{"text_format":"1","workbook":"xlsx","n_sheets":7,"sheets":["Overview & Instructions","Organizations","MBE Maturity Index","MBE Lexicon","Assessment Charts","Score Summary","Peer Comments"],"not_rendered":{"charts":6,"images":4,"macros":1,"external_links":0,"defined_names":11,"comments":1,"pivot_tables":0},"unopened":[],"bounds":{"document_bytes":16777216,"sheet_cells":100000,"rows_first":2000,"rows_last":500,"rows_between":2000,"halvings":0,"cell_chars":16384,"cell_head_chars":4096},"cells_cut":0,"cells_raw":0,"read":"whole","date_system":"1900"}

{"sheet":"Overview & Instructions","index":0,"n_rows":123,"n_cols":4,"rows_kept":123,"cut":false,"hidden":false,"merged":[[119,1,119,15],[67,1,69,1],[110,1,110,15],[56,1,56,19],[57,1,57,19],[108,1,108,15]]}
["Overview and Instructions for Model-Based Enterprise (MBE) Maturity Index"]
[null,"The NSE MBE Maturity Index is a rubric-like tool that an organization uses to assess itself as, and facilitates its transition to, a Model-Based Enterprise (MBE). "]
[null,null,"The intent of this index is to allow an organization to assess their MBE maturity and to identify distinctive steps along their MBE implementation journey. In other words, it identifies the gap from where you are to where you want to be. "]
[null,null,null,"There is no assumption that higher levels of maturity are necessarily better for your organization under assessment."]
[null,null,"The index provides a common point of reference for MBE communication.  It establishes a common context and a common language: the MBE lexicon."]
[null,null,"Through broad categories of activities, topics within a category, and facets of a topic, this tool shows a progression towards becoming more digital, better integrated, and more automated."]
[null,null,"The index is designed to allow an organization to identify different levels of maturity for each of the categories, topics, and facets at three different as-is ratings (i.e., capability, readiness, and adoption). "]
[null,null,"Results from this assessment will allow your organization to tailor an MBE roadmap of where you want your organization to be in some future state. Then this roadmap can be used to develop an MBE implementation plan."]
[null,null,"** There is no requirement to assess all the facets, nor is there a requirement to use all three of the As-is rating areas.  Assessors should complete only those parts of the Index that provide value to the organization under assessment."]
[]
["Contents of this Workbook"]
[null,"Tab 1","Overview & instructions: Some explanations and instructions for using this workbook (this tab)"]
[null,"Tab 2","Organizations: A tool for you to list the organizations pertinent to this assessment, consistent with the definitions in the lexicon."]
[null,"Tab 3","MBE Maturity Index: This is the full assessment tool.  See instructions below."]
[null,"Tab 4","MBE Lexicon: Some key terms with normalized definitions in the MBE vocabulary. Use \"Specialized\" column to refine the definition to your needs.  Use \"Organization Comments\" column to record your thoughts on these terms."]
[null,"Tab 5","Assessment Charts: Shows RADAR charts for your assessment results.  A chart for overall MBE maturity and a chart for each category of activities. (Read Only)"]
[null,"Tab 6","Score Summary: Shows the results of your assessment in tabular fashion. (Read Only)"]
[null,"Tab 7","Peer Comments: Worksheet for capturing peer review comments."]
[]
["Structure of the MBE Maturity Index"]
["Note: You can expand/collapse sections using the +/- symbols or the [1][2] boxes to the left of the Index."]
["●","Columns L0 through L6 are the maturity levels."]
[null,null,"Two columns to the left of L0 provide the description and intent of each row. You can show/hide these columns by clicking on the +/- sign above them."]
["●","Rows are items to assess, and are organized as follows:"]
[null,null,"C# is a broad category of activities."]
[null,null,"T# is a topic within a category"]
[null,null,"F# is a facet of a topic to be assessed.  This is what you actually rate."]
["●","The cell at the intersection of each Facet (row) and Level (column) is an assertion that you will compare your organization against."]
["●","At the far right are the areas where you record your assessment ratings:"]
[null,null,"The TO-BE column is where you record the targets for your organization."]
[null,null,"The AS-IS columns are where you record the ratings for your organization in its current condition:"]
[null,null,null,"Capability refers to the tools, technologies, and standards available for use within the organization."]
[null,null,null,"Readiness refers to the processes, policies, procedures that are ready to be exercised within the organization."]
[null,null,null,"Adoption refers to the degree that people in your organization are actually using those tools and processes."]
[null,null,"Only the WHITE cells are available for input.  All other numeric cells are calculated."]
["●","The index uses grouping, indicated by [1] [2] boxes at the upper left of the sheet, and by +/- indicators"]
[null,null,"Categories/Topics/Facets are grouped rows"]
[null,null,"The columns that contain descriptions of the assessment rows are grouped."]
[null,null,"The columns that contain Point of Contact (POC) and comment fields are grouped."]
["●","A few Categories or Topics have a note/comment that indicate various ways in which the assessor might want to access this Category or Topic.  "]
[null,"These 'Usage' comments prompt the assessor to consider conducting separate assessments (instances of the index) for different usages."]
[]
["When you open the file…"]
["●","Enable macros (click on the prompt, if it shows near the top of the window)."]
["●","Optionally, File->Options->Trust Center->Trust Settings->Macro Settings->Enable all macros"]
[]
["Before you Start with the MBE Assessment…"]
["●","Determine the scope of your assessment."]
["●","Define your organizational structure on the Organizations tab."]
["●","Define the scope of the assessment by organizational, part/subsystem/product, functional, classification, or other boundary conditions (e.g. a horizontal fragment or vertical slice of a supply chain)"]
["●","Determine which categories, topics, and facets to include in the assessment. Also, determine which of the As-is rating areas to include."]
["●","At the top of the MBE Maturity Index worksheet, fill in the header information (ID, name of organization, description of environment, assessor, target date/event, and version)."]
[null,null,"The Organization Under Assessment (OUA) defines your organization. Get this from the Organizations tab."]
[null,null,"The Description of Environment captures the scope."]
[null,null,"The Target Date/Event is when the organization desires to realize their \"TO-BE\" state.  Specify either an event that represents a strategic juncture, or the date associated with the event."]
["●","Browse the entire MBE Maturity Index to become familiar with the content."]
["●","Dependent upon the structure of the OUA, the OUA’s appropriate supra-organization or OUA’s knowledgeable business infrastructure personnel could perform the Capability and Readiness assessment ratings and then the OUA could perform its Adoption assessment ratings."]
["●","Dependent upon the knowledge of the OOA, the appropriate supra-organization or knowledgeable business infrastructure personnel could perform the Capability and Readiness Ratings and then the OOA could perform the Adoption and Target ratings."]
[]
["How to Assess a Given Facet"]
[1,"Read the facet and understand the progression from Level 0 to Level 6."]
[null,"For each assessment, determine which AS-IS rating area (Capability, Readiness, and Adoption) is being assessed:"]
[null,null,"Starting at L0, determine if your organization meets or exceeds the assertion."]
[null,null,"* If YES, then move right to the next level.  If the cell has \"same\", move to the right."]
[null,null,"* If NO, then the previous level is your current level for that facet."]
[null,null,"(For example, if you satisfy the assessment at Level 4 but not Level 5, then your score for that facet is Level 4.)"]
[2,"At the right of each Facet, place your AS-IS ratings in the WHITE cells."]
[null,"Ask yourself -->","Does my organization have technology/tools Capable to perform these requirements?"]
[null,null,"Does my organization have processes Ready to implement these tools to perform these requirements?"]
[null,null,"Has my organization Adopted (actually using) these processes and capabilities to perform their work?"]
[null,"The Index automatically calculates cumulative the AS-IS averages for the Topic, Category, and overall Index."]
[null,"** If the Facet is not applicable to your organization under assessment, fill in the rating cells as N/A.  This line will not be added to your overall score."]
[3,"At the far right of each Facet select a TO-BE rating in the Target column (WHITE cell) per the scope of your assessment."]
[null,"The Index automatically calculates cumulative TO-BE average for topic, category and overall index."]
[4,"As appropriate, use the columns to the far right of the ratings to describe the basis of your assessment."]
[]
["Tips and Tricks"]
["●","You can expand/collapse sections using the +/- symbols or the [1][2] boxes to the left of the Index. "]
[null,"Click here to learn how to use grouping indicators"]
["●","To make mass changes to a block of ratings, use native Excel features (e.g., drag cells, copy & paste)."]
["●","To indicate that you haven't addressed that row yet, you can blank out (empty) a rating cell, instead of using N/A."]
["●","To see a tooltip identifying your position (e.g. C1:T1:F1:L5) in the Index, left-click on any row heading or assertion in the index. (where, C=Category; T=Topic: F=Facet; L=Level.)"]
["●","To go directly to a known position in the Index, right-click anywhere in the index, select \"Go to CTFL Position\", and type a position specifier in the form: \"C#:T#:F#\" or \"C#:T#:F#:L#\"."]
["●","To copy the position of the current cell in the Index, right-click on that cell and select \"Copy Position in Index\"."]
["●","What if I want to skip a Level for a Facet? Consider the progression.  "]
[null,"* If the facet is not cumulative, you may be able to skip a level of maturity without implementing each."]
[null,"* If the facet is cumulative with \"and\" statements, levels are likely not skippable."]
["●","Some Facet definitions have a comment on usage."]
["●","If you really want to reset all scores (to either \"N/A\" or empty) then"]
[null,"* Click on the \"R\" button in the TO-BE column header  to reset all target scores."]
[null,"* Click on the \"Reset\" button in the AS-IS column header to reset all AS-IS scores."]
[]
["Special Meanings"]
[null,"Any assertion cell that says \"Same\" means that level has the same maturity as the one to the LEFT of it. If a new idea or requirement appears in the next level, add or 'AND' that new requirement with the preceding assertion (to the left)."]
[]
["As You Work through the Assessment, Review your MBE Maturity Assessment Charts and Score Summary"]
[null,"As you modify and complete your assessment ratings, the Chart and Chart Data tabs automatically change to reflect your input."]
[null,"Use these aids to determine whether you need to change some of your ratings."]
[null,"The Score Summary sheet contains a Topic Only Summary that helps produce the Assessment Charts; as well as contain a Score Summary for ALL Facets."]
[]
["When You are Done with the Assessment:"]
[null,"Check your work on the Index sheet, Score Summary, and Assessment Charts."]
[null,"Enter the Assessment date at the top of the Index."]
[]
["Distribution Statement:  "]
[null,"Title: NSE MBE Maturity Index (UUR), Issue C.1, February 18, 2026, © 2026"]
[null,"Issue: C.1.b"]
[null,"Creator: Model-Based Integrated Team (MBIT), MBE Committee, lead editor Mr. Curtis W. Brown, Kansas City Nuclear Security Complex (KCNSC)."]
[null,"This document is Issue C.1 of the NSE MBE Maturity Index and approved for public distribution via report NSC-614-7804, dated 20260218 and is designated as Unclassified Unlimited Release (UUR). "]
[null,"License grant: Creative Commons CC BY-SA:\n"]
[null,"This license enables re-users to distribute, remix, adapt, and build upon the material in any medium or format, so long as attribution is given to the creator. The license allows for commercial use. If you remix, adapt, or build upon the material, you must license the modified material under identical terms. CC BY-SA includes the following elements:\n\n BY: credit must be given to the creator.\n SA: Adaptations must be shared under the same terms.\n"]
[null,"Comments, suggestions, or questions on this document should be addressed to Curtis Brown, cbrown@kcnsc.doe.gov"]
[]
["Distribution Location:"]
[null,"The latest released version of this index, C.1, and corresponding papers and presentations can be located via the following URLs."]
[null,"NSC MBE Maturity Index (UUR) Issue C.1 – MBIT Model Based Enterprise (sandia.gov)"]
[null,"https://www.sandia.gov/mbit-mbe/category/index/"]
[null,"Note: Both URL's point to the same destination URL."]
[]
[null,"Honeywell Federal Manufacturing & Technologies, LLC operates the Kansas City National Security Campus for the United States Department of Energy / National Nuclear Security Administration under Contract Number DE-NA0002839"]
[]
[null,"NSC-614-7804 dated 20260218 Unclassified Unlimited Release (UUR)"]
[null,"SAND2026-200560"]

{"sheet":"Organizations","index":1,"n_rows":53,"n_cols":12,"rows_kept":53,"cut":false,"hidden":false,"merged":[[8,1,8,5],[7,8,7,11],[8,8,8,11],[4,1,4,5],[4,8,4,11],[5,1,5,5],[5,8,5,11],[6,1,6,5],[6,8,6,11],[7,1,7,5],[1,1,1,5],[1,7,1,11],[2,1,2,5],[2,8,2,11],[3,1,3,5],[3,8,3,11]]}
[]
[null,"How to Identify The Organizations Within Your Enterprise",null,null,null,null,null,"Term Definitions for Convenience (also referenced within the MBE Lexicon worksheet):"]
[null,"The terms at the tops of the lists shown below are used throughout the index, usually to indicate the scope of a particular facet.",null,null,null,null,null,"Organization",{"$f":"_xlfn.XLOOKUP(H3,'MBE Lexicon'!B:B,'MBE Lexicon'!C:C,NA(),0,1)","v":"An autonomous group of people who work together for a common purpose of activities."}]
[null,"Typically, as the maturity score increases, the particular facet expands in scope to include more organizations.",null,null,null,null,null,"Organization Under Assessment",{"$f":"_xlfn.XLOOKUP(H4,'MBE Lexicon'!B:B,'MBE Lexicon'!C:C,NA(),0,1)","v":"The organization that is the subject of this assessment."}]
[null,"This sheet is a place to list those organizations that are, or may become, part of your Model-Based Enterprise.",null,null,null,null,null,"Organization, Peer",{"$f":"_xlfn.XLOOKUP(H5,'MBE Lexicon'!B:B,'MBE Lexicon'!C:C,NA(),0,1)","v":"An organization that is of equal standing with the OUA under the same Supra-Organization."}]
[null,"Fill out light blue cells in columns 1, 2, 3, and 5 below.  (See Term Definitions for Convenience)",null,null,null,null,null,"Organization, Supra",{"$f":"_xlfn.XLOOKUP(H6,'MBE Lexicon'!B:B,'MBE Lexicon'!C:C,NA(),0,1)","v":"An organization that is hierarchically above the OUA and Peer-Organizations."}]
[null,"The light orange cells in columns 4 and 6, auto-populate to demonstrate that the Enterprise and Extended Enterprise are a combination from others.",null,null,null,null,null,"Enterprise",{"$f":"_xlfn.XLOOKUP(H7,'MBE Lexicon'!B:B,'MBE Lexicon'!C:C,NA(),0,1)","v":"The organization that comprises the OUA, Peer-Organizations, and Supra-Organization."}]
[null,"Optionally, fill out the blue cell above list 4 if your Enterprise has an explicit name. This will override the combination of the prior lists.",null,null,null,null,null,"Organization, Extended",{"$f":"_xlfn.XLOOKUP(H8,'MBE Lexicon'!B:B,'MBE Lexicon'!C:C,NA(),0,1)","v":"An organization outside of the Enterprise (e.g., supplier, customer) but coordinated with."}]
[null,"The organizational related definitions from the MBE Lexicon are repeated to the right for convenience.",null,null,null,null,null,"Enterprise, Extended",{"$f":"_xlfn.XLOOKUP(H9,'MBE Lexicon'!B:B,'MBE Lexicon'!C:C,NA(),0,1)","v":"The group of organizations comprised of the Enterprise and Extended Organizations."}]
[]
[]
[null,1,null,2,null,3,null,4,null,5,null,6]
[null,"Organization Under Assessment (OUA)",null,"Peer-Organizations",null,"Supra-Organization",null,"Enterprise",null,"Extended Organization",null,"Extended Enterprise"]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"IF(Named_Enterprise<>\"\",\n    IF(COUNTA(H$13:H13)=1,Named_Enterprise,\"\"),\n    IFERROR(\n        INDEX(\n            T_OUA[],\n            _xlfn.AGGREGATE(15,6,\n                (ROW(T_OUA[]) - ROW(T_OUA[#Headers])) / (T_OUA[] <> \"\"),\n                ROW() - ROW(T_Enterprise[#Headers])\n            )\n        ),\n        IFERROR(\n            INDEX(\n                T_Peer_Orgs[],\n                _xlfn.AGGREGATE(15,6,\n                    (ROW(T_Peer_Orgs[]) - ROW(T_Peer_Orgs[#Headers])) / (T_Peer_Orgs[] <> \"\"),\n                    (ROW() - ROW(T_Enterprise[#Headers])) - COUNTIF(T_OUA[], \"<>\")\n                )\n            ),\n            IFERROR(\n                INDEX(\n                    T_Supra_Org[],\n                    _xlfn.AGGREGATE(15,6,\n                        (ROW(T_Supra_Org[]) - ROW(T_Supra_Org[#Headers])) / (T_Supra_Org[] <> \"\"),\n                        (ROW() - ROW(T_Enterprise[#Headers])) - COUNTIF(T_OUA[], \"<>\") - COUNTIF(T_Peer_Orgs[], \"<>\")\n                    )\n                ),\n                \"\"\n            )\n        )\n    )\n)","v":""},null,null,null,{"$f":"IFERROR(\n    INDEX(\n        T_Enterprise[],\n        _xlfn.AGGREGATE(15,6,\n            (ROW(T_Enterprise[]) - ROW(T_Enterprise[#Headers])) / (T_Enterprise[] <> \"\"),\n            ROW() - ROW(T_Extended_Enterprise[#Headers])\n        )\n    ),\n    IFERROR(\n        INDEX(\n            T_Extended_Orgs[],\n            _xlfn.AGGREGATE(15,6,\n                (ROW(T_Extended_Orgs[]) - ROW(T_Extended_Orgs[#Headers])) / (T_Extended_Orgs[] <> \"\"),\n                ROW() - ROW(T_Extended_Enterprise[#Headers]) - COUNTIF(T_Enterprise[], \"<>\") + COUNTBLANK(T_Enterprise[])\n            )\n        ),\"\")\n)","v":""}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"IF(Named_Enterprise<>\"\",\n    IF(COUNTA(H$13:H14)=1,Named_Enterprise,\"\"),\n    IFERROR(\n        INDEX(\n            T_OUA[],\n            _xlfn.AGGREGATE(15,6,\n                (ROW(T_OUA[]) - ROW(T_OUA[#Headers])) / (T_OUA[] <> \"\"),\n                ROW() - ROW(T_Enterprise[#Headers])\n            )\n        ),\n        IFERROR(\n            INDEX(\n                T_Peer_Orgs[],\n                _xlfn.AGGREGATE(15,6,\n                    (ROW(T_Peer_Orgs[]) - ROW(T_Peer_Orgs[#Headers])) / (T_Peer_Orgs[] <> \"\"),\n                    (ROW() - ROW(T_Enterprise[#Headers])) - COUNTIF(T_OUA[], \"<>\")\n                )\n            ),\n            IFERROR(\n                INDEX(\n                    T_Supra_Org[],\n                    _xlfn.AGGREGATE(15,6,\n                        (ROW(T_Supra_Org[]) - ROW(T_Supra_Org[#Headers])) / (T_Supra_Org[] <> \"\"),\n                        (ROW() - ROW(T_Enterprise[#Headers])) - COUNTIF(T_OUA[], \"<>\") - COUNTIF(T_Peer_Orgs[], \"<>\")\n                    )\n                ),\n                \"\"\n            )\n        )\n    )\n)","v":""},null,null,null,{"$f":"IFERROR(\n    INDEX(\n        T_Enterprise[],\n        _xlfn.AGGREGATE(15,6,\n            (ROW(T_Enterprise[]) - ROW(T_Enterprise[#Headers])) / (T_Enterprise[] <> \"\"),\n            ROW() - ROW(T_Extended_Enterprise[#Headers])\n        )\n    ),\n    IFERROR(\n        INDEX(\n            T_Extended_Orgs[],\n            _xlfn.AGGREGATE(15,6,\n                (ROW(T_Extended_Orgs[]) - ROW(T_Extended_Orgs[#Headers])) / (T_Extended_Orgs[] <> \"\"),\n                ROW() - ROW(T_Extended_Enterprise[#Headers]) - COUNTIF(T_Enterprise[], \"<>\") + COUNTBLANK(T_Enterprise[])\n            )\n        ),\"\")\n)","v":""}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"IF(Named_Enterprise<>\"\",\n    IF(COUNTA(H$13:H15)=1,Named_Enterprise,\"\"),\n    IFERROR(\n        INDEX(\n            T_OUA[],\n            _xlfn.AGGREGATE(15,6,\n                (ROW(T_OUA[]) - ROW(T_OUA[#Headers])) / (T_OUA[] <> \"\"),\n                ROW() - ROW(T_Enterprise[#Headers])\n            )\n        ),\n        IFERROR(\n            INDEX(\n                T_Peer_Orgs[],\n                _xlfn.AGGREGATE(15,6,\n                    (ROW(T_Peer_Orgs[]) - ROW(T_Peer_Orgs[#Headers])) / (T_Peer_Orgs[] <> \"\"),\n                    (ROW() - ROW(T_Enterprise[#Headers])) - COUNTIF(T_OUA[], \"<>\")\n                )\n            ),\n            IFERROR(\n                INDEX(\n                    T_Supra_Org[],\n                    _xlfn.AGGREGATE(15,6,\n                        (ROW(T_Supra_Org[]) - ROW(T_Supra_Org[#Headers])) / (T_Supra_Org[] <> \"\"),\n                        (ROW() - ROW(T_Enterprise[#Headers])) - COUNTIF(T_OUA[], \"<>\") - COUNTIF(T_Peer_Orgs[], \"<>\")\n                    )\n                ),\n                \"\"\n            )\n        )\n    )\n)","v":""},null,null,null,{"$f":"IFERROR(\n    INDEX(\n        T_Enterprise[],\n        _xlfn.AGGREGATE(15,6,\n            (ROW(T_Enterprise[]) - ROW(T_Enterprise[#Headers])) / (T_Enterprise[] <> \"\"),\n            ROW() - ROW(T_Extended_Enterprise[#Headers])\n        )\n    ),\n    IFERROR(\n        INDEX(\n            T_Extended_Orgs[],\n            _xlfn.AGGREGATE(15,6,\n                (ROW(T_Extended_Orgs[]) - ROW(T_Extended_Orgs[#Headers])) / (T_Extended_Orgs[] <> \"\"),\n                ROW() - ROW(T_Extended_Enterprise[#Headers]) - COUNTIF(T_Enterprise[], \"<>\") + COUNTBLANK(T_Enterprise[])\n            )\n        ),\"\")\n)","v":""}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"IF(Named_Enterprise<>\"\",\n    IF(COUNTA(H$13:H16)=1,Named_Enterprise,\"\"),\n    IFERROR(\n        INDEX(\n            T_OUA[],\n            _xlfn.AGGREGATE(15,6,\n                (ROW(T_OUA[]) - ROW(T_OUA[#Headers])) / (T_OUA[] <> \"\"),\n                ROW() - ROW(T_Enterprise[#Headers])\n            )\n        ),\n        IFERROR(\n            INDEX(\n                T_Peer_Orgs[],\n                _xlfn.AGGREGATE(15,6,\n                    (ROW(T_Peer_Orgs[]) - ROW(T_Peer_Orgs[#Headers])) / (T_Peer_Orgs[] <> \"\"),\n                    (ROW() - ROW(T_Enterprise[#Headers])) - COUNTIF(T_OUA[], \"<>\")\n                )\n            ),\n            IFERROR(\n                INDEX(\n                    T_Supra_Org[],\n                    _xlfn.AGGREGATE(15,6,\n                        (ROW(T_Supra_Org[]) - ROW(T_Supra_Org[#Headers])) / (T_Supra_Org[] <> \"\"),\n                        (ROW() - ROW(T_Enterprise[#Headers])) - COUNTIF(T_OUA[], \"<>\") - COUNTIF(T_Peer_Orgs[], \"<>\")\n                    )\n                ),\n                \"\"\n            )\n        )\n    )\n)","v":""},null,null,null,{"$f":"IFERROR(\n    INDEX(\n        T_Enterprise[],\n        _xlfn.AGGREGATE(15,6,\n            (ROW(T_Enterprise[]) - ROW(T_Enterprise[#Headers])) / (T_Enterprise[] <> \"\"),\n            ROW() - ROW(T_Extended_Enterprise[#Headers])\n        )\n    ),\n    IFERROR(\n        INDEX(\n            T_Extended_Orgs[],\n            _xlfn.AGGREGATE(15,6,\n                (ROW(T_Extended_Orgs[]) - ROW(T_Extended_Orgs[#Headers])) / (T_Extended_Orgs[] <> \"\"),\n                ROW() - ROW(T_Extended_Enterprise[#Headers]) - COUNTIF(T_Enterprise[], \"<>\") + COUNTBLANK(T_Enterprise[])\n            )\n        ),\"\")\n)","v":""}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"IF(Named_Enterprise<>\"\",\n    IF(COUNTA(H$13:H17)=1,Named_Enterprise,\"\"),\n    IFERROR(\n        INDEX(\n            T_OUA[],\n            _xlfn.AGGREGATE(15,6,\n                (ROW(T_OUA[]) - ROW(T_OUA[#Headers])) / (T_OUA[] <> \"\"),\n                ROW() - ROW(T_Enterprise[#Headers])\n            )\n        ),\n        IFERROR(\n            INDEX(\n                T_Peer_Orgs[],\n                _xlfn.AGGREGATE(15,6,\n                    (ROW(T_Peer_Orgs[]) - ROW(T_Peer_Orgs[#Headers])) / (T_Peer_Orgs[] <> \"\"),\n                    (ROW() - ROW(T_Enterprise[#Headers])) - COUNTIF(T_OUA[], \"<>\")\n                )\n            ),\n            IFERROR(\n                INDEX(\n                    T_Supra_Org[],\n                    _xlfn.AGGREGATE(15,6,\n                        (ROW(T_Supra_Org[]) - ROW(T_Supra_Org[#Headers])) / (T_Supra_Org[] <> \"\"),\n                        (ROW() - ROW(T_Enterprise[#Headers])) - COUNTIF(T_OUA[], \"<>\") - COUNTIF(T_Peer_Orgs[], \"<>\")\n                    )\n                ),\n                \"\"\n            )\n        )\n    )\n)","v":""},null,null,null,{"$f":"IFERROR(\n    INDEX(\n        T_Enterprise[],\n        _xlfn.AGGREGATE(15,6,\n            (ROW(T_Enterprise[]) - ROW(T_Enterprise[#Headers])) / (T_Enterprise[] <> \"\"),\n            ROW() - ROW(T_Extended_Enterprise[#Headers])\n        )\n    ),\n    IFERROR(\n        