{"text_format":"1","workbook":"xlsx","n_sheets":6,"sheets":["Overview & Instructions","MBE Maturity Index","MBE Lexicon","Assessment Charts","Score Summary","Peer Comments"],"not_rendered":{"charts":6,"images":4,"macros":1,"external_links":0,"defined_names":14,"comments":1,"pivot_tables":0},"unopened":[],"bounds":{"document_bytes":16777216,"sheet_cells":100000,"rows_first":2000,"rows_last":500,"rows_between":2000,"halvings":0,"cell_chars":16384,"cell_head_chars":4096},"cells_cut":0,"cells_raw":0,"read":"whole","date_system":"1900"}

{"sheet":"Overview & Instructions","index":0,"n_rows":108,"n_cols":4,"rows_kept":108,"cut":false,"hidden":false,"merged":[[61,1,63,1]]}
["Overview and Instructions for Model-Based Enterprise (MBE) Maturity Index"]
[null,"The NSE MBE Maturity Index is a rubric-like tool that an organization uses to assess itself as, and facilitate transition to, a Model-Based Enterprise (MBE).\n"]
[null,null,"The intent of this index is to allow an organization to assess their MBE maturity and to identify distinctive steps along their MBE implementation journey. "]
[null,null,"The index provides a common point of reference for MBE communication.  It establishes a common context that is no less indispensable than a common language: the MBE lexicon."]
[null,null,"Through broad categories of activities, topics within a category, and facets of a topic, this tool shows a progression towards becoming more digital, better integrated, and more automated."]
[null,null,"The index is designed to allow an organization to identify different levels of maturity for each of the categories, topics, and facets at three different as-is ratings (i.e., capability, readiness, and adoption). "]
[null,null,"Results from this assessment will allow your organization to tailor a MBE roadmap of where you want your organization to be in some future state. Then this roadmap can be used to develop a MBE implementation plan."]
[]
["Contents of this Workbook"]
[null,"Tab 1","Overview & instructions for using this workbook (this tab)"]
[null,"Tab 2","MBE Maturity Index: This is the full assessment tool.  See instructions below."]
[null,"Tab 3","MBE Lexicon: Some key terms in the MBE vocabulary. Use \"Specialization\" column to refine the definition to your needs.  Use \"Organization Comments\" column to record your thoughts on these terms."]
[null,"Tab 4","Assessment Charts: Shows RADAR charts for your assessment results.  A chart for overall MBE maturity and a chart for each category of activities. (Read Only)"]
[null,"Tab 5","Peer Comments: Worksheet for capturing peer review comments."]
[null,"Tab 6","Score Summary: Shows the results of your assessment in tabular fashion. (Read Only)"]
[]
["Structure of the MBE Maturity Index"]
["Note: You can expand/collapse sections using the +/- symbols or the [1][2] boxes to the left of the Index."]
["●","Columns L0 through L6 are the maturity levels."]
[null,null,"Two columns to the left of L0 provide the description and intent of each row. You can show/hide these columns by clicking on the +/- sign above them."]
["●","Rows are items to assess, and are organized as follows:"]
[null,null,"C# is a broad category of activities."]
[null,null,"T# is a topic within a category"]
[null,null,"F# is a facet of a topic to be assessed.  This is what you actually rate."]
["●","The cell at the intersection of each Facet (row) and Level (column) is an assertion that you will compare your organization against."]
["●","At the far right are the areas where you record your assessment ratings:"]
[null,null,"The TO-BE column is where you record the targets for your organization."]
[null,null,"The AS-IS columns are where you record the ratings for your organization in its current condition:"]
[null,null,null,"Capability refers to the tools, technologies, and standards available for use within the organization."]
[null,null,null,"Readiness refers to the processes, policies, procedures that are ready to be exercised within the organization."]
[null,null,null,"Adoption refers to the degree that people in your organization are actually using those tools and processes."]
[null,null,"Only the WHITE cells are available for input.  All other numeric cells are calculated."]
