presumed. These results demonstrate how close experiment–theory feedback can elucidate mechanistic understanding of complex metal hydride chemistry and potentially impactful roles of unavoidable surface impurities.
Use of electrolytes, in the form of LiBH4/KBH4 and LiI/KI/CsI eutectics, is shown to significantly improve (by more than a factor of 10) both the dehydrogenation and full rehydrogenation of the MgH2/Sn destabilized hydride system and the hydrogenation of MgB2 to Mg(BH4)2. The improvement revealed that interparticle transport of atoms heavier than hydrogen can be an important rate-limiting step during hydrogen cycling in hydrogen storage materials consisting of multiple phases in powder form. Electrolytes enable solubilizing heavy ions into a liquid environment and thereby facilitate the reaction over full surface areas of interacting particles. The examples presented suggest that use of electrolytes in the form of eutectics, ionic liquids, or solvents containing dissolved salts may be generally applicable for increasing reaction rates in complex and destabilized hydride materials.
Knowledge and foundational understanding of phenomena associated with the behavior of materials at the nanoscale is one of the key scientific challenges toward a sustainable energy future. Size reduction from bulk to the nanoscale leads to a variety of exciting and anomalous phenomena due to enhanced surface-to-volume ratio, reduced transport length, and tunable nanointerfaces. Nanostructured metal hydrides are an important class of materials with significant potential for energy storage applications. Hydrogen storage in nanoscale metal hydrides has been recognized as a potentially transformative technology, and the field is now growing steadily due to the ability to tune the material properties more independently and drastically compared to those of their bulk counterparts. The numerous advantages of nanostructured metal hydrides compared to bulk include improved reversibility, altered heats of hydrogen absorption/desorption, nanointerfacial reaction pathways with faster rates, and new surface states capable of activating chemical bonds. This review aims to summarize the progress to date in the area of nanostructured metal hydrides and intends to understand and explain the underpinnings of the innovative concepts and strategies developed over the past decade to tune the thermodynamics and kinetics of hydrogen storage reactions. These recent achievements have the potential to propel further the prospects of tuning the hydride properties at nanoscale, with several promising directions and strategies that could lead to the next generation of solid-state materials for hydrogen storage applications.
Confining NaAlH4 in nanoporous carbon scaffolds is known to alter the sorption kinetics and/or pathways of the characteristic bulk hydride reactions through interaction with the framework at the interface, increased specific surface area of the resulting nanoparticles, decreased hydrogen diffusion distances, and prevention of phase segregation. Although the nanosize effects have been well studied, the influence of the carbon scaffold surface chemistry remains unclear. Here we compare the hydrogen sorption characteristics of NaAlH4 confined by melt infiltration in nitrogen-doped/undoped ordered nanoporous carbon of two different geometries. 23Na and 27Al MAS NMR, N2 sorption, and PXRD verify NaAlH4 was successfully confined and remains intact in the carbon nanopores after infiltration. Both the N-doped/undoped nanoconfined systems demonstrate improved reversibility in relation to the bulk hydride during hydrogen desorption/absorption cycling. Isothermal kinetic measurements indicate a lowering of the activation energy for H2 desorption by as much as 70 kJ/mol in N-doped frameworks, far larger than the reduction in carbon-only frameworks. Most interestingly, this dramatic lowering of the activation energy is accompanied by an unexpected and anomalously low NaAlH4 desorption rate in the N-doped frameworks. This suggests that the framework surface chemistry plays an important role in the desorption process and that the rate limiting step for desorption may be associated with interactions of the hydride and host surface. Our results indicate that functionalization of carbon scaffold surface chemistry with heteroatoms provides a powerful method of altering the characteristic hydrogen sorption properties of confined metal hydride systems. This technique may prove beneficial in the path to a viable metal hydride-based hydrogen storage system.
Lightweight complex metal hydrides are of interest for use as energy-dense on-board vehicular hydrogen stores. One material of particular interest, magnesium borohydride (Mg(BH4)2), has very high hydrogen capacity, at 14.9 wt.% H, but suffers from slow kinetics and the need for extreme conditions for both dehydrogenation and rehydrogenation from magnesium diboride (MgB2). In order to establish methods to improve the kinetic properties of this system, a greater understanding of the nucleation and growth of various solid phases is essential.