INDEX(\n            T_Extended_Orgs[],\n            _xlfn.AGGREGATE(15,6,\n                (ROW(T_Extended_Orgs[]) - ROW(T_Extended_Orgs[#Headers])) / (T_Extended_Orgs[] <> \"\"),\n                ROW() - ROW(T_Extended_Enterprise[#Headers]) - COUNTIF(T_Enterprise[], \"<>\") + COUNTBLANK(T_Enterprise[])\n            )\n        ),\"\")\n)","v":""}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"IF(Named_Enterprise<>\"\",\n    IF(COUNTA(H$13:H18)=1,Named_Enterprise,\"\"),\n    IFERROR(\n        INDEX(\n            T_OUA[],\n            _xlfn.AGGREGATE(15,6,\n                (ROW(T_OUA[]) - ROW(T_OUA[#Headers])) / (T_OUA[] <> \"\"),\n                ROW() - ROW(T_Enterprise[#Headers])\n            )\n        ),\n        IFERROR(\n            INDEX(\n                T_Peer_Orgs[],\n                _xlfn.AGGREGATE(15,6,\n                    (ROW(T_Peer_Orgs[]) - ROW(T_Peer_Orgs[#Headers])) / (T_Peer_Orgs[] <> \"\"),\n                    (ROW() - ROW(T_Enterprise[#Headers])) - COUNTIF(T_OUA[], \"<>\")\n                )\n            ),\n            IFERROR(\n                INDEX(\n                    T_Supra_Org[],\n                    _xlfn.AGGREGATE(15,6,\n                        (ROW(T_Supra_Org[]) - ROW(T_Supra_Org[#Headers])) / (T_Supra_Org[] <> \"\"),\n                        (ROW() - ROW(T_Enterprise[#Headers])) - COUNTIF(T_OUA[], \"<>\") - COUNTIF(T_Peer_Orgs[], \"<>\")\n                    )\n                ),\n                \"\"\n            )\n        )\n    )\n)","v":""},null,null,null,{"$f":"IFERROR(\n    INDEX(\n        T_Enterprise[],\n        _xlfn.AGGREGATE(15,6,\n            (ROW(T_Enterprise[]) - ROW(T_Enterprise[#Headers])) / (T_Enterprise[] <> \"\"),\n            ROW() - ROW(T_Extended_Enterprise[#Headers])\n        )\n    ),\n    IFERROR(\n        INDEX(\n            T_Extended_Orgs[],\n            _xlfn.AGGREGATE(15,6,\n                (ROW(T_Extended_Orgs[]) - ROW(T_Extended_Orgs[#Headers])) / (T_Extended_Orgs[] <> \"\"),\n                ROW() - ROW(T_Extended_Enterprise[#Headers]) - COUNTIF(T_Enterprise[], \"<>\") + COUNTBLANK(T_Enterprise[])\n            )\n        ),\"\")\n)","v":""}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"IF(Named_Enterprise<>\"\",\n    IF(COUNTA(H$13:H19)=1,Named_Enterprise,\"\"),\n    IFERROR(\n        INDEX(\n            T_OUA[],\n            _xlfn.AGGREGATE(15,6,\n                (ROW(T_OUA[]) - ROW(T_OUA[#Headers])) / (T_OUA[] <> \"\"),\n                ROW() - ROW(T_Enterprise[#Headers])\n            )\n        ),\n        IFERROR(\n            INDEX(\n                T_Peer_Orgs[],\n                _xlfn.AGGREGATE(15,6,\n                    (ROW(T_Peer_Orgs[]) - ROW(T_Peer_Orgs[#Headers])) / (T_Peer_Orgs[] <> \"\"),\n                    (ROW() - ROW(T_Enterprise[#Headers])) - COUNTIF(T_OUA[], \"<>\")\n                )\n            ),\n            IFERROR(\n                INDEX(\n                    T_Supra_Org[],\n                    _xlfn.AGGREGATE(15,6,\n                        (ROW(T_Supra_Org[]) - ROW(T_Supra_Org[#Headers])) / (T_Supra_Org[] <> \"\"),\n                        (ROW() - ROW(T_Enterprise[#Headers])) - COUNTIF(T_OUA[], \"<>\") - COUNTIF(T_Peer_Orgs[], \"<>\")\n                    )\n                ),\n                \"\"\n            )\n        )\n    )\n)","v":""},null,null,null,{"$f":"IFERROR(\n    INDEX(\n        T_Enterprise[],\n        _xlfn.AGGREGATE(15,6,\n            (ROW(T_Enterprise[]) - ROW(T_Enterprise[#Headers])) / (T_Enterprise[] <> \"\"),\n            ROW() - ROW(T_Extended_Enterprise[#Headers])\n        )\n    ),\n    IFERROR(\n        INDEX(\n            T_Extended_Orgs[],\n            _xlfn.AGGREGATE(15,6,\n                (ROW(T_Extended_Orgs[]) - ROW(T_Extended_Orgs[#Headers])) / (T_Extended_Orgs[] <> \"\"),\n                ROW() - ROW(T_Extended_Enterprise[#Headers]) - COUNTIF(T_Enterprise[], \"<>\") + COUNTBLANK(T_Enterprise[])\n            )\n        ),\"\")\n)","v":""}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"IF(Named_Enterprise<>\"\",\n    IF(COUNTA(H$13:H20)=1,Named_Enterprise,\"\"),\n    IFERROR(\n        INDEX(\n            T_OUA[],\n            _xlfn.AGGREGATE(15,6,\n                (ROW(T_OUA[]) - ROW(T_OUA[#Headers])) / (T_OUA[] <> \"\"),\n                ROW() - ROW(T_Enterprise[#Headers])\n            )\n        ),\n        IFERROR(\n            INDEX(\n                T_Peer_Orgs[],\n                _xlfn.AGGREGATE(15,6,\n                    (ROW(T_Peer_Orgs[]) - ROW(T_Peer_Orgs[#Headers])) / (T_Peer_Orgs[] <> \"\"),\n                    (ROW() - ROW(T_Enterprise[#Headers])) - COUNTIF(T_OUA[], \"<>\")\n                )\n            ),\n            IFERROR(\n                INDEX(\n                    T_Supra_Org[],\n                    _xlfn.AGGREGATE(15,6,\n                        (ROW(T_Supra_Org[]) - ROW(T_Supra_Org[#Headers])) / (T_Supra_Org[] <> \"\"),\n                        (ROW() - ROW(T_Enterprise[#Headers])) - COUNTIF(T_OUA[], \"<>\") - COUNTIF(T_Peer_Orgs[], \"<>\")\n                    )\n                ),\n                \"\"\n            )\n        )\n    )\n)","v":""},null,null,null,{"$f":"IFERROR(\n    INDEX(\n        T_Enterprise[],\n        _xlfn.AGGREGATE(15,6,\n            (ROW(T_Enterprise[]) - ROW(T_Enterprise[#Headers])) / (T_Enterprise[] <> \"\"),\n            ROW() - ROW(T_Extended_Enterprise[#Headers])\n        )\n    ),\n    IFERROR(\n        INDEX(\n            T_Extended_Orgs[],\n            _xlfn.AGGREGATE(15,6,\n                (ROW(T_Extended_Orgs[]) - ROW(T_Extended_Orgs[#Headers])) / (T_Extended_Orgs[] <> \"\"),\n                ROW() - ROW(T_Extended_Enterprise[#Headers]) - COUNTIF(T_Enterprise[], \"<>\") + COUNTBLANK(T_Enterprise[])\n            )\n        ),\"\")\n)","v":""}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"IF(Named_Enterprise<>\"\",\n    IF(COUNTA(H$13:H21)=1,Named_Enterprise,\"\"),\n    IFERROR(\n        INDEX(\n            T_OUA[],\n            _xlfn.AGGREGATE(15,6,\n                (ROW(T_OUA[]) - ROW(T_OUA[#Headers])) / (T_OUA[] <> \"\"),\n                ROW() - ROW(T_Enterprise[#Headers])\n            )\n        ),\n        IFERROR(\n            INDEX(\n                T_Peer_Orgs[],\n                _xlfn.AGGREGATE(15,6,\n                    (ROW(T_Peer_Orgs[]) - ROW(T_Peer_Orgs[#Headers])) / (T_Peer_Orgs[] <> \"\"),\n                    (ROW() - ROW(T_Enterprise[#Headers])) - COUNTIF(T_OUA[], \"<>\")\n                )\n            ),\n            IFERROR(\n                INDEX(\n                    T_Supra_Org[],\n                    _xlfn.AGGREGATE(15,6,\n                        (ROW(T_Supra_Org[]) - ROW(T_Supra_Org[#Headers])) / (T_Supra_Org[] <> \"\"),\n                        (ROW() - ROW(T_Enterprise[#Headers])) - COUNTIF(T_OUA[], \"<>\") - COUNTIF(T_Peer_Orgs[], \"<>\")\n                    )\n                ),\n                \"\"\n            )\n        )\n    )\n)","v":""},null,null,null,{"$f":"IFERROR(\n    INDEX(\n        T_Enterprise[],\n        _xlfn.AGGREGATE(15,6,\n            (ROW(T_Enterprise[]) - ROW(T_Enterprise[#Headers])) / (T_Enterprise[] <> \"\"),\n            ROW() - ROW(T_Extended_Enterprise[#Headers])\n        )\n    ),\n    IFERROR(\n        INDEX(\n            T_Extended_Orgs[],\n            _xlfn.AGGREGATE(15,6,\n                (ROW(T_Extended_Orgs[]) - ROW(T_Extended_Orgs[#Headers])) / (T_Extended_Orgs[] <> \"\"),\n                ROW() - ROW(T_Extended_Enterprise[#Headers]) - COUNTIF(T_Enterprise[], \"<>\") + COUNTBLANK(T_Enterprise[])\n            )\n        ),\"\")\n)","v":""}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"IF(Named_Enterprise<>\"\",\n    IF(COUNTA(H$13:H22)=1,Named_Enterprise,\"\"),\n    IFERROR(\n        INDEX(\n            T_OUA[],\n            _xlfn.AGGREGATE(15,6,\n                (ROW(T_OUA[]) - ROW(T_OUA[#Headers])) / (T_OUA[] <> \"\"),\n                ROW() - ROW(T_Enterprise[#Headers])\n            )\n        ),\n        IFERROR(\n            INDEX(\n                T_Peer_Orgs[],\n                _xlfn.AGGREGATE(15,6,\n                    (ROW(T_Peer_Orgs[]) - ROW(T_Peer_Orgs[#Headers])) / (T_Peer_Orgs[] <> \"\"),\n                    (ROW() - ROW(T_Enterprise[#Headers])) - COUNTIF(T_OUA[], \"<>\")\n                )\n            ),\n            IFERROR(\n                INDEX(\n                    T_Supra_Org[],\n                    _xlfn.AGGREGATE(15,6,\n                        (ROW(T_Supra_Org[]) - ROW(T_Supra_Org[#Headers])) / (T_Supra_Org[] <> \"\"),\n                        (ROW() - ROW(T_Enterprise[#Headers])) - COUNTIF(T_OUA[], \"<>\") - COUNTIF(T_Peer_Orgs[], \"<>\")\n                    )\n                ),\n                \"\"\n            )\n        )\n    )\n)","v":""},null,null,null,{"$f":"IFERROR(\n    INDEX(\n        T_Enterprise[],\n        _xlfn.AGGREGATE(15,6,\n            (ROW(T_Enterprise[]) - ROW(T_Enterprise[#Headers])) / (T_Enterprise[] <> \"\"),\n            ROW() - ROW(T_Extended_Enterprise[#Headers])\n        )\n    ),\n    IFERROR(\n        INDEX(\n            T_Extended_Orgs[],\n            _xlfn.AGGREGATE(15,6,\n                (ROW(T_Extended_Orgs[]) - ROW(T_Extended_Orgs[#Headers])) / (T_Extended_Orgs[] <> \"\"),\n                ROW() - ROW(T_Extended_Enterprise[#Headers]) - COUNTIF(T_Enterprise[], \"<>\") + COUNTBLANK(T_Enterprise[])\n            )\n        ),\"\")\n)","v":""}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"IF(Named_Enterprise<>\"\",\n    IF(COUNTA(H$13:H23)=1,Named_Enterprise,\"\"),\n    IFERROR(\n        INDEX(\n            T_OUA[],\n            _xlfn.AGGREGATE(15,6,\n                (ROW(T_OUA[]) - ROW(T_OUA[#Headers])) / (T_OUA[] <> \"\"),\n                ROW() - ROW(T_Enterprise[#Headers])\n            )\n        ),\n        IFERROR(\n            INDEX(\n                T_Peer_Orgs[],\n                _xlfn.AGGREGATE(15,6,\n                    (ROW(T_Peer_Orgs[]) - ROW(T_Peer_Orgs[#Headers])) / (T_Peer_Orgs[] <> \"\"),\n                    (ROW() - ROW(T_Enterprise[#Headers])) - COUNTIF(T_OUA[], \"<>\")\n                )\n            ),\n            IFERROR(\n                INDEX(\n                    T_Supra_Org[],\n                    _xlfn.AGGREGATE(15,6,\n                        (ROW(T_Supra_Org[]) - ROW(T_Supra_Org[#Headers])) / (T_Supra_Org[] <> \"\"),\n                        (ROW() - ROW(T_Enterprise[#Headers])) - COUNTIF(T_OUA[], \"<>\") - COUNTIF(T_Peer_Orgs[], \"<>\")\n                    )\n                ),\n                \"\"\n            )\n        )\n    )\n)","v":""},null,null,null,{"$f":"IFERROR(\n    INDEX(\n        T_Enterprise[],\n        _xlfn.AGGREGATE(15,6,\n            (ROW(T_Enterprise[]) - ROW(T_Enterprise[#Headers])) / (T_Enterprise[] <> \"\"),\n            ROW() - ROW(T_Extended_Enterprise[#Headers])\n        )\n    ),\n    IFERROR(\n        INDEX(\n            T_Extended_Orgs[],\n            _xlfn.AGGREGATE(15,6,\n                (ROW(T_Extended_Orgs[]) - ROW(T_Extended_Orgs[#Headers])) / (T_Extended_Orgs[] <> \"\"),\n                ROW() - ROW(T_Extended_Enterprise[#Headers]) - COUNTIF(T_Enterprise[], \"<>\") + COUNTBLANK(T_Enterprise[])\n            )\n        ),\"\")\n)","v":""}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"IF(Named_Enterprise<>\"\",\n    IF(COUNTA(H$13:H24)=1,Named_Enterprise,\"\"),\n    IFERROR(\n        INDEX(\n            T_OUA[],\n            _xlfn.AGGREGATE(15,6,\n                (ROW(T_OUA[]) - ROW(T_OUA[#Headers])) / (T_OUA[] <> \"\"),\n                ROW() - ROW(T_Enterprise[#Headers])\n            )\n        ),\n        IFERROR(\n            INDEX(\n                T_Peer_Orgs[],\n                _xlfn.AGGREGATE(15,6,\n                    (ROW(T_Peer_Orgs[]) - ROW(T_Peer_Orgs[#Headers])) / (T_Peer_Orgs[] <> \"\"),\n                    (ROW() - ROW(T_Enterprise[#Headers])) - COUNTIF(T_OUA[], \"<>\")\n                )\n            ),\n            IFERROR(\n                INDEX(\n                    T_Supra_Org[],\n                    _xlfn.AGGREGATE(15,6,\n                        (ROW(T_Supra_Org[]) - ROW(T_Supra_Org[#Headers])) / (T_Supra_Org[] <> \"\"),\n                        (ROW() - ROW(T_Enterprise[#Headers])) - COUNTIF(T_OUA[], \"<>\") - COUNTIF(T_Peer_Orgs[], \"<>\")\n                    )\n                ),\n                \"\"\n            )\n        )\n    )\n)","v":""},null,null,null,{"$f":"IFERROR(\n    INDEX(\n        T_Enterprise[],\n        _xlfn.AGGREGATE(15,6,\n            (ROW(T_Enterprise[]) - ROW(T_Enterprise[#Headers])) / (T_Enterprise[] <> \"\"),\n            ROW() - ROW(T_Extended_Enterprise[#Headers])\n        )\n    ),\n    IFERROR(\n        INDEX(\n            T_Extended_Orgs[],\n            _xlfn.AGGREGATE(15,6,\n                (ROW(T_Extended_Orgs[]) - ROW(T_Extended_Orgs[#Headers])) / (T_Extended_Orgs[] <> \"\"),\n                ROW() - ROW(T_Extended_Enterprise[#Headers]) - COUNTIF(T_Enterprise[], \"<>\") + COUNTBLANK(T_Enterprise[])\n            )\n        ),\"\")\n)","v":""}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"IF(Named_Enterprise<>\"\",\n    IF(COUNTA(H$13:H25)=1,Named_Enterprise,\"\"),\n    IFERROR(\n        INDEX(\n            T_OUA[],\n            _xlfn.AGGREGATE(15,6,\n                (ROW(T_OUA[]) - ROW(T_OUA[#Headers])) / (T_OUA[] <> \"\"),\n                ROW() - ROW(T_Enterprise[#Headers])\n            )\n        ),\n        IFERROR(\n            INDEX(\n                T_Peer_Orgs[],\n                _xlfn.AGGREGATE(15,6,\n                    (ROW(T_Peer_Orgs[]) - ROW(T_Peer_Orgs[#Headers])) / (T_Peer_Orgs[] <> \"\"),\n                    (ROW() - ROW(T_Enterprise[#Headers])) - COUNTIF(T_OUA[], \"<>\")\n                )\n            ),\n            IFERROR(\n                INDEX(\n                    T_Supra_Org[],\n                    _xlfn.AGGREGATE(15,6,\n                        (ROW(T_Supra_Org[]) - ROW(T_Supra_Org[#Headers])) / (T_Supra_Org[] <> \"\"),\n                        (ROW() - ROW(T_Enterprise[#Headers])) - COUNTIF(T_OUA[], \"<>\") - COUNTIF(T_Peer_Orgs[], \"<>\")\n                    )\n                ),\n                \"\"\n            )\n        )\n    )\n)","v":""},null,null,null,{"$f":"IFERROR(\n    INDEX(\n        T_Enterprise[],\n        _xlfn.AGGREGATE(15,6,\n            (ROW(T_Enterprise[]) - ROW(T_Enterprise[#Headers])) / (T_Enterprise[] <> \"\"),\n            ROW() - ROW(T_Extended_Enterprise[#Headers])\n        )\n    ),\n    IFERROR(\n        INDEX(\n            T_Extended_Orgs[],\n            _xlfn.AGGREGATE(15,6,\n                (ROW(T_Extended_Orgs[]) - ROW(T_Extended_Orgs[#Headers])) / (T_Extended_Orgs[] <> \"\"),\n                ROW() - ROW(T_Extended_Enterprise[#Headers]) - COUNTIF(T_Enterprise[], \"<>\") + COUNTBLANK(T_Enterprise[])\n            )\n        ),\"\")\n)","v":""}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"IF(Named_Enterprise<>\"\",\n    IF(COUNTA(H$13:H26)=1,Named_Enterprise,\"\"),\n    IFERROR(\n        INDEX(\n            T_OUA[],\n            _xlfn.AGGREGATE(15,6,\n                (ROW(T_OUA[]) - ROW(T_OUA[#Headers])) / (T_OUA[] <> \"\"),\n                ROW() - ROW(T_Enterprise[#Headers])\n            )\n        ),\n        IFERROR(\n            INDEX(\n                T_Peer_Orgs[],\n                _xlfn.AGGREGATE(15,6,\n                    (ROW(T_Peer_Orgs[]) - ROW(T_Peer_Orgs[#Headers])) / (T_Peer_Orgs[] <> \"\"),\n                    (ROW() - ROW(T_Enterprise[#Headers])) - COUNTIF(T_OUA[], \"<>\")\n                )\n            ),\n            IFERROR(\n                INDEX(\n                    T_Supra_Org[],\n                    _xlfn.AGGREGATE(15,6,\n                        (ROW(T_Supra_Org[]) - ROW(T_Supra_Org[#Headers])) / (T_Supra_Org[] <> \"\"),\n                        (ROW() - ROW(T_Enterprise[#Headers])) - COUNTIF(T_OUA[], \"<>\") - COUNTIF(T_Peer_Orgs[], \"<>\")\n                    )\n                ),\n                \"\"\n            )\n        )\n    )\n)","v":""},null,null,null,{"$f":"IFERROR(\n    INDEX(\n        T_Enterprise[],\n        _xlfn.AGGREGATE(15,6,\n            (ROW(T_Enterprise[]) - ROW(T_Enterprise[#Headers])) / (T_Enterprise[] <> \"\"),\n            ROW() - ROW(T_Extended_Enterprise[#Headers])\n        )\n    ),\n    IFERROR(\n        INDEX(\n            T_Extended_Orgs[],\n            _xlfn.AGGREGATE(15,6,\n                (ROW(T_Extended_Orgs[]) - ROW(T_Extended_Orgs[#Headers])) / (T_Extended_Orgs[] <> \"\"),\n                ROW() - ROW(T_Extended_Enterprise[#Headers]) - COUNTIF(T_Enterprise[], \"<>\") + COUNTBLANK(T_Enterprise[])\n            )\n        ),\"\")\n)","v":""}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"IF(Named_Enterprise<>\"\",\n    IF(COUNTA(H$13:H27)=1,Named_Enterprise,\"\"),\n    IFERROR(\n        INDEX(\n            T_OUA[],\n            _xlfn.AGGREGATE(15,6,\n                (ROW(T_OUA[]) - ROW(T_OUA[#Headers])) / (T_OUA[] <> \"\"),\n                ROW() - ROW(T_Enterprise[#Headers])\n            )\n        ),\n        IFERROR(\n            INDEX(\n                T_Peer_Orgs[],\n                _xlfn.AGGREGATE(15,6,\n                    (ROW(T_Peer_Orgs[]) - ROW(T_Peer_Orgs[#Headers])) / (T_Peer_Orgs[] <> \"\"),\n                    (ROW() - ROW(T_Enterprise[#Headers])) - COUNTIF(T_OUA[], \"<>\")\n                )\n            ),\n            IFERROR(\n                INDEX(\n                    T_Supra_Org[],\n                    _xlfn.AGGREGATE(15,6,\n                        (ROW(T_Supra_Org[]) - ROW(T_Supra_Org[#Headers])) / (T_Supra_Org[] <> \"\"),\n                        (ROW() - ROW(T_Enterprise[#Headers])) - COUNTIF(T_OUA[], \"<>\") - COUNTIF(T_Peer_Orgs[], \"<>\")\n                    )\n                ),\n                \"\"\n            )\n        )\n    )\n)","v":""},null,null,null,{"$f":"IFERROR(\n    INDEX(\n        T_Enterprise[],\n        _xlfn.AGGREGATE(15,6,\n            (ROW(T_Enterprise[]) - ROW(T_Enterprise[#Headers])) / (T_Enterprise[] <> \"\"),\n            ROW() - ROW(T_Extended_Enterprise[#Headers])\n        )\n    ),\n    IFERROR(\n        INDEX(\n            T_Extended_Orgs[],\n            _xlfn.AGGREGATE(15,6,\n                (ROW(T_Extended_Orgs[]) - ROW(T_Extended_Orgs[#Headers])) / (T_Extended_Orgs[] <> \"\"),\n                ROW() - ROW(T_Extended_Enterprise[#Headers]) - COUNTIF(T_Enterprise[], \"<>\") + COUNTBLANK(T_Enterprise[])\n            )\n        ),\"\")\n)","v":""}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"IF(Named_Enterprise<>\"\",\n    IF(COUNTA(H$13:H28)=1,Named_Enterprise,\"\"),\n    IFERROR(\n        INDEX(\n            T_OUA[],\n            _xlfn.AGGREGATE(15,6,\n                (ROW(T_OUA[]) - ROW(T_OUA[#Headers])) / (T_OUA[] <> \"\"),\n                ROW() - ROW(T_Enterprise[#Headers])\n            )\n        ),\n        IFERROR(\n            INDEX(\n                T_Peer_Orgs[],\n                _xlfn.AGGREGATE(15,6,\n                    (ROW(T_Peer_Orgs[]) - ROW(T_Peer_Orgs[#Headers])) / (T_Peer_Orgs[] <> \"\"),\n                    (ROW() - ROW(T_Enterprise[#Headers])) - COUNTIF(T_OUA[], \"<>\")\n                )\n            ),\n            IFERROR(\n                INDEX(\n                    T_Supra_Org[],\n                    _xlfn.AGGREGATE(15,6,\n                        (ROW(T_Supra_Org[]) - ROW(T_Supra_Org[#Headers])) / (T_Supra_Org[] <> \"\"),\n                        (ROW() - ROW(T_Enterprise[#Headers])) - COUNTIF(T_OUA[], \"<>\") - COUNTIF(T_Peer_Orgs[], \"<>\")\n                    )\n                ),\n                \"\"\n            )\n        )\n    )\n)","v":""},null,null,null,{"$f":"IFERROR(\n    INDEX(\n        T_Enterprise[],\n        _xlfn.AGGREGATE(15,6,\n            (ROW(T_Enterprise[]) - ROW(T_Enterprise[#Headers])) / (T_Enterprise[] <> \"\"),\n            ROW() - ROW(T_Extended_Enterprise[#Headers])\n        )\n    ),\n    IFERROR(\n        INDEX(\n            T_Extended_Orgs[],\n            _xlfn.AGGREGATE(15,6,\n                (ROW(T_Extended_Orgs[]) - ROW(T_Extended_Orgs[#Headers])) / (T_Extended_Orgs[] <> \"\"),\n                ROW() - ROW(T_Extended_Enterprise[#Headers]) - COUNTIF(T_Enterprise[], \"<>\") + COUNTBLANK(T_Enterprise[])\n            )\n        ),\"\")\n)","v":""}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"IF(Named_Enterprise<>\"\",\n    IF(COUNTA(H$13:H29)=1,Named_Enterprise,\"\"),\n    IFERROR(\n        INDEX(\n            T_OUA[],\n            _xlfn.AGGREGATE(15,6,\n                (ROW(T_OUA[]) - ROW(T_OUA[#Headers])) / (T_OUA[] <> \"\"),\n                ROW() - ROW(T_Enterprise[#Headers])\n            )\n        ),\n        IFERROR(\n            INDEX(\n                T_Peer_Orgs[],\n                _xlfn.AGGREGATE(15,6,\n                    (ROW(T_Peer_Orgs[]) - ROW(T_Peer_Orgs[#Headers])) / (T_Peer_Orgs[] <> \"\"),\n                    (ROW() - ROW(T_Enterprise[#Headers])) - COUNTIF(T_OUA[], \"<>\")\n                )\n            ),\n            IFERROR(\n                INDEX(\n                    T_Supra_Org[],\n                    _xlfn.AGGREGATE(15,6,\n                        (ROW(T_Supra_Org[]) - ROW(T_Supra_Org[#Headers])) / (T_Supra_Org[] <> \"\"),\n                        (ROW() - ROW(T_Enterprise[#Headers])) - COUNTIF(T_OUA[], \"<>\") - COUNTIF(T_Peer_Orgs[], \"<>\")\n                    )\n                ),\n                \"\"\n            )\n        )\n    )\n)","v":""},null,null,null,{"$f":"IFERROR(\n    INDEX(\n        T_Enterprise[],\n        _xlfn.AGGREGATE(15,6,\n            (ROW(T_Enterprise[]) - ROW(T_Enterprise[#Headers])) / (T_Enterprise[] <> \"\"),\n            ROW() - ROW(T_Extended_Enterprise[#Headers])\n        )\n    ),\n    IFERROR(\n        INDEX(\n            T_Extended_Orgs[],\n            _xlfn.AGGREGATE(15,6,\n                (ROW(T_Extended_Orgs[]) - ROW(T_Extended_Orgs[#Headers])) / (T_Extended_Orgs[] <> \"\"),\n                ROW() - ROW(T_Extended_Enterprise[#Headers]) - COUNTIF(T_Enterprise[], \"<>\") + COUNTBLANK(T_Enterprise[])\n            )\n        ),\"\")\n)","v":""}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"IF(Named_Enterprise<>\"\",\n    IF(COUNTA(H$13:H30)=1,Named_Enterprise,\"\"),\n    IFERROR(\n        INDEX(\n            T_OUA[],\n            _xlfn.AGGREGATE(15,6,\n                (ROW(T_OUA[]) - ROW(T_OUA[#Headers])) / (T_OUA[] <> \"\"),\n                ROW() - ROW(T_Enterprise[#Headers])\n            )\n        ),\n        IFERROR(\n            INDEX(\n                T_Peer_Orgs[],\n                _xlfn.AGGREGATE(15,6,\n                    (ROW(T_Peer_Orgs[]) - ROW(T_Peer_Orgs[#Headers])) / (T_Peer_Orgs[] <> \"\"),\n                    (ROW() - ROW(T_Enterprise[#Headers])) - COUNTIF(T_OUA[], \"<>\")\n                )\n            ),\n            IFERROR(\n                INDEX(\n                    T_Supra_Org[],\n                    _xlfn.AGGREGATE(15,6,\n                        (ROW(T_Supra_Org[]) - ROW(T_Supra_Org[#Headers])) / (T_Supra_Org[] <> \"\"),\n                        (ROW() - ROW(T_Enterprise[#Headers])) - COUNTIF(T_OUA[], \"<>\") - COUNTIF(T_Peer_Orgs[], \"<>\")\n                    )\n                ),\n                \"\"\n            )\n        )\n    )\n)","v":""},null,null,null,{"$f":"IFERROR(\n    INDEX(\n        T_Enterprise[],\n        _xlfn.AGGREGATE(15,6,\n            (ROW(T_Enterprise[]) - ROW(T_Enterprise[#Headers])) / (T_Enterprise[] <> \"\"),\n            ROW() - ROW(T_Extended_Enterprise[#Headers])\n        )\n    ),\n    IFERROR(\n        INDEX(\n            T_Extended_Orgs[],\n            _xlfn.AGGREGATE(15,6,\n                (ROW(T_Extended_Orgs[]) - ROW(T_Extended_Orgs[#Headers])) / (T_Extended_Orgs[] <> \"\"),\n                ROW() - ROW(T_Extended_Enterprise[#Headers]) - COUNTIF(T_Enterprise[], \"<>\") + COUNTBLANK(T_Enterprise[])\n            )\n        ),\"\")\n)","v":""}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"IF(Named_Enterprise<>\"\",\n    IF(COUNTA(H$13:H31)=1,Named_Enterprise,\"\"),\n    IFERROR(\n        INDEX(\n            T_OUA[],\n            _xlfn.AGGREGATE(15,6,\n                (ROW(T_OUA[]) - ROW(T_OUA[#Headers])) / (T_OUA[] <> \"\"),\n                ROW() - ROW(T_Enterprise[#Headers])\n            )\n        ),\n        IFERROR(\n            INDEX(\n                T_Peer_Orgs[],\n                _xlfn.AGGREGATE(15,6,\n                    (ROW(T_Peer_Orgs[]) - ROW(T_Peer_Orgs[#Headers])) / (T_Peer_Orgs[] <> \"\"),\n                    (ROW() - ROW(T_Enterprise[#Headers])) - COUNTIF(T_OUA[], \"<>\")\n                )\n            ),\n            IFERROR(\n                INDEX(\n                    T_Supra_Org[],\n                    _xlfn.AGGREGATE(15,6,\n                        (ROW(T_Supra_Org[]) - ROW(T_Supra_Org[#Headers])) / (T_Supra_Org[] <> \"\"),\n                        (ROW() - ROW(T_Enterprise[#Headers])) - COUNTIF(T_OUA[], \"<>\") - COUNTIF(T_Peer_Orgs[], \"<>\")\n                    )\n                ),\n                \"\"\n            )\n        )\n    )\n)","v":""},null,null,null,{"$f":"IFERROR(\n    INDEX(\n        T_Enterprise[],\n        _xlfn.AGGREGATE(15,6,\n            (ROW(T_Enterprise[]) - ROW(T_Enterprise[#Headers])) / (T_Enterprise[] <> \"\"),\n            ROW() - ROW(T_Extended_Enterprise[#Headers])\n        )\n    ),\n    IFERROR(\n        INDEX(\n            