Naturally occurring structures like birds’ wings or tree trunks are thought to have evolved over eons to reach the best possible balance between stiffness and density.
But in a June paper in Nature Materials, the Brinker and Fan groups at Sandia and the University of New Mexico (UNM), in conjunction with researchers at Case Western Reserve and Princeton universities, show that nanoscale materials self-assembled in artificially determined patterns can improve upon nature’s designs.
Finer scale than found in nature
“Using self-assembly we can construct silica materials at a finer scale than those found in nature,” says principal investigator Jeff Brinker (1002). “Because, at very small dimensions, the structure and mechanical properties of the materials change, facile fabrication of stiff, porous materials needed for microelectronics and membrane applications may be possible.”
Nuclear magnetic resonance and Raman spectroscopic studies performed by Roger Assink (ret.) and Dave Tallant (1822), along with molecular modeling studies performed by Dan Lacks at Case Western Reserve University showed that, as the ordered porous films became more porous, the silica pore walls thinned below 2 nm, rearranging the silica framework to become denser and stiffer.
Less sensitive to increasing porosity
While the stiffness of evolved optimized bone declines proportional to the square of its density, mechanical studies performed by Thomas Buchheit (1814) working with University of New Mexico student Christopher Hartshorn showed that the stiffness/modulus of self-assembled materials was much less sensitive to increasing porosity: For a material synthesized with a cubic arrangement of pores, the modulus declined only as the square root of its density.
The silica nanostructures — basically a synthetic analogue of bone-like cellular structures, replicated at the nanoscale using silica compounds — thus may improve performance where increased pore volume is important.
These include modern thin-film applications such as membrane barriers, molecular recognition sensors, and low-dielectric-constant insulators needed for future generations of microelectronic devices.
Closely examined bones
“Bone, closely examined, is a structured cellular material,” says Jeff, a Sandia Fellow and chemical engineering professor at UNM. “Because, using self-assembly, we had demonstrated the fabrication of a variety of ordered cellular materials at the nanoscale with worm-like (curving cylinders), hexagonal (soda
straw packing) and cubic sphere arrangements of pores (Lab News, Oct. 6, 2000, we wondered whether the modulus-density scaling relationships of these nanoscale materials would be similar to the optimized evolved materials [like bone].
“We found that both material structure and pore sizes matter,” says Jeff. “At all densities we observed that the cubic arrangement was stiffer than the hexagonal arrangement, which was stiffer than the worm-like.”
For each of these structures, increasing porosity caused a reduction in modulus, but the reduction was less than for theoretically optimized or naturally evolved materials due to the attendant stiffening of the thinning nanoscale silica walls resulting from the formation of small stiff silica rings.
“This change in ring structure only happens at the nanoscale,” says Jeff.
Hongyou Fan (1815-1 ) created cubic, cylindrical, and worm-like (or disordered) pores to evaluate differences in stiffness resulting from these differently shaped internal spaces.
Other paper authors include Dave Kissel of UNM, Regina Simpson (1822), and Salvatore Torquato of Princeton.
Funding was provided by DOE’s Office of Science and Sandia’s Laboratory Directed Research and Development office.