Unexpected effect could lessen instabilities in fusion effort

A Moment of Awe — Sandia physicist Tom Awe (1688) examines coils that reduce plasma instabilities in the quest for controlled nuclear fusion at Sandia's Z machine.

(Photo by Randy Montoya)

by Neal Singer


A surprising effect created by a 19th century device — the Helmholtz coil — has provided hints about how to achieve controlled nuclear fusion at Sandia’s powerful Z machine.

A Helmholtz coil produces a magnetic field when electrified. Two such coils, providing a secondary magnetic field to Z’s huge one, unexpectedly altered and slowed the growth of the magneto-Rayleigh-Taylor instabilities, an unavoidable, game-ending plasma distortion that usually spins quickly out of control and has sunk past efforts to achieve controlled fusion.

“[Our recent experiments] dramatically altered the nature of the instability,” says lead researcher Tom Awe (1688). “We don’t yet understand all the implications, but it’s become a different beast, which is an exciting physics result.”

The experiment was reported in December in Physical Review Letters.

The purpose of adding two Helmholtz coils to fusion experiments at the Z machine (which produces a magnetic field a thousand times stronger than the coils) was to demonstrate that the secondary field would create a magnetic barrier that, like insulation, would maintain the energy of charged particles in a Z-created plasma. Theoretically, the coils’ field would do this by keeping particles away from the machine’s walls. Contact would lower the fusion reaction’s temperature and cause it to fail.

Researchers also feared that the Helmholtz field might cause a short in Z’s huge electrical pulse as it (and its corresponding magnetic field) sped toward its target, a small deuterium-stuffed cylinder.

Z’s magnetic field is intended to crush the cylinder, called a liner, fusing the deuterium and releasing neutrons and other energies associated with nuclear fusion. Anything hindering that “pinch” or “Z-pinch,” would doom the experiment.

In  preliminary experiments of Tom’s group, the coils indeed buffered the particles and didn’t interfere with the pinch.

Enter, the coils

But unexpectedly, radiographs of the process showed that the coils’ field had altered and slowed the growth of distortions known as magneto-Rayleigh-Taylor instabilities, which had been thought to occur unavoidably. (Unavoidably, because even the most minute differences in materials turned to plasma are magnified by pressures applied over time.) 

The strength of instabilities seen in hundreds of previous Z pinches were reduced, possibly  significantly.

 The typical distortion pattern had also changed shape from horizontal to helical.

The unexpected results occurred in a series of experiments to study a concept called Magnetized Liner Inertial Fusion, or MagLIF.

MagLIF: Like soaking bread in beaten eggs and milk

Researchers placed the Helmholtz coils around a liner containing deuterium so the coils’ magnetic field lines soaked both container and fuel over a period of milliseconds. The relatively slow process, like soaking bread in beaten eggs and milk to make French toast, allowed time for the magnetic field lines to fully permeate the material. Then the liner was crushed in tens of nanoseconds by the massive magnetic implosion generated by Sandia’s Z machine.

In previous attempts to use Z’s huge field without the Helmholtz coils, radiographs showed instabilities appearing on the exterior of the liner. These disturbances caused the liner’s initially smooth exterior to resemble a stack of metallic washers, or small sausage links separated by horizontal rubber bands. Such instabilities increase dramatically in mere nanoseconds, eating through the liner wall like decay through a tooth. Eventually, they may collapse portions of the inner wall of the liner, releasing microrubble and causing uneven fuel compression that would make impossible the fusing of significant amounts of deuterium.

 The disturbances are a warning sign that the liner might crumple before fully completing its fusion mission.

But firing with the secondary field up and running clearly altered and slowed formation of the instability as the liner quickly shrank to a fraction of its initial diameter. Introducing the secondary magnetic field seemed to realign the instabilities from simple circles — stacks of washers or rubberbands around sausages — into a helical pattern that more resembles the slanting patchwork of a plaid sweater.

A kayak’s slanted track across the waters

Researchers speculate that the vertical magnetic field created by the helical coils, cutting across Z’s horizontal field, may create the same effect as a river slanting a kayak downstream rather than straight across a channel. Or it may be that the kayak’s original direction is pre-set by the secondary magnetic field to angle it downstream in its crossing. Whatever the reason, the helical instability created does not appear to eat through the liner wall as rapidly as the typical horizontal Rayleigh-Taylor instabilities. Flashes of X-rays that were released when material from the horizontal instabilities collided in the liner’s center no longer appeared, suggesting more uniform fuel compression occurred, possibly a result of the increasing resistance of the implanted vertical magnetic field to the compression generated by the Z horizontal field.

The overall approach of Tom and colleagues uses a method described in two papers by theorist Steve Slutz (1684). In a 2010 article in Physics of Plasmas, Steve suggested that the magnetic field generated by Z could crush a metallic liner filled with deuterium, fusing the atoms. Steve et al then indicated, in a 2012 paper in Physical Review Letters, that a more powerful version of Z could create high-yield fusion — much more fusion energy out than the electrical energy put in.

The apparently simple method — switch on a huge magnetic field and wait a few nanoseconds — takes for granted the complicated host of engineered devices and technical services that allow Z to function. But, those aside, the process as described by Steve needed only two additional aids: a powerful laser to preheat the fuel, making it easier for the compressed fuel to reach fusion temperatures, and Helmholtz coils above and below the target to generate a separate, weaker magnetic field that would insulate charged particles from giving up their energy, thereby lowering the temperature of the reaction.

Results warmly received

Ongoing experiments on Z will determine how well reality bears out Steve’s predictions, but for now, the reduction of distortions have been warmly received by fusion researchers, leading to an invitation to Tom to present his team’s results at the world’s largest plasma meeting.