T_Extended_Orgs[],\n            _xlfn.AGGREGATE(15,6,\n                (ROW(T_Extended_Orgs[]) - ROW(T_Extended_Orgs[#Headers])) / (T_Extended_Orgs[] <> \"\"),\n                ROW() - ROW(T_Extended_Enterprise[#Headers]) - COUNTIF(T_Enterprise[], \"<>\") + COUNTBLANK(T_Enterprise[])\n            )\n        ),\"\")\n)","v":""}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"IF(Named_Enterprise<>\"\",\n    IF(COUNTA(H$13:H32)=1,Named_Enterprise,\"\"),\n    IFERROR(\n        INDEX(\n            T_OUA[],\n            _xlfn.AGGREGATE(15,6,\n                (ROW(T_OUA[]) - ROW(T_OUA[#Headers])) / (T_OUA[] <> \"\"),\n                ROW() - ROW(T_Enterprise[#Headers])\n            )\n        ),\n        IFERROR(\n            INDEX(\n                T_Peer_Orgs[],\n                _xlfn.AGGREGATE(15,6,\n                    (ROW(T_Peer_Orgs[]) - ROW(T_Peer_Orgs[#Headers])) / (T_Peer_Orgs[] <> \"\"),\n                    (ROW() - ROW(T_Enterprise[#Headers])) - COUNTIF(T_OUA[], \"<>\")\n                )\n            ),\n            IFERROR(\n                INDEX(\n                    T_Supra_Org[],\n                    _xlfn.AGGREGATE(15,6,\n                        (ROW(T_Supra_Org[]) - ROW(T_Supra_Org[#Headers])) / (T_Supra_Org[] <> \"\"),\n                        (ROW() - ROW(T_Enterprise[#Headers])) - COUNTIF(T_OUA[], \"<>\") - COUNTIF(T_Peer_Orgs[], \"<>\")\n                    )\n                ),\n                \"\"\n            )\n        )\n    )\n)","v":""},null,null,null,{"$f":"IFERROR(\n    INDEX(\n        T_Enterprise[],\n        _xlfn.AGGREGATE(15,6,\n            (ROW(T_Enterprise[]) - ROW(T_Enterprise[#Headers])) / (T_Enterprise[] <> \"\"),\n            ROW() - ROW(T_Extended_Enterprise[#Headers])\n        )\n    ),\n    IFERROR(\n        INDEX(\n            T_Extended_Orgs[],\n            _xlfn.AGGREGATE(15,6,\n                (ROW(T_Extended_Orgs[]) - ROW(T_Extended_Orgs[#Headers])) / (T_Extended_Orgs[] <> \"\"),\n                ROW() - ROW(T_Extended_Enterprise[#Headers]) - COUNTIF(T_Enterprise[], \"<>\") + COUNTBLANK(T_Enterprise[])\n            )\n        ),\"\")\n)","v":""}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"IF(Named_Enterprise<>\"\",\n    IF(COUNTA(H$13:H33)=1,Named_Enterprise,\"\"),\n    IFERROR(\n        INDEX(\n            T_OUA[],\n            _xlfn.AGGREGATE(15,6,\n                (ROW(T_OUA[]) - ROW(T_OUA[#Headers])) / (T_OUA[] <> \"\"),\n                ROW() - ROW(T_Enterprise[#Headers])\n            )\n        ),\n        IFERROR(\n            INDEX(\n                T_Peer_Orgs[],\n                _xlfn.AGGREGATE(15,6,\n                    (ROW(T_Peer_Orgs[]) - ROW(T_Peer_Orgs[#Headers])) / (T_Peer_Orgs[] <> \"\"),\n                    (ROW() - ROW(T_Enterprise[#Headers])) - COUNTIF(T_OUA[], \"<>\")\n                )\n            ),\n            IFERROR(\n                INDEX(\n                    T_Supra_Org[],\n                    _xlfn.AGGREGATE(15,6,\n                        (ROW(T_Supra_Org[]) - ROW(T_Supra_Org[#Headers])) / (T_Supra_Org[] <> \"\"),\n                        (ROW() - ROW(T_Enterprise[#Headers])) - COUNTIF(T_OUA[], \"<>\") - COUNTIF(T_Peer_Orgs[], \"<>\")\n                    )\n                ),\n                \"\"\n            )\n        )\n    )\n)","v":""},null,null,null,{"$f":"IFERROR(\n    INDEX(\n        T_Enterprise[],\n        _xlfn.AGGREGATE(15,6,\n            (ROW(T_Enterprise[]) - ROW(T_Enterprise[#Headers])) / (T_Enterprise[] <> \"\"),\n            ROW() - ROW(T_Extended_Enterprise[#Headers])\n        )\n    ),\n    IFERROR(\n        INDEX(\n            T_Extended_Orgs[],\n            _xlfn.AGGREGATE(15,6,\n                (ROW(T_Extended_Orgs[]) - ROW(T_Extended_Orgs[#Headers])) / (T_Extended_Orgs[] <> \"\"),\n                ROW() - ROW(T_Extended_Enterprise[#Headers]) - COUNTIF(T_Enterprise[], \"<>\") + COUNTBLANK(T_Enterprise[])\n            )\n        ),\"\")\n)","v":""}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"IF(Named_Enterprise<>\"\",\n    IF(COUNTA(H$13:H34)=1,Named_Enterprise,\"\"),\n    IFERROR(\n        INDEX(\n            T_OUA[],\n            _xlfn.AGGREGATE(15,6,\n                (ROW(T_OUA[]) - ROW(T_OUA[#Headers])) / (T_OUA[] <> \"\"),\n                ROW() - ROW(T_Enterprise[#Headers])\n            )\n        ),\n        IFERROR(\n            INDEX(\n                T_Peer_Orgs[],\n                _xlfn.AGGREGATE(15,6,\n                    (ROW(T_Peer_Orgs[]) - ROW(T_Peer_Orgs[#Headers])) / (T_Peer_Orgs[] <> \"\"),\n                    (ROW() - ROW(T_Enterprise[#Headers])) - COUNTIF(T_OUA[], \"<>\")\n                )\n            ),\n            IFERROR(\n                INDEX(\n                    T_Supra_Org[],\n                    _xlfn.AGGREGATE(15,6,\n                        (ROW(T_Supra_Org[]) - ROW(T_Supra_Org[#Headers])) / (T_Supra_Org[] <> \"\"),\n                        (ROW() - ROW(T_Enterprise[#Headers])) - COUNTIF(T_OUA[], \"<>\") - COUNTIF(T_Peer_Orgs[], \"<>\")\n                    )\n                ),\n                \"\"\n            )\n        )\n    )\n)","v":""},null,null,null,{"$f":"IFERROR(\n    INDEX(\n        T_Enterprise[],\n        _xlfn.AGGREGATE(15,6,\n            (ROW(T_Enterprise[]) - ROW(T_Enterprise[#Headers])) / (T_Enterprise[] <> \"\"),\n            ROW() - ROW(T_Extended_Enterprise[#Headers])\n        )\n    ),\n    IFERROR(\n        INDEX(\n            T_Extended_Orgs[],\n            _xlfn.AGGREGATE(15,6,\n                (ROW(T_Extended_Orgs[]) - ROW(T_Extended_Orgs[#Headers])) / (T_Extended_Orgs[] <> \"\"),\n                ROW() - ROW(T_Extended_Enterprise[#Headers]) - COUNTIF(T_Enterprise[], \"<>\") + COUNTBLANK(T_Enterprise[])\n            )\n        ),\"\")\n)","v":""}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"IF(Named_Enterprise<>\"\",\n    IF(COUNTA(H$13:H35)=1,Named_Enterprise,\"\"),\n    IFERROR(\n        INDEX(\n            T_OUA[],\n            _xlfn.AGGREGATE(15,6,\n                (ROW(T_OUA[]) - ROW(T_OUA[#Headers])) / (T_OUA[] <> \"\"),\n                ROW() - ROW(T_Enterprise[#Headers])\n            )\n        ),\n        IFERROR(\n            INDEX(\n                T_Peer_Orgs[],\n                _xlfn.AGGREGATE(15,6,\n                    (ROW(T_Peer_Orgs[]) - ROW(T_Peer_Orgs[#Headers])) / (T_Peer_Orgs[] <> \"\"),\n                    (ROW() - ROW(T_Enterprise[#Headers])) - COUNTIF(T_OUA[], \"<>\")\n                )\n            ),\n            IFERROR(\n                INDEX(\n                    T_Supra_Org[],\n                    _xlfn.AGGREGATE(15,6,\n                        (ROW(T_Supra_Org[]) - ROW(T_Supra_Org[#Headers])) / (T_Supra_Org[] <> \"\"),\n                        (ROW() - ROW(T_Enterprise[#Headers])) - COUNTIF(T_OUA[], \"<>\") - COUNTIF(T_Peer_Orgs[], \"<>\")\n                    )\n                ),\n                \"\"\n            )\n        )\n    )\n)","v":""},null,null,null,{"$f":"IFERROR(\n    INDEX(\n        T_Enterprise[],\n        _xlfn.AGGREGATE(15,6,\n            (ROW(T_Enterprise[]) - ROW(T_Enterprise[#Headers])) / (T_Enterprise[] <> \"\"),\n            ROW() - ROW(T_Extended_Enterprise[#Headers])\n        )\n    ),\n    IFERROR(\n        INDEX(\n            T_Extended_Orgs[],\n            _xlfn.AGGREGATE(15,6,\n                (ROW(T_Extended_Orgs[]) - ROW(T_Extended_Orgs[#Headers])) / (T_Extended_Orgs[] <> \"\"),\n                ROW() - ROW(T_Extended_Enterprise[#Headers]) - COUNTIF(T_Enterprise[], \"<>\") + COUNTBLANK(T_Enterprise[])\n            )\n        ),\"\")\n)","v":""}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"IF(Named_Enterprise<>\"\",\n    IF(COUNTA(H$13:H36)=1,Named_Enterprise,\"\"),\n    IFERROR(\n        INDEX(\n            T_OUA[],\n            _xlfn.AGGREGATE(15,6,\n                (ROW(T_OUA[]) - ROW(T_OUA[#Headers])) / (T_OUA[] <> \"\"),\n                ROW() - ROW(T_Enterprise[#Headers])\n            )\n        ),\n        IFERROR(\n            INDEX(\n                T_Peer_Orgs[],\n                _xlfn.AGGREGATE(15,6,\n                    (ROW(T_Peer_Orgs[]) - ROW(T_Peer_Orgs[#Headers])) / (T_Peer_Orgs[] <> \"\"),\n                    (ROW() - ROW(T_Enterprise[#Headers])) - COUNTIF(T_OUA[], \"<>\")\n                )\n            ),\n            IFERROR(\n                INDEX(\n                    T_Supra_Org[],\n                    _xlfn.AGGREGATE(15,6,\n                        (ROW(T_Supra_Org[]) - ROW(T_Supra_Org[#Headers])) / (T_Supra_Org[] <> \"\"),\n                        (ROW() - ROW(T_Enterprise[#Headers])) - COUNTIF(T_OUA[], \"<>\") - COUNTIF(T_Peer_Orgs[], \"<>\")\n                    )\n                ),\n                \"\"\n            )\n        )\n    )\n)","v":""},null,null,null,{"$f":"IFERROR(\n    INDEX(\n        T_Enterprise[],\n        _xlfn.AGGREGATE(15,6,\n            (ROW(T_Enterprise[]) - ROW(T_Enterprise[#Headers])) / (T_Enterprise[] <> \"\"),\n            ROW() - ROW(T_Extended_Enterprise[#Headers])\n        )\n    ),\n    IFERROR(\n        INDEX(\n            T_Extended_Orgs[],\n            _xlfn.AGGREGATE(15,6,\n                (ROW(T_Extended_Orgs[]) - ROW(T_Extended_Orgs[#Headers])) / (T_Extended_Orgs[] <> \"\"),\n                ROW() - ROW(T_Extended_Enterprise[#Headers]) - COUNTIF(T_Enterprise[], \"<>\") + COUNTBLANK(T_Enterprise[])\n            )\n        ),\"\")\n)","v":""}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"IF(Named_Enterprise<>\"\",\n    IF(COUNTA(H$13:H37)=1,Named_Enterprise,\"\"),\n    IFERROR(\n        INDEX(\n            T_OUA[],\n            _xlfn.AGGREGATE(15,6,\n                (ROW(T_OUA[]) - ROW(T_OUA[#Headers])) / (T_OUA[] <> \"\"),\n                ROW() - ROW(T_Enterprise[#Headers])\n            )\n        ),\n        IFERROR(\n            INDEX(\n                T_Peer_Orgs[],\n                _xlfn.AGGREGATE(15,6,\n                    (ROW(T_Peer_Orgs[]) - ROW(T_Peer_Orgs[#Headers])) / (T_Peer_Orgs[] <> \"\"),\n                    (ROW() - ROW(T_Enterprise[#Headers])) - COUNTIF(T_OUA[], \"<>\")\n                )\n            ),\n            IFERROR(\n                INDEX(\n                    T_Supra_Org[],\n                    _xlfn.AGGREGATE(15,6,\n                        (ROW(T_Supra_Org[]) - ROW(T_Supra_Org[#Headers])) / (T_Supra_Org[] <> \"\"),\n                        (ROW() - ROW(T_Enterprise[#Headers])) - COUNTIF(T_OUA[], \"<>\") - COUNTIF(T_Peer_Orgs[], \"<>\")\n                    )\n                ),\n                \"\"\n            )\n        )\n    )\n)","v":""},null,null,null,{"$f":"IFERROR(\n    INDEX(\n        T_Enterprise[],\n        _xlfn.AGGREGATE(15,6,\n            (ROW(T_Enterprise[]) - ROW(T_Enterprise[#Headers])) / (T_Enterprise[] <> \"\"),\n            ROW() - ROW(T_Extended_Enterprise[#Headers])\n        )\n    ),\n    IFERROR(\n        INDEX(\n            T_Extended_Orgs[],\n            _xlfn.AGGREGATE(15,6,\n                (ROW(T_Extended_Orgs[]) - ROW(T_Extended_Orgs[#Headers])) / (T_Extended_Orgs[] <> \"\"),\n                ROW() - ROW(T_Extended_Enterprise[#Headers]) - COUNTIF(T_Enterprise[], \"<>\") + COUNTBLANK(T_Enterprise[])\n            )\n        ),\"\")\n)","v":""}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"IF(Named_Enterprise<>\"\",\n    IF(COUNTA(H$13:H38)=1,Named_Enterprise,\"\"),\n    IFERROR(\n        INDEX(\n            T_OUA[],\n            _xlfn.AGGREGATE(15,6,\n                (ROW(T_OUA[]) - ROW(T_OUA[#Headers])) / (T_OUA[] <> \"\"),\n                ROW() - ROW(T_Enterprise[#Headers])\n            )\n        ),\n        IFERROR(\n            INDEX(\n                T_Peer_Orgs[],\n                _xlfn.AGGREGATE(15,6,\n                    (ROW(T_Peer_Orgs[]) - ROW(T_Peer_Orgs[#Headers])) / (T_Peer_Orgs[] <> \"\"),\n                    (ROW() - ROW(T_Enterprise[#Headers])) - COUNTIF(T_OUA[], \"<>\")\n                )\n            ),\n            IFERROR(\n                INDEX(\n                    T_Supra_Org[],\n                    _xlfn.AGGREGATE(15,6,\n                        (ROW(T_Supra_Org[]) - ROW(T_Supra_Org[#Headers])) / (T_Supra_Org[] <> \"\"),\n                        (ROW() - ROW(T_Enterprise[#Headers])) - COUNTIF(T_OUA[], \"<>\") - COUNTIF(T_Peer_Orgs[], \"<>\")\n                    )\n                ),\n                \"\"\n            )\n        )\n    )\n)","v":""},null,null,null,{"$f":"IFERROR(\n    INDEX(\n        T_Enterprise[],\n        _xlfn.AGGREGATE(15,6,\n            (ROW(T_Enterprise[]) - ROW(T_Enterprise[#Headers])) / (T_Enterprise[] <> \"\"),\n            ROW() - ROW(T_Extended_Enterprise[#Headers])\n        )\n    ),\n    IFERROR(\n        INDEX(\n            T_Extended_Orgs[],\n            _xlfn.AGGREGATE(15,6,\n                (ROW(T_Extended_Orgs[]) - ROW(T_Extended_Orgs[#Headers])) / (T_Extended_Orgs[] <> \"\"),\n                ROW() - ROW(T_Extended_Enterprise[#Headers]) - COUNTIF(T_Enterprise[], \"<>\") + COUNTBLANK(T_Enterprise[])\n            )\n        ),\"\")\n)","v":""}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"IF(Named_Enterprise<>\"\",\n    IF(COUNTA(H$13:H39)=1,Named_Enterprise,\"\"),\n    IFERROR(\n        INDEX(\n            T_OUA[],\n            _xlfn.AGGREGATE(15,6,\n                (ROW(T_OUA[]) - ROW(T_OUA[#Headers])) / (T_OUA[] <> \"\"),\n                ROW() - ROW(T_Enterprise[#Headers])\n            )\n        ),\n        IFERROR(\n            INDEX(\n                T_Peer_Orgs[],\n                _xlfn.AGGREGATE(15,6,\n                    (ROW(T_Peer_Orgs[]) - ROW(T_Peer_Orgs[#Headers])) / (T_Peer_Orgs[] <> \"\"),\n                    (ROW() - ROW(T_Enterprise[#Headers])) - COUNTIF(T_OUA[], \"<>\")\n                )\n            ),\n            IFERROR(\n                INDEX(\n                    T_Supra_Org[],\n                    _xlfn.AGGREGATE(15,6,\n                        (ROW(T_Supra_Org[]) - ROW(T_Supra_Org[#Headers])) / (T_Supra_Org[] <> \"\"),\n                        (ROW() - ROW(T_Enterprise[#Headers])) - COUNTIF(T_OUA[], \"<>\") - COUNTIF(T_Peer_Orgs[], \"<>\")\n                    )\n                ),\n                \"\"\n            )\n        )\n    )\n)","v":""},null,null,null,{"$f":"IFERROR(\n    INDEX(\n        T_Enterprise[],\n        _xlfn.AGGREGATE(15,6,\n            (ROW(T_Enterprise[]) - ROW(T_Enterprise[#Headers])) / (T_Enterprise[] <> \"\"),\n            ROW() - ROW(T_Extended_Enterprise[#Headers])\n        )\n    ),\n    IFERROR(\n        INDEX(\n            T_Extended_Orgs[],\n            _xlfn.AGGREGATE(15,6,\n                (ROW(T_Extended_Orgs[]) - ROW(T_Extended_Orgs[#Headers])) / (T_Extended_Orgs[] <> \"\"),\n                ROW() - ROW(T_Extended_Enterprise[#Headers]) - COUNTIF(T_Enterprise[], \"<>\") + COUNTBLANK(T_Enterprise[])\n            )\n        ),\"\")\n)","v":""}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"IF(Named_Enterprise<>\"\",\n    IF(COUNTA(H$13:H40)=1,Named_Enterprise,\"\"),\n    IFERROR(\n        INDEX(\n            T_OUA[],\n            _xlfn.AGGREGATE(15,6,\n                (ROW(T_OUA[]) - ROW(T_OUA[#Headers])) / (T_OUA[] <> \"\"),\n                ROW() - ROW(T_Enterprise[#Headers])\n            )\n        ),\n        IFERROR(\n            INDEX(\n                T_Peer_Orgs[],\n                _xlfn.AGGREGATE(15,6,\n                    (ROW(T_Peer_Orgs[]) - ROW(T_Peer_Orgs[#Headers])) / (T_Peer_Orgs[] <> \"\"),\n                    (ROW() - ROW(T_Enterprise[#Headers])) - COUNTIF(T_OUA[], \"<>\")\n                )\n            ),\n            IFERROR(\n                INDEX(\n                    T_Supra_Org[],\n                    _xlfn.AGGREGATE(15,6,\n                        (ROW(T_Supra_Org[]) - ROW(T_Supra_Org[#Headers])) / (T_Supra_Org[] <> \"\"),\n                        (ROW() - ROW(T_Enterprise[#Headers])) - COUNTIF(T_OUA[], \"<>\") - COUNTIF(T_Peer_Orgs[], \"<>\")\n                    )\n                ),\n                \"\"\n            )\n        )\n    )\n)","v":""},null,null,null,{"$f":"IFERROR(\n    INDEX(\n        T_Enterprise[],\n        _xlfn.AGGREGATE(15,6,\n            (ROW(T_Enterprise[]) - ROW(T_Enterprise[#Headers])) / (T_Enterprise[] <> \"\"),\n            ROW() - ROW(T_Extended_Enterprise[#Headers])\n        )\n    ),\n    IFERROR(\n        INDEX(\n            T_Extended_Orgs[],\n            _xlfn.AGGREGATE(15,6,\n                (ROW(T_Extended_Orgs[]) - ROW(T_Extended_Orgs[#Headers])) / (T_Extended_Orgs[] <> \"\"),\n                ROW() - ROW(T_Extended_Enterprise[#Headers]) - COUNTIF(T_Enterprise[], \"<>\") + COUNTBLANK(T_Enterprise[])\n            )\n        ),\"\")\n)","v":""}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"IFERROR(\n    INDEX(\n        T_Enterprise[],\n        _xlfn.AGGREGATE(15,6,\n            (ROW(T_Enterprise[]) - ROW(T_Enterprise[#Headers])) / (T_Enterprise[] <> \"\"),\n            ROW() - ROW(T_Extended_Enterprise[#Headers])\n        )\n    ),\n    IFERROR(\n        INDEX(\n            T_Extended_Orgs[],\n            _xlfn.AGGREGATE(15,6,\n                (ROW(T_Extended_Orgs[]) - ROW(T_Extended_Orgs[#Headers])) / (T_Extended_Orgs[] <> \"\"),\n                ROW() - ROW(T_Extended_Enterprise[#Headers]) - COUNTIF(T_Enterprise[], \"<>\") + COUNTBLANK(T_Enterprise[])\n            )\n        ),\"\")\n)","v":""}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"IFERROR(\n    INDEX(\n        T_Enterprise[],\n        _xlfn.AGGREGATE(15,6,\n            (ROW(T_Enterprise[]) - ROW(T_Enterprise[#Headers])) / (T_Enterprise[] <> \"\"),\n            ROW() - ROW(T_Extended_Enterprise[#Headers])\n        )\n    ),\n    IFERROR(\n        INDEX(\n            T_Extended_Orgs[],\n            _xlfn.AGGREGATE(15,6,\n                (ROW(T_Extended_Orgs[]) - ROW(T_Extended_Orgs[#Headers])) / (T_Extended_Orgs[] <> \"\"),\n                ROW() - ROW(T_Extended_Enterprise[#Headers]) - COUNTIF(T_Enterprise[], \"<>\") + COUNTBLANK(T_Enterprise[])\n            )\n        ),\"\")\n)","v":""}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"IFERROR(\n    INDEX(\n        T_Enterprise[],\n        _xlfn.AGGREGATE(15,6,\n            (ROW(T_Enterprise[]) - ROW(T_Enterprise[#Headers])) / (T_Enterprise[] <> \"\"),\n            ROW() - ROW(T_Extended_Enterprise[#Headers])\n        )\n    ),\n    IFERROR(\n        INDEX(\n            T_Extended_Orgs[],\n            _xlfn.AGGREGATE(15,6,\n                (ROW(T_Extended_Orgs[]) - ROW(T_Extended_Orgs[#Headers])) / (T_Extended_Orgs[] <> \"\"),\n                ROW() - ROW(T_Extended_Enterprise[#Headers]) - COUNTIF(T_Enterprise[], \"<>\") + COUNTBLANK(T_Enterprise[])\n            )\n        ),\"\")\n)","v":""}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"IFERROR(\n    INDEX(\n        T_Enterprise[],\n        _xlfn.AGGREGATE(15,6,\n            (ROW(T_Enterprise[]) - ROW(T_Enterprise[#Headers])) / (T_Enterprise[] <> \"\"),\n            ROW() - ROW(T_Extended_Enterprise[#Headers])\n        )\n    ),\n    IFERROR(\n        INDEX(\n            T_Extended_Orgs[],\n            _xlfn.AGGREGATE(15,6,\n                (ROW(T_Extended_Orgs[]) - ROW(T_Extended_Orgs[#Headers])) / (T_Extended_Orgs[] <> \"\"),\n                ROW() - ROW(T_Extended_Enterprise[#Headers]) - COUNTIF(T_Enterprise[], \"<>\") + COUNTBLANK(T_Enterprise[])\n            )\n        ),\"\")\n)","v":""}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"IFERROR(\n    INDEX(\n        T_Enterprise[],\n        _xlfn.AGGREGATE(15,6,\n            (ROW(T_Enterprise[]) - ROW(T_Enterprise[#Headers])) / (T_Enterprise[] <> \"\"),\n            ROW() - ROW(T_Extended_Enterprise[#Headers])\n        )\n    ),\n    IFERROR(\n        INDEX(\n            T_Extended_Orgs[],\n            _xlfn.AGGREGATE(15,6,\n                (ROW(T_Extended_Orgs[]) - ROW(T_Extended_Orgs[#Headers])) / (T_Extended_Orgs[] <> \"\"),\n                ROW() - ROW(T_Extended_Enterprise[#Headers]) - COUNTIF(T_Enterprise[], \"<>\") + COUNTBLANK(T_Enterprise[])\n            )\n        ),\"\")\n)","v":""}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"IFERROR(\n    INDEX(\n        T_Enterprise[],\n        _xlfn.AGGREGATE(15,6,\n            (ROW(T_Enterprise[]) - ROW(T_Enterprise[#Headers])) / (T_Enterprise[] <> \"\"),\n            ROW() - ROW(T_Extended_Enterprise[#Headers])\n        )\n    ),\n    IFERROR(\n        INDEX(\n            T_Extended_Orgs[],\n            _xlfn.AGGREGATE(15,6,\n                (ROW(T_Extended_Orgs[]) - ROW(T_Extended_Orgs[#Headers])) / (T_Extended_Orgs[] <> \"\"),\n                ROW() - ROW(T_Extended_Enterprise[#Headers]) - COUNTIF(T_Enterprise[], \"<>\") + COUNTBLANK(T_Enterprise[])\n            )\n        ),\"\")\n)","v":""}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"IFERROR(\n    INDEX(\n        T_Enterprise[],\n        _xlfn.AGGREGATE(15,6,\n            (ROW(T_Enterprise[]) - ROW(T_Enterprise[#Headers])) / (T_Enterprise[] <> \"\"),\n            ROW() - ROW(T_Extended_Enterprise[#Headers])\n        )\n    ),\n    IFERROR(\n        INDEX(\n            T_Extended_Orgs[],\n            _xlfn.AGGREGATE(15,6,\n                (ROW(T_Extended_Orgs[]) - ROW(T_Extended_Orgs[#Headers])) / (T_Extended_Orgs[] <> \"\"),\n                ROW() - ROW(T_Extended_Enterprise[#Headers]) - COUNTIF(T_Enterprise[], \"<>\") + COUNTBLANK(T_Enterprise[])\n            )\n        ),\"\")\n)","v":""}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"IFERROR(\n    INDEX(\n        T_Enterprise[],\n        _xlfn.AGGREGATE(15,6,\n            (ROW(T_Enterprise[]) - ROW(T_Enterprise[#Headers])) / (T_Enterprise[] <> \"\"),\n            ROW() - ROW(T_Extended_Enterprise[#Headers])\n        )\n    ),\n    IFERROR(\n        INDEX(\n            T_Extended_Orgs[],\n            _xlfn.AGGREGATE(15,6,\n                (ROW(T_Extended_Orgs[]) - ROW(T_Extended_Orgs[#Headers])) / (T_Extended_Orgs[] <> \"\"),\n                ROW() - ROW(T_Extended_Enterprise[#Headers]) - COUNTIF(T_Enterprise[], \"<>\") + COUNTBLANK(T_Enterprise[])\n            )\n        ),\"\")\n)","v":""}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"IFERROR(\n    INDEX(\n        T_Enterprise[],\n        _xlfn.AGGREGATE(15,6,\n            (ROW(T_Enterprise[]) - ROW(T_Enterprise[#Headers])) / (T_Enterprise[] <> \"\"),\n            ROW() - ROW(T_Extended_Enterprise[#Headers])\n        )\n    ),\n    IFERROR(\n        INDEX(\n            T_Extended_Orgs[],\n            _xlfn.AGGREGATE(15,6,\n                (ROW(T_Extended_Orgs[]) - ROW(T_Extended_Orgs[#Headers])) / (T_Extended_Orgs[] <> \"\"),\n                ROW() - ROW(T_Extended_Enterprise[#Headers]) - COUNTIF(T_Enterprise[], \"<>\") + COUNTBLANK(T_Enterprise[])\n            )\n        ),\"\")\n)","v":""}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"IFERROR(\n    INDEX(\n        T_Enterprise[],\n        _xlfn.AGGREGATE(15,6,\n            (ROW(T_Enterprise[]) - ROW(T_Enterprise[#Headers])) / (T_Enterprise[] <> \"\"),\n            ROW() - ROW(T_Extended_Enterprise[#Headers])\n        )\n    ),\n    IFERROR(\n        INDEX(\n            T_Extended_Orgs[],\n            _xlfn.AGGREGATE(15,6,\n                (ROW(T_Extended_Orgs[]) - ROW(T_Extended_Orgs[#Headers])) / (T_Extended_Orgs[] <> \"\"),\n                ROW() - ROW(T_Extended_Enterprise[#Headers]) - COUNTIF(T_Enterprise[], \"<>\") + COUNTBLANK(T_Enterprise[])\n            )\n        ),\"\")\n)","v":""}]
[]
[null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!C175","v":"NSC-614-7804 dated 20260218 Unclassified Unlimited Release (UUR)"}]

{"sheet":"MBE Maturity Index","index":2,"n_rows":175,"n_cols":22,"rows_kept":175,"cut":false,"hidden":false,"merged":[[0,0,0,2],[69,1,69,4],[79,1,79,4],[83,1,83,4],[87,1,87,4],[18,1,18,4],[22,1,22,4],[29,1,29,4],[33,1,33,4],[41,1,41,4],[39,0,39,2],[44,1,44,4],[52,1,52,4],[60,1,60,4],[64,1,64,4],[56,1,56,4],[3,20,3,21],[2,0,2,2],[1,0,1,2],[1,6,1,10],[2,6,2,10],[1,11,1,12],[2,11,2,12],[1,14,1,16],[2,14,2,16],[1,20,1,21],[2,20,2,21],[2,3,2,4],[1,3,1,4],[1,17,1,19],[2,17,2,19],[3,15,3,17],[142,1,142,4],[72,0,72,2],[117,1,117,4],[121,1,121,4],[126,1,126,4],[130,1,130,4],[134,1,134,4],[98,1,98,4],[101,1,101,4],[108,1,108,4],[113,1,113,4],[106,0,106,2],[107,0,107,2],[74,1,74,4],[92,1,92,4],[163,1,163,4],[170,1,170,4],[3,2,3,12],[40,0,40,2],[6,0,6,2],[4,0,5,2],[7,1,7,4],[9,1,9,4],[12,1,12,4],[73,0,73,2],[138,0,138,2],[137,0,137,2],[157,1,157,4],[146,1,146,4],[151,1,151,4],[139,1,139,4]]}
["MBE Category / Topic / Facet / (Context)",null,null,"Description: How the organization . . .","Transition: As maturity increases, the organization's . . .",null,"Drawing-Centric \n(L0)","Drawing \nModel-Centric \n(L1)","Validated \nModel-Centric \n(L2)","Formalized \nModel-Based Definition (L3)","Trusted \nModel-Based Definition (L4)","Integrated \nModel-Based Enterprise (L5)","Extended \nModel-Based Enterprise (L6)",null,null,"AS-IS Level: Capability","AS-IS Level: Readiness","AS-IS Level: Adoption","TO-BE Level: Target",null,"POC","Comment"]
["Assessment Identifier (AID):",null,null,"Organization under assessment (OUA):",null,null,"Description of Environment:",null,null,null,null,"Assessor:",null,null,"Assessment Date:",null,null,"Target Date/Event:",null,null,"Version of Assessment:"]
[]
[null,null,"NSE MBE Maturity Index Rev: C.1",null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,"AS-IS Level",null,null,"TO-BE Level",null,"Assessor comments below."]