["●","The index uses grouping, indicated by [1] [2] boxes at the upper left of the sheet, and by +/- indicators"]
[null,null,"Categories/Topics/Facets are grouped rows"]
[null,null,"The columns that contain descriptions of the assessment rows are grouped."]
[null,null,"The columns that contain Point of Contact (POC) and comment fields are grouped."]
["●","A few Categories or Topics have a usage note comment, in which the accessor may want to access this Category or Topic separately via selected contexts as denoted as X#."]
[]
["When you open the file…"]
["●","Enable macros (click on the prompt, if it shows near the top of the window)."]
["●","Optionally, File->Options->Trust Center->Trust Settings->Macro Settings->Enable all macros"]
[]
["Before you Start with the MBE Assessment…"]
["●","Determine the scope of your assessment."]
[null,null,"Define your organization. "]
[null,null,"Define scope by organizational, part/subsystem/product, functional, classification, or other boundary conditions (e.g. a horizontal fragment or vertical slice of a supply chain)"]
[null,null,"Within the Index, the term inter-organization refers to between peer organization whereas the term supra-organization refers to an entity above, in positional sense, over the organization. "]
["●","At the top of the MBE Maturity Index worksheet, fill in the general information (ID, name of organization, description of environment, assessor, target date/event, version)."]
[null,null,"The Target Date/Event is when the organization desires to realize their \"TO-BE\" state.  Specify either an event that represents a strategic juncture, or the date associated with the event."]
["●","Browse the entire MBE Maturity Index to become familiar with the content."]
["●","Any assertion cell that says \"Same\" means that level has the same maturity as the one to the LEFT of it."]
["●","If a new idea or requirement appears in the next level, add or 'AND' that new requirement with the preceding assertion (to the left)."]
[]
["How to Perform an MBE Assessment"]
[1,"For each Facet, determine the current AS-IS Level (N/A, 0, 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6)."]
[null,"For each assessment, determine which AS-IS rating area (Capability, Readiness, and Adoption) is being assessed:"]
[null,null,"Starting at L0, determine if your organization meets or exceeds the assertion."]
[null,null,"* If YES, then move right to the next level.  If the cell has \"same\",  move to the right."]
[null,null,"* If NO, then the previous level is your current level for that facet."]
[null,null,"(For example, if you satisfy Level 4 but not Level 5, then your score for the facet is 4.)"]
[2,"At the right of each Facet, select the appropriate AS-IS ratings in the WHITE cells."]
[null,"Ask yourself -->","Does my organization have technology/tools Capable to perform these requirements?"]
[null,null,"Does my organization have processes Ready to implement these tools to perform these requirements?"]
[null,null,"Has my organization Adopted (actually using) these processes and capabilities to perform their work?"]
[null,"The Index automatically calculates cumulative the AS-IS averages for the Topic, Category, and overall Index."]
[null,"If the Facet is not applicable to your organization under assessment, fill in the rating cells as N/A.  This line will not be added to your overall score."]
[3,"At the far right of each Facet select a TO-BE rating in the Target column (WHITE cell) per the scope of your assessment."]
[null,"The Index automatically calculates cumulative TO-BE average for topic, category and overall index."]
[4,"As appropriate, use the columns to the far right of the ratings to describe the basis of your assessment."]
[5,"When you are done, enter the Assessment date at the top of the Index. It means that your enterprise had the \"AS-IS\" scores on this date."]
[]
["Tips and Tricks"]
["●","Click here to learn how to use grouping indicators"]
["●","To make mass changes to a block of ratings, use native Excel features (e.g., drag cells, copy+paste)."]
["●","The concept of 'enterprise' is contextual and may vary across Facets. Generally, 'enterprise' refers to the supra-organization that is accountable for delivering an output/outcome to a customer, whereas a local business unit is responsible for certain accomplishments."]
[null,"whereas an 'organization' typically refers to the OUA, and a local business unit is responsible for the most granular accomplishments."]
["●","To indicate that you haven't addressed that row yet, you can blank out (empty) a rating cell, instead of using N/A."]