The principle of the Z machine is simple: Z’s magnetic force can crush any metal in its path. Possibly, then, it could force the fusion of ions like deuterium in a metal liner a few millimeters in diameter. The magnetic field would crush the liner’s fuel to a diameter of a human hair, causing deuterium to fuse. This would release neutrons that could be used to study radiation effects, one of the key concerns of the National Nuclear Security Administration, which funds the bulk of this research. Additionally, in the far future, and with additional engineering problems solved, the technique,when engineered to fire repetitively, could be used as the basis for an electrical generating plant whose fuel is sea water, a carbon-free energy source for humankind.

“Of course the reality is not that simple,” says Tom, “but the new ability to modify the instability growth on the liner surface may be a step in the right direction.”

-- Neal Singer

Back to top of page

Sandia’s highest grossing patent, granted in 1996, ends its run

Sandia’s Jerry Rejent (1831) applies lead-free solder to a metal. The solder is hardy, environmentally safe, and low-temperature, and has been sold all over the world.  (Photo by Randy Montoya)

by Neal Singer

The simplest products sometimes offer the widest applications.  So seems the case with lead-free solder, Sandia’s simplest yet highest grossing patent. It was granted in 1996 to Sandia, Ames Laboratory, and Iowa State University, and brought millions of dollars back to taxpayers before it ran out in July.

According to Sandia senior manager Mark F. Smith (1830), US Patent 5,527,628 came about because government tests showed that lead-based solder in discarded materials “oxidized, turned to powder, was driven into the ground by rain and snow, and found its way to local aquifers.”

But lead-free solders of the time put electronic fabrication techniques at risk because they required melt temperatures higher than Sandia, and industry, could tolerate.

Sandia researcher Fred Yost (ret.) mentioned this problem to his former PhD advisor, ISU professor J.F. Smith (and Mark Smith’s father), visiting Sandia on a consulting contract. The elder Smith said that there was a region of the tin-silver-copper phase diagram that “looked funny” to him, and he asked Iver Anderson at Ames Lab to collect more data on this alloy. These new data revealed a melting point only slightly higher than the traditional leaded-solder melting point, 217°C vs. 188°C.

Sandia tested the properties of the new solder. When it appeared on the market — hardy, environmentally safe, and low-temperature — it was bought all over the world. —Neal Singer


-- Neal Singer

Back to top of page

Computer power clicks with geochemistry

Randy Cygan (6910) says molecular modeling sheds light on how a waste repository might perform. “It allows us to develop performance assessment tools the Environmental Protection Agency and Nuclear Regulatory Commission need to technically and officially say, ‘Yes, let’s go ahead and put nuclear waste in these repositories.’”  (Photo by Lloyd Wilson)

by Nancy Salem

Radioactive waste disposal can worry people. They want to know where contamination might end up and how it can be kept away from drinking water.

“Very little is known about the fundamental chemistry and whether contaminants will stay in soil or rock or be pulled off those materials and get into the water that flows to communities,” says geoscientist Randy Cygan (6910).

Researchers have studied the geochemistry of contaminants such as radioactive materials or toxic heavy metals like lead, arsenic, and cadmium. But laboratory testing of soils is difficult. “The tricky thing about soils is that the constituent minerals are hard to characterize by traditional methods,” Randy says. “In microscopy there are limits on how much information can be extracted.”

Randy says soils are dominated by clay minerals with ultra-fine grains less than two microns in diameter. “That’s pretty small,” he says. “We can’t slap these materials on a microscope or conventional spectrometer and see if contaminants are incorporated into them.”

Randy and his colleagues are instead developing computer models of how contaminants interact with soil and sediments. “On a computer we can build conceptual models,” he says. “Such molecular models provide a valuable way of testing viable mechanisms for how contaminants interact with the mineral surface.”

He describes clay minerals as the original nanomaterial, the final product of the weathering process of deep-seated rocks. “Rocks weather chemically and physically into clay minerals,” he says. “They have a large surface area that can potentially adsorb many different types of contaminants.”

Clay minerals are made up of aluminosilicate layers held together by electrostatic forces. Water and ions can seep between the layers, causing them to swell, pull apart, and adsorb contaminants. “That’s an efficient way to sequester radionuclides or heavy metals from ground waters,” Randy says. “It’s very difficult to analyze what’s going on in the interlayers at the molecular level through traditional experimental methods.”

Molecular modeling describes the characteristics and interaction of the contaminants in and on the clay minerals. Sandia researchers are developing the simulation tools and the critical energy force field needed to make the tools as accurate and predictive as possible. “We’ve developed a foundational understanding of how the clay minerals interact with contaminants and their atomic components,” Randy says. “That allows us to predict how much of a contaminant can be incorporated into the interlayer and onto external surfaces, and how strongly they bind to the clay.”

The computer models quantify how well a waste repository might perform. “It allows us to develop performance assessment tools the Environmental Protection Agency and Nuclear Regulatory Commission need to technically and officially say, ‘Yes, let’s go ahead and put nuclear waste in these repositories.’”

Molecular modeling methods are also used by industry and government to determine the best types of waste treatment and mitigation. “We’re providing the fundamental science to improve performance assessment models to be as accurate as possible in understanding the surface chemistry of natural materials,” Randy says. “This work helps provide quantification of how strongly or weakly uranium, for example, may adsorb to a clay surface, and whether one type of clay over another may provide a better barrier to radionuclide transport from a waste repository. Our molecular models provide a direct way of making this assessment to better guide the design and engineering of the waste site. How cool is that?”

-- Nancy Salem

Back to top of page

Download Lab News January 10, 2014 (PDF, 2MB)