["       Maturity Level Name\n                                 Level #\n\n\n\n\n\nCategories (e.g., C1)\n└─Topics (e.g., T3) \n   └─Facets (e.g., F2)",null,null,null,null,null,"Drawing-Centric","Drawing Model-Centric","Validated Model-Centric","Formalized Model-Based Definition","Trusted Model-Based Definition","Digitial Integrated Model-Based Enterprise","Extended Model-Based Enterprise","Weight Factor for Topic/Facet\n[0,2,5,8,10]",null,"Capability: Tools are Available?","Readiness: Processes are Ready?","Adoption: People are Using?","Target Adoption",null,"POC","Comment"]
[null,null,null,"Description: How the organization . . .","Transition: As MBE maturity increases, the organization's . . .",null,"L0","L1","L2","L3","L4","L5","L6",null,null,{"$f":"IF(COUNT(P7,P41,P74,P108,P139)=0,\"N/A\",SUM(IF(P7<>\"N/A\",P7*$N7,0),IF(P41<>\"N/A\",P41*$N41,0),IF(P74<>\"N/A\",P74*$N74,0),IF(P108<>\"N/A\",P108*$N108,0),IF(P139<>\"N/A\",P139*$N139,0))/SUM(IF(P7<>\"N/A\",$N7,0),IF(P41<>\"N/A\",$N41,0),IF(P74<>\"N/A\",$N74,0),IF(P108<>\"N/A\",$N108,0),IF(P139<>\"N/A\",$N139,0)))","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"IF(COUNT(Q7,Q41,Q74,Q108,Q139)=0,\"N/A\",SUM(IF(Q7<>\"N/A\",Q7*$N7,0),IF(Q41<>\"N/A\",Q41*$N41,0),IF(Q74<>\"N/A\",Q74*$N74,0),IF(Q108<>\"N/A\",Q108*$N108,0),IF(Q139<>\"N/A\",Q139*$N139,0))/SUM(IF(Q7<>\"N/A\",$N7,0),IF(Q41<>\"N/A\",$N41,0),IF(Q74<>\"N/A\",$N74,0),IF(Q108<>\"N/A\",$N108,0),IF(Q139<>\"N/A\",$N139,0)))","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"IF(COUNT(R7,R41,R74,R108,R139)=0,\"N/A\",SUM(IF(R7<>\"N/A\",R7*$N7,0),IF(R41<>\"N/A\",R41*$N41,0),IF(R74<>\"N/A\",R74*$N74,0),IF(R108<>\"N/A\",R108*$N108,0),IF(R139<>\"N/A\",R139*$N139,0))/SUM(IF(R7<>\"N/A\",$N7,0),IF(R41<>\"N/A\",$N41,0),IF(R74<>\"N/A\",$N74,0),IF(R108<>\"N/A\",$N108,0),IF(R139<>\"N/A\",$N139,0)))","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"IF(COUNT(S7,S41,S74,S108,S139)=0,\"N/A\",SUM(IF(S7<>\"N/A\",S7*$N7,0),IF(S41<>\"N/A\",S41*$N41,0),IF(S74<>\"N/A\",S74*$N74,0),IF(S108<>\"N/A\",S108*$N108,0),IF(S139<>\"N/A\",S139*$N139,0))/SUM(IF(S7<>\"N/A\",$N7,0),IF(S41<>\"N/A\",$N41,0),IF(S74<>\"N/A\",$N74,0),IF(S108<>\"N/A\",$N108,0),IF(S139<>\"N/A\",$N139,0)))","v":"N/A"}]
["C1: Product Design Activities",null,null,"Activities involved in designing the product and preparing product definition.","Complete product definition becomes a product definition dataset with a trusted model-based definition model.",null,"2D Drawings and documents used for all activities","2D Drawings sourced from 3D models; Complete product definition requires additional support documents","2D Drawings and other derivatives sourced from validated 3D model; Complete product definition requires additional support documents","3DIV drawings and other model derivatives derived from MBD Models.; Complete product definition includes additional support artifacts","Certified MBD models are authorized with derivative models and 3DIV drawings derived from MBD models; Complete product definition includes additional support artifacts.","Complete product definition dataset (PDD) containing a MBD model and other support artifacts made useable for all lifecycle activities throughout Enterprise.","Complete product definition system model made useable for all lifecycle activities.",4,null,{"$f":"IF(COUNT(P8,P10,P13,P19,P23,P30,P34)=0,\"N/A\",SUM(IF(P8<>\"N/A\",P8*$N8,0),IF(P10<>\"N/A\",P10*$N10,0),IF(P13<>\"N/A\",P13*$N13,0),IF(P19<>\"N/A\",P19*$N19,0),IF(P23<>\"N/A\",P23*$N23,0),IF(P30<>\"N/A\",P30*$N30,0),IF(P34<>\"N/A\",P34*$N34,0))/SUM(IF(P8<>\"N/A\",$N8,0),IF(P10<>\"N/A\",$N10,0),IF(P13<>\"N/A\",$N13,0),IF(P19<>\"N/A\",$N19,0),IF(P23<>\"N/A\",$N23,0),IF(P30<>\"N/A\",$N30,0),IF(P34<>\"N/A\",$N34,0)))","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"IF(COUNT(Q8,Q10,Q13,Q19,Q23,Q30,Q34)=0,\"N/A\",SUM(IF(Q8<>\"N/A\",Q8*$N8,0),IF(Q10<>\"N/A\",Q10*$N10,0),IF(Q13<>\"N/A\",Q13*$N13,0),IF(Q19<>\"N/A\",Q19*$N19,0),IF(Q23<>\"N/A\",Q23*$N23,0),IF(Q30<>\"N/A\",Q30*$N30,0),IF(Q34<>\"N/A\",Q34*$N34,0))/SUM(IF(Q8<>\"N/A\",$N8,0),IF(Q10<>\"N/A\",$N10,0),IF(Q13<>\"N/A\",$N13,0),IF(Q19<>\"N/A\",$N19,0),IF(Q23<>\"N/A\",$N23,0),IF(Q30<>\"N/A\",$N30,0),IF(Q34<>\"N/A\",$N34,0)))","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"IF(COUNT(R8,R10,R13,R19,R23,R30,R34)=0,\"N/A\",SUM(IF(R8<>\"N/A\",R8*$N8,0),IF(R10<>\"N/A\",R10*$N10,0),IF(R13<>\"N/A\",R13*$N13,0),IF(R19<>\"N/A\",R19*$N19,0),IF(R23<>\"N/A\",R23*$N23,0),IF(R30<>\"N/A\",R30*$N30,0),IF(R34<>\"N/A\",R34*$N34,0))/SUM(IF(R8<>\"N/A\",$N8,0),IF(R10<>\"N/A\",$N10,0),IF(R13<>\"N/A\",$N13,0),IF(R19<>\"N/A\",$N19,0),IF(R23<>\"N/A\",$N23,0),IF(R30<>\"N/A\",$N30,0),IF(R34<>\"N/A\",$N34,0)))","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"IF(COUNT(S8,S10,S13,S19,S23,S30,S34)=0,\"N/A\",SUM(IF(S8<>\"N/A\",S8*$N8,0),IF(S10<>\"N/A\",S10*$N10,0),IF(S13<>\"N/A\",S13*$N13,0),IF(S19<>\"N/A\",S19*$N19,0),IF(S23<>\"N/A\",S23*$N23,0),IF(S30<>\"N/A\",S30*$N30,0),IF(S34<>\"N/A\",S34*$N34,0))/SUM(IF(S8<>\"N/A\",$N8,0),IF(S10<>\"N/A\",$N10,0),IF(S13<>\"N/A\",$N13,0),IF(S19<>\"N/A\",$N19,0),IF(S23<>\"N/A\",$N23,0),IF(S30<>\"N/A\",$N30,0),IF(S34<>\"N/A\",$N34,0)))","v":"N/A"}]
[null,"T1: Product Definition Authorization",null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,4,null,{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(P9:P9,\"N/A\")=ROWS(P9:P9),\"N/A\",P9)","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(Q9:Q9,\"N/A\")=ROWS(Q9:Q9),\"N/A\",Q9)","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(R9:R9,\"N/A\")=ROWS(R9:R9),\"N/A\",R9)","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(S9:S9,\"N/A\")=ROWS(S9:S9),\"N/A\",S9)","v":"N/A"}]
[null,null,"F1: Authorized Product Definition","Identifies the complete authorized product definition (i.e. legal definition) set.","Collects the complete product definition as a MBD model-based product definition dataset PDD. The PDD becomes the product definition authority.",null,"Paper document set w/ 2D graphical drawing(s) and support documents","Electronic document set w/ 2D graphical drawing(s) and support documents. Models may be provided as courtesy","Electronic document set w/2D graphical drawing from 3D model, support documents and support model","Electronic document set w/ graphical drawing (e.g. 3D Interactive Viewable) from MBD model, support documents and support model(s)","Electronic document set w/ a MBD model, human-readable support drawing, support documents and support model(s)","Product definition dataset (PDD) containing a MBD model and all related support product definition artifacts","Product definition data model communicating a system and all product definition artifacts along with their relationships.",4,null,"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A"]
[null,"T2: Product Requirements Association",null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,4,null,{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(P11:P12,\"N/A\")=ROWS(P11:P12),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(P11:P12<>\"N/A\"),$N11:$N12,P11:P12))/SUMIF(P11:P12,\"<>N/A\",$N11:$N12))","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(Q11:Q12,\"N/A\")=ROWS(Q11:Q12),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(Q11:Q12<>\"N/A\"),$N11:$N12,Q11:Q12))/SUMIF(Q11:Q12,\"<>N/A\",$N11:$N12))","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(R11:R12,\"N/A\")=ROWS(R11:R12),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(R11:R12<>\"N/A\"),$N11:$N12,R11:R12))/SUMIF(R11:R12,\"<>N/A\",$N11:$N12))","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(S11:S12,\"N/A\")=ROWS(S11:S12),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(S11:S12<>\"N/A\"),$N11:$N12,S11:S12))/SUMIF(S11:S12,\"<>N/A\",$N11:$N12))","v":"N/A"}]
[null,null,"F1: Form","States the representation of the product requirements as data.","Product requirements become more discrete and digital.",null,"Non-electronic document(s)","Electronic document(s)","Same, with itemized identifications","Uniquely identifiable digital objects/records, manifested as electronic document(s)","Same, with attribution aligning items to generated electronic document(s)","Same, with generated electronic document’s items traced back to digital object sources","Discrete digital references to persistently identifiable digital objects/records.",4,null,"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A"]
[null,null,"F2: Associativity","States how well product requirements are linked to product definition.","Product requirements become more discrete and linked to distinct features of the model.",null,"Disconnected","Manually linked to characteristic on 2D drawing","Replicated to part object in PDM system","Linked to part object in PDM system","Linked to product characteristics in MBD model","Bi-directional link","Automated bi-directional link",4,null,"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A"]
[null,"T3: Product Description",null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,4,null,{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(P14:P18,\"N/A\")=ROWS(P14:P18),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(P14:P18<>\"N/A\"),$N14:$N18,P14:P18))/SUMIF(P14:P18,\"<>N/A\",$N14:$N18))","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(Q14:Q18,\"N/A\")=ROWS(Q14:Q18),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(Q14:Q18<>\"N/A\"),$N14:$N18,Q14:Q18))/SUMIF(Q14:Q18,\"<>N/A\",$N14:$N18))","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(R14:R18,\"N/A\")=ROWS(R14:R18),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(R14:R18<>\"N/A\"),$N14:$N18,R14:R18))/SUMIF(R14:R18,\"<>N/A\",$N14:$N18))","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(S14:S18,\"N/A\")=ROWS(S14:S18),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(S14:S18<>\"N/A\"),$N14:$N18,S14:S18))/SUMIF(S14:S18,\"<>N/A\",$N14:$N18))","v":"N/A"}]
[null,null,"F1: Shape Definition","States how the base geometric shape of the product is defined and serves as the authoritative representation of product geometry.","Shape definition becomes more precise, unambiguous, feature-rich, and generatively capable.",null,"Shape is defined using 2D technical drawings. ","Shape is defined using 3D solid geometry–based models.","Shape is defined using feature-based, parametric 3D solid models","Shape is defined using one or multiple available modeling techniques (e.g., feature-based, direct, parametric, primitive modeling).","Shape is defined using Interdisciplinary feature-based modeling that support multiple lifecycle domains enabling consistent geometry across disciplines.","Shape is defined using precisely bounded models with unambiguous complex surfaces and volumes","Shape is defined using generative and algorithmically derived geometry.",4,null,"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A"]
[null,null,"F2: Non-Shape Information","States how visible non-shape product and manufacturing information (PMI) is represented, embedded, and associated with model elements","PMI becomes increasingly semantic, embedded, structured, and linked to model digital elements.",null,"Non-shape information is conveyed using unstructured textual notes and annotations on 2D drawings.","Non-shape information on 2D drawing are driven from 3D models.","Non-shape annotations and notes are embedded graphically within 3D models and shown on 2D drawings","PMI is embedded within the MBD models and represented as structured, semantic PMI associated to model geometric elements.","Semantic PMI is common, shared, and enriched with product characteristics across Peer-Organizations","Semantic PMI incorporates product characteristic tags with any criticality classification designators, enabling advanced downstream consumption and standardized within the enterprise..","PMI is fully semantic and enriched  with augmentations to product characteristics (e.g., product requirement associations, verification plan requirements)",4,null,"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A"]
[null,null,"F3: Metadata","States where and how product metadata is recorded, managed, and controlled.","Metadata becomes more complete, digital, standardized, synchronized, and enterprise-managed.",null,"Metadata recorded as text on drawings.","Metadata captured as parameters within 3D models.","Metadata embedded and structured within 3D models.","Metadata managed within integrated 3D Model and PDM systems.","Automatically synchronized between Model Metadata and PDM metadata.","Model-specific metadata stored with the model; whereas product metadata stored with part object in the PDM system","Standardized metadata linked and governed across external enterprise systems.",4,null,"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A"]
[null,null,"F4: Presentation Views","Identifies the types of presentation views used to communicate product definition.","Views become more standardized, interactive, semantically meaningful and tailored to enterprise and discipline-specific needs.",null,"2D presentation views, sections, & details","Standardized 2D drawing views, sections, & detail","Model-driven 2D views automatically derived from the 3D Models","Interactive 3D views using standardized view sets.","Interactive views that include standardized product characteristic views shared across Peer-Organization","Enterprise-wide standardized interactive views consistently applied across the organization.","User-defined, role-specific, and discipline-specific interactive views generated dynamically from the authoritative model.",4,null,"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A"]
[null,null,"F5: Tolerancing Scheme","States how acceptable deviation (i.e., tolerances) from nominal shape are defined and applied.","Tolerancing schemes become more standardized, consistent, functionally driven, and increasingly inferred from product and assembly context.",null,"Tolerances applied as dimensional without formal geometric tolerances controls.","Tolerances applied using basic GD&T practices.","Standards-based GD&T applied with respect to functional datum features.","Functional datum features on piece-parts derived from an assembly perspective and applied consistently.","Tolerancing practices standardized and aligned between Peer-Organizations","Tolerancing schemes inferred automatically from a from a piece-part perspective.","Tolerancing schemes inferred automatically from an assembly-level functional perspective.",4,null,"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A"]
[null,"T4: Model Quality & Certification",null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,4,null,{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(P20:P22,\"N/A\")=ROWS(P20:P22),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(P20:P22<>\"N/A\"),$N20:$N22,P20:P22))/SUMIF(P20:P22,\"<>N/A\",$N20:$N22))","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(Q20:Q22,\"N/A\")=ROWS(Q20:Q22),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(Q20:Q22<>\"N/A\"),$N20:$N22,Q20:Q22))/SUMIF(Q20:Q22,\"<>N/A\",$N20:$N22))","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(R20:R22,\"N/A\")=ROWS(R20:R22),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(R20:R22<>\"N/A\"),$N20:$N22,R20:R22))/SUMIF(R20:R22,\"<>N/A\",$N20:$N22))","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(S20:S22,\"N/A\")=ROWS(S20:S22),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(S20:S22<>\"N/A\"),$N20:$N22,S20:S22))/SUMIF(S20:S22,\"<>N/A\",$N20:$N22))","v":"N/A"}]
[null,null,"F1: Verification","States the subject of model checking","Model checks are progressive and more inclusive",null,"Business practice checks","Same with geometry checks","Same with metadata checks","Same with semantic PMI checks","Same with product characteristic checks","Same with design for X checks","Same with advanced analytic checks",4,null,"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A"]
[null,null,"F2: Verification Mode-of-Operation","States degree of mode-of-operation for verification of model quality.","Model verification progresses from human-dominated to hybrid to system-driven.",null,"Ad-hoc checks","Manual checks","Interactive checks","On-demand checking","Semi-Automated checks performed through workflow(s)","Scheduled/batch check by promotion state change event","Automatic/Real-Time/ Continuous checks",4,null,"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A"]
[null,null,"F3: Certified","States the methods for certifying the quality of the model.","Certificate becomes more digital and integrated with procedural workflows.",null,"Perform manual drawing quality assurance via engineering checklists","Same and perform drawing to model comparison (i.e., dimensional checks, visual verification)","Perform formal model validation. Issue a Certificate of Model Quality (or equivalent)","Same with standard conformance for semantic PMI. Issue Certificate of Annotated Model Quality (or equivalent)","Extend certification to ensure trusted model framework. Use digital signatures. Authorize source model for reuse across teams.","Validate that both model with its derivatives work correctly for manufacturing (CAM), inspection (CMM), simulation, and PLM processes. Certification ensures a trusted model framework in downstream use.","Continuously certify the model across the digital thread: as-designed, as-built, and as-maintained. Use feedback loops, data traceability, and digital twin synchronization to detect deviations and certify consistency.",4,null,"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A"]
[null,"T5: Model Derivatives",null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,4,null,{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(P24:P29,\"N/A\")=ROWS(P24:P29),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(P24:P29<>\"N/A\"),$N24:$N29,P24:P29))/SUMIF(P24:P29,\"<>N/A\",$N24:$N29))","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(Q24:Q29,\"N/A\")=ROWS(Q24:Q29),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(Q24:Q29<>\"N/A\"),$N24:$N29,Q24:Q29))/SUMIF(Q24:Q29,\"<>N/A\",$N24:$N29))","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(R24:R29,\"N/A\")=ROWS(R24:R29),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(R24:R29<>\"N/A\"),$N24:$N29,R24:R29))/SUMIF(R24:R29,\"<>N/A\",$N24:$N29))","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(S24:S29,\"N/A\")=ROWS(S24:S29),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(S24:S29<>\"N/A\"),$N24:$N29,S24:S29))/SUMIF(S24:S29,\"<>N/A\",$N24:$N29))","v":"N/A"}]
[null,null,"F1: Content","States the information contained in a derivative model.","Derivative model’s content becomes richer with more level of structure, semantics, and declared context of use (e.g., functionally equivalent, production-process-specific content).",null,"No derivative models are created; only native design models may exist.","Derivative models contain only basic delineation (e.g., shape-only MCAD geometry) with no structured or enriched information.","Derivative models include basic geometry plus structured metadata (e.g., attributes, identifiers, material tags).","Derivative models include geometry, structured metadata, and graphical/textual PMI (non-semantic annotations, notes, tolerances).","Derivative models include semantic PMI and may be explicitly declared by the author as functionally equivalent to the source model for specific contexts","Derivative models include semantic PMI plus precision and detail targeted to a specific production process, and may represent representative or complementary variants needed for that process.","Derivative models include process-specific precision for multiple target production processes (e.g., machining, forming, and additive) and explicitly support multi-context functional equivalence declarations.",4,null,"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A"]
[null,null,"F2: Authoring Mode-of-Operation","States the degree of mode-of-operation used to generate derivatives models.","Derivative generation progresses from manual, user-driven creation to automated, rules-based generation triggered by system events",null,"No derivative models exist.","Derivatives are created manually using client desktop tools.","Derivatives are generated on-demand from a PDM interface by user request","Derivatives are generated automatically from defined PDM commands.","Derivatives are generated automatically based on PDM promotion states and/or workflow triggers.","Derivatives are generated automatically with rule-based logic determining derivative type and format.","Derivatives are generated automatically based upon context-aware governed events, requiring no user initiation",4,null,"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A"]
[null,null,"F3: Validation & Certification Mode-of-Operation","States the degree of mode-of-operation used to validate derivative models against their source, and the form, integration, and trustworthiness of validation certificates.","Validation becomes increasingly automated and certificates become more integrated, authoritative, and persistent.",null,"No validation is performed on derivative models.","Validation is performed manually and documented informally with no formal certificate.","Validation is manual, and a separate electronic certificate is issued and stored independently of the derivative.","Derivative is validated interactively and the certificate is electronically linked to its PDM object.","The validation certificate becomes part of the derivative model package, embedded and persistently associated","Validation is automatically executed based on a PDM/PLM promotion state or workflow event, and a certified record is stored with the derivative.","Validation is continuous, event-driven, and monitored across the digital thread, with trusted certificates generated, updated, and verified automatically.",4,null,"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A"]
[null,null,"F4: Traceability","States the depth and completeness of traceability information available for derivative models back to their authoritative sources.","Traceability expands from non-existent or manual references to a fully navigable digital thread back to the authoritative source.",null,"No traceability exists because derivatives are not created","Derivative models exist but have no recorded origin or source information","Derivative includes basic trace-to-source information identifying the originating model","Traceability includes structured metadata that establishes context and version information","Trace links to the authoritative basis model (native or sanctioned derivative) with identification of derivative operations","Full lineage from derivative back to the original authoritative source model, including transformations and logic used.","Full, automated end-to-end digital-thread traceability establishes complete, system-managed lineage across all derivative uses",4,null,"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A"]
[null,null,"F5: Managed","States how derivative models are stored, controlled, and associated with the authoritative part definition.","Derivatives move from disconnected storage to integrated, enterprise-wide PLM management with persistent associativity.",null,"Derivative models are not created or managed.","Derivatives are stored in shared file directories without formal links to the part definition or authoritative systems.","Derivative models are stored in a document-centric PDM, but associations to part-definition artifacts are weak or manual.","Derivative models are managed within a part-centric PDM with formal, authoritative association to the part definition.","Derivative models are governed in a connected PLM system with common schemas enabling consistent data exchange among Peers.","All derivatives are controlled in a unified enterprise PLM environment with consistent lifecycle management.","Derivative models are governed across Enterprise and Extended-Enterprise environments with shared schema, access control, and persistent association to the authoritative part definition.",4,null,"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A"]
[null,null,"F6: Viewables","States the human-readable mechanism used to communicate product definition through viewable representations.","Viewables evolve from static 2D documents to interactive, annotated, interrogatable, and visually realistic digital representations.",null,"Product definition is communicated via printed 2D drawings only.","Electronic static 2D drawings (e.g., PDF) are used to communicate definition","3D Viewables are supported by proprietary viewing tools with simple rotation/zoom.","Interactive 3D Viewables support standard formats with geometric interrogation and annotation visibility.","Users can interrogate semantic dimensions, tolerances, and product characteristics directly from the viewable","Viewables support markup, persistent comments, structured redlines, and PLM-controlled review workflows.","Viewables become realistic, immersive, and suitable for virtual validation, training, or simulation in high-fidelity environments",4,null,"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A"]
[null,"T6: ECAD/MCAD Collaboration",null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,4,null,{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(P31:P33,\"N/A\")=ROWS(P31:P33),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(P31:P33<>\"N/A\"),$N31:$N33,P31:P33))/SUMIF(P31:P33,\"<>N/A\",$N31:$N33))","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(Q31:Q33,\"N/A\")=ROWS(Q31:Q33),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(Q31:Q33<>\"N/A\"),$N31:$N33,Q31:Q33))/SUMIF(Q31:Q33,\"<>N/A\",$N31:$N33))","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(R31:R33,\"N/A\")=ROWS(R31:R33),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(R31:R33<>\"N/A\"),$N31:$N33,R31:R33))/SUMIF(R31:R33,\"<>N/A\",$N31:$N33))","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(S31:S33,\"N/A\")=ROWS(S31:S33),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(S31:S33<>\"N/A\"),$N31:$N33,S31:S33))/SUMIF(S31:S33,\"<>N/A\",$N31:$N33))","v":"N/A"}]
[null,null,"F1: Condition","States the events that drive MCAD-ECAD collaboration.","MCAD-ECAD collaboration becomes more frequent, predictable, and seamless.",null,"Ad hoc","Design reviews","Design changes","Same","Same","Concurrent design","Same",4,null,"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A"]
[null,null,"F2: Mode","Identifies mechanisms for MCAD-ECAD collaboration.","Mechanisms for MCAD-ECAD collaboration become more capable and unified.",null,"Email and verbal","Exchange of model files","Shared access to PDM systems","User initiated workflow","Same","Application tool integration ","Common application tools",4,null,"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A"]
[null,null,"F3: Commonality","Identifies common/shared resources for MCAD-ECAD collaboration.","The resources used by MCAD and ECAD practitioners become more common and shared.",null,"None","Duplicate component library","Same with 3D component library with response time guarantees","Shared library via PDM system","Shared part-centric library via PLM system between Peer-Organizations","Same throughout the Enterprise ","Common MCAD-ECAD application tool",4,null,"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A"]
[null,"T7: Design Analysis & Simulation ",null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,4,null,{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(P35:P39,\"N/A\")=ROWS(P35:P39),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(P35:P39<>\"N/A\"),$N35:$N39,P35:P39))/SUMIF(P35:P39,\"<>N/A\",$N35:$N39))","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(Q35:Q39,\"N/A\")=ROWS(Q35:Q39),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(Q35:Q39<>\"N/A\"),$N35:$N39,Q35:Q39))/SUMIF(Q35:Q39,\"<>N/A\",$N35:$N39))","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(R35:R39,\"N/A\")=ROWS(R35:R39),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(R35:R39<>\"N/A\"),$N35:$N39,R35:R39))/SUMIF(R35:R39,\"<>N/A\",$N35:$N39))","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(S35:S39,\"N/A\")=ROWS(S35:S39),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(S35:S39<>\"N/A\"),$N35:$N39,S35:S39))/SUMIF(S35:S39,\"<>N/A\",$N35:$N39))","v":"N/A"}]
[null,null,"F1: Basis Model Source","States the source of basis model (e.g., product definition) used to create the analysis model.","Analysis models are derived more directly from the native model.",null,"Independently generated","Same","Courtesy Model","Authorized derivative model","Authorized native model","Same with authorized derivative model embellished specifically for analysis","Analysis integral within design process",4,null,"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A"]
[null,null,"F2: Analysis Model Authoring Mode-of-Operation","States how the analysis geometry, material, and physics models are created.","Creation of the analysis model becomes more automated.",null,"Manually created","Same","Manually modified","Interactive modification","On-demand modification","Automatic modification","Source model satisfies analysis model needs",4,null,"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A"]
[null,null,"F3: Managed","States how analysis models, results, and decisions are stored, controlled, and managed.","Analysis models, results, and decisions are stored more closely to the basis definition and more digitally.",null,"Paper file cabinets","Disconnected, electronic file directories.","Disconnected, document-centric PDM systems.","Disconnected, part-centric PDM systems.","Harmonized PLM schema between Peer-Organizations.","Single, part-centric PLM throughout Enterprise.","Same with Extended Enterprise.",4,null,"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A"]
[null,null,"F4: Influence","States how analysis results and conclusions influence design definition.","Influence and automation of analysis increases.",null,"Independent of design.","Shared with product and production process design teams.","Same","Business practices include design simulation results in design review.","Same and shared as part of change management.","Change automatically proposed.","Automatic update of design definition with digital twin.",4,null,"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A"]
[null,null,"F5: Traceability","States the breadth and depth of traceability of basis information used for analysis","Traceability to other disciplines increases in breadth, depth, and capability.",null,"Textual references","Electronic, textual references","System-level awareness of other discipline business systems.","Part-level, Cross-discipline business system navigation.","MBD Model element-level, Cross-discipline business system navigation,","Same with bi-directional navigation.","Same with write-back access, as appropriate",4,null,"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A"]
[]
["C2: Product Data/Lifecycle Management Activities",null,null,"Activities that interrelate product data.","PDM capabilities change from manual to automated, document-centric to part-centric, CAD files only to all product lifecycle (PLM) data, disconnected to integration with other organizational disciplines, and Extended- Enterprise.",null,"File-sharing directory","Document-centric PDM with disconnected models","Document-centric PDM with connected models","Part-centric PDM connected to product related disciplines","Authoritative part-centric PDM is the source for product definition, connected production processes, & lifecycle related disciplines","Connected part-centric PLM for product lifecycle disciplines.","Common part-centric PLM exchange with Extended-Enterprise.",4,null,{"$f":"IF(COUNT(P42,P45,P53,P57,P61,P65,P70)=0,\"N/A\",SUM(IF(P42<>\"N/A\",P42*$N42,0),IF(P45<>\"N/A\",P45*$N45,0),IF(P53<>\"N/A\",P53*$N53,0),IF(P57<>\"N/A\",P57*$N57,0),IF(P61<>\"N/A\",P61*$N61,0),IF(P65<>\"N/A\",P65*$N65,0),IF(P70<>\"N/A\",P70*$N70,0))/SUM(IF(P42<>\"N/A\",$N42,0),IF(P45<>\"N/A\",$N45,0),IF(P53<>\"N/A\",$N53,0),IF(P57<>\"N/A\",$N57,0),IF(P61<>\"N/A\",$N61,0),IF(P65<>\"N/A\",$N65,0),IF(P70<>\"N/A\",$N70,0)))","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"IF(COUNT(Q42,Q45,Q53,Q57,Q61,Q65,Q70)=0,\"N/A\",SUM(IF(Q42<>\"N/A\",Q42*$N42,0),IF(Q45<>\"N/A\",Q45*$N45,0),IF(Q53<>\"N/A\",Q53*$N53,0),IF(Q57<>\"N/A\",Q57*$N57,0),IF(Q61<>\"N/A\",Q61*$N61,0),IF(Q65<>\"N/A\",Q65*$N65,0),IF(Q70<>\"N/A\",Q70*$N70,0))/SUM(IF(Q42<>\"N/A\",$N42,0),IF(Q45<>\"N/A\",$N45,0),IF(Q53<>\"N/A\",$N53,0),IF(Q57<>\"N/A\",$N57,0),IF(Q61<>\"N/A\",$N61,0),IF(Q65<>\"N/A\",$N65,0),IF(Q70<>\"N/A\",$N70,0)))","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"IF(COUNT(R42,R45,R53,R57,R61,R65,R70)=0,\"N/A\",SUM(IF(R42<>\"N/A\",R42*$N42,0),IF(R45<>\"N/A\",R45*$N45,0),IF(R53<>\"N/A\",R53*$N53,0),IF(R57<>\"N/A\",R57*$N57,0),IF(R61<>\"N/A\",R61*$N61,0),IF(R65<>\"N/A\",R65*$N65,0),IF(R70<>\"N/A\",R70*$N70,0))/SUM(IF(R42<>\"N/A\",$N42,0),IF(R45<>\"N/A\",$N45,0),IF(R53<>\"N/A\",$N53,0),IF(R57<>\"N/A\",$N57,0),IF(R61<>\"N/A\",$N61,0),IF(R65<>\"N/A\",$N65,0),IF(R70<>\"N/A\",$N70,0)))","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"IF(COUNT(S42,S45,S53,S57,S61,S65,S70)=0,\"N/A\",SUM(IF(S42<>\"N/A\",S42*$N42,0),IF(S45<>\"N/A\",S45*$N45,0),IF(S53<>\"N/A\",S53*$N53,0),IF(S57<>\"N/A\",S57*$N57,0),IF(S61<>\"N/A\",S61*$N61,0),IF(S65<>\"N/A\",S65*$N65,0),IF(S70<>\"N/A\",S70*$N70,0))/SUM(IF(S42<>\"N/A\",$N42,0),IF(S45<>\"N/A\",$N45,0),IF(S53<>\"N/A\",$N53,0),IF(S57<>\"N/A\",$N57,0),IF(S61<>\"N/A\",$N61,0),IF(S65<>\"N/A\",$N65,0),IF(S70<>\"N/A\",$N70,0)))","v":"N/A"}]
[null,"T1: Product Definition Authority",null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,4,null,{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(P43:P44,\"N/A\")=ROWS(P43:P44),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(P43:P44<>\"N/A\"),$N43:$N44,P43:P44))/SUMIF(P43:P44,\"<>N/A\",$N43:$N44))","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(Q43:Q44,\"N/A\")=ROWS(Q43:Q44),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(Q43:Q44<>\"N/A\"),$N43:$N44,Q43:Q44))/SUMIF(Q43:Q44,\"<>N/A\",$N43:$N44))","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(R43:R44,\"N/A\")=ROWS(R43:R44),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(R43:R44<>\"N/A\"),$N43:$N44,R43:R44))/SUMIF(R43:R44,\"<>N/A\",$N43:$N44))","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(S43:S44,\"N/A\")=ROWS(S43:S44),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(S43:S44<>\"N/A\"),$N43:$N44,S43:S44))/SUMIF(S43:S44,\"<>N/A\",$N43:$N44))","v":"N/A"}]
[null,null,"F1: Part-Centricity ","States how cohesively product definition is maintained within an authoritative PDM/PLM.","Product definition is managed in a more unified part-centric manner as an authoritative source.",null,"Paper file cabinets","Electronic file directories ","Document-centric PDM system connected to models","Part-centric PDM system for product definition is an authoritative source for organization.","Common part-centric PLM schema with single authoritative source between Peer-Organization ","Same throughout the Enterprise.","Same with Extended-Enterprise.",4,null,"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A"]
[null,null,"F2: Associativity","States how broadly and deeply product definition links to other authoritative sources in related disciplines.","Associativity, to other discipline's items, increases in breadth, depth, and capability. ",null,"Textual references","Electronic, textual references","System-level awareness of other discipline business systems.","Part/item-level navigation to objects in other discipline systems","Model digital element-level navigation to data/objects in other discipline systems","Same with bi-directional navigation","Same with comment or write-back access",4,null,"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A"]
[null,"T2: Data Management Approach",null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,4,null,{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(P46:P52,\"N/A\")=ROWS(P46:P52),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(P46:P52<>\"N/A\"),$N46:$N52,P46:P52))/SUMIF(P46:P52,\"<>N/A\",$N46:$N52))","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(Q46:Q52,\"N/A\")=ROWS(Q46:Q52),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(Q46:Q52<>\"N/A\"),$N46:$N52,Q46:Q52))/SUMIF(Q46:Q52,\"<>N/A\",$N46:$N52))","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(R46:R52,\"N/A\")=ROWS(R46:R52),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(R46:R52<>\"N/A\"),$N46:$N52,R46:R52))/SUMIF(R46:R52,\"<>N/A\",$N46:$N52))","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(S46:S52,\"N/A\")=ROWS(S46:S52),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(S46:S52<>\"N/A\"),$N46:$N52,S46:S52))/SUMIF(S46:S52,\"<>N/A\",$N46:$N52))","v":"N/A"}]
[null,null,"F1: Content Management Scope","States the extent of information (e.g., configurable items) that is managed in PDM.","Scope of the content managed in PDM/PLM extends to product and production process definition.",null,"Individual, disconnected electronic documents and 2D drawings","Same , and digital models","Collected as Product Definition set","Same with supplementary definition data and associated links","Same with production process definition data","Same with product data supplied by other discipline authoritative sources","Same with Extended-Enterprise",4,null,"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A"]
[null,null,"F2: Change Management","States how closely change management (CM) activities relate to the product and/or production process definition.","Change management becomes more closely linked to discrete product/ production process definition content in an authoritative source.",null,"Change textually tied to product definition","Electronic CM system exists disconnected from PDM","CM integrated with PDM","Same and change request digitally tied to product definition part","CM integrated with product lifecycle within PLM","Single inter-organization wide workflows imbedded within PLM","Same and change request digitally tied to discrete item within product or production process definition",4,null,"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A"]
[null,null,"F3: Product Structure Management","States the granularity of product structure and the means to represent it. Note: other BoMs are described C2:T5.","Product structure stored in the authoritative source becomes more detailed and easier to manage.",null,"On drawing(s)","Same and structured data duplicated in PDM","Subassemblies partially defined in PDM","Same with product's characterized attributes in PDM","Substructures fully defined with characterized attributes in PDM","Full up product structure (i.e., systems) defined and characterized attributes with product variants in PDM","Same and available to Extended-Enterprise",4,null,"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A"]
[null,null,"F4: User Interface Applications","States how applications are implemented to improve usability of accessing PDM data for casual users","Access to contextualized information available from PDM and other organizational sources easier and more interactive.",null,"None","Default tool interface for each application","Same with limited linkage to other discipline sources","Role/task-based application for viewing of data items","Same and contributing to existing data items","Same and authoring content","Same with combining data from other sources.",4,null,"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A"]
[null,null,"F5: Data Governance","States the extent of product data governance. ","Extent of governance of product data increases.",null,"None ","Informal guidelines","Formal governance applied within local PDM/PLM capability","Same across OUA","Same between Peer-Organization ","Same throughout the Enterprise.","Same with Extended- Enterprise.",4,null,"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A"]
[null,null,"F6: Traceability of Data","States the extent and validity of traceability between authoritative sources.","Data becomes more trusted through traceability of data across authoritative sources back to the source of truth.",null,"Unknown authority ","Authorized and unauthorized sources","Multiple authorized sources for a given data item.","Single authorized source for a given data item.","Same with verifiable traceability to source of truth.","Same with on-demand audits","Same with Extended-Enterprise.",4,null,"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A"]
[null,null,"F7: Change Control ","States the approach to co controlling change of production realization artifacts. ","Change control process becomes formalized using industry standard change management workflows connected to affected items and analyzed for enterprise impact.",null,"Ad-hoc with textual description","Formal, textual documentation required for authorization","Same with change control documentation manually associated to design document-centric items as unincorporated or incorporated","Industry standard change management workflows (i.e., problem reports, change requests, change notices, change tasks, change authorization) connected to part-centric PDM; Integrated unincorporated change workflow","Same with the option change review boards for impact analysis; Change control objects serve as change control documentation and authorization; Change description include annotations (e.g., red marks) ","Same with common change control l systems (e.g., ERP, MES) for data traceability throughout the Enterprise.","Same with predictive analytics for corrective actions; Standard change control with Extended-Enterprise",4,null,"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A"]