["●","To see a tooltip identifying your position (e.g. C1:T1:F1:L5) in the Index, left-click on any row heading or assertion in the index. (where, C=Category; T=Topic: F=Facet; L=Level.)"]
["●","To go directly to a known position in the Index, right-click anywhere in the index, select \"Go to CTFL Position\", and type a position specifier in the form: \"C#:T#:F#\" or \"C#:T#:F#:L#\"."]
["●","To copy the position of the current cell in the Index, right-click on that cell and select \"Copy Position in Index\"."]
["●","What if I want to skip a Level for a Facet? Consider the progression.  If the facet is cumulative with and statements, levels are likely not skippable.  If the facet is not cumulative, you may be able to skip a level of maturity without implementing each."]
["●","Some Facet definitions have a comment on usage."]
["●","If you really want to reset all scores (to either \"N/A\" or empty)…"]
[null,"* Click on the \"R\" button in the TO-BE column header  to reset all target scores."]
[null,"* Click on the \"Reset\" button in the AS-IS column header to reset all AS-IS scores."]
[]
["Review your MBE Maturity Assessment Charts and Score Summary"]
[null,"As you modify and complete your assessment ratings, the Chart and Chart Data tabs automatically change to reflect your input."]
[null,"Use these aids to determine whether you need to change some of your ratings."]
[null,"The Score Summary sheet contains a Topic Only Summary that helps produce the Assessment Charts; as well as contain a Score Summary for ALL Facets."]
[]
[{"$f":"Title_and_version","v":"NSE MBE Maturity Index Rev: B"}]
[null,"This document contains the results from the MBIT, MBE Committee's MBE Maturity Index task group."]
[null,"The information conveyed in this document has been normalized to help progress the maturation of Model-Based Enterprise (MBE) for digital product realization."]
[null,"Comments, suggestions, or questions on this document should be addressed to Curtis Brown, cbrown@kcnsc.doe.gov"]
[null,null,"Please use the \"Peer Comments\" worksheet to capture your comments."]
[]
["Distribution Statement:  "]
[null,"This document is an updated Rev B of the NSE MBE Maturity Index and approved for public distribution via report NSC-614-4279, dated 20220126 and is designated as Unclassified Unlimited Release (UUR).  "]
[null,"This version is a working release and has been made available as a rubic tool that an organization can:"]
[null,null,"use to assess itself as, and facilitate transition to, a model-based enterprise."]
[null,"Furthermore, we continue to solicit peer review and appreciate any focus area validation and improvement requests via the Peer Comments worksheet."]
[]
["Distribution Location:"]
[null,"The latest released version of this index and corresponding papers with presentations are located via the following URLs."]
[null,"NSC MBE Maturity Index Issue B – MBIT Model Based Enterprise (sandia.gov)"]
[null,"https://www.sandia.gov/mbit-mbe/2022/04/05/nsc-mbe-maturity-index-issue-b/"]
[null,"Both URL's point to the same destination URL."]