The hydrogen absorption properties of metal closo-borate/metal hydride composites, M2B10H10-8MH and M2B12H12-10MH, M = Li or Na, are studied under high hydrogen pressures to understand the formation mechanism of metal borohydrides. The hydrogen storage properties of the composites have been investigated by in situ synchrotron radiation powder X-ray diffraction at p(H2) = 400 bar and by ex situ hydrogen absorption measurements at p(H2) = 526 to 998 bar. The in situ experiments reveal the formation of crystalline intermediates before metal borohydrides (MBH4) are formed. On the contrary, the M2B12H12-10MH (M = Li and Na) systems show no formation of the metal borohydride at T = 400 °C and p(H2) = 537 to 970 bar. 11B MAS NMR of the M2B10H10-8MH composites reveal that the molar ratio of LiBH4 or NaBH4 and the remaining B species is 1:0.63 and 1:0.21, respectively. Solution and solid-state 11B NMR spectra reveal new intermediates with a B:H ratio close to 1:1. Our results indicate that the M2B10H10 (M = Li, Na) salts display a higher reactivity towards hydrogen in the presence of metal hydrides compared to the corresponding [B12H12]2- composites, which represents an important step towards understanding the factors that determine the stability and reversibility of high hydrogen capacity metal borohydrides for hydrogen storage.
The Sandia HyMARC team continued its development of new synthetic, modeling, and diagnostic tools that are providing new insights into all major classes of storage materials, ranging from relatively simple systems such as PdHx and MgH2, to exceptionally complex ones, such as the metal borohydrides, as well as materials thought to be very well-understood, such as Ti-doped NaAlH4. This unprecedented suite of capabilities, capable of probing all relevant length scales within storage materials, is already having a significant impact, as they are now being used by both Seedling projects and collaborators at other laboratories within HyMARC. We expect this impact to grow as new Seedling projects begin and through collaborations with other scientists outside HyMARC. In the coming year, Sandia efforts will focus on the highest impact problems, in coordination with the other HyMARC National Laboratory partners, to provide the foundational science necessary to accelerate the discovery of new hydrogen storage materials.
Mg(BH4)2 is a promising solid-state hydrogen storage material, releasing 14.9 wt% hydrogen upon conversion to MgB2. Although several dehydrogenation pathways have been proposed, the hydrogenation process is less well understood. Here, we present a joint experimental-theoretical study that elucidates the key atomistic mechanisms associated with the initial stages of hydrogen uptake within MgB2. Fourier transform infrared, X-ray absorption, and X-ray emission spectroscopies are integrated with spectroscopic simulations to show that hydrogenation can initially proceed via direct conversion of MgB2 to Mg(BH4)2 complexes. The associated energy landscape is mapped by combining ab initio calculations with barriers extracted from the experimental uptake curves, from which a kinetic model is constructed. The results from the kinetic model suggest that initial hydrogenation takes place via a multi-step process: molecular H2 dissociation, likely at Mg-terminated MgB2 surfaces, is followed by migration of atomic hydrogen to defective boron sites, where the formation of stable B-H bonds ultimately leads to the direct creation of Mg(BH4)2 complexes without persistent BxHy intermediates. Implications for understanding the chemical, structural, and electronic changes upon hydrogenation of MgB2 are discussed.
Alkali metal borohydrides can reversibly store hydrogen; however, the materials display poor cyclability, oftentimes linked to the occurrence of stable closo-polyborate intermediate species. In an effort to understand the role of such intermediates on the hydrogen storage properties of metal borohydrides, several alkali metal dodecahydro-closo-dodecaborate salts were isolated in anhydrous form and characterized by diffraction and spectroscopic techniques. Mixtures of Li2B12H12, Na2B12H12, and K2B12H12 with the corresponding alkali metal hydrides were subjected to hydrogenation conditions known to favor partial or full reversibility in metal borohydrides. The stoichiometric mixtures of MH and M2B12H12 salts form the corresponding metal borohydrides MBH4 (M = Li, Na, K) in almost quantitative yield at 100 MPa H2 and 500°C. In addition, stoichiometric mixtures of Li2B12H12 and MgH2 were found to form MgB2 at 500°C and above upon desorption in vacuum. The two destabilization strategies outlined above suggest that metal polyhydro-closo-polyborate species can be converted into the corresponding metal borohydrides or borides, albeit under rather harsh conditions of hydrogen pressure and temperature. (Chemical Equation Presented).