[null,"T3: Product Definition Management",null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,4,null,{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(P54:P56,\"N/A\")=ROWS(P54:P56),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(P54:P56<>\"N/A\"),$N54:$N56,P54:P56))/SUMIF(P54:P56,\"<>N/A\",$N54:$N56))","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(Q54:Q56,\"N/A\")=ROWS(Q54:Q56),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(Q54:Q56<>\"N/A\"),$N54:$N56,Q54:Q56))/SUMIF(Q54:Q56,\"<>N/A\",$N54:$N56))","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(R54:R56,\"N/A\")=ROWS(R54:R56),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(R54:R56<>\"N/A\"),$N54:$N56,R54:R56))/SUMIF(R54:R56,\"<>N/A\",$N54:$N56))","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(S54:S56,\"N/A\")=ROWS(S54:S56),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(S54:S56<>\"N/A\"),$N54:$N56,S54:S56))/SUMIF(S54:S56,\"<>N/A\",$N54:$N56))","v":"N/A"}]
[null,null,"F1: Product Definition Set ","States the format of, and method for creating, the product definition set.","Product definition set becomes more trusted, digital, and automated.",null,"Paper document package, manually compiled","Electronic document list, manually compiled","Electronic product definition set with manifest, manually compiled","Same and managed in PDM system. allows for additional 3D model types (e.g., natives, derivatives), manually compiled","Product definition datasets managed as PDM baselines, standardized, interactively compiled.","Same and automated compilation ","Same, and digitally consumable, and available to Extended-Enterprise ",4,null,"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A"]
[null,null,"F2: Supplemental Data Reference","States how supplemental data is referenced within the product definition set.","Links to supplemental data become more digital and connected to authoritative sources.",null,"Supplemental data called out","Same and available in OUA’s repositories","Same","PDM links to OUA’s authoritative sources.","PLM linked through part objects to authoritative sources between Peer-Organizations. ","Same throughout the Enterprise.","Model digital elements linked to authoritative sources with Extended-Enterprise.",4,null,"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A"]
[null,null,"F3: Product Definition Authorization","Specifies the use or placement of product definition in a configuration management system.","Authorization becomes more automated and integrated and PDM becomes the single authorized source for product definition.",null,"Manual","Electronic separate from PDM","Same","Same and PDM is informed","Same and digital","Automated release process within PDM/PLM","Same",4,null,"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A"]
[null,"T4: Production Process Data Management",null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,4,null,{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(P58:P60,\"N/A\")=ROWS(P58:P60),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(P58:P60<>\"N/A\"),$N58:$N60,P58:P60))/SUMIF(P58:P60,\"<>N/A\",$N58:$N60))","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(Q58:Q60,\"N/A\")=ROWS(Q58:Q60),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(Q58:Q60<>\"N/A\"),$N58:$N60,Q58:Q60))/SUMIF(Q58:Q60,\"<>N/A\",$N58:$N60))","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(R58:R60,\"N/A\")=ROWS(R58:R60),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(R58:R60<>\"N/A\"),$N58:$N60,R58:R60))/SUMIF(R58:R60,\"<>N/A\",$N58:$N60))","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(S58:S60,\"N/A\")=ROWS(S58:S60),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(S58:S60<>\"N/A\"),$N58:$N60,S58:S60))/SUMIF(S58:S60,\"<>N/A\",$N58:$N60))","v":"N/A"}]
[null,null,"F1: Product Definition Association","States how production process data are associated with product definition. ","Production Process data are well connected with product as part-centric and provide a single authorized source for process data.",null,"Manual reference to 2D paper definition via part number","Textual reference to 2D electronic document via part number","Digital reference to product definition drawing","Digital association to product definition model","Digital association to product definition set within PLM","Same but association to items within product definition set","Digital bi-directional association to items within product definition set",4,null,"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A"]
[null,null,"F2: Definition Set","States the format of, and method for creating, the production process definition set (e.g., xBoMs, operation sequences, process derivative models and related data).","Production process definition datasets become more trusted, digital, and automated, and available to Extended-Organizations",null,"Paper document package, manually compiled","Electronic document list, manually compiled","Electronic production process definition set with manifest, manually compiled","Same and managed in PDM system, manually compiled","Production process definition datasets managed as PDM baselines, standardized, interactively compiled.","Same and automated, compilation","Same and digitally available to Extended-Enterprise.",4,null,"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A"]
[null,null,"F3: Supplemental Data Reference","States how supplemental data is referenced within the production process definition set.","Links to supplemental data become more digital and connected to authoritative sources.",null,"Supplemental data called out","Same and available in OUA’s repositories","Same","PDM links to OUA’s authoritative sources.","PLM linked through part objects to authoritative sources between Peer-Organizations.","Same throughout the Enterprise.","Model digital elements linked to authoritative sources with Extended-Enterprise.",4,null,"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A"]
[null,"T5: Bill of Materials (BoM) Management",null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,4,null,{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(P62:P64,\"N/A\")=ROWS(P62:P64),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(P62:P64<>\"N/A\"),$N62:$N64,P62:P64))/SUMIF(P62:P64,\"<>N/A\",$N62:$N64))","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(Q62:Q64,\"N/A\")=ROWS(Q62:Q64),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(Q62:Q64<>\"N/A\"),$N62:$N64,Q62:Q64))/SUMIF(Q62:Q64,\"<>N/A\",$N62:$N64))","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(R62:R64,\"N/A\")=ROWS(R62:R64),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(R62:R64<>\"N/A\"),$N62:$N64,R62:R64))/SUMIF(R62:R64,\"<>N/A\",$N62:$N64))","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(S62:S64,\"N/A\")=ROWS(S62:S64),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(S62:S64<>\"N/A\"),$N62:$N64,S62:S64))/SUMIF(S62:S64,\"<>N/A\",$N62:$N64))","v":"N/A"}]
[null,null,"F1: Authoring","States how various view of BoMs (xBoMs) are generated.","BoMs are generated from digital artifacts with assured data provenance",null,"No Digital BoMs","xBoMs are manually parsed from document data","xBoMs are interactively parsed from document data","Design is digitally represented as hierarchical product structure in PDM","Same and eBoM automatically derived from digital product structure","Same and mBoM automatically derived from eBoM","Same and all xBOMs automatically derived from other xBOMs",4,null,"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A"]
[null,null,"F2: Managed","States how BoMs are stored, controlled, and managed.","All BoM types are managed in a part-centric manner.",null,"Paper file cabinets","Disconnected electronic file directories","Disconnected, document-centric PDM systems","Part-centric PDM systems","Harmonized PLM schema between Peer-Organizations","Single, part-centric PLM throughout Enterprise.","Same with Extended-Enterprise",4,null,"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A"]
[null,null,"F3: Traceability","States how various views of BoMs (xBoMs) trace to and connect with product and production process definitions.","xBoMs are bi-directionally connected and interact with other xBoMs.",null,"Textual references","Electronic, textual references","Same","eBoM digitally traceable to 3D Model(s)","mBoM digitally traceable to product definition via eBoM","Each xBoM digitally traceable to all other BoMs, discrepancies automatically identified","Same and bi-directional xBOM notification & reconciliation",4,null,"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A"]
[null,"T6: Common Digital Libraries",null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,4,null,{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(P66:P69,\"N/A\")=ROWS(P66:P69),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(P66:P69<>\"N/A\"),$N66:$N69,P66:P69))/SUMIF(P66:P69,\"<>N/A\",$N66:$N69))","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(Q66:Q69,\"N/A\")=ROWS(Q66:Q69),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(Q66:Q69<>\"N/A\"),$N66:$N69,Q66:Q69))/SUMIF(Q66:Q69,\"<>N/A\",$N66:$N69))","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(R66:R69,\"N/A\")=ROWS(R66:R69),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(R66:R69<>\"N/A\"),$N66:$N69,R66:R69))/SUMIF(R66:R69,\"<>N/A\",$N66:$N69))","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(S66:S69,\"N/A\")=ROWS(S66:S69),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(S66:S69<>\"N/A\"),$N66:$N69,S66:S69))/SUMIF(S66:S69,\"<>N/A\",$N66:$N69))","v":"N/A"}]
[null,null,"F1: Extent","States the availability of common, structured (schema, attributes), digital libraries of reusable information deemed important to the organization that support product definition and production process definition for the MBE.","Common, structured, digital libraries of critical disciplines become available for smarter decision making, reuse, and automation.",null,"No digital libraries","Some shared (i.e., copied) structured digital libraries","Common structured digital libraries for selected product definition types","Same for most (i.e., more than half but not all) product definition types","Same for all product definition types and selected production process definition types","Same for all production process definition types","Structure digital libraries to support all product lifecycle activities",4,null,"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A"]
[null,null,"F2: Library Governance","States the extent of library data governance.","Library data governance is done at a wider level and becomes more automated",null,"Manual by individual librarian","Shared librarians, ad hoc","Assigned librarian(s)","OUA governance team","Peer-organization governance team","Enterprise governance team","Same with automated “smart” librarian governance.",4,null,"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A"]
[null,null,"F3: Managed","States how libraries are stored, controlled, and managed.","Libraries are managed in common, available PDM.",null,"Paper file cabinets","Disconnected electronic file directories","Disconnected, document-centric PDM systems","Part-centric PDM systems","Harmonized PLM schema between Peer-Organization","Common, part-centric PLM throughout Enterprise.","Same with PLM portals with Extended-Organizations.",4,null,"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A"]
[null,null,"F4: Access","States the disciplines that access and reuse common libraries.","Libraries will be reused among all disciplines.",null,"Ad hoc","Separated by discipline","PDM share common document-centric libraries for product definition discipline","PDM/PLM share common part-centric libraries for product definition discipline","Same and for production process definition discipline","Same for all common disciplines throughout the enterprise","Same and controlled access with Extended-Organizations",4,null,"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A"]
[null,"T7: Data Records",null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,4,null,{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(P71:P72,\"N/A\")=ROWS(P71:P72),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(P71:P72<>\"N/A\"),$N71:$N72,P71:P72))/SUMIF(P71:P72,\"<>N/A\",$N71:$N72))","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(Q71:Q72,\"N/A\")=ROWS(Q71:Q72),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(Q71:Q72<>\"N/A\"),$N71:$N72,Q71:Q72))/SUMIF(Q71:Q72,\"<>N/A\",$N71:$N72))","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(R71:R72,\"N/A\")=ROWS(R71:R72),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(R71:R72<>\"N/A\"),$N71:$N72,R71:R72))/SUMIF(R71:R72,\"<>N/A\",$N71:$N72))","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(S71:S72,\"N/A\")=ROWS(S71:S72),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(S71:S72<>\"N/A\"),$N71:$N72,S71:S72))/SUMIF(S71:S72,\"<>N/A\",$N71:$N72))","v":"N/A"}]
[null,null,"F1: Long Term Archival & Retrieval (LOTAR)","States how record copies of product data are managed for long term archival and retrieval (LOTAR).","Record copies of product data are increasingly managed in LOTAR per industry standards.",null,"2D paper drawing or other physical medium (e.g., film, microfiche, Mylar)","2D drawing as electronic file","2D drawing as PDF format, with functionally equivalent derivative model in standard (e.g., STEP AP203) format","Drawing (2D or 3DIV) and documents as PDF/A format, with functionally equivalent derivative model per National Archival and Records Adminstration (NARA) - compliant archival formats","Complete design definition—including 3D mechanical CAD, PMI, and product structure--compliant with NAS-9300.","Same with as-planned and as-built production data (per NAS-9300 series, if available)","Same with electrical, model-based system engineering (MBSE), and/or analysis & simulation data.",4,null,"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A"]
[null,null,"F2: Data Package","States the creation and format of data packages for product and/or production related data.","Data packages become more trusted, digital, unambiguous, and automated.",null,"Manually prepare paper package","Manually prepare electronic documents collected and compressed","Manually prepare electronic data packaged with manifest","Same but packaged using standard format","Same between Peer-Organizations","Same throughout the Enterprise and managed and generated from PLM.","Same and available to Extended-Organizations.",4,null,"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A"]
[]
["C3: Product Manufacturing Activities",null,null,"Activities involved in fabricating (e.g., manufacturing, assembling) a product.","Parts become easier to manufacture. Manufacturing practice transitions from drawing-based to model-based to automation; and from document-centric to part-centric and includes Extended-Organizations.",null,"2D Drawings used for all manufacturing related activities","Manufacturing via 2D drawings supported by disconnected models, obtained as courtesy or recreated from 2D drawings. ","Manufacturing via 2D drawings with validated support derivative models","Manufacturing via drawings (3DIV & 2D) with certified support derivative models","Digital Manufacturing via trusted MBD and support 3DIV drawings","Digital manufacturing from a trusted MBD dataset via part-centric PDM","Digital manufacturing processes are automated and includes Extended-Organizations via enterprise PDM",4,null,{"$f":"IF(COUNT(P75,P80,P84,P88,P93,P99,P102)=0,\"N/A\",SUM(IF(P75<>\"N/A\",P75*$N75,0),IF(P80<>\"N/A\",P80*$N80,0),IF(P84<>\"N/A\",P84*$N84,0),IF(P88<>\"N/A\",P88*$N88,0),IF(P93<>\"N/A\",P93*$N93,0),IF(P99<>\"N/A\",P99*$N99,0),IF(P102<>\"N/A\",P102*$N102,0))/SUM(IF(P75<>\"N/A\",$N75,0),IF(P80<>\"N/A\",$N80,0),IF(P84<>\"N/A\",$N84,0),IF(P88<>\"N/A\",$N88,0),IF(P93<>\"N/A\",$N93,0),IF(P99<>\"N/A\",$N99,0),IF(P102<>\"N/A\",$N102,0)))","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"IF(COUNT(Q75,Q80,Q84,Q88,Q93,Q99,Q102)=0,\"N/A\",SUM(IF(Q75<>\"N/A\",Q75*$N75,0),IF(Q80<>\"N/A\",Q80*$N80,0),IF(Q84<>\"N/A\",Q84*$N84,0),IF(Q88<>\"N/A\",Q88*$N88,0),IF(Q93<>\"N/A\",Q93*$N93,0),IF(Q99<>\"N/A\",Q99*$N99,0),IF(Q102<>\"N/A\",Q102*$N102,0))/SUM(IF(Q75<>\"N/A\",$N75,0),IF(Q80<>\"N/A\",$N80,0),IF(Q84<>\"N/A\",$N84,0),IF(Q88<>\"N/A\",$N88,0),IF(Q93<>\"N/A\",$N93,0),IF(Q99<>\"N/A\",$N99,0),IF(Q102<>\"N/A\",$N102,0)))","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"IF(COUNT(R75,R80,R84,R88,R93,R99,R102)=0,\"N/A\",SUM(IF(R75<>\"N/A\",R75*$N75,0),IF(R80<>\"N/A\",R80*$N80,0),IF(R84<>\"N/A\",R84*$N84,0),IF(R88<>\"N/A\",R88*$N88,0),IF(R93<>\"N/A\",R93*$N93,0),IF(R99<>\"N/A\",R99*$N99,0),IF(R102<>\"N/A\",R102*$N102,0))/SUM(IF(R75<>\"N/A\",$N75,0),IF(R80<>\"N/A\",$N80,0),IF(R84<>\"N/A\",$N84,0),IF(R88<>\"N/A\",$N88,0),IF(R93<>\"N/A\",$N93,0),IF(R99<>\"N/A\",$N99,0),IF(R102<>\"N/A\",$N102,0)))","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"IF(COUNT(S75,S80,S84,S88,S93,S99,S102)=0,\"N/A\",SUM(IF(S75<>\"N/A\",S75*$N75,0),IF(S80<>\"N/A\",S80*$N80,0),IF(S84<>\"N/A\",S84*$N84,0),IF(S88<>\"N/A\",S88*$N88,0),IF(S93<>\"N/A\",S93*$N93,0),IF(S99<>\"N/A\",S99*$N99,0),IF(S102<>\"N/A\",S102*$N102,0))/SUM(IF(S75<>\"N/A\",$N75,0),IF(S80<>\"N/A\",$N80,0),IF(S84<>\"N/A\",$N84,0),IF(S88<>\"N/A\",$N88,0),IF(S93<>\"N/A\",$N93,0),IF(S99<>\"N/A\",$N99,0),IF(S102<>\"N/A\",$N102,0)))","v":"N/A"}]
[null,"T1: Manufacturing Process Definition",null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,4,null,{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(P76:P79,\"N/A\")=ROWS(P76:P79),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(P76:P79<>\"N/A\"),$N76:$N79,P76:P79))/SUMIF(P76:P79,\"<>N/A\",$N76:$N79))","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(Q76:Q79,\"N/A\")=ROWS(Q76:Q79),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(Q76:Q79<>\"N/A\"),$N76:$N79,Q76:Q79))/SUMIF(Q76:Q79,\"<>N/A\",$N76:$N79))","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(R76:R79,\"N/A\")=ROWS(R76:R79),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(R76:R79<>\"N/A\"),$N76:$N79,R76:R79))/SUMIF(R76:R79,\"<>N/A\",$N76:$N79))","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(S76:S79,\"N/A\")=ROWS(S76:S79),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(S76:S79<>\"N/A\"),$N76:$N79,S76:S79))/SUMIF(S76:S79,\"<>N/A\",$N76:$N79))","v":"N/A"}]
[null,null,"F1: Product Definition Source","States how the manufacturing process definition and fixture models are sourced from the product definition.","Manufacturing process definition activities will be derived from the product definition basis MBD.",null,"Use basis artifacts derived from authorized 2D drawings, obtained from file directory.","Use basis artifacts derived from both authorized 2D drawings and ad-hoc derivative models, obtained from file directory.","Use basis artifacts derived from authorized 2D drawings and support models, obtained via in PDM.","Use basis artifacts derived from authorized 3D drawing (e.g., 3DIV) and support models, obtained via part objects in PDM.","Use basis artifacts derived from authorized MBD model, obtained via part objects in PDM.","Use basis artifacts derived from authorized product definition dataset (PDD), obtained via part objects in PDM.","Use basis artifacts derived from authorized product definition system model, obtained via part objects in PDM.",4,null,"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A"]
[null,null,"F2: Method","States how the manufacturing process definition (i.e., mBoM, process plans, start model, in-process models, cutting tool & fixture definitions, NC data package,) are defined and generated.","Manufacturing process definition becomes more digital and confidently reuse basis MBDs to define manufacturing plans and create embellished derivatives of, in-process models, fixture definitions, NC work packages & mBoMs.",null,"Manual mode-of-operation via 2D drawings of product, cutting tools, fixtures, and other resources; mBoM and manufacturing process operations (i.e., BOP) are outlined in documents.","Same with a start-process model and each machining process operation has a manually generated in-process model.","Same with interactive mode-of-operation using in-process and fixture models made from the basis model; Basis models are associate with respective mBoM items.","Basis model is MBD; In-process MBD models are made from basis MBD model and/or previous operation’s final-process model; Operations reference cutting tools listed in a common digital cutting tool resource library used; mBoMs are transformed from eBoMs","Same and MBD model can auto generate a “dimensional arithmetic mean” derivative model; Each operation references additional resources contained in digital resource libraries for plants, work-centers, tooling (e.g., fixtures, gages) special skills, and process materials (i.e., BoR) ; mBoM items are linked to eBoMs items.","All in-process models inherited from basis MBD; Operation’s cutting tools models & tooling models linked with in-process models; Some operation resources are auto selected from digital resource libraries.","Manufacturing BOP is auto generated from start-process model to last final-process model equivalent to the basis MBD model and from manufacturing knowledge and process definition system models and digital resource libraries; mBoMs auto generated",4,null,"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A"]
[null,null,"F3: Managed","States how the production process definition and contents are stored, controlled and managed.","Production process definition dataset (PPDD) and contents will be managed as part-centric within the PLM system.",null,"Paper file cabinets","Disconnected electronic file directories","Grouped as common file in document-centric PDM systems","Managed within a production folder with related derivative models in part-centric PDM systems","Managed as associated objects PPDD within part-centric PLM between Peer-Organizations.","Same and as part-centric item to connected mBoM and derivatives","Same and Extended-Organization’s artifacts are managed within authorized PLM",4,null,"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A"]
[null,null,"F4: Response to Change","States how the manufacturing process definition is notified and responds to changes from either product definition or associated in-process definitions.","Manufacturing process definition, specifically in-process models, response to change notifications are more automated, timely, & guaranteed.",null,"No notifications","Respond to an ad hoc notification of change","Respond to a procedural task notification of change via PDM","Same with stated response time guarantee","Same with visual product change notification within PLM","Same with automated object state change of related changed artifact","Same with automated updates of related changed artifacts",4,null,"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A"]
[null,"T2: Tooling Definition & Realization",null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,4,null,{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(P81:P83,\"N/A\")=ROWS(P81:P83),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(P81:P83<>\"N/A\"),$N81:$N83,P81:P83))/SUMIF(P81:P83,\"<>N/A\",$N81:$N83))","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(Q81:Q83,\"N/A\")=ROWS(Q81:Q83),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(Q81:Q83<>\"N/A\"),$N81:$N83,Q81:Q83))/SUMIF(Q81:Q83,\"<>N/A\",$N81:$N83))","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(R81:R83,\"N/A\")=ROWS(R81:R83),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(R81:R83<>\"N/A\"),$N81:$N83,R81:R83))/SUMIF(R81:R83,\"<>N/A\",$N81:$N83))","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(S81:S83,\"N/A\")=ROWS(S81:S83),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(S81:S83<>\"N/A\"),$N81:$N83,S81:S83))/SUMIF(S81:S83,\"<>N/A\",$N81:$N83))","v":"N/A"}]
[null,null,"F1: Basis","Identifies the basis of information for tooling (e.g., fixtures, gauges) design (see C1: Design Activity's contexts) and tooling realization.","Tooling design and realization confidently reuses basis MBD with automations",null,"Visual analysis of product definition","Same","Created from basis 3D model","Same ","Created from basis 3D MBD","Created from basis MBD dataset","Created automatically from MBD product definition",4,null,"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A"]
[null,null,"F2: Managed","States how tooling definitions and fabrication datasets are stored, controlled, & managed. ","Tooling definitions, fabrication dataset, and their contents become managed as part-centric within the PLM system.",null,"Paper file cabinets","Disconnected electronic file directories ","Disconnected, document-centric PDM systems ","Disconnected, part-centric PDM systems","Harmonized PLM schema across Peer-Organization.","Single, part-centric PLM throughout Enterprise.","Same with Extended-Enterprise.",4,null,"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A"]
[null,null,"F3: Traceability","States how tooling definitions are traced back to a basis model and their respective manufacturing process definitions.","Tooling definition and fabrication dataset become associated to its associated manufacturing process definition and their part’s basis MBD.",null,"Textual references","Electronic, textual references","System-level awareness of other discipline business systems.","Part-level, Cross-discipline business system navigation.","MBD Model element-level, Cross-discipline business system navigation,","Same with bi-directional navigation","Same with write-back access, as appropriate",4,null,"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A"]
[null,"T3: Manufacturing Process Instructions ",null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,4,null,{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(P85:P87,\"N/A\")=ROWS(P85:P87),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(P85:P87<>\"N/A\"),$N85:$N87,P85:P87))/SUMIF(P85:P87,\"<>N/A\",$N85:$N87))","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(Q85:Q87,\"N/A\")=ROWS(Q85:Q87),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(Q85:Q87<>\"N/A\"),$N85:$N87,Q85:Q87))/SUMIF(Q85:Q87,\"<>N/A\",$N85:$N87))","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(R85:R87,\"N/A\")=ROWS(R85:R87),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(R85:R87<>\"N/A\"),$N85:$N87,R85:R87))/SUMIF(R85:R87,\"<>N/A\",$N85:$N87))","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(S85:S87,\"N/A\")=ROWS(S85:S87),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(S85:S87<>\"N/A\"),$N85:$N87,S85:S87))/SUMIF(S85:S87,\"<>N/A\",$N85:$N87))","v":"N/A"}]
[null,null,"F1: Method","States how fabrication (e.g., manufacturing, assembling) work instructions are authored and generated.","Manufacturing instructions progress from manual to text to model images to animations to augmented reality. ",null,"Authored manually using Text, graphics, & photographs","Authored within execution business system using text, graphics photographs, and 3D model-based images","Same with 3D model-based animations","Authored within PDM/MPM business system using text, images, visualizations, and animations.","Same and with using annotations from MBD models.","Automatic generation of process instructions from BOP","Same with use of augmented or mixed reality.",4,null,"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A"]
[null,null,"F2: Managed","States how manufacturing work instructions are stored, controlled, and managed.","Manufacturing instructions are increasingly linked to the part in the PDM system.",null,"Paper file cabinets","Disconnected electronic file directories ","Disconnected, managed in delivery system (e.g., MES)","Same with supplemental data managed in other systems","Managed as objects within a part-centric PLM and published in delivery system","Directional connected from part-centric PLM system to delivery system","Bi-Directional connected between part-centric PLM system and delivery system",4,null,"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A"]
[null,null,"F3: Response to Change","States how the manufacturing work instructions discipline responds to changes in manufacturing process definition.","Manufacturing instructions response to change notifications are more automated, timely, & guaranteed.",null,"No notifications","Response to ad hoc notification of change","Response to procedural notification of change","Same with stated response time guarantee","Response to product change notification via PLM","Same with automated state change of related artifacts","Same with automated instruction segment updates and updates to delivery system",4,null,"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A"]
[null,"T4: Manufacturing Numeric Control Code",null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,4,null,{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(P89:P92,\"N/A\")=ROWS(P89:P92),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(P89:P92<>\"N/A\"),$N89:$N92,P89:P92))/SUMIF(P89:P92,\"<>N/A\",$N89:$N92))","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(Q89:Q92,\"N/A\")=ROWS(Q89:Q92),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(Q89:Q92<>\"N/A\"),$N89:$N92,Q89:Q92))/SUMIF(Q89:Q92,\"<>N/A\",$N89:$N92))","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(R89:R92,\"N/A\")=ROWS(R89:R92),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(R89:R92<>\"N/A\"),$N89:$N92,R89:R92))/SUMIF(R89:R92,\"<>N/A\",$N89:$N92))","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(S89:S92,\"N/A\")=ROWS(S89:S92),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(S89:S92<>\"N/A\"),$N89:$N92,S89:S92))/SUMIF(S89:S92,\"<>N/A\",$N89:$N92))","v":"N/A"}]
[null,null,"F1: Basis Model Source ","States how the manufacturing numeric control (NC) code is sourced from manufacturing process definition)","Manufacturing numeric control (NC) code generation becomes sourced from content within the manufacturing process definition data ",null,"NC code document set contains 2D drawings","NC code document set contains 2D drawings and ad hoc derivative models from shared file directory","NC code document set contains 2D drawings and open-standard derivative models from PDM","NC code dataset contains technical drawings (i.e. 3DIV, 2D) and validated models from PDM","NC code dataset contains basis MBD derivative models and 3DIVs via part object in PLM","Same and includes basis MBD native models","Same and using inheritance models from native models.",4,null,"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A"]
[null,null,"F2: Method","States how manufacturing numeric control (NC) code is generated and validated using CAM/CNC software per manufacturing process definition.","Manufacturing numeric control (NC) code reuses basis MBD models and derivatives while following a manufacturing process definition dataset.",null,"Manually created NC Code","Interactively generated NC code using a 3D model-based CAM application and code is validated against a 3D tool-path model-based application.","Same with basis model and separate instructive narrative","Same with manufacturing PMI incorporated with in-process models","Semi-automated NC code generation with a MBD model-based CAM application with integrated NC code tool-path validation","Same with using inheritance models","Automatically generated from manufacturing feature-based rule set",4,null,"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A"]
[null,null,"F3: Managed","States how NC datasets (code files, simulation files, models, drawing, and support information) are stored, controlled, and managed.","Manufacturing numeric control (NC) dataset, and their contents will be managed as part-centric within the PDM system.",null,"Paper file cabinets","Disconnected electronic file directories","Grouped as common file in document-centric PDM systems","Collected with support models in part-centric PDM systems","Managed as objects within part-centric PLM","Same and as part-centric item to connected mBoM","Same and Extended-Organization’s artifacts are managed within authorized PDM",4,null,"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A"]
[null,null,"F4: Response to Change","States how the manufacturing numeric control (NC) code generation discipline is notified and responds to changes in either product or manufacturing process definition.","Manufacturing numeric control (NC) code generation response to change notifications are more automated, timely, & guaranteed.",null,"No notifications","Response to ad hoc notification of change","Response to procedural notification of change","Same with stated response time guarantee","Response to product change notification via PLM","Same with automated state change of related artifacts","Same with automated code segment updates",4,null,"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A"]
[null,"T5: Manufacturing Analysis & Simulation",null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,4,null,{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(P94:P98,\"N/A\")=ROWS(P94:P98),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(P94:P98<>\"N/A\"),$N94:$N98,P94:P98))/SUMIF(P94:P98,\"<>N/A\",$N94:$N98))","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(Q94:Q98,\"N/A\")=ROWS(Q94:Q98),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(Q94:Q98<>\"N/A\"),$N94:$N98,Q94:Q98))/SUMIF(Q94:Q98,\"<>N/A\",$N94:$N98))","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(R94:R98,\"N/A\")=ROWS(R94:R98),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(R94:R98<>\"N/A\"),$N94:$N98,R94:R98))/SUMIF(R94:R98,\"<>N/A\",$N94:$N98))","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(S94:S98,\"N/A\")=ROWS(S94:S98),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(S94:S98<>\"N/A\"),$N94:$N98,S94:S98))/SUMIF(S94:S98,\"<>N/A\",$N94:$N98))","v":"N/A"}]
[null,null,"F1: Basis Model Source","States the source of basis model (e.g., product definition) used to create the analysis model.","Basis model for analysis model are derived more directly from the native model.",null,"Analysis model is Independently generated, usually from a 2D drawing","Same and validated checked by co-worker","Analysis model’s basis is from a Courtesy Model","Analysis model’s basis is from an authorized open-standard derivative model","Analysis model’s basis is from an authorized native model","Analysis model’s basis is from an authorized derivative model embellished specifically for analysis","Analysis model is concurrent within design process",4,null,"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A"]
[null,null,"F2: Analysis Model Authoring Mode-of-Operation","States how the analysis geometry, material, and physics models are created.","Creation of the analysis model becomes more automated.",null,"Manually created","Same","Manually modified","Interactive modification","On-demand modification","Automatic modification","Source model satisfies analysis model needs",4,null,"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A"]
[null,null,"F3: Managed","States how analysis models, input parameters, reporting of results, and decisions are stored, controlled, and managed.","Analysis models, reporting results, and decisions are stored more closely to the basis definition and more digitally.",null,"Paper file cabinets","Disconnected electronic file directories","Grouped as common file, disconnected in document-centric PDM systems","Collected with support models in part-centric PDM systems","Managed as objects within part-centric PLM between Peer-Organizations.","Single, part-centric PLM throughout Enterprise.","Same and Extended-Enterprise’s artifacts are managed within authorized PLM",4,null,"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A"]
[null,null,"F4: Influence","States how analysis results and conclusions influence both product design and manufacturing process definition.","Influence and automation of analysis increases.",null,"Independent of design","Shared with design and production teams","Same","Business practices include manufacturing simulation results in design and production reviews","Same and shared to stakeholders via change management","Change automatically proposed.","Automatic update of design & manufacturing process definition with digital twin",4,null,"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A"]
[null,null,"F5: Traceability","States the breadth and depth of traceability of basis information used for analysis.","Traceability to other disciplines increases in breadth, depth, and capability.",null,"Textual references","Electronic, textual references","System-level awareness of other discipline business systems.","Part-level, Cross-discipline business system navigation.","MBD Model element-level, Cross-discipline business system navigation,","Same with bi-directional navigation","Same with write-back access, as appropriate",4,null,"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A"]
[null,"T6: Manufacturing Operations ",null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,4,null,{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(P100:P101,\"N/A\")=ROWS(P100:P101),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(P100:P101<>\"N/A\"),$N100:$N101,P100:P101))/SUMIF(P100:P101,\"<>N/A\",$N100:$N101))","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(Q100:Q101,\"N/A\")=ROWS(Q100:Q101),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(Q100:Q101<>\"N/A\"),$N100:$N101,Q100:Q101))/SUMIF(Q100:Q101,\"<>N/A\",$N100:$N101))","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(R100:R101,\"N/A\")=ROWS(R100:R101),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(R100:R101<>\"N/A\"),$N100:$N101,R100:R101))/SUMIF(R100:R101,\"<>N/A\",$N100:$N101))","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(S100:S101,\"N/A\")=ROWS(S100:S101),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(S100:S101<>\"N/A\"),$N100:$N101,S100:S101))/SUMIF(S100:S101,\"<>N/A\",$N100:$N101))","v":"N/A"}]
[null,null,"F1: Basis Model Reference","States how manufacturing operations’ reference and use basis artifacts","Manufacturing operations reference and use 3DIV drawings and basis models.",null,"Paper 2D drawing","Electronic documents and 2D drawing","Same with open-standard 3D model derivatives","Documents and 3D interactive viewable (3DIV) drawings","Same with open-standard MBD model derivatives","Contents from a MBD dataset","Same with enhanced 3DIV drawing",4,null,"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A"]
[null,null,"F2: Presentation","States the medium of how the manufacturing work instructions are presented for the operator.","Manufacturing work instructions will contain more digital model-based content.",null,"Textual instructions on paper ","Electronic textual instructions","Same with graphics and photo images","Same with images from model","Same with model-based interactions","Same with interactive model-based animations","Same with augmented or mixed reality",4,null,"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A"]
[null,"T7: Product-Related Procurement ",null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,4,null,{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(P103:P106,\"N/A\")=ROWS(P103:P106),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(P103:P106<>\"N/A\"),$N103:$N106,P103:P106))/SUMIF(P103:P106,\"<>N/A\",$N103:$N106))","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(Q103:Q106,\"N/A\")=ROWS(Q103:Q106),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(Q103:Q106<>\"N/A\"),$N103:$N106,Q103:Q106))/SUMIF(Q103:Q106,\"<>N/A\",$N103:$N106))","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(R103:R106,\"N/A\")=ROWS(R103:R106),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(R103:R106<>\"N/A\"),$N103:$N106,R103:R106))/SUMIF(R103:R106,\"<>N/A\",$N103:$N106))","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(S103:S106,\"N/A\")=ROWS(S103:S106),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(S103:S106<>\"N/A\"),$N103:$N106,S103:S106))/SUMIF(S103:S106,\"<>N/A\",$N103:$N106))","v":"N/A"}]
[null,null,"F1: Content","States how product related (e.g., supplier, service provider) procurement data packages are generated.","Product procurement data packages automatically conform to business rules and data package practices.",null,"Documents and 2D product drawings","Documents, 2D product drawings and derivative model","Same","Documents, 3DIV product drawing and derivative models","Documents, 3DIV product drawing and derivative models as product procurement data package","Product procurement datasets are auto-generated per established business rules and packaged for delivery","Same and includes quality planning and returns with quality results",4,null,"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A"]