{"sheet":"MBE Maturity Index","index":1,"n_rows":173,"n_cols":22,"rows_kept":173,"cut":false,"hidden":false,"merged":[[163,1,163,4],[168,1,168,4],[3,2,3,12],[40,0,40,2],[6,0,6,2],[4,0,5,2],[7,1,7,4],[9,1,9,4],[12,1,12,4],[73,0,73,2],[138,0,138,2],[137,0,137,2],[157,1,157,4],[146,1,146,4],[151,1,151,4],[139,1,139,4],[142,1,142,4],[72,0,72,2],[117,1,117,4],[121,1,121,4],[126,1,126,4],[130,1,130,4],[134,1,134,4],[98,1,98,4],[101,1,101,4],[108,1,108,4],[113,1,113,4],[106,0,106,2],[107,0,107,2],[74,1,74,4],[92,1,92,4],[3,20,3,21],[2,0,2,2],[1,0,1,2],[1,6,1,10],[2,6,2,10],[1,11,1,12],[2,11,2,12],[1,14,1,16],[2,14,2,16],[1,20,1,21],[2,20,2,21],[2,3,2,4],[1,3,1,4],[1,17,1,19],[2,17,2,19],[3,15,3,17],[0,0,0,2],[69,1,69,4],[79,1,79,4],[83,1,83,4],[87,1,87,4],[18,1,18,4],[22,1,22,4],[29,1,29,4],[33,1,33,4],[41,1,41,4],[39,0,39,2],[44,1,44,4],[52,1,52,4],[60,1,60,4],[64,1,64,4],[56,1,56,4]]}
["MBE Category / Topic / Facet / (Context)",null,null,"Description: How the organization . . .","Transition: As maturity increases, the organization's . . .",null,"Drawing-Centric \n(L0)","Drawing \nModel-Centric \n(L1)","Validated  \nModel-Centric \n(L2)","Formalized \nModel-Based Definition (L3)","Trusted \nModel-Based Definition (L4)","Integrated \nModel-Based Enterprise (L5)","Extended \nModel-Based Enterprise (L6)",null,null,"AS-IS Level: Capability","AS-IS Level: Readiness","AS-IS Level: Adoption","TO-BE Level: Target",null,"POC","Comment"]
["Assessment Identifier (AID):",null,null,"Organization under assessment (OUA):",null,null,"Description of Environment:",null,null,null,null,"Assessor:",null,null,"Assessment Date:",null,null,"Target Date/Event:",null,null,"Version of Assessment:"]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,1.2]
[null,null,{"$f":"\"NSE MBE Maturity Index Rev: \" & getDraftFromFilename()","v":"NSE MBE Maturity Index Rev: B"},null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,"AS-IS Level",null,null,"TO-BE Level",null,"Assessor comments below."]
["\n                      Maturity Level Name\n\n                                               Level #\nCategories (e.g., C1)\n└─Topics (e.g., T3) \n      └─Facets (e.g., F2)",null,null,null,null,null,"Drawing-Centric","Drawing Model-Centric","Validated  Model-Centric","Formalized Model-Based Definition","Trusted Model-Based Definition","Integrated Model-Based Enterprise","Extended Model-Based Enterprise","Weight Factor for Topic/Facet\n[0,2,5,8,10]",null,"Capability:  Tools are Available?","Readiness:  Processes are Ready?","Adoption:  People are Using?","Target Adoption",null,"POC","Comment"]
[null,null,null,"Description: How the organization . . .","Transition: As maturity increases, the organization's . . .",null,"L0","L1","L2","L3","L4","L5","L6",null,null,{"$f":"IF(COUNT(P7,P41,P74,P108,P139)=0,\"N/A\",SUM(IF(P7<>\"N/A\",P7*$N7,0),IF(P41<>\"N/A\",P41*$N41,0),IF(P74<>\"N/A\",P74*$N74,0),IF(P108<>\"N/A\",P108*$N108,0),IF(P139<>\"N/A\",P139*$N139,0))/SUM(IF(P7<>\"N/A\",$N7,0),IF(P41<>\"N/A\",$N41,0),IF(P74<>\"N/A\",$N74,0),IF(P108<>\"N/A\",$N108,0),IF(P139<>\"N/A\",$N139,0)))","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"IF(COUNT(Q7,Q41,Q74,Q108,Q139)=0,\"N/A\",SUM(IF(Q7<>\"N/A\",Q7*$N7,0),IF(Q41<>\"N/A\",Q41*$N41,0),IF(Q74<>\"N/A\",Q74*$N74,0),IF(Q108<>\"N/A\",Q108*$N108,0),IF(Q139<>\"N/A\",Q139*$N139,0))/SUM(IF(Q7<>\"N/A\",$N7,0),IF(Q41<>\"N/A\",$N41,0),IF(Q74<>\"N/A\",$N74,0),IF(Q108<>\"N/A\",$N108,0),IF(Q139<>\"N/A\",$N139,0)))","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"IF(COUNT(R7,R41,R74,R108,R139)=0,\"N/A\",SUM(IF(R7<>\"N/A\",R7*$N7,0),IF(R41<>\"N/A\",R41*$N41,0),IF(R