[null,null,"F2: Managed","States how product procurement data packages are managed.","Product procurement data packages are managed in a part-centric PDM.",null,"Paper file cabinets","Disconnected electronic file directories ","Disconnected, document-centric PDM systems ","Disconnected, part-centric PDM systems","Harmonized PLM schema between Peer-Organization.","Single, part-centric PLM throughout Enterprise.","Same with Extended-Enterprise.",4,null,"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A"]
[null,null,"F3: Response to Change","States how product procurement package discipline responds to changes in product definition.","Product procurement data package response to change notifications are more automated, timely, & guaranteed.",null,"No notifications","Response to ad hoc notification of change","Response to procedural notification of change","Same with stated response time guarantee","Response to product change notification via PLM","Same with automated state change by discipline","Same with automated updates from discipline",4,null,"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A"]
[null,null,"F4: Delivery","States how product procurement packages are delivered Extended-Organizations.","Product procurement data packages are auto delivered Extended-Organizations.",null,"Postal Services with enclosed documents","Electronic Mail (eMail) with document attachments","Electronic Mail with reference links to documents provided in authenticated file exchange site","Email with links to dedicated authenticated supplier portal file exchange site","Notification with links to authenticate supply portal connected to organization’s PLM","Same with automatic notification via email","Auto delivered to Extended-Organizations with confirmation",4,null,"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A"]
[]
["C4: Product Quality Activities ",null,null,"Activities involved in verification, testing, inspection, and product acceptance.","Inspection and acceptance of parts becomes easier. Verification, inspection, & acceptance practices change from drawing-based to model-based to automatic; from document-centric to part-centric; and includes Extended-Organizations.",null,"2D Drawings used for verification, inspection, testing, & acceptance activities","Verification, inspection, & acceptance via 2D drawings supported by disconnected models, obtained as courtesy or recreated from 2D drawings.","Verification, inspection, & acceptance via 2D drawings with validated support derivative models","Verification, inspection, & acceptance via 3DIV drawings with certified support derivative models","Digital verification, inspection, & acceptance via trusted MBD models and support 3DIV drawings","Digital metrology via trusted MBD datasets with associated product characteristics","Quality embellished models; Automated metrology processes, includes Extended-Organizations.",4,null,{"$f":"IF(COUNT(P109,P114,P118,P122,P127,P131,P135)=0,\"N/A\",SUM(IF(P109<>\"N/A\",P109*$N109,0),IF(P114<>\"N/A\",P114*$N114,0),IF(P118<>\"N/A\",P118*$N118,0),IF(P122<>\"N/A\",P122*$N122,0),IF(P127<>\"N/A\",P127*$N127,0),IF(P131<>\"N/A\",P131*$N131,0),IF(P135<>\"N/A\",P135*$N135,0))/SUM(IF(P109<>\"N/A\",$N109,0),IF(P114<>\"N/A\",$N114,0),IF(P118<>\"N/A\",$N118,0),IF(P122<>\"N/A\",$N122,0),IF(P127<>\"N/A\",$N127,0),IF(P131<>\"N/A\",$N131,0),IF(P135<>\"N/A\",$N135,0)))","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"IF(COUNT(Q109,Q114,Q118,Q122,Q127,Q131,Q135)=0,\"N/A\",SUM(IF(Q109<>\"N/A\",Q109*$N109,0),IF(Q114<>\"N/A\",Q114*$N114,0),IF(Q118<>\"N/A\",Q118*$N118,0),IF(Q122<>\"N/A\",Q122*$N122,0),IF(Q127<>\"N/A\",Q127*$N127,0),IF(Q131<>\"N/A\",Q131*$N131,0),IF(Q135<>\"N/A\",Q135*$N135,0))/SUM(IF(Q109<>\"N/A\",$N109,0),IF(Q114<>\"N/A\",$N114,0),IF(Q118<>\"N/A\",$N118,0),IF(Q122<>\"N/A\",$N122,0),IF(Q127<>\"N/A\",$N127,0),IF(Q131<>\"N/A\",$N131,0),IF(Q135<>\"N/A\",$N135,0)))","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"IF(COUNT(R109,R114,R118,R122,R127,R131,R135)=0,\"N/A\",SUM(IF(R109<>\"N/A\",R109*$N109,0),IF(R114<>\"N/A\",R114*$N114,0),IF(R118<>\"N/A\",R118*$N118,0),IF(R122<>\"N/A\",R122*$N122,0),IF(R127<>\"N/A\",R127*$N127,0),IF(R131<>\"N/A\",R131*$N131,0),IF(R135<>\"N/A\",R135*$N135,0))/SUM(IF(R109<>\"N/A\",$N109,0),IF(R114<>\"N/A\",$N114,0),IF(R118<>\"N/A\",$N118,0),IF(R122<>\"N/A\",$N122,0),IF(R127<>\"N/A\",$N127,0),IF(R131<>\"N/A\",$N131,0),IF(R135<>\"N/A\",$N135,0)))","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"IF(COUNT(S109,S114,S118,S122,S127,S131,S135)=0,\"N/A\",SUM(IF(S109<>\"N/A\",S109*$N109,0),IF(S114<>\"N/A\",S114*$N114,0),IF(S118<>\"N/A\",S118*$N118,0),IF(S122<>\"N/A\",S122*$N122,0),IF(S127<>\"N/A\",S127*$N127,0),IF(S131<>\"N/A\",S131*$N131,0),IF(S135<>\"N/A\",S135*$N135,0))/SUM(IF(S109<>\"N/A\",$N109,0),IF(S114<>\"N/A\",$N114,0),IF(S118<>\"N/A\",$N118,0),IF(S122<>\"N/A\",$N122,0),IF(S127<>\"N/A\",$N127,0),IF(S131<>\"N/A\",$N131,0),IF(S135<>\"N/A\",$N135,0)))","v":"N/A"}]
[null,"T1: Quality Process Definition",null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,4,null,{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(P110:P113,\"N/A\")=ROWS(P110:P113),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(P110:P113<>\"N/A\"),$N110:$N113,P110:P113))/SUMIF(P110:P113,\"<>N/A\",$N110:$N113))","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(Q110:Q113,\"N/A\")=ROWS(Q110:Q113),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(Q110:Q113<>\"N/A\"),$N110:$N113,Q110:Q113))/SUMIF(Q110:Q113,\"<>N/A\",$N110:$N113))","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(R110:R113,\"N/A\")=ROWS(R110:R113),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(R110:R113<>\"N/A\"),$N110:$N113,R110:R113))/SUMIF(R110:R113,\"<>N/A\",$N110:$N113))","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(S110:S113,\"N/A\")=ROWS(S110:S113),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(S110:S113<>\"N/A\"),$N110:$N113,S110:S113))/SUMIF(S110:S113,\"<>N/A\",$N110:$N113))","v":"N/A"}]
[null,null,"F1: Product Definition Source","States how the quality process definition’s inspection plans and fixture models are sourced from the product definition.","Quality process definition activities will be derived from the product definition basis MBD.",null,"Use basis artifacts derived from authorized 2D drawings, obtained from file directory.","Use basis artifacts derived from both authorized 2D drawings and ad-hoc derivative models, obtained from file directory.","Use basis artifacts derived from authorized 2D drawings and support models, obtained via PDM.","Use basis artifacts derived from authorized 3DIV drawing and support models, obtained via part objects in PDM.","Use basis artifacts derived from authorized MBD model, obtained via part objects in PDM.","Use basis artifacts derived from authorized product definition dataset (PDD), obtained via part objects in PDM.","Use basis artifacts derived from authorized product definition system model, obtained via part objects in PDM.",4,null,"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A"]
[null,null,"F2: Method","States how the product quality process definition (i.e. qBoM, verification plans, sampling strategies, gage definitions, and fixture definitions CMM program data package) are defined and generated.","Quality process definition becomes more digital and confidently reuses basis MBDs to define product quality plans, embellished derivatives, fixture definitions, CMM work packages, from Bill of Characteristics (BoC)s.",null,"Manual mode-of-operation via 2D drawings of product, fixtures, gage and other resources; qBoM and quality process operations (i.e., BOP) are outlined in documents.","Same with quality visual aids (QVA); Inspection plan manually generated from BoCs.","Same with interactive mode-of-operation using fixture and gage models made from basis 3D model.","Interactive mode-of-operation with BOCs driving the generation of the inspection plans; 3DIV QVAs are generated from basis models.","Same with on-demand extension of product characteristics on native basis MBD; BoC exported in electronic format.","Same with on-demand extension of verification methods and/or sampling plans on model-based product characteristics in model.","Quality BOP is auto generated from rule-based inspection methods from model-based product characteristics; Inspection plan exported in standard (e.g., QIF) digital format.",4,null,"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A"]
[null,null,"F3: Managed","States how the quality process definition dataset is stored, controlled, and managed.","Quality process definition dataset and contents will be managed as part-centric within the PDM system.",null,"Paper file cabinets","Disconnected electronic file directories ","Grouped as common file in document-centric PDM systems ","Collected with support models in part-centric PDM systems","Managed as associated objects within part-centric PLM between Peer-Organizations.","Same and as part-centric item to connected BoC","Same and Extended-Organization’s artifacts are managed within authorized PLM",4,null,"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A"]
[null,null,"F4: Response to Change","States how the quality process definition is notified and responds to change from product definition. ","Quality process definition, specifically BoC, response to change notifications are more automated, timely, & guaranteed.",null,"No notifications","Response to ad hoc notification of change","Response to procedural notification of change","Same with stated response time guarantee","Response to product change notification via PLM","Same with automated state change of related artifacts","Same with automated updates of related artifacts",4,null,"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A"]
[null,"T2: Product Characteristics & BoC",null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,4,null,{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(P115:P117,\"N/A\")=ROWS(P115:P117),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(P115:P117<>\"N/A\"),$N115:$N117,P115:P117))/SUMIF(P115:P117,\"<>N/A\",$N115:$N117))","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(Q115:Q117,\"N/A\")=ROWS(Q115:Q117),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(Q115:Q117<>\"N/A\"),$N115:$N117,Q115:Q117))/SUMIF(Q115:Q117,\"<>N/A\",$N115:$N117))","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(R115:R117,\"N/A\")=ROWS(R115:R117),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(R115:R117<>\"N/A\"),$N115:$N117,R115:R117))/SUMIF(R115:R117,\"<>N/A\",$N115:$N117))","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(S115:S117,\"N/A\")=ROWS(S115:S117),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(S115:S117<>\"N/A\"),$N115:$N117,S115:S117))/SUMIF(S115:S117,\"<>N/A\",$N115:$N117))","v":"N/A"}]
[null,null,"F1: Method","States how product characteristics (PC) are determined, identified, and organized as a bill of characteristics (BoC).","Product characteristic tags and UUIDs are persistently associated with inspection requirements within an MBD and are exported as a BoC in digital standards format.",null,"Manual labeling of PCs as a bi-product during the operation of “ballooning” the 2D drawing just before inspection.","Interactive labeling of PCs during the operation of “ballooning” an electronic 2D drawing just before inspection.","Interactive generation of BoC from quality planning activity on  electronic drawing.","On-demand tagging of PCs from derivative MBD model; BoC exported as formatted document.","On-demand tagging of PCs from native MBD model. PC Tags are augmented with criticality classification. BOC are published as QVAs. BOCs are exported in an open-standard MBD format (e.g., QIF)","Same and PCs are augmented with verification plan requirement (VPR) and/or product requirement associations (PRA).","Same and BoC is provided to extended enterprise via open-standard  (e.g., QIF)",4,null,"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A"]
[null,null,"F2: Managed","States how the Bill of Product Characteristics (BOC) are stored, controlled, and managed.","Product characteristics as BoCs are managed in a part-centric PDM.",null,"Paper file cabinets","Disconnected electronic file directories","Grouped as common file in document-centric PDM systems","Collected with product definition in part-centric PDM system","Managed as objects within part-centric PLM","Same and as part-centric item to connected xBoMs","Same and Extended-Organization’s BoC are managed within authorized PLM",4,null,"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A"]
[null,null,"F3: Traceability","States how Product Characteristics (PC) are traced to and connected with product definitions.","Product Characteristics are bi-directionally connected with models, measurement results and product requirements associations.",null,"PC Tags are textual associated on drawings","PC Tags are visually associated on drawing via symbol (e.g., balloons)","PC Tags are visually associated to MBD model elements on model.","PCs are digitally referenced to PMI on MBD model.","Same and PC tags are augmented with criticality classifications.","Same with each PC Tag having digitally persistent universally unique ID (UUID)","Same with associations with product requirements",4,null,"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A"]
[null,"T3: Quality Process Instructions",null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,4,null,{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(P119:P121,\"N/A\")=ROWS(P119:P121),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(P119:P121<>\"N/A\"),$N119:$N121,P119:P121))/SUMIF(P119:P121,\"<>N/A\",$N119:$N121))","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(Q119:Q121,\"N/A\")=ROWS(Q119:Q121),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(Q119:Q121<>\"N/A\"),$N119:$N121,Q119:Q121))/SUMIF(Q119:Q121,\"<>N/A\",$N119:$N121))","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(R119:R121,\"N/A\")=ROWS(R119:R121),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(R119:R121<>\"N/A\"),$N119:$N121,R119:R121))/SUMIF(R119:R121,\"<>N/A\",$N119:$N121))","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(S119:S121,\"N/A\")=ROWS(S119:S121),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(S119:S121<>\"N/A\"),$N119:$N121,S119:S121))/SUMIF(S119:S121,\"<>N/A\",$N119:$N121))","v":"N/A"}]
[null,null,"F1: Method","States how inspection work instructions are authored and generated.","Inspection instructions progress from text to model images to animations to augmented reality. ",null,"Authored manually using Text, graphics & photographs","Authored within execution business system using text, graphics, photographs, and 3D model-based images","Same with 3D model-based animations","Authored within  PDM/MPM business system using text, images, visualizations and animations","Same and with using annotation and product characteristics from MBD models.","Automatic generation of process instructions from BOP","Same with use of augmented or mixed reality.",4,null,"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A"]
[null,null,"F2: Managed","States how inspection work instructions are stored, controlled, and managed.","Inspection instructions become increasingly linked to the part in the PLM system.",null,"Paper file cabinets","Disconnected electronic file directories ","Disconnected, managed in delivery system (e.g., MES)","Same with supplemental data managed in other systems","Managed as objects within a part-centric PLM and published in delivery system","Directional connected from part-centric PLM system to delivery system","Bi-Directional connected between part-centric PLM system and delivery system",4,null,"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A"]
[null,null,"F3: Response to Change","States how the inspection work instructions discipline is notified responds to changes in quality process definition.","Inspection instructions response to change notifications are more automated, timely, & guaranteed.",null,"No notifications","Response to ad hoc notifications of change","Response to procedural notifications of change","Same with stated response time guarantee","Response to product change notification via PLM","Same with automated state change of related artifacts","Same with automated instruction segment changes and updates to delivery system",4,null,"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A"]
[null,"T4: Inspection Numeric Control Code",null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,4,null,{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(P123:P126,\"N/A\")=ROWS(P123:P126),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(P123:P126<>\"N/A\"),$N123:$N126,P123:P126))/SUMIF(P123:P126,\"<>N/A\",$N123:$N126))","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(Q123:Q126,\"N/A\")=ROWS(Q123:Q126),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(Q123:Q126<>\"N/A\"),$N123:$N126,Q123:Q126))/SUMIF(Q123:Q126,\"<>N/A\",$N123:$N126))","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(R123:R126,\"N/A\")=ROWS(R123:R126),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(R123:R126<>\"N/A\"),$N123:$N126,R123:R126))/SUMIF(R123:R126,\"<>N/A\",$N123:$N126))","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(S123:S126,\"N/A\")=ROWS(S123:S126),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(S123:S126<>\"N/A\"),$N123:$N126,S123:S126))/SUMIF(S123:S126,\"<>N/A\",$N123:$N126))","v":"N/A"}]
[null,null,"F1: Product Definition Source","States how the inspection numeric control (NC) (e.g., CMM) code is sourced from the product definition.","Inspection numeric control (NC) code generation becomes sourced from content within the authorized product definition dataset",null,"Use basis artifacts derived from authorized 2D drawings, obtained from file directory.",null,"Use basis artifacts derived from both authorized 2D drawings and ad-hoc derivative models, obtained from file directory.","Use basis artifacts derived from authorized 2D drawings and support models, obtained via in PDM.","Use basis artifacts derived from authorized 3DIV drawing and support models, obtained via part objects in PDM.","Use basis artifacts derived from authorized MBD model, obtained via part objects in PDM.","Use basis artifacts derived from authorized product definition dataset, obtained via part objects in PDM.",4,null,"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A"]
[null,null,"F2: Method","States how inspection numeric control (NC) code is generated and validated using CAI software per quality process definition.","Inspection numeric control (NC) code confidently reuses basis MBD models and derivatives while following a quality process definition dataset",null,"Manually created NC code from 2D drawings","Interactively generated NC code per work request and using a 3D model-based CAI/CMM application",null,"Same with basis model and separate instructive narrative","Same with basis models containing PMI(aka MBD model)","Same but Semi-automated NC code generation based upon product characteristic’s stated verification plan requirement.","Semi-automated NC code generation based upon minimum metrology feature set with MBD Model PMI",4,null,"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A"]
[null,null,"F3: Managed","States how CNC datasets (code files, persistent identifiers, models, drawing, and support information) are managed.","Inspection numeric control (NC)code definitions, CNC dataset, and their contents will be managed as part-centric within the PDM system.",null,"Paper file cabinets","Disconnected electronic file directories ","Packaged as common file in document-centric PDM systems","Collected with support models in part-centric PDM systems","Managed as objects within part-centric PLM","Same and connected to inspection plan with BoC","Same and extended enterprise’s artifacts are managed within authorized PLM",4,null,"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A"]
[null,null,"F4: Response to change","States how inspection numeric control (NC) code generation discipline is notified and responds to changes in product or process quality definition.","Inspection numeric control (NC)code generation response to change notifications are more automated, timely, & guaranteed.",null,"No notifications","Response to ad hoc notification of change","Response to procedural notifications of change","Same with stated response time guarantee","Response to product change notification via PLM","Same with automated state change of related artifacts","Same with automated code segment updates ",4,null,"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A"]
[null,"T5: Quality Results Management & Analysis",null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,4,null,{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(P128:P130,\"N/A\")=ROWS(P128:P130),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(P128:P130<>\"N/A\"),$N128:$N130,P128:P130))/SUMIF(P128:P130,\"<>N/A\",$N128:$N130))","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(Q128:Q130,\"N/A\")=ROWS(Q128:Q130),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(Q128:Q130<>\"N/A\"),$N128:$N130,Q128:Q130))/SUMIF(Q128:Q130,\"<>N/A\",$N128:$N130))","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(R128:R130,\"N/A\")=ROWS(R128:R130),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(R128:R130<>\"N/A\"),$N128:$N130,R128:R130))/SUMIF(R128:R130,\"<>N/A\",$N128:$N130))","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(S128:S130,\"N/A\")=ROWS(S128:S130),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(S128:S130<>\"N/A\"),$N128:$N130,S128:S130))/SUMIF(S128:S130,\"<>N/A\",$N128:$N130))","v":"N/A"}]
[null,null,"F1: Managed","States how test, measurement, inspection, and statistical results for products are collected, stored, controlled, and managed.","Product quality results will be managed within and/or linked from a part-centric PDM system.",null,"Paper file cabinets","Disconnected electronic file directories ","Grouped as common files within document-centric PDM systems","Collected within part-centric PDM systems","Managed as objects identified within part-centric PLM with external references to quality results management tool","Same with respect to serialized part instances","Same and Extended-Organization’s quality results are managed within authorized PLM.",4,null,"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A"]
[null,null,"F2: Traceability (Serialization)","States how quality results are tied to serialized parts and to product definition.","Quality results are associated to individual model-based product characteristic of serialized parts",null,"Textual reference to part and serialized parts","Electronic reference to part and serialized parts","Same with references to inspection process key identifiers.","Same with references to product characteristic tags","Same with references to persistent product characteristic universally unique identifiers (aka UUID)","Digitally associated to model-based product characteristic on serialized part","Same with associations from Extended-Organizations.",4,null,"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A"]
[null,null,"F3: Reporting","States how quality results, recaps, and statistical conclusions are reported and communicate.","Quality results are communicated, visualized, and reported digitally via an as-measured virtual models.",null,"Individual ad hoc textual part summary report","Disconnected, results recaps with statistical analysis","Automatic results recaps and statistical analysis","Same and import results for display on derivative model","Results via digital interoperability standards (e.g., QIF-Results) format.","Same with statistical analysis and quality plans.","Same and shown via product characteristics on MBD digital as-measured derivative model",4,null,"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A"]
[null,"T6: Test Equipment Definition & Realization",null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,4,null,{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(P132:P134,\"N/A\")=ROWS(P132:P134),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(P132:P134<>\"N/A\"),$N132:$N134,P132:P134))/SUMIF(P132:P134,\"<>N/A\",$N132:$N134))","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(Q132:Q134,\"N/A\")=ROWS(Q132:Q134),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(Q132:Q134<>\"N/A\"),$N132:$N134,Q132:Q134))/SUMIF(Q132:Q134,\"<>N/A\",$N132:$N134))","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(R132:R134,\"N/A\")=ROWS(R132:R134),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(R132:R134<>\"N/A\"),$N132:$N134,R132:R134))/SUMIF(R132:R134,\"<>N/A\",$N132:$N134))","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(S132:S134,\"N/A\")=ROWS(S132:S134),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(S132:S134<>\"N/A\"),$N132:$N134,S132:S134))/SUMIF(S132:S134,\"<>N/A\",$N132:$N134))","v":"N/A"}]
[null,null,"F1: Basis","Identifies the basis of information for test equipment design (see C1: Design Activity's contexts) and test equipment realization.","Test equipment design and realization confidently reuses basis MBD with automations",null,"Visual analysis of product definition","Same","Created from basis 3D model","Same ","Created from basis 3D MBD","Created from basis MBD dataset","Defined automatically from product definition",4,null,"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A"]
[null,null,"F2: Managed","States how test equipment definitions and fabrication datasets are stored, controlled, and managed.","Test equipment definitions, fabrication datasets, and their contents will be managed as part-centric within the PDM system.",null,"Paper file cabinets","Disconnected electronic file directories ","Disconnected, document-centric PDM systems ","Disconnected, part-centric PDM systems","Harmonized PLM schema between Peer-Organizations.","Single, part-centric PLM throughout Enterprise.","Same with Extended-Enterprise",4,null,"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A"]
[null,null,"F3: Traceability","States how test equipment definitions are traced back to a basis model and their associated test equipment process definition.","Test equipment definition and fabrication dataset become associated to test equipment process definition and their part’s basis MBD.",null,"Textual references","Electronic, textual references","System-level awareness of other discipline business systems.","Part-level, Cross-discipline business system navigation.","MBD Model element-level, Cross-discipline business system navigation,","Same with bi-directional navigation","Same with write-back access, as appropriate",4,null,"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A"]
[null,"T7: Inspection Operations",null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,4,null,{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(P136:P137,\"N/A\")=ROWS(P136:P137),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(P136:P137<>\"N/A\"),$N136:$N137,P136:P137))/SUMIF(P136:P137,\"<>N/A\",$N136:$N137))","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(Q136:Q137,\"N/A\")=ROWS(Q136:Q137),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(Q136:Q137<>\"N/A\"),$N136:$N137,Q136:Q137))/SUMIF(Q136:Q137,\"<>N/A\",$N136:$N137))","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(R136:R137,\"N/A\")=ROWS(R136:R137),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(R136:R137<>\"N/A\"),$N136:$N137,R136:R137))/SUMIF(R136:R137,\"<>N/A\",$N136:$N137))","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(S136:S137,\"N/A\")=ROWS(S136:S137),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(S136:S137<>\"N/A\"),$N136:$N137,S136:S137))/SUMIF(S136:S137,\"<>N/A\",$N136:$N137))","v":"N/A"}]
[null,null,"F1: Product Definition Reference","States how inspection operations’ reference and use product definition and models.","Inspection operations reference and use 3DIV drawings and MBD models with product characteristics",null,"Paper documents and 2D drawing","Electronic documents and 2D drawing","Same with open-standard 3D models derivatives","Documents and 3D interactive viewable (3DIV) drawings","Same with open-standard MBD model derivatives and references to product characteristic.","Contents from a MBD dataset and references to product characteristics.","Same but with model-based product characteristics",4,null,"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A"]
[null,null,"F2: Presentation","States the medium of how the inspection work instructions are presented for the operator.","Inspection work instructions will contain more digital, model-based content.",null,"Textual instructions on paper ","Electronic textual instructions","Same with graphics and photo images","Same with images from model","Same with model-based interactions","Same with interactive model-based animations","Same with augmented or mixed reality",4,null,"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A"]
[]
["C5: Enterprise Enabling Activities",null,null,"Activities that enable an organization to act as an MBE, but may not directly add value to a product.","Make it easier to enable, develop, implement, adopt, and sustain an MBE.",null,"Non-existent MBE","MBE Awareness","Reactive MBE","Repeatable MBE","Digital MBE","Integrated MBE","Extended MBE",4,null,{"$f":"IF(COUNT(P140,P143,P147,P152,P158,P164,P171)=0,\"N/A\",SUM(IF(P140<>\"N/A\",P140*$N140,0),IF(P143<>\"N/A\",P143*$N143,0),IF(P147<>\"N/A\",P147*$N147,0),IF(P152<>\"N/A\",P152*$N152,0),IF(P158<>\"N/A\",P158*$N158,0),IF(P164<>\"N/A\",P164*$N164,0),IF(P171<>\"N/A\",P171*$N171,0))/SUM(IF(P140<>\"N/A\",$N140,0),IF(P143<>\"N/A\",$N143,0),IF(P147<>\"N/A\",$N147,0),IF(P152<>\"N/A\",$N152,0),IF(P158<>\"N/A\",$N158,0),IF(P164<>\"N/A\",$N164,0),IF(P171<>\"N/A\",$N171,0)))","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"IF(COUNT(Q140,Q143,Q147,Q152,Q158,Q164,Q171)=0,\"N/A\",SUM(IF(Q140<>\"N/A\",Q140*$N140,0),IF(Q143<>\"N/A\",Q143*$N143,0),IF(Q147<>\"N/A\",Q147*$N147,0),IF(Q152<>\"N/A\",Q152*$N152,0),IF(Q158<>\"N/A\",Q158*$N158,0),IF(Q164<>\"N/A\",Q164*$N164,0),IF(Q171<>\"N/A\",Q171*$N171,0))/SUM(IF(Q140<>\"N/A\",$N140,0),IF(Q143<>\"N/A\",$N143,0),IF(Q147<>\"N/A\",$N147,0),IF(Q152<>\"N/A\",$N152,0),IF(Q158<>\"N/A\",$N158,0),IF(Q164<>\"N/A\",$N164,0),IF(Q171<>\"N/A\",$N171,0)))","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"IF(COUNT(R140,R143,R147,R152,R158,R164,R171)=0,\"N/A\",SUM(IF(R140<>\"N/A\",R140*$N140,0),IF(R143<>\"N/A\",R143*$N143,0),IF(R147<>\"N/A\",R147*$N147,0),IF(R152<>\"N/A\",R152*$N152,0),IF(R158<>\"N/A\",R158*$N158,0),IF(R164<>\"N/A\",R164*$N164,0),IF(R171<>\"N/A\",R171*$N171,0))/SUM(IF(R140<>\"N/A\",$N140,0),IF(R143<>\"N/A\",$N143,0),IF(R147<>\"N/A\",$N147,0),IF(R152<>\"N/A\",$N152,0),IF(R158<>\"N/A\",$N158,0),IF(R164<>\"N/A\",$N164,0),IF(R171<>\"N/A\",$N171,0)))","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"IF(COUNT(S140,S143,S147,S152,S158,S164,S171)=0,\"N/A\",SUM(IF(S140<>\"N/A\",S140*$N140,0),IF(S143<>\"N/A\",S143*$N143,0),IF(S147<>\"N/A\",S147*$N147,0),IF(S152<>\"N/A\",S152*$N152,0),IF(S158<>\"N/A\",S158*$N158,0),IF(S164<>\"N/A\",S164*$N164,0),IF(S171<>\"N/A\",S171*$N171,0))/SUM(IF(S140<>\"N/A\",$N140,0),IF(S143<>\"N/A\",$N143,0),IF(S147<>\"N/A\",$N147,0),IF(S152<>\"N/A\",$N152,0),IF(S158<>\"N/A\",$N158,0),IF(S164<>\"N/A\",$N164,0),IF(S171<>\"N/A\",$N171,0)))","v":"N/A"}]
[null,"T1: Product Work Collaboration",null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,4,null,{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(P141:P142,\"N/A\")=ROWS(P141:P142),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(P141:P142<>\"N/A\"),$N141:$N142,P141:P142))/SUMIF(P141:P142,\"<>N/A\",$N141:$N142))","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(Q141:Q142,\"N/A\")=ROWS(Q141:Q142),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(Q141:Q142<>\"N/A\"),$N141:$N142,Q141:Q142))/SUMIF(Q141:Q142,\"<>N/A\",$N141:$N142))","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(R141:R142,\"N/A\")=ROWS(R141:R142),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(R141:R142<>\"N/A\"),$N141:$N142,R141:R142))/SUMIF(R141:R142,\"<>N/A\",$N141:$N142))","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(S141:S142,\"N/A\")=ROWS(S141:S142),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(S141:S142<>\"N/A\"),$N141:$N142,S141:S142))/SUMIF(S141:S142,\"<>N/A\",$N141:$N142))","v":"N/A"}]
[null,null,"F1: Actors","States who are collaborating on product realization information.","Collaboration crosses more boundaries (e.g., security, location, organizational).",null,"Ad hoc","Core group","Cross-functional team","OUA ","Peer-Organization","Enterprise","Extended-Enterprise",4,null,"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A"]
[null,null,"F2:Methods","States the methods used to collaborate on product realization information activities.","Collaboration tools transition to common joint authoring over increasingly rich media.",null,"Phone and in-person meetings","Same and asynchronous messaging (email, voice mail, instant messaging)","Same and synchronous sharing (voice & video conferencing)","Same and multi-user screen sharing","Same with common collaborative virtual meetings, access to calendars, schedules, and web-based tools","Same and common, concurrent, multi-user authoring tools","Same and augmented or virtual reality collaboration",4,null,"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A"]
[null,"T2: MBE Governance",null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,4,null,{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(P144:P146,\"N/A\")=ROWS(P144:P146),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(P144:P146<>\"N/A\"),$N144:$N146,P144:P146))/SUMIF(P144:P146,\"<>N/A\",$N144:$N146))","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(Q144:Q146,\"N/A\")=ROWS(Q144:Q146),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(Q144:Q146<>\"N/A\"),$N144:$N146,Q144:Q146))/SUMIF(Q144:Q146,\"<>N/A\",$N144:$N146))","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(R144:R146,\"N/A\")=ROWS(R144:R146),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(R144:R146<>\"N/A\"),$N144:$N146,R144:R146))/SUMIF(R144:R146,\"<>N/A\",$N144:$N146))","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(S144:S146,\"N/A\")=ROWS(S144:S146),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(S144:S146<>\"N/A\"),$N144:$N146,S144:S146))/SUMIF(S144:S146,\"<>N/A\",$N144:$N146))","v":"N/A"}]
[null,null,"F1: Leadership","States the extent of the MBE leadership team.","MBE leadership becomes more formalized, full time, and at higher levels.",null,"None","Informal, part-time MBE champion ","Formal part-time MBE Champion","Formal, full-time MBE champion ","Same and Peer-Organization management leadership","MBE leadership at Supra-Organization management level. ","MBE leadership extends to Extended-Organizations.",4,null,"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A"]
[null,null,"F2: Structure","States how an organization's business structure supports the MBE strategy.","MBE activities becomes more formalized with more involved in the structure.",null,"None","Ad hoc","Non-authoritative or informal group","Team led with core team","Centralized MBE program amongst Peer-Organizations.","Same with embedded liaisons throughout Enterprise.","Same including Extended-Organizations.",4,null,"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A"]
[null,null,"F3: Commitment to Change","States organization proficiency and effectiveness toward managing, successful implementing and sustaining MBE change initiatives.","MBE change initiatives progress from no Organizational Change Management (OCM) to enterprise-wide competency",null,"Absent, project teams are unaware for their need to manage the people-side of change","Ad-hoc, no formal practices or plans. OCM is reactive to people resistance and becomes an add-on to the project","Isolated Projects, some elements OCM begin to emerge in isolated parts of the organization.  Efforts to manage the people-side of change is infrequent and not centralized","Multiple Projects, groups begin using structured OCM process, OCM is localized to particular teams of areas in the organization.","Organizational standards, organization has selected common approach and implemented standards for using OCM on every new project or technical change.","Enterprise Competency, OCM competency is part of the skill set of the organization.","Same and OCM steps are completely integrated into project management, OCM activities begins before project kick-off and viewed as standard practice..",4,null,"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A"]
[null,"T3: MBE People",null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,4,null,{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(P148:P151,\"N/A\")=ROWS(P148:P151),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(P148:P151<>\"N/A\"),$N148:$N151,P148:P151))/SUMIF(P148:P151,\"<>N/A\",$N148:$N151))","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(Q148:Q151,\"N/A\")=ROWS(Q148:Q151),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(Q148:Q151<>\"N/A\"),$N148:$N151,Q148:Q151))/SUMIF(Q148:Q151,\"<>N/A\",$N148:$N151))","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(R148:R151,\"N/A\")=ROWS(R148:R151),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(R148:R151<>\"N/A\"),$N148:$N151,R148:R151))/SUMIF(R148:R151,\"<>N/A\",$N148:$N151))","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(S148:S151,\"N/A\")=ROWS(S148:S151),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(S148:S151<>\"N/A\"),$N148:$N151,S148:S151))/SUMIF(S148:S151,\"<>N/A\",$N148:$N151))","v":"N/A"}]
[null,null,"F1: Training","States how engineers, designers, machinists, inspectors, and others are trained to work with MBE.","Training curriculum becomes more consistent and on demand. ",null,"Ad-Hoc","Locally managed, inconsistently delivered.","Centrally managed, classroom based.","Same and electronic delivery.","Digital, on demand, consistent on all mediums.","Role-based, in context of Enterprise systems and business processes.","Independently audited, aligns with industry best practices.",4,null,"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A"]
[null,null,"F2: Support","States how people working with MBE are assisted with problem solutions and instruction.","Support becomes more complete, consistent, and accessible at point of consumption. ",null,"Ad-Hoc","Info wiki; quick reference guides; intranet sources.","Same with FAQ and on-demand instructions","Same with help request mechanism","Same with interactive scripts (e.g., tutorials)","Same with content incorporated in Enterprise’s multi-tiered help desk","Same as Enterprise-Organizations have access to Enterprise’s help content.",4,null,"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A"]
[null,null,"F3: Certified Roles","States which MBE contributors are certified and level of recognition.","More MBE contributors are certified by more widely recognized bodies.",null,"No defined roles","Not standardized, no formal certification","Standardized, certification for key roles","Standardized in business processes; certification for formally recognized roles","Roles granted when formal certification achieved, digital approvals ","Roles and permissions align with training records","Accredited and recognized by external professional bodies",4,null,"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A"]
[null,null,"F4: Awareness","States how workers become informed about MBE processes and technology.","Information about MBE processes and technology is richer and more readily available.",null,"Oblivious","Ad hoc","Broadcasts to interested parties","MBE communications portal","Interactive MBE communications portal (e.g., internal wiki / web-page)","Automated feeds from core MBE business functions and capabilities","Metrics from integrated business intelligence capability",4,null,"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A"]
[null,"T4: MBE Process",null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,4,null,{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(P153:P157,\"N/A\")=ROWS(P153:P157),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(P153:P157<>\"N/A\"),$N153:$N157,P153:P157))/SUMIF(P153:P157,\"<>N/A\",$N153:$N157))","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(Q153:Q157,\"N/A\")=ROWS(Q153:Q157),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(Q153:Q157<>\"N/A\"),$N153:$N157,Q153:Q157))/SUMIF(Q153:Q157,\"<>N/A\",$N153:$N157))","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(R153:R157,\"N/A\")=ROWS(R153:R157),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(R153:R157<>\"N/A\"),$N153:$N157,R153:R157))/SUMIF(R153:R157,\"<>N/A\",$N153:$N157))","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(S153:S157,\"N/A\")=ROWS(S153:S157),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(S153:S157<>\"N/A\"),$N153:$N157,S153:S157))/SUMIF(S153:S157,\"<>N/A\",$N153:$N157))","v":"N/A"}]
[null,null,"F1: Business Policies","States how business polices are modified to accommodate the use of authorized 3D Models.","Authorized MBD becomes a ubiquitous practice.",null,"Business policies based upon Paper drawing/ documents","Polices address electronic 2D drawing/ document-based","Same with accommodations for  3D models","Introduce MBD-specific polices along with enduring policies","Locally applied end-to-end policies for MBD between Peer-Organizations.","End-to-end polices for MBD throughout the Enterprise.","Same with Extended-Enterprise.",4,null,"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A"]
[null,null,"F2: Repeatable (Documented)","States how MBE processes are documented and managed.","Business processes become more digital, interactive, and repeatable.",null,"Unmanaged","Inconsistent, reliant on subject matter expert knowledge","Documented, OUA managed","Same","Digital in designated repository between Peer-Organizations.","Fully integrated business process framework throughout the Enterprise.","Closed loop business process includes Extended-Enterprise",4,null,"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A"]
[null,null,"F3: Governance Scope","States how MBE processes are governed.","Business processes are governed more centrally across the Enterprise.",null,"No governance","Same","OUA management","Same","Centrally governed, standardized between Peer-Organizations.","Actively managed by Supra-Organization through a team of business process specialists to support the Enterprise.","Same with Extended-Organizations.",4,null,"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A"]
[null,null,"F4: Optimize","States how Key Performance Indicators (KPIs) of MBE processes are measured and used for optimization.","Business processes become better understood, measured and optimized.",null,"Not used","Not well understood","Efficiency not measured","KPIs measured, but inefficient","Align KPIs with business processes.","KPIs are assessed and optimized.","Continuous improvement",4,null,"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A"]
[null,null,"F5: Industry Standard","States how MBE processes are aligned to industry and/or national standards.","Local business processes are first benchmarked against, aligned to industry standards, then influenced by national standards.",null,"Oblivious to any standards","Locally conceived standards","No alignment to known standards","Benchmark key business processes to standards","COTS systems aligned to industry standards","Regularly benchmark all related business processes","Standards organizations engagement, influence standard definitions; regular audits",4,null,"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A"]
[null,"T5: MBE Technology",null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,4,null,{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(P159:P163,\"N/A\")=ROWS(P159:P163),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(P159:P163<>\"N/A\"),$N159:$N163,P159:P163))/SUMIF(P159:P163,\"<>N/A\",$N159:$N163))","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(Q159:Q163,\"N/A\")=ROWS(Q159:Q163),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(Q159:Q163<>\"N/A\"),$N159:$N163,Q159:Q163))/SUMIF(Q159:Q163,\"<>N/A\",$N159:$N163))","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(R159:R163,\"N/A\")=ROWS(R159:R163),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(R159:R163<>\"N/A\"),$N159:$N163,R159:R163))/SUMIF(R159:R163,\"<>N/A\",$N159:$N163))","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(S159:S163,\"N/A\")=ROWS(S159:S163),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(S159:S163<>\"N/A\"),$N159:$N163,S159:S163))/SUMIF(S159:S163,\"<>N/A\",$N159:$N163))","v":"N/A"}]
[null,null,"F1: Standardized","States the degree of standardization for MBE technologies.","Digital technology used for MBE becomes more standardized.",null,"No defined standardization.","Non-scalable customized, non-standard, disconnected.","Non-scalable customized, non-standard but connected.","Standardized for discrete workflows with OUA customizations.","Standardized for discrete workflows with Peer-Organization customizations","Enterprise platform","Same with interoperability to Extended-Organizations.",4,null,"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A"]
[null,null,"F2: Integrated","States the alignment between MBE technology and business goals.","Technology becomes more aligned, digital, and accessible across the Enterprise.",null,"No alignment to business goals and technology.","Disjointed technologies.","Technologies enable distinct, coherent, non-integrated workflows.","Technology enables integrated workflows.","All MBE technologies are either integrated or interoperable between Peer-Organizations.","Technology enables a digital thread across inter-organization and lifecycle phases throughout the Enterprise.","Technology enables digital thread with Extended-Enterprise.",4,null,"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A"]
[null,null,"F3: Verification & Validation","States how the organization proves the veracity of software agents that process MBE data.","Veracity of MBE software is increasingly proven. ",null,"No reliable regime.","Functional verification checks on installations and upgrades.","Same with verification of no unintended effects.","Same, plus exercise software against benchmarks.","Same and exercised on routine schedule","Same with continuous verification","Independent verification & validation (V&V)",4,null,"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A"]
[null,null,"F4: Maintained","States how the organization proves that MBE-related technologies have correct and up-to-date software configurations (e.g. versions, patch levels, configuration files).","Qualification of software versions and configurations becomes specialized, continuous, and integrated.",null,"No reliable configuration checking regime","Configuration check of individual technologies","Same","Ad hoc configuration check of dependencies","Routine configuration check of dependencies","Continuous configuration check of dependencies","Same with self-aware and self-organizing technologies",4,null,"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A"]
[null,null,"F5: Tool Availability","States the availability of MBE tools to MBE people.","Tools become more easily accessible in more environments.",null,"None ","None","Pilot projects only","Limited environments","Between Peer-Organizations.","Throughout Enterprise.","Extended-Enterprise access.",null,null,"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A"]
[null,"T6: MBE Information Assurance",null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,4,null,{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(P165:P170,\"N/A\")=ROWS(P165:P170),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(P165:P170<>\"N/A\"),$N165:$N170,P165:P170))/SUMIF(P165:P170,\"<>N/A\",$N165:$N170))","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(Q165:Q170,\"N/A\")=ROWS(Q165:Q170),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(Q165:Q170<>\"N/A\"),$N165:$N170,Q165:Q170))/SUMIF(Q165:Q170,\"<>N/A\",$N165:$N170))","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(R165:R170,\"N/A\")=ROWS(R165:R170),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(R165:R170<>\"N/A\"),$N165:$N170,R165:R170))/SUMIF(R165:R170,\"<>N/A\",$N165:$N170))","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(S165:S170,\"N/A\")=ROWS(S165:S170),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(S165:S170<>\"N/A\"),$N165:$N170,S165:S170))/SUMIF(S165:S170,\"<>N/A\",$N165:$N170))","v":"N/A"}]
[null,null,"F1: Authenticated","States how the organization assures authenticity of models and derivatives.","Authenticity evolves from physical controls to authoritative sources and intrinsic digital certificate.",null,"Markings on 2D drawing","Release records","Electronic certificate of authenticity for 2D drawing with associated 3D model","Authoritative sources. Linked electronic certificate of authenticity","Same, with intrinsic, digital certificates for applicable content between Peer-Organizations","On-demand digital trust framework to verify authenticity, authorization, and certification per user provided agreements throughout the Enterprise. ","Same trust framework extends to Extended-Organizations.",4,null,"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A"]
[null,null,"F2: Accessibility","States the MBE ensures timely and reliable access to, and use of information.","Information becomes more digital, discoverable, and easy to access.",null,"Paper documents accessible by librarians.","Electronic documents in disorganized stores and accessible by OUA / local organization only.","Same, but stored in organized collections.","Searchable distinct sources.","Searchable across sources and accessible between Peer-Organizations","Searchable across sources throughout the Enterprise.","Selected sources accessible and searchable by Extended-Organizations",4,null,"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A"]
[null,null,"F3: Confidentiality","States how the organization controls access to models and derivatives.","Access controls become richer, automatic, and consistently applied throughout the Enterprise.",null,"Physical control","Control of individual electronic files ","Control of sets of electronic files","Encryption and trust policies across all authoritative sources within QUA.","Same with digital rights management and digital redaction between Peer-Organizations.","Same, with object/feature-level access controls throughout the Enterprise.","Extended-Organizations participate in digital rights management system and/or automated redaction.",4,null,"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A"]
[null,null,"F4: Governance of Access Control","States how data access controls are managed.","Role-based access controls become more common and centrally managed throughout the Enterprise.",null,"No access controls","Ad hoc access granted by individual in possession.","Granted by individual per OUA’s documented access control policy","Granted by program per OUA’s documented access control policy","Granted by program per Peer-Organizations agreement.","Granted by policy across all programs throughout the Enterprise.","Access controls extends to Enterprise-Organizations; Automatic, adaptive management of access controls.",4,null,"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A"]
[null,null,"F5: Data State & Stewardship","Assess the readiness, reliability, and traceability of digital information by defining and managing its progression through established states of governance and assurance.","Advances, data evolve from isolated, unmanaged files to governed, authorized, and certified artifacts that form trusted digital threads across the enterprise.",null,"Disconnected: Uncontrolled, isolated data","Grouped: Informally organized","Collected: Aggregated within shared repositories","Managed: Versioned and configuration-controlled","Published: Released and validated for consumption","Authorized: Approved for defined lifecycle use","Certified: Proven to meet quality and standards compliance; fully trusted artifact",4,null,"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A"]
[null,null,"F6: Cybersecurity","Protects, monitors, and governs its digital engineering environment, data assets, and MBE workflows against unauthorized access, corruption, or loss","Evolves cybersecurity from ad hoc IT protection to a fully integrated digital assurance framework that governs data, identity, and trust across the model-based enterprise.",null,"None / Unprotected: Has no established cybersecurity practices; data and tools are unprotected.","Basic Protection: Minimal controls (passwords, basic access); ad hoc protection for files and systems.","Documented Controls: Formal policies and documented practices; baseline configuration & backups.","Managed Security: Implemented processes for monitoring, incident response, and vulnerability management.","Proactive Resilience: Continuous monitoring, risk-based controls, and supply-chain vetting; threat-informed defenses.","Adaptive Assurance: Integrated cyber / MBE governance, automation for detection & remediation, supplier assurance.","Enterprise Resilient / Assured: Enterprise-wide, measurable cyber assurance tied to digital-thread, continuous certification, and cross-enterprise trust",4,null,"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A"]
[null,"T7: MBE Financials",null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,4,null,{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(P172:P173,\"N/A\")=ROWS(P172:P173),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(P172:P173<>\"N/A\"),$N172:$N173,P172:P173))/SUMIF(P172:P173,\"<>N/A\",$N172:$N173))","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(Q172:Q173,\"N/A\")=ROWS(Q172:Q173),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(Q172:Q173<>\"N/A\"),$N172:$N173,Q172:Q173))/SUMIF(Q172:Q173,\"<>N/A\",$N172:$N173))","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(R172:R173,\"N/A\")=ROWS(R172:R173),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(R172:R173<>\"N/A\"),$N172:$N173,R172:R173))/SUMIF(R172:R173,\"<>N/A\",$N172:$N173))","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(S172:S173,\"N/A\")=ROWS(S172:S173),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(S172:S173<>\"N/A\"),$N172:$N173,S172:S173))/SUMIF(S172:S173,\"<>N/A\",$N172:$N173))","v":"N/A"}]
[null,null,"F1: Mechanism","States the source and extent of funding for MBE.","MBE funding mechanism progresses from ad hoc projects, to programs, to portfolios.",null,"None","Ad hoc","Projects for technology capability maturation","Same and pilot applications for maturation of MBE practices","Program of MBE related projects","Same and coordinated across multiple funding venues","Portfolio of MBE programs",4,null,"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A"]
[null,null,"F2: Continuity","States the continuity of funding for MBE.","MBE funding continues from competitive short-term to organizationally sustained funding.",null,"None","Ad hoc","Funding requested annually.","Multiyear funding.","Sustained amongst Peer-Organizations.","Sustained throughout the Enterprise.","Sustained throughout Extended-Enterprise.",4,null,"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A"]
[null,null,"END"]
[null,null,{"$f":"'Overview & Instructions'!B122","v":"NSC-614-7804 dated 20260218 Unclassified Unlimited Release (UUR)"}]

{"sheet":"MBE Lexicon","index":3,"n_rows":217,"n_cols":6,"rows_kept":217,"cut":false,"hidden":false,"merged":[[215,1,215,4]]}
["Abbrev.","Term","Definition, Normalized","Definition, Specialized (editable)","Organization Comments (Add your comments here)","Lexicon Clarifications"]
["3DIV","3D Interactive Viewable","A three-dimensional, derivative viewable that is intended for human interaction and is published in a ubiquitous format (e.g., html, .pdf)."]
[null,"Activities, Enterprise Enabling","An MBE Maturity Index category of activities that enable an organization to act as an MBE, but may not directly add value to products."]
[null,"Activities, Product Data / Lifecycle Management","An MBE Maturity Index category of activities involved in managing and interrelating product data."]
[null,"Activities, Product Design","An MBE Maturity Index category of activities involved in designing the product and preparing the product definition."]
[null,"Activities, Product Manufacturing","An MBE Maturity Index category of activities involved in fabricating (e.g., manufacturing, assembling) products."]
[null,"Activities, Product Quality","An MBE Maturity Index category of activities involved in verifying, testing, inspecting, and accepting products."]
[null,"Activities, Product Sustainment ","An MBE Maturity Index category of activities involved in servicing/sustaining products."]
[null,"Activities, Systems Engineering","An MBE Maturity Index category of activities involved in system engineering of products."]
[null,"Annotation","Visible, non-shape information contained in a 3D model.","[ASME Y14.41-2019, Annotation] visible dimensions, tolerances, notes, text, or symbols.  "]
[null,"Assembly","A collection of two or more parts (or components) joined together to perform a function."]
[null,"Assembly, Inseparable","An assembly that cannot be disassembled without destroying its parts."]
[null,"Assembly, Separable","An assembly that can be disassembled without destruction of its components."]
[null,"Assertion","In the MBE Maturity Index, a statement to be assessed at the intersection of a maturity level and a facet."]
[null,"Attribute","Non-visible information contained in, or related to, a model.","[ASME Y14.41-2019, Attribute] a dimension, tolerance, note, text, or symbol required to complete the product definition or feature of the product that is not visible, but available upon interrogation of the annotated model.","[DoDI 5000.70, Metadata] Searchable information describing the characteristics of data; data or information about data; or descriptive information about an object’s data, data activities, systems, and holdings."]
[null,"Artifact","Any tangible or intangible output produced during the execution of a process.",null,null,"Artifacts may become Items when they are placed under lifecycle management and governance."]
[null,"Artifact, Courtesy","An unauthorized artifact provided to a recipient for reference only, without lifecycle authority."]
[null,"Artifact, Digital","An artifact that exists in digital form."]
[null,"Authenticated","A condition that an artifact has been proven to be genuine as issued by its originator."]
[null,"Authentication","See \"Specialized Definition\"","[ASME Y14.100-2017, Authentication] the process of verifying the claimed identity of a document’s author and approver(s)."]
[null,"Authoritative Source","An information provider that is sanctioned for a given lifecycle activity. "]
[null,"Authorized","Approved by an authority for use in a lifecycle activity."]
[null,"Automated","A mode of operation performed by a machine for a person."]
[null,"Baseline","An immutable dataset created at a particular point in time and used for comparison or control."]
[null,"Baseline, Product Definition","See product definition and baseline."]
["BoC","Bill of Characteristic","A list of product characteristics that need to be verified."]
["BoI","Bill of Items","A list of associated information items, along with quantities and optional activity-specific information, needed to perform a lifecycle activity."]
["BoM","Bill of Materials","A list of associated parts and materials, along with quantities and optional activity-specific information, needed to perform a lifecycle activity."]
["BoP","Bill of Process","A list of associated process operations needed to perform a process plan for a lifecycle activity"]
["BoR","Bill of Resource","A list of associate production resources needed to perform one or more process plan operation(s) for a lifecycle activity"]
["eBoM","BOM, Engineering","A bill of material, which identifies and authorizes the items that define the product definition as designed."]
["mBoM","BOM, Manufacturing","A bill of material, which identifies the items needed to realize a shippable product."]
["qBoM","BOM, Quality","A bill of material, which identifies the items needed to inspect, text, or accept a product."]
[" xBoM","BOM, x","A bill of material with a view of \"x\""]
[null,"Bounded Surface","See \"Specialized Definition\"","[ASME Y14.46, Bounded Surface Region] A surface subset within a part or on a part surface that is bounded by a set of connected or intersecting edges"]
[null,"Bounded Volume","See \"Specialized Definition\"","[ASME Y14.46, Bounded Volume Region] A volume subset within a part that is bounded by a set of connected or intersecting surfaces."]
[null,"Category","In the MBE Maturity Index, an activity that contains topics."]
[null,"Certified","Guaranteed to conform to specific, agreed-upon business protocols."]
[null,"Certificate","Evidence that an artifact is certified."]
[null,"Characteristic","See \"Specialized Definition\"","[DMSC:MBC v1.0, Characteristics] a trait, quality, or attribute on an element of a feature such as its size, location, form, or property, which may be a specification limit, a dimension with tolerance, a geometric tolerance within a feature control frame, or some other numerical or non-numerical control."]
["OC","Characteristic, Operation","See \"Specialized Definition\"","[DMSC:MBC v1.0, Operation Characteristics] a characteristic, which is created to identify an operation or process requirement for the product realization process of a product or of a feature of a product"]
["PC","Characteristic, Product","See \"Specialized Definition\"","[DMSC:MBC v1.0, Product Characteristics] a characteristic, which is created to identify a verification requirement, such as a tolerance or specification, applied to a feature or of a product"]
["SC","Characteristic, Service","See \"Specialized Definition\"","[DMSC:MBC v1.0, Service Characteristics] a characteristic, which is created to identify a service or maintenance requirement for the sustainment of a product or of a feature of a product"]
["NC","Code, Numeric Control","Computer coded instructions inserted into a machine tool to control its operation."]
["CAD","Computer Aided Design","A computer-based tool used to aid in the design processes."]
["MCAD","CAD, Mechanical","A CAD tool used to design and help define mechanical product."]
["ECAD","CAD, Electrical","A CAD tool used to design and help define electrical product"]
[null,"Context","In the MBE Maturity Index, a user-defined discipline."]
[null,"Copy","See “Specialized Definition”","[ASME Y14.100- 2017, Copy] any reproduction or duplication, in any media, of an original."]
[null,"Copy, Controlled","A copy of an information item that is managed per a governing protocol and is authorized for use."]
[null,"Copy, LOTAR","A record copy that contains authentication information to validate a trusted retrieval."]
[null,"Copy, Record","An information item that is designated as the official copy for reference and preservation."]
["CC","Criticality Classification","An optional augmentation applied to a Product Characteristic (PC) that defines the risk or importance level of that characteristic regarding safety, compliance, function, or quality. ","[DMSC:MBC v1.0, Criticality Classification] a characteristic augmentation that optionally designates a criticality"]
[null,"Data","Facts given for storage or processing.","[ASME Y14.41-2019, Data] Information represented in a formal manner suitable for communication, interpretation, or processing by human beings or computers."]
[null,"Data, Process ","Product data that pertains to a process."]
[null,"Data, Product","Data that pertains to the product lifecycle."]
[null,"Data, Structured","Information that is organized according to a defined structure, schema, or model."]
[null,"Data, Supplemental","Data within product definition, which communicates requirements and/or characteristics but is not intended to represent an item.","[ASME Y14.41-2019, Supplemental Geometry] Geometric elements included in product definition data to communicate design requirements but not intended to represent an item."]
[null,"Data, Trusted","Data that is governed, validated, and accepted as authoritative for its intended use. (See trusted and data)"]
[null,"Dataset","An identifiable collection of related data that serves a lifecycle activity."]
[null,"Dataset, MBD","A definition dataset that includes a model-based definition model."]
["PPDD","Dataset, Production Process Definition","A dataset that contains a collection of items that defines a production process definition baseline."]
["PDD","Dataset, Product Definition ","A dataset that contains a collection of items that defines a production definition baseline. ","[Y14.41-2019, Product definition data set] A collection of one or more data file(s) that discloses, directly or by reference, by means of presentation (e.g., graphic or textual), representation (e.g., semantics or machine readable), or combinations of both, the physical or functional requirements of an item."]
["QPDD","Dataset, Quality Process Definition","A dataset that contains a collection of items that defines a quality process definition baseline."]
[null,"Data Package","An identifiable digital container of dataset(s) that is intended for the specific purpose of storage or delivery. "]
["PPDP","Data Package, Purchased Product","A data package that contains a dataset that defines a product procurement baseline."]
[null,"Datum Feature","See “Specialized Definition”","[ASME Y14.5-2018, Datum Feature] a feature that is identified with either a datum feature symbol or a datum target symbol(s)."]
[null,"Datum Feature, Functional","A datum feature on a part that contributes to the fit and/or functional intent of the product.  "]
[null,"Definition, Normalized Term","Within the MBE Lexicon, a definition of a term, which is a generalization with common applicability across a large body of disciplines and used as a basis for any specializations."]
[null,"Definition, Specialized Term","Within the MBE Lexicon, a definition of a term, which is a specialization of the normalized definition adapted to a specific discipline, user base, or Organization Under Assessment (OUA)."]
[null,"Derivative","An artifact created from a source artifact that may be transformed into a different format.","[ASME Y14.41 - 2019, Derivative] Data duplicated or extracted from the original.  A copy of a derivative is also a derivative"]
[null,"Derivative, Context-Declared","A derivative explicitly declared as functionally equivalent or fit-for-purpose for a defined lifecycle context."]
[null,"Derivative, Embellished ","The condition of a derivative being enhanced from its source with respect to an intended use."]
[null,"Derivative, Equivalent ","The condition of a derivative being functionally equivalent from its source with respect to an intended use."]
[null,"Derivative, Open-Standard","A derivative that is structured, formatted and validated in accordance with an open, non-proprietary, data exchange standard"]
[null,"Designator","See Specialization","[DMSC:MBC v1.0, Designator] a means to identify and set apart for a specific purpose."]
[null,"Designator, Characteristic","See Specialization","[DMSC:MBC v1.0, Designator] a designator that labels a characteristic with its tag."]
[null,"Designator, Criticality Classification","See Specialization","[DMSC:MBC v1.0, Designator] a designator that labels a Criticality Classification."]
[null,"Designator, Product Requirement Association","See Specialization","[DMSC:MBC v1.0, Designator] a designator for the Product Requirement Association."]
[null,"Designator, Verification Plan Requirement","See Specialization","[DMSC:MBC v1.0, Designator] a designator for the Verification Plan Requirement."]
["DfX","Design for X","An activity that optimizes a design for a goal as designated by \"X\""]
[null,"Digital","Data intended for interpretation by computer applications."]
[null,"Digital Thread","The linkages of data from authoritative sources that interconnects a digital enterprise. "]
[null,"Digital Twin","A virtual representation of a physical product digitally connected with its realization(s)."]
[null,"Discipline","An area of practice within product lifecycle activities."]
[null,"Document","A medium that contains human-readable information intended for communication, reference, or recordkeeping."]
[null,"Drawing","A document that communicates technical information primarily through graphical representation."]
[null,"Drawing, 2D","A technical drawing that represents an object or system using two-dimensional geometry to produce flat, static images."]
[null,"Drawing, 3D","A technical drawing that represents an object or system using three-dimensional geometry to convey spatial relationships, volume, and realism."]
[null,"Drawing, 3DIV","A specialized technical drawing derived from a Model-Based Definition (MBD) model and published as an interactive, human-viewable 3D representation in a widely accessible digital format (e.g., PDF, HTML)."]
[null,"Drawing, Graphical","A drawing created with the specific intent to visually communicate information, concepts, or data."]
[null,"Drawing, Simplified","A technical drawing that presents a limited set of basic dimensions and annotations, while relying on a functionally equivalent 3D or MBD model for on-demand details.","[ASME Y14.41 - 2019 Simplified Drawing] A drawing with minimal views and dimensional characteristics that relies on the model to provide complete part definition."]
[null,"Drawing Technical","A precise and detailed graphical drawing used to formally communicate technical information necessary for the definition, fabrication, inspection, or maintenance of a product, process, or system."]
[null,"Electronic","A computerized document intended for presentation to humans."]
[null,"Enterprise","The organization that comprises the OUA, Peer-Organizations, and Supra-Organization."]
[null,"Enterprise, Digital","An organization that uses a digital thread to conduct business activities."]
[null,"Enterprise, Extended","The group of organizations comprised of the Enterprise and Extended Organizations."]
[null,"Extended","An increase in the scope of collaboration, influence, and/or innovation. "]
[null,"Equivalent, Functionally","An item or group of items that can be used in the same basic manner as another item or items to perform a task to the same standard."]
[null,"Facet","In the MBE Maturity Index, an activity within a topic that contains a set of assertions regarding the current state."]
[null,"Formalized","The means to make something official or to arrange it according to a fixed structure."]
[null,"Governance","The system of rules, practices, and processes by which an organization directs and controls its activities."]
[null,"Governance, Data","A system of policies, processes, and controls that establishes standards for the collection, structure, usage, and management of data, for organizational data assets, within information management activities."]
[null,"Governance, Information","A system of policies, processes, and controls that governs the lifecycle, authority, accessibility, integrity, and trust of information for lifecycle information assets, within organizational and digital environments."]
[null,"Harmonized","A process of integrating and standardizing data from various sources."]
[null,"Integrated, Digitally","The concept of connecting an organization’s tools, systems, and data in a programmatic way"]
[null,"Item","A managed entity within lifecycle processes, such as a part, assembly, software, document, model, dataset, or other artifact placed under lifecycle governance.",null,null,"In digital engineering environments, items are typically represented as digital artifacts managed within lifecycle management systems."]
[null,"Item, Authorized","An item formally designated as the authoritative representation of information for its intended lifecycle purpose.","Authoritative: Designated as the official source of truth",null,"Authoritative: Designated as the official source of truth"]
[null,"Item, Certified","An authorized item whose integrity, compliance, or performance has been formally verified and attested through defined validation, certification, or regulatory processes.","Trusted: Verified and attested for integrity or compliance",null,"Trusted: Verified and attested for integrity or compliance"]
[null,"Item, Collected","An item organized as part of a defined dataset or collection in which relationships to other items are identified and maintained.","Structured: Organized into a defined dataset with relationships",null,"Structured: Organized into a defined dataset with relationships"]
[null,"Item, Disconnected","An item that exists as an isolated artifact without managed relationships to other lifecycle information or governance within lifecycle management systems.","Isolated, Exists without relationships or governance",null,"Isolated, Exists without relationships or governance"]
[null,"Item, End","A discrete deliverable unit of a product, usually serialized or lot-tracked, delivered to a customer.","[ASME Y14.24-2020, End Product (End Item)] an item, such as an individual part or assembly, in its final or completed state."]
[null,"Item, Grouped","An item stored together with related artifacts within a shared location or collection but without structured relationships or lifecycle governance.","Co-located: Stored together with related artifacts",null,"Co-located: Stored together with related artifacts"]
[null,"Item, Managed","An item controlled within a managed system that governs its identification, versioning, relationships, and lifecycle state.","Controlled: Governed within lifecycle management systems",null,"Controlled: Governed within lifecycle management systems"]
[null,"Item, Published","A managed item that has been made available to defined stakeholders or lifecycle activities through controlled access mechanisms.","Accessible: Made available to defined stakeholders ",null,"Accessible: Made available to defined stakeholders "]
[null,"Item, Released","A managed item that has been formally approved and issued under configuration management for controlled dissemination and operational use.","Approved: Approved and issued for operational use ",null,"Approved: Approved and issued for operational use "]
[null,"Item State","The condition of an item that reflects the level of organization, lifecycle governance, accessibility, authority, and trust applied to the item within lifecycle management processes.","Item States progress from unmanaged states of Disconnected, to organized states of Grouped & Collected, to governed states of Managed, & Published, and to trusted states of Authorized, & Certified.",null,"Item states progresses from unmanaged states of disconnected, to organized states of grouped & collected, to governed states of managed, & published, and trusted states of authorized, & certified."]
[null,"Lifecycle","See product lifecycle."]
[null,"Lifecycle Activity","An activity related to a product lifecycle."]
["LOTAR","Long Term Archiving and Retrieval","A capability that preserves information and makes it available for communities of interest."]
[null,"Manifest (Artifact)","A structured artifact that enumerates and identifies the contents of a dataset or data package."]
[null,"Maturity level","In the MBE Maturity Index, a state of maturity that contains a set of assertions."]
[null,"Metadata","A set of attributes that describes and gives context about other data."]
[null,"Metrology","A discipline that is concerned with the science of measurement."]
[null,"MBE Maturity Index","A tool that an organization uses to assess itself as, and facilitate transition to, a model-based enterprise."]
[null,"Model","A digital representation of a thing.","[DoDI 5000.70, Model] A physical, mathematical, or otherwise logical representation of a system, entity, phenomenon, or process."]
[null,"Model, 3D","A three-dimensional spatial model."]
[null,"Model, 3D CAD ","3D model of a physical item that is generated using drafting and design software."]
[null,"Model, Authorized ","A model approved by an authority for use in a lifecycle activity.",null,null,"Note: An Authorized Model could be native or derivative, 3D or MBD."]
[null,"Model, Basis ","The model that a practitioner uses as the starting point for a given lifecycle activity.",null,null,"Note: A Basis Model could be authorized or courtesy, native or derivative, 3D or MBD, "]
[null,"Model, Courtesy ","An unauthorized model provided to a recipient.",null,null,"Note: A Courtesy Model could be native or derivative, 3D or MBD."]
[null,"Model, Data","A conceptual representation and formal diagram of a data elements, their relationships, and the constraints that govern them."]
[null,"Model, Derivative","A model created from a source model that may be transformed into a different format. (See derivative and model)"]
[null,"Model, Final-Process","The final process model for a process definition."]
[null,"Model, Inheritance","A derivative model with one-way associative propagation of source model changes."]
[null,"Model, In-Process","The intermediate process model(s) with a process definition."]
[null,"Model, MBD","A 3D model that requires semantic PMI, and structured data attributes. (See MBD and model)","[ASME Y14.47-2023, Model-Based Definition (MBD)] an annotated model and its associated data that define the product in a manner that can be used effectively without a drawing graphic sheet. "]
[null,"Model, Native ","A model in the format of its originating software application."]
[null,"Model, Process","A model that defines or represents one or more states of a production process."]
[null,"Model, Source ","The model from which a derivative is created from. (See source and model)",null,null,"Note: A Source Model could be native or derivative, 3D or MBD."]
[null,"Model, Spatial","A model that represents geometric and/or spatial relationships."]
[null,"Model, Start-Process","The initial process model for a process definition."]
[null,"Model, Support","A model provided as complementary to a primary artifact. (See support and model)",null,null,"Note: A Support Model could be native or derivative, 3D or MBD."]
[null,"Model, System","A logical model of interconnected structures, behaviors, parametrics, and/or requirements of a system."]
[null,"Model, Trusted ","A model that is governed, validated, and accepted as authoritative for its intended use.  (See trusted and model)"]
["MBD","Model-Based Definition","A 3D model that requires semantic PMI and structured data attributes.","[ANSI Y14.41, annotated model] A model and its associated data elements that define the product in a manner that can be used effectively without a drawing graphic sheet."]
["MBE","Model-Based Enterprise","A digital enterprise that uses digital models and associated datasets as the foundation for the product lifecycle.","[ASME Y14.47-2023, Model-Based Enterprise] an organization that uses digital methodologies as the foundation to enable deployment of products from concept to disposal."]
["MBSE","Model-Based Systems Engineering","A method of system engineering that is based on models."]
[null,"Mode-of-Operation","The manner in which a lifecycle activity is initiated and executed, indicating the degree of human involvement and system automation used to perform the task. ",null,null,"Lower modes of operation are typically human-initiated and manually executed, while higher modes increasingly rely on system-initiated and automated execution."]
[null,"Mode-of-Operation, Ad hoc","A mode-of-operation performed in an informal or unstructured manner without defined procedures, repeatability, or system support.",null,null,"Spontaneous work"]
[null,"Mode-of-Operation, Automated","A mode-of-operation fully initiated and executed by systems without routine human intervention, governed by defined policies, workflows, or system logic.",null,null,"Autonomous system execution"]
[null,"Mode-of-Operation, Interactive","A mode-of-operation initiated by a human operator and performed through direct interaction with software tools that assist in executing the task.",null,null,"Tool-assisted work"]
[null,"Mode-of-Operation, Manual","A mode-of-operation initiated and performed entirely by human operators using manual procedures with minimal system assistance.",null,null,"Structured but human driven"]
[null,"Mode-of-Operation, On-demand","A mode-of-operation initiated by a human operator that triggers an automated or system-executed process when needed.",null,null,"Human-triggered automation"]
[null,"Mode-of-Operation, Semi-Automated","A mode-of-operation in which portions of the process are executed automatically by systems while other steps require human intervention, approval, or oversight.",null,null,"Mixed human/system execution"]
[null,"Mode-of-Operation, Scheduled","A mode-of-operation automatically initiated and executed by systems according to defined schedules, events, or workflow conditions",null,null,"System-triggered automation"]
[null,"Modeling, Direct","A modeling method that allows designers to interact directly with the geometry of the model. "]
[null,"Modeling, Parametric","A modeling process with the ability to change the shape of model geometry as soon as the dimension value is modified."]
[null,"Object","An identifiable informational element representing a business concept, which has state, data, and associated operations."]
[null,"Organization","An autonomous group of people who work together for a common purpose of activities."]
[null,"Organization, Extended","An organization outside of the Enterprise (e.g., supplier, customer) but coordinated with."]
[null,"Organization, Peer","An organization that is of equal standing with the OUA under the same Supra-Organization."]
[null,"Organization, Supra","An organization that is hierarchically above the OUA and Peer-Organizations."]