74<>\"N/A\",R74*$N74,0),IF(R108<>\"N/A\",R108*$N108,0),IF(R139<>\"N/A\",R139*$N139,0))/SUM(IF(R7<>\"N/A\",$N7,0),IF(R41<>\"N/A\",$N41,0),IF(R74<>\"N/A\",$N74,0),IF(R108<>\"N/A\",$N108,0),IF(R139<>\"N/A\",$N139,0)))","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"IF(COUNT(S7,S41,S74,S108,S139)=0,\"N/A\",SUM(IF(S7<>\"N/A\",S7*$N7,0),IF(S41<>\"N/A\",S41*$N41,0),IF(S74<>\"N/A\",S74*$N74,0),IF(S108<>\"N/A\",S108*$N108,0),IF(S139<>\"N/A\",S139*$N139,0))/SUM(IF(S7<>\"N/A\",$N7,0),IF(S41<>\"N/A\",$N41,0),IF(S74<>\"N/A\",$N74,0),IF(S108<>\"N/A\",$N108,0),IF(S139<>\"N/A\",$N139,0)))","v":"N/A"}]
["C1: Design Activities",null,null,{"$f":"DesignActivities","v":"Activities involved in designing a product."},"Product definition becomes a trusted model-based definition dataset.",null,"2D Drawings used for all activities","2D Drawings derived from models","2D Drawings and other derivatives from validated 3D model","Semantic PMI included within 3D model","Certified, Authorized MBD","MBD dataset made useable for all lifecycle activities within enterprise","Product definition system model made useable for all lifecycle activities",4,null,{"$f":"IF(COUNT(P8,P10,P13,P19,P23,P30,P34)=0,\"N/A\",SUM(IF(P8<>\"N/A\",P8*$N8,0),IF(P10<>\"N/A\",P10*$N10,0),IF(P13<>\"N/A\",P13*$N13,0),IF(P19<>\"N/A\",P19*$N19,0),IF(P23<>\"N/A\",P23*$N23,0),IF(P30<>\"N/A\",P30*$N30,0),IF(P34<>\"N/A\",P34*$N34,0))/SUM(IF(P8<>\"N/A\",$N8,0),IF(P10<>\"N/A\",$N10,0),IF(P13<>\"N/A\",$N13,0),IF(P19<>\"N/A\",$N19,0),IF(P23<>\"N/A\",$N23,0),IF(P30<>\"N/A\",$N30,0),IF(P34<>\"N/A\",$N34,0)))","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"IF(COUNT(Q8,Q10,Q13,Q19,Q23,Q30,Q34)=0,\"N/A\",SUM(IF(Q8<>\"N/A\",Q8*$N8,0),IF(Q10<>\"N/A\",Q10*$N10,0),IF(Q13<>\"N/A\",Q13*$N13,0),IF(Q19<>\"N/A\",Q19*$N19,0),IF(Q23<>\"N/A\",Q23*$N23,0),IF(Q30<>\"N/A\",Q30*$N30,0),IF(Q34<>\"N/A\",Q34*$N34,0))/SUM(IF(Q8<>\"N/A\",$N8,0),IF(Q10<>\"N/A\",$N10,0),IF(Q13<>\"N/A\",$N13,0),IF(Q19<>\"N/A\",$N19,0),IF(Q23<>\"N/A\",$N23,0),IF(Q30<>\"N/A\",$N30,0),IF(Q34<>\"N/A\",$N34,0)))","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"IF(COUNT(R8,R10,R13,R19,R23,R30,R34)=0,\"N/A\",SUM(IF(R8<>\"N/A\",R8*$N8,0),IF(R10<>\"N/A\",R10*$N10,0),IF(R13<>\"N/A\",R13*$N13,0),IF(R19<>\"N/A\",R19*$N19,0),IF(R23<>\"N/A\",R23*$N23,0),IF(R30<>\"N/A\",R30*$N30,0),IF(R34<>\"N/A\",R34*$N34,0))/SUM(IF(R8<>\"N/A\",$N8,0),IF(R10<>\"N/A\",$N10,0),IF(R13<>\"N/A\",$N13,0),IF(R19<>\"N/A\",$N19,0),IF(R23<>\"N/A\",$N23,0),IF(R30<>\"N/A\",$N30,0),IF(R34<>\"N/A\",$N34,0)))","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"IF(COUNT(S8,S10,S13,S19,S23,S30,S34)=0,\"N/A\",SUM(IF(S8<>\"N/A\",S8*$N8,0),IF(S10<>\"N/A\",S10*$N10,0),IF(S13<>\"N/A\",S13*$N13,0),IF(S19<>\"N/A\",S19*$N19,0),IF(S23<>\"N/A\",S23*$N23,0),IF(S30<>\"N/A\",S30*$N30,0),IF(S34<>\"N/A\",S34*$N34,0))/SUM(IF(S8<>\"N/A\",$N8,0),IF(S10<>\"N/A\",$N10,0),IF(S13<>\"N/A\",$N13,0),IF(S19<>\"N/A\",$N19,0),IF(S23<>\"N/A\",$N23,0),IF(S30<>\"N/A\",$N30,0),IF(S34<>\"N/A\",$N34,0)))","v":"N/A"}]
[null,"T1: Product Authority",null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,4,null,{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(P9:P9,\"N/A\")=ROWS(P9:P9),\"N/A\",P9)","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(Q9:Q9,\"N/A\")=ROWS(Q9:Q9),\"N/A\",Q9)","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(R9:R9,\"N/A\")=ROWS(R9:R9),\"N/A\",R9)","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(S9:S9,\"N/A\")=ROWS(S9:S9),\"N/A\",S9)","v":"N/A"}]