["OUA","Organization Under Assessment","The organization that is the subject of this assessment."]
["OCM","Organizational Change Management","The mechanisms that integrate change and the ability to adapt change within an organization."]
[null,"Part","A definable item with a unique identifier.","[ASME Y14.100-2017, Part] one item, or two or more items joined together, that is not normally subject to disassembly without destruction or impairment of designed use, e.g., transistor, composition resistor, screw, transformer, and gear."]
[null,"Part-Centric","An organizing principle that enables product data management to relate all product lifecycle data to a single point of reference."]
[null,"PDM System","An information system that implements product data management.","[ASME Y14.34 - 2018, Product Data Management (PDM) System] an automated database system for managing the creation, change, and archive of all information related to a product. PDM facilitates the retrieval, review, approval, release, and control of product definition data.  "]
[null,"Precise","Describes a result that has sufficient decision precision."]
[null,"Presentation","See \"Specialized Definition\"","[ASME Y14.47 - 2019, Presentation] The manner in which information is displayed for use by a human."]
[null,"Process, Production","Activity that contributes to realizing a product. "]
[null,"Process Definition, Production","Engineering information that defines a production or procurement process that contributes to realizing a product."]
[null,"Product","A complete item intended to fulfill customer requirements.","[ASME Y14.100-2017, Product] includes materials, parts, components, subassemblies, assemblies, and equipment. The term product wherever used in this document shall also encompass a family of products.  "]
["PMI","Product and Manufacturing Information","The data, often presented as annotations within a 3D model, which support various lifecycle activities."]
[null,"PMI, Semantic","PMI that is structured data and associates with digital elements on a MBD model."]
["PDM","Product Data Management","A capability that manages, controls, and interrelates  product data.",null,null,"PDM usage is frequently confined to the design stage of product development, although may extend to planning for manufacture.\n"]
[null,"Product Definition","Any information that defines the physical or functional characteristics of a product, to ensure design intent."]
[null,"Product Definition Archive","An information system that stores record copies (44 U.S.C. 3301) of product definition for their long-term archive and retrieval."]
[null,"Product Definition Authorization","The record of transmittal and supporting procedures that authorize product definition for a lifecycle activity."]
[null,"Product Lifecycle","A series of stages through which a product passes during its lifetime."]
[null,"Product Lifecycle Data","See product data."]
["PLM","Product Lifecycle Management","A PDM that extends the scope to include all product lifecycle activities (e.g., design, manufacturing, quality)."]
[null,"Product Realization","The comprehensive process of transforming a product from initial concept to a final, deliverable item that meets customer requirements.","[ISO 9001: 2000, Product Realization] the work that the organization goes through to develop, manufacture, and deliver the finished goods or services"]
["PRA","Product Requirement Association","An optional augmentation applied to a Product Characteristic (PC) that relates a product requirement that is satisfied by this characteristic.","[DMSC:MBC v1.0, Product Requirement Association] a characteristic augmentation that optionally relates a product requirement to a characteristic"]
[null,"Product Structure","A hierarchical list of items that constitute a product."]
[null,"Promotion","A behavior of PLM that transitions an artifact to the next lifecycle state."]
[null,"Provenance, Data","The lineage that validates the authenticity and/or quality of data."]
["QIF","Quality Information Framework","An American and International open-standard for computer-interpretable model-based definition and product quality information.","[ANSI/DMSC QIF 3.0 - 2018, Quality Information Framework]  A standard which enable the effective exchange of metrology data throughout the entire manufacturing quality measurement process - from product design to inspection planning to execution to analysis and reporting. "]
["QVA","Quality Visual Aid","A human-readable drawing used to communicate information clearly and quickly, particularly in the context of improving product quality."]
[null,"Representation","See \"Specialized Definition\"","[ASME Y14.47 - 2019, Representation] The manner in which information is stored for interpretation by a machine."]
[null,"Requirement, Customer","A source requirement that addresses a customer's expectations for the functionality, performance, and quality of a product being developed."]
[null,"Requirement, Product","A derived requirement that addresses a product's purpose, features, functionalities, and behavior that traces to customer requirements and informs product definition."]
[null,"Schema","A framework or concept that helps organize and interpret related information."]
[null,"Source of Truth","The single authoritative source that contains the original information item."]
[null,"Source","The artifact from which a derivative is created."]
[null,"Supplier","An organization selling materials, parts, components, apparatus, or services."]
[null,"Support","An artifact provided as complementary to a primary artifact."]
[null,"System","See \"Specialized Definition\"","[INCOSE, System ] an arrangement of parts or elements that together exhibit behavior or meaning that the individual constituents do not."]
[null,"System Model, Production Process Definition","A system model that encapsulates a product's production process definition."]
[null,"System Model, Product Definition","A system model that encapsulates a product's design and its product definition."]
[null,"Tag","See \"Specialized Definition\"","[DMSC MBC v1.0, Tag] a digital element identifier used as a human-readable identifier, unique within a local context."]
[null,"Tag, Characteristic","See \"Specialized Definition\"","DMSC MBC v1.0, Tag, Characteristic] a tag used for a characteristic (e.g., product characteristic)"]
[null,"Topic","In the MBE Maturity Index, an activity within a category that contains facets and can be assessed for future state."]
[null,"Traceability","The ability to traverse the digital thread to and from its source of truth."]
[null,"Trusted","Regarded with confidence for its intended use, typically through certification, authorization, and authentication."]
[null,"Unambiguous","Resolves to the intended interpretation."]
["UUID","Universal Unique Identifier","See \"Specialized Definition\"","[DMSC MBC v1.0, UUID] a digital element identifier used as a persistent machine-readable universally unique identifier. The UUID should be generated according to the ISO/IEC 9834-8 standard."]
[null,"UUID, Characteristic","A UUID used for a characteristic (e.g., product characteristic)"]
[null,"Validated","Assured to satisfy intent."]
[null,"Validation","An activity that assures that a product satisfies intent."]
[null,"Verification","An activity that assures that a product satisfies requirements."]
["VPR","Verification Plan Requirement","An optional augmentation applied to a Product Characteristic (PC) that identifies a verification method, context, and/or sampling plan used to assure that this characteristic is verified. ","[DMSC:MBC v1.0, Verification Plan Requirement] a characteristic augmentation that optionally relates a verification plan requirement to the characteristic"]
[null,"Verified","Assured to satisfy requirements."]
[null,"Write-back","The ability to update and save data from a source back to the original data store"]
[]
[null,"Note: The Term and/or Definition with a cell background filled as \"light green\" was new or changed within this version."]
[null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!C175","v":"NSC-614-7804 dated 20260218 Unclassified Unlimited Release (UUR)"}]

{"sheet":"Assessment Charts","index":4,"n_rows":125,"n_cols":1,"rows_kept":125,"cut":false,"hidden":false,"merged":[]}
["Model-Based Enterprise"]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[{"$f":"'Score Summary'!A9","v":"C1: Product Design Activities"}]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[{"$f":"'Score Summary'!A18","v":"C2: Product Data/Lifecycle Management Activities"}]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[{"$f":"'Score Summary'!A27","v":"C3: Product Manufacturing Activities"}]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[{"$f":"'Score Summary'!A36","v":"C4: Product Quality Activities "}]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[{"$f":"'Score Summary'!A45","v":"C5: Enterprise Enabling Activities"}]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!C175","v":"NSC-614-7804 dated 20260218 Unclassified Unlimited Release (UUR)"}]

{"sheet":"Score Summary","index":5,"n_rows":176,"n_cols":22,"rows_kept":176,"cut":false,"hidden":false,"merged":[[0,19,0,21]]}
["Do Not Modify - Used for Radar Charts",null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,"Score Summary by Facet",null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,"Score Gaps"]
["MBE","Category",null,"Max Scale","Target","Capability","Readiness","Adoption",null,null,"MBE Category",null,null,null,"Capability","Readiness","Adoption","Target",null,"C-R","R-A","T-A"]
[null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!A7","v":"C1: Product Design Activities"},null,6,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S7","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P7","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q7","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R7","v":"N/A"},null,null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!A7","v":"C1: Product Design Activities"},null,null,{"$f":"F3","v":"N/A"},"N/A","N/A",{"$f":"E3","v":"N/A"},null,{"$f":"O3-P3","v":{"$error":"#VALUE!"}},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$f":"R3-Q3","v":{"$error":"#VALUE!"}}]
[null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!A41","v":"C2: Product Data/Lifecycle Management Activities"},null,6,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S41","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P41","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q41","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R41","v":"N/A"},null,null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!A41","v":"C2: Product Data/Lifecycle Management Activities"},null,null,"N/A","N/A","N/A",{"$f":"E4","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$f":"R4-Q4","v":{"$error":"#VALUE!"}}]
[null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!A74","v":"C3: Product Manufacturing Activities"},null,6,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S74","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P74","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q74","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R74","v":"N/A"},null,null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!A74","v":"C3: Product Manufacturing Activities"},null,null,"N/A","N/A","N/A",{"$f":"E5","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$f":"R5-Q5","v":{"$error":"#VALUE!"}}]
[null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!A108","v":"C4: Product Quality Activities "},null,6,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S108","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P108","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q108","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R108","v":"N/A"},null,null,null,{"$f":"$B$6","v":"C4: Product Quality Activities "},null,null,"N/A","N/A","N/A",{"$f":"E6","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$f":"R6-Q6","v":{"$error":"#VALUE!"}}]
[null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!A139","v":"C5: Enterprise Enabling Activities"},null,6,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S139","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P139","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q139","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R139","v":"N/A"},null,null,null,{"$f":"$B$7","v":"C5: Enterprise Enabling Activities"},null,null,"N/A","N/A","N/A",{"$f":"E7","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$f":"R7-Q7","v":{"$error":"#VALUE!"}}]
[]
[{"$f":"B3","v":"C1: Product Design Activities"},null,null,"Max Scale","Target","Capability","Readiness","Adoption",null,null,{"$f":"L3","v":"C1: Product Design Activities"},null,null,null,"Capability","Readiness","Adoption","Target",null,"C-R","R-A","T-A"]
[null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!B8","v":"T1: Product Definition Authorization"},null,6,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S8","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P8","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q8","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R8","v":"N/A"},null,null,null,{"$f":"B10","v":"T1: Product Definition Authorization"},null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P8","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q8","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R8","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S8","v":"N/A"},null,{"$f":"O10-P10","v":{"$error":"#VALUE!"}},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$f":"R10-Q10","v":{"$error":"#VALUE!"}}]
[null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!B10","v":"T2: Product Requirements Association"},null,6,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S10","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P10","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q10","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R10","v":"N/A"},null,null,null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!C9","v":"F1: Authorized Product Definition"},null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P9","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q9","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R9","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S9","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!B13","v":"T3: Product Description"},null,6,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S13","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P13","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q13","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R13","v":"N/A"},null,null,null,{"$f":"B11","v":"T2: Product Requirements Association"},null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P10","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q10","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R10","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S10","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!B19","v":"T4: Model Quality & Certification"},null,6,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S19","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P19","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q19","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R19","v":"N/A"},null,null,null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!C11","v":"F1: Form"},null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P11","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q11","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R11","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S11","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!B23","v":"T5: Model Derivatives"},null,6,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S23","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P23","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q23","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R23","v":"N/A"},null,null,null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!C12","v":"F2: Associativity"},null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P12","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q12","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R12","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S12","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!B30","v":"T6: ECAD/MCAD Collaboration"},null,6,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S30","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P30","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q30","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R30","v":"N/A"},null,null,null,{"$f":"B12","v":"T3: Product Description"},null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P13","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q13","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R13","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S13","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!B34","v":"T7: Design Analysis & Simulation "},null,6,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S34","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P34","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q34","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R34","v":"N/A"},null,null,null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!C14","v":"F1: Shape Definition"},null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P14","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q14","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R14","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S14","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!C15","v":"F2: Non-Shape Information"},null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P15","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q15","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R15","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S15","v":"N/A"},null,{"$f":"O17-P17","v":{"$error":"#VALUE!"}},{"$f":"P17-Q17","v":{"$error":"#VALUE!"}},{"$f":"R17-Q17","v":{"$error":"#VALUE!"}}]
[{"$f":"B4","v":"C2: Product Data/Lifecycle Management Activities"},null,null,"Max Scale","Target","Capability","Readiness","Adoption",null,null,null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!C16","v":"F3: Metadata"},null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P16","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q16","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R16","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S16","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!B42","v":"T1: Product Definition Authority"},null,6,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S42","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P42","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q42","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R42","v":"N/A"},null,null,null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!C17","v":"F4: Presentation Views"},null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P17","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q17","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R17","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S17","v":"N/A"},null,{"$f":"O19-P19","v":{"$error":"#VALUE!"}},{"$f":"P19-Q19","v":{"$error":"#VALUE!"}},{"$f":"R19-Q19","v":{"$error":"#VALUE!"}}]
[null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!B45","v":"T2: Data Management Approach"},null,6,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S45","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P45","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q45","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R45","v":"N/A"},null,null,null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!C18","v":"F5: Tolerancing Scheme"},null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P18","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q18","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R18","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S18","v":"N/A"},null,{"$f":"O20-P20","v":{"$error":"#VALUE!"}},{"$f":"P20-Q20","v":{"$error":"#VALUE!"}},{"$f":"R20-Q20","v":{"$error":"#VALUE!"}}]
[null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!B53","v":"T3: Product Definition Management"},null,6,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S53","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P53","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q53","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R53","v":"N/A"},null,null,null,{"$f":"B13","v":"T4: Model Quality & Certification"},null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P19","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q19","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R19","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S19","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!B57","v":"T4: Production Process Data Management"},null,6,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S57","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P57","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q57","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R57","v":"N/A"},null,null,null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!C20","v":"F1: Verification"},null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P20","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q20","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R20","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S20","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!B61","v":"T5: Bill of Materials (BoM) Management"},null,6,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S61","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P61","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q61","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R61","v":"N/A"},null,null,null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!C21","v":"F2: Verification Mode-of-Operation"},null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P21","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q21","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R21","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S21","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!B65","v":"T6: Common Digital Libraries"},null,6,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S65","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P65","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q65","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R65","v":"N/A"},null,null,null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!C22","v":"F3: Certified"},null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P22","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q22","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R22","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S22","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!B70","v":"T7: Data Records"},null,6,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S70","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P70","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q70","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R70","v":"N/A"},null,null,null,{"$f":"B14","v":"T5: Model Derivatives"},null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P23","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q23","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R23","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S23","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!C24","v":"F1: Content"},null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P24","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q24","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R24","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S24","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[{"$f":"B5","v":"C3: Product Manufacturing Activities"},null,null,"Max Scale","Target","Capability","Readiness","Adoption",null,null,null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!C25","v":"F2: Authoring Mode-of-Operation"},null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P25","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q25","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R25","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S25","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!B75","v":"T1: Manufacturing Process Definition"},null,6,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S75","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P75","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q75","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R75","v":"N/A"},null,null,null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!C26","v":"F3: Validation & Certification Mode-of-Operation"},null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P26","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q26","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R26","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S26","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!B80","v":"T2: Tooling Definition & Realization"},null,6,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S80","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P80","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q80","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R80","v":"N/A"},null,null,null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!C27","v":"F4: Traceability"},null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P27","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q27","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R27","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S27","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!B84","v":"T3: Manufacturing Process Instructions "},null,6,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S84","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P84","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q84","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R84","v":"N/A"},null,null,null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!C28","v":"F5: Managed"},null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P28","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q28","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R28","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S28","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!B88","v":"T4: Manufacturing Numeric Control Code"},null,6,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S88","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P88","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q88","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R88","v":"N/A"},null,null,null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!C29","v":"F6: Viewables"},null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P29","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q29","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R29","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S29","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!B93","v":"T5: Manufacturing Analysis & Simulation"},null,6,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S93","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P93","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q93","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R93","v":"N/A"},null,null,null,{"$f":"B15","v":"T6: ECAD/MCAD Collaboration"},null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P30","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q30","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R30","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S30","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!B99","v":"T6: Manufacturing Operations "},null,6,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S99","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P99","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q99","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R99","v":"N/A"},null,null,null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!C31","v":"F1: Condition"},null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P31","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q31","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R31","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S31","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!B102","v":"T7: Product-Related Procurement "},null,6,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S102","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P102","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q102","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R102","v":"N/A"},null,null,null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!C32","v":"F2: Mode"},null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P32","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q32","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R32","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S32","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!C33","v":"F3: Commonality"},null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P33","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q33","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R33","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S33","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[{"$f":"B6","v":"C4: Product Quality Activities "},null,null,"Max Scale","Target","Capability","Readiness","Adoption",null,null,null,{"$f":"B16","v":"T7: Design Analysis & Simulation "},null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P34","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q34","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R34","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S34","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!B109","v":"T1: Quality Process Definition"},null,6,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S109","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P109","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q109","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R109","v":"N/A"},null,null,null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!C35","v":"F1: Basis Model Source"},null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P35","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q35","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R35","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S35","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!B114","v":"T2: Product Characteristics & BoC"},null,6,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S114","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P114","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q114","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R114","v":"N/A"},null,null,null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!C36","v":"F2: Analysis Model Authoring Mode-of-Operation"},null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P36","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q36","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R36","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S36","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!B118","v":"T3: Quality Process Instructions"},null,6,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S118","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P118","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q118","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R118","v":"N/A"},null,null,null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!C37","v":"F3: Managed"},null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P37","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q37","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R37","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S37","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!B122","v":"T4: Inspection Numeric Control Code"},null,6,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S122","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P122","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q122","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R122","v":"N/A"},null,null,null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!C38","v":"F4: Influence"},null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P38","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q38","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R38","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S38","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!B127","v":"T5: Quality Results Management & Analysis"},null,6,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S127","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P127","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q127","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R127","v":"N/A"},null,null,null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!C39","v":"F5: Traceability"},null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P39","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q39","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R39","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S39","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!B131","v":"T6: Test Equipment Definition & Realization"},null,6,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S131","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P131","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q131","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R131","v":"N/A"}]
[null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!B135","v":"T7: Inspection Operations"},null,6,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S135","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P135","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q135","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R135","v":"N/A"},null,null,{"$f":"L4","v":"C2: Product Data/Lifecycle Management Activities"},null,null,null,"Capability","Readiness","Adoption","Target",null,"C-R","R-A","T-A"]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"B19","v":"T1: Product Definition Authority"},null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P42","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q42","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R42","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S42","v":"N/A"},null,{"$f":"O44-P44","v":{"$error":"#VALUE!"}},{"$f":"P44-Q44","v":{"$error":"#VALUE!"}},{"$f":"R44-Q44","v":{"$error":"#VALUE!"}}]
[{"$f":"B7","v":"C5: Enterprise Enabling Activities"},null,null,"Max Scale","Target","Capability","Readiness","Adoption",null,null,null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!C43","v":"F1: Part-Centricity "},null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P43","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q43","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R43","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S43","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!B140","v":"T1: Product Work Collaboration"},null,6,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S140","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P140","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q140","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R140","v":"N/A"},null,null,null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!C44","v":"F2: Associativity"},null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P44","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q44","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R44","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S44","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!B143","v":"T2: MBE Governance"},null,6,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S143","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P143","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q143","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R143","v":"N/A"},null,null,null,{"$f":"B20","v":"T2: Data Management Approach"},null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P45","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q45","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R45","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S45","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!B147","v":"T3: MBE People"},null,6,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S147","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P147","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q147","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R147","v":"N/A"},null,null,null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!C46","v":"F1: Content Management Scope"},null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P46","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q46","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R46","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S46","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!B152","v":"T4: MBE Process"},null,6,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S152","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P152","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q152","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R152","v":"N/A"},null,null,null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!C47","v":"F2: Change Management"},null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P47","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q47","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R47","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S47","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!B158","v":"T5: MBE Technology"},null,6,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S158","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P158","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q158","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R158","v":"N/A"},null,null,null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!C48","v":"F3: Product Structure Management"},null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P48","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q48","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R48","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S48","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!B164","v":"T6: MBE Information Assurance"},null,6,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S164","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P164","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q164","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R164","v":"N/A"},null,null,null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!C49","v":"F4: User Interface Applications"},null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P49","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q49","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R49","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S49","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!B171","v":"T7: MBE Financials"},null,6,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S171","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P171","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q171","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R171","v":"N/A"},null,null,null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!C50","v":"F5: Data Governance"},null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P50","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q50","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R50","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S50","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!C52","v":"F7: Change Control "},null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P52","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q52","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R52","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S52","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
["Do Not Modify - Used for Radar Charts",null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"B21","v":"T3: Product Definition Management"},null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P53","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q53","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R53","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S53","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!C54","v":"F1: Product Definition Set "},null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P54","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q54","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R54","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S54","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!C55","v":"F2: Supplemental Data Reference"},null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P55","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q55","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R55","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S55","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!C56","v":"F3: Product Definition Authorization"},null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P56","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q56","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R56","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S56","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"B22","v":"T4: Production Process Data Management"},null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P57","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q57","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R57","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S57","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!C58","v":"F1: Product Definition Association"},null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P58","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q58","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R58","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S58","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!C59","v":"F2: Definition Set"},null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P59","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q59","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R59","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S59","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!C60","v":"F3: Supplemental Data Reference"},null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P60","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q60","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R60","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S60","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"B23","v":"T5: Bill of Materials (BoM) Management"},null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P61","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q61","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R61","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S61","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!C62","v":"F1: Authoring"},null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P62","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q62","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R62","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S62","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!C63","v":"F2: Managed"},null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P63","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q63","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R63","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S63","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!C64","v":"F3: Traceability"},null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P64","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q64","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R64","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S64","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"B24","v":"T6: Common Digital Libraries"},null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P65","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q65","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R65","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S65","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!C66","v":"F1: Extent"},null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P66","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q66","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R66","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S66","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!C67","v":"F2: Library Governance"},null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P67","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q67","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R67","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S67","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!C68","v":"F3: Managed"},null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P68","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q68","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R68","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S68","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!C69","v":"F4: Access"},null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P69","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q69","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R69","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S69","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"B25","v":"T7: Data Records"},null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P70","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q70","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R70","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S70","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!C71","v":"F1: Long Term Archival & Retrieval (LOTAR)"},null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P71","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q71","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R71","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S71","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!C72","v":"F2: Data Package"},null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P72","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q72","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R72","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S72","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"L5","v":"C3: Product Manufacturing Activities"},null,null,null,"Capability","Readiness","Adoption","Target",null,"C-R","R-A","T-A"]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"B28","v":"T1: Manufacturing Process Definition"},null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P75","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q75","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R75","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S75","v":"N/A"},null,{"$f":"O76-P76","v":{"$error":"#VALUE!"}},{"$f":"P76-Q76","v":{"$error":"#VALUE!"}},{"$f":"R76-Q76","v":{"$error":"#VALUE!"}}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!C76","v":"F1: Product Definition Source"},null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P76","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q76","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R76","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S76","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!C77","v":"F2: Method"},null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P77","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q77","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R77","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S77","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!C78","v":"F3: Managed"},null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P78","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q78","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R78","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S78","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!C79","v":"F4: Response to Change"},null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P79","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q79","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R79","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S79","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"B29","v":"T2: Tooling Definition & Realization"},null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P80","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q80","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R80","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S80","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!C81","v":"F1: Basis"},null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P81","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q81","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R81","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S81","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!C82","v":"F2: Managed"},null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P82","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q82","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R82","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S82","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!C83","v":"F3: Traceability"},null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P83","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q83","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R83","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S83","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"B30","v":"T3: Manufacturing Process Instructions "},null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P84","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q84","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R84","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S84","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!C85","v":"F1: Method"},null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P85","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q85","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R85","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S85","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!C86","v":"F2: Managed"},null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P86","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q86","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R86","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S86","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!C87","v":"F3: Response to Change"},null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P87","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q87","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R87","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S87","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"B31","v":"T4: Manufacturing Numeric Control Code"},null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P88","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q88","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R88","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S88","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!C89","v":"F1: Basis Model Source "},null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P89","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q89","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R89","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S89","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!C90","v":"F2: Method"},null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P90","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q90","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R90","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S90","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!C91","v":"F3: Managed"},null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P91","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q91","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R91","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S91","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!C92","v":"F4: Response to Change"},null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P92","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q92","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R92","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S92","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"B32","v":"T5: Manufacturing Analysis & Simulation"},null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P93","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q93","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R93","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S93","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!C94","v":"F1: Basis Model Source"},null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P94","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q94","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R94","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S94","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!C95","v":"F2: Analysis Model Authoring Mode-of-Operation"},null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P95","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q95","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R95","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S95","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!C96","v":"F3: Managed"},null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P96","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q96","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R96","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S96","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!C97","v":"F4: Influence"},null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P97","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q97","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R97","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S97","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!C98","v":"F5: Traceability"},null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P98","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q98","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R98","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S98","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"B33","v":"T6: Manufacturing Operations "},null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P99","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q99","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R99","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S99","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!C100","v":"F1: Basis Model Reference"},null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P100","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q100","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R100","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S100","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!C101","v":"F2: Presentation"},null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P101","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q101","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R101","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S101","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"B34","v":"T7: Product-Related Procurement "},null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P102","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q102","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R102","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S102","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!C103","v":"F1: Content"},null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P103","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q103","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R103","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S103","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!C104","v":"F2: Managed"},null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P104","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q104","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R104","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S104","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!C105","v":"F3: Response to Change"},null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P105","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q105","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R105","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S105","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!C106","v":"F4: Delivery"},null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P106","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q106","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R106","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S106","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"L6","v":"C4: Product Quality Activities "},null,null,null,"Capability","Readiness","Adoption","Target",null,"C-R","R-A","T-A"]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"B37","v":"T1: Quality Process Definition"},null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P109","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q109","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R109","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S109","v":"N/A"},null,{"$f":"O110-P110","v":{"$error":"#VALUE!"}},{"$f":"P110-Q110","v":{"$error":"#VALUE!"}},{"$f":"R110-Q110","v":{"$error":"#VALUE!"}}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!C110","v":"F1: Product Definition Source"},null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P110","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q110","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R110","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S110","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!C111","v":"F2: Method"},null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P111","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q111","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R111","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S111","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!C112","v":"F3: Managed"},null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P112","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q112","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R112","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S112","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!C113","v":"F4: Response to Change"},null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P113","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q113","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R113","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S113","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"B38","v":"T2: Product Characteristics & BoC"},null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P114","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q114","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R114","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S114","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!C115","v":"F1: Method"},null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P115","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q115","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R115","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S115","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!C116","v":"F2: Managed"},null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P116","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q116","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R116","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S116","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!C117","v":"F3: Traceability"},null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P117","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q117","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R117","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S117","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"B39","v":"T3: Quality Process Instructions"},null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P118","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q118","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R118","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S118","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!C119","v":"F1: Method"},null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P119","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q119","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R119","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S119","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!C120","v":"F2: Managed"},null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P120","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q120","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R120","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S120","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!C121","v":"F3: Response to Change"},null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P121","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q121","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R121","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S121","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"B40","v":"T4: Inspection Numeric Control Code"},null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P122","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q122","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R122","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S122","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!C123","v":"F1: Product Definition Source"},null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P123","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q123","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R123","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S123","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!C124","v":"F2: Method"},null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P124","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q124","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R124","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S124","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!C125","v":"F3: Managed"},null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P125","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q125","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R125","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S125","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!C126","v":"F4: Response to change"},null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P126","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q126","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R126","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S126","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"B41","v":"T5: Quality Results Management & Analysis"},null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P127","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q127","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R127","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S127","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!C128","v":"F1: Managed"},null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P128","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q128","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R128","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S128","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!C129","v":"F2: Traceability (Serialization)"},null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P129","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q129","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R129","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S129","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!C130","v":"F3: Reporting"},null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P130","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q130","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R130","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S130","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"B42","v":"T6: Test Equipment Definition & Realization"},null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P131","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q131","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R131","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S131","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!C132","v":"F1: Basis"},null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P132","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q132","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R132","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S132","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!C133","v":"F2: Managed"},null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P133","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q133","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R133","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S133","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!C134","v":"F3: Traceability"},null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P134","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q134","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R134","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S134","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"B43","v":"T7: Inspection Operations"},null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P135","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q135","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R135","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S135","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!C136","v":"F1: Product Definition Reference"},null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P136","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q136","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R136","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S136","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!C137","v":"F2: Presentation"},null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P137","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q137","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R137","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S137","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"L7","v":"C5: Enterprise Enabling Activities"},null,null,null,"Capability","Readiness","Adoption","Target",null,"C-R","R-A","T-A"]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"B46","v":"T1: Product Work Collaboration"},null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P140","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q140","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R140","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S140","v":"N/A"},null,{"$f":"O141-P141","v":{"$error":"#VALUE!"}},{"$f":"P141-Q141","v":{"$error":"#VALUE!"}},{"$f":"R141-Q141","v":{"$error":"#VALUE!"}}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!C141","v":"F1: Actors"},null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P141","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q141","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R141","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S141","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!C142","v":"F2:Methods"},null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P142","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q142","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R142","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S142","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"B47","v":"T2: MBE Governance"},null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P143","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q143","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R143","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S143","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!C144","v":"F1: Leadership"},null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P144","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q144","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R144","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S144","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!C145","v":"F2: Structure"},null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P145","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q145","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R145","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S145","v":"N/A"},null,{"$f":"O146-P146","v":{"$error":"#VALUE!"}},{"$f":"P146-Q146","v":{"$error":"#VALUE!"}},{"$f":"R146-Q146","v":{"$error":"#VALUE!"}}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!C146","v":"F3: Commitment to Change"},null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P146","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q146","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R146","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S146","v":"N/A"},null,{"$f":"O147-P147","v":{"$error":"#VALUE!"}},{"$f":"P147-Q147","v":{"$error":"#VALUE!"}},{"$f":"R147-Q147","v":{"$error":"#VALUE!"}}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"B48","v":"T3: MBE People"},null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P147","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q147","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R147","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S147","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!C148","v":"F1: Training"},null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P148","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q148","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R148","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S148","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!C149","v":"F2: Support"},null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P149","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q149","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R149","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S149","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!C150","v":"F3: Certified Roles"},null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P150","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q150","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R150","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S150","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!C151","v":"F4: Awareness"},null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P151","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q151","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R151","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S151","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"B49","v":"T4: MBE Process"},null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P152","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q152","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R152","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S152","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!C153","v":"F1: Business Policies"},null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P153","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q153","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R153","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S153","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!C154","v":"F2: Repeatable (Documented)"},null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P154","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q154","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R154","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S154","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!C155","v":"F3: Governance Scope"},null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P155","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q155","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R155","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S155","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!C156","v":"F4: Optimize"},null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P156","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q156","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R156","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S156","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!C157","v":"F5: Industry Standard"},null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P157","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q157","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R157","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S157","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"B50","v":"T5: MBE Technology"},null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P158","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q158","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R158","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S158","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!C159","v":"F1: Standardized"},null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P159","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q159","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R159","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S159","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!C160","v":"F2: Integrated"},null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P160","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q160","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R160","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S160","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!C161","v":"F3: Verification & Validation"},null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P161","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q161","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R161","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S161","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!C162","v":"F4: Maintained"},null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P162","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q162","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R162","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S162","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!C163","v":"F5: Tool Availability"},null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P163","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q163","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R163","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S163","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"B51","v":"T6: MBE Information Assurance"},null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P164","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q164","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R164","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S164","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!C165","v":"F1: Authenticated"},null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P165","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q165","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R165","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S165","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!C166","v":"F2: Accessibility"},null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P166","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q166","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R166","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S166","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!C167","v":"F3: Confidentiality"},null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P167","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q167","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R167","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S167","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!C168","v":"F4: Governance of Access Control"},null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P168","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q168","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R168","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S168","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!C169","v":"F5: Data State & Stewardship"},null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P169","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q169","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R169","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S169","v":"N/A"},null,{"$f":"O170-P170","v":{"$error":"#VALUE!"}},{"$f":"P170-Q170","v":{"$error":"#VALUE!"}},{"$f":"R170-Q170","v":{"$error":"#VALUE!"}}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!C170","v":"F6: Cybersecurity"},null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P170","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q170","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R170","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S170","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"B52","v":"T7: MBE Financials"},null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P171","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q171","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R171","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S171","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!C172","v":"F1: Mechanism"},null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P172","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q172","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R172","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S172","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!C173","v":"F2: Continuity"},null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P173","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q173","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R173","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S173","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[]
[null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!C175","v":"NSC-614-7804 dated 20260218 Unclassified Unlimited Release (UUR)"}]

{"sheet":"Peer Comments","index":6,"n_rows":83,"n_cols":9,"rows_kept":83,"cut":false,"hidden":false,"merged":[]}
["Peer Reviewer:","[peer reviewers name]",null,null,null,null,null,"MBE Maturity Index Task Group "]
["Comment ID","Comment","Worksheet","Cell in Index\n(e.g., C1; T3; F1; L5)","Source","Date",null,"Response","Date"]
[1,"Many people ask, what is supplemental data in C2:T4:F3?","MBE Lexicon","C2:T4:F3","Sarah Hale",20220131,null,"Added \"Data, Supplemental\" with definition to MBE Lexicon",20220314]
[2,"In contrast to a duplicate copy from one disconnected systems to another, need a term (e.g., \"controlled copy\") that addresses the coping of a digital artifact from an authoritative source with  provenance. ","MBE Lexicon",null,"Curtis Brown",20220228,null,"Added \"Copy, Controlled\" with definition to MBE Lexicon",20220321]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!C175","v":"NSC-614-7804 dated 20260218 Unclassified Unlimited Release (UUR)"}]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!C202","v":0}]