[null,null,"F1: Authorized Definition","Identifies the authorized product definition (i.e. legal definition).","MBD data collection becomes the product authority.",null,"Paper 2D drawing with support documents","Electronic 2D drawing with support documents","2D drawing from 3D model with support documents and support model ","3D drawing (e.g. 3D Interactive Viewable) from MBD model with support documents and support model","MBD model with support drawing and support documents","MBD dataset containing all authorized product definition artifacts","Product definition system model communicating all authorized product definition artifacts along with their relationships.",4,null,"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A"]
[null,"T2: Product Requirements Association\n",null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,4,null,{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(P11:P12,\"N/A\")=ROWS(P11:P12),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(P11:P12<>\"N/A\"),$N11:$N12,P11:P12))/SUMIF(P11:P12,\"<>N/A\",$N11:$N12))","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(Q11:Q12,\"N/A\")=ROWS(Q11:Q12),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(Q11:Q12<>\"N/A\"),$N11:$N12,Q11:Q12))/SUMIF(Q11:Q12,\"<>N/A\",$N11:$N12))","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(R11:R12,\"N/A\")=ROWS(R11:R12),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(R11:R12<>\"N/A\"),$N11:$N12,R11:R12))/SUMIF(R11:R12,\"<>N/A\",$N11:$N12))","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(S11:S12,\"N/A\")=ROWS(S11:S12),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(S11:S12<>\"N/A\"),$N11:$N12,S11:S12))/SUMIF(S11:S12,\"<>N/A\",$N11:$N12))","v":"N/A"}]
[null,null,"F1: Form","States the representation of the product requirements as data.","Product requirements become more discrete and  digital.",null,"Non-electronic document","Electronic document","Same","Uniquely identifiable digital objects/records","Same","Same","Same",4,null,"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A"]
[null,null,"F2: Associativity","States how well product requirements are linked to product definition.","Product requirements become more discrete and linked to distinct features of the model.",null,"Disconnected","Manually linked to characteristic on 2D drawing","Replicated to part object in PDM system","Linked to part object in PDM system","Linked to product characteristics in 3D model","Bi-directional link","Automated bi-directional link",4,null,"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A"]
[null,"T3: Product Definition Description\n",null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,4,null,{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(P14:P18,\"N/A\")=ROWS(P14:P18),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(P14:P18<>\"N/A\"),$N14:$N18,P14:P18))/SUMIF(P14:P18,\"<>N/A\",$N14:$N18))","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(Q14:Q18,\"N/A\")=ROWS(Q14:Q18),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(Q14:Q18<>\"N/A\"),$N14:$N18,Q14:Q18))/SUMIF(Q14:Q18,\"<>N/A\",$N14:$N18))","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(R14:R18,\"N/A\")=ROWS(R14:R18),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(R14:R18<>\"N/A\"),$N14:$N18,R14:R18))/SUMIF(R14:R18,\"<>N/A\",$N14:$N18))","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(S14:S18,\"N/A\")=ROWS(S14:S18),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(S14:S18<>\"N/A\"),$N14:$N18,S14:S18))/SUMIF(S14:S18,\"<>N/A\",$N14:$N18))","v":"N/A"}]
[null,null,"F1: Shape Definition","States how to define the base shape definition.","Shape definition becomes more applicable, precise and unambiguous.",null,"2D drawing","3D model as solid geometry","Same via feature-based design and parametric capabilities","Same with mixed modes of modeling (e.g., parametric, direct) techniques","Same with multiple feature-based disciplines (e.g.,. design, manufacturing, metrology, deburring)","Same with precise & unambiguous bounded complex surfaces & volumes ","Same with generative design",4,null,"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A"]
[null,null,"F2: Non-Shape Information","States how to define visible non-shape product and manufacturing information (PMI) (e.g., annotations and notes)","PMI becomes more semantic, embedded in the model, and linked to model elements.",null,"Textual annotations and notes on 2D drawing","Same with textual notes driven from 3D model","Annotations and notes in 3D model","Semantic annotations and notes in MBD model","Same with common notes across inter-organization","Minimum standard PMI including product characteristic tags with any criticality designators","Same, with augmentations to product characteristics (e.g., product requirement associations, quality requirements)",4,null,"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A"]
[null,null,"F3: Metadata","States where to record a product’s metadata.","Metadata becomes digital and more complete, standardized, and managed.",null,"As text on drawing","Parameters within 3D Model","Same","3D Model and PDM","Automatic syncing  between Model and PDM","Model metadata stored with model; product metadata stored with part in the PDM system","Enterprise standardized metadata linked to  external systems.",4,null,"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A"]
[null,null,"F4: Presentation Views","Identifies the types of presentation views included in product definition.","Views become more standardized, interactive, and meaningful.",null,"2D drawing views, sections, & detail","Standard 2D drawing views, sections, & detail","Same","3D model presented in organization's standard set of interactive views","3D model presented in inter-organization's standard set of interactive views","Same with product characteristic views","Same with additional discipline specific views",4,null,"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A"]
[null,null,"F5: Tolerancing Scheme","Defines acceptable deviation (i.e., tolerances) from nominal shape.","Tolerancing scheme becomes standardized, consistent, and geometric dimensioning and tolerancing with functional datums.",null,"Dimensional tolerances only","Geometrical dimensioning and tolerancing (GD&T)","Standards-based GD&T with functional datums","Same with piece-part functional datums from an assembly perspective","Same with enterprise standards-based GD&T and functional datums","Infer tolerancing schemes from a piece-part perspective.","Infer tolerancing schemes from an assembly perspective.",4,null,"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A"]
[null,"T4: Model Quality & Certification",null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,4,null,{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(P20:P22,\"N/A\")=ROWS(P20:P22),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(P20:P22<>\"N/A\"),$N20:$N22,P20:P22))/SUMIF(P20:P22,\"<>N/A\",$N20:$N22))","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(Q20:Q22,\"N/A\")=ROWS(Q20:Q22),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(Q20:Q22<>\"N/A\"),$N20:$N22,Q20:Q22))/SUMIF(Q20:Q22,\"<>N/A\",$N20:$N22))","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(R20:R22,\"N/A\")=ROWS(R20:R22),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(R20:R22<>\"N/A\"),$N20:$N22,R20:R22))/SUMIF(R20:R22,\"<>N/A\",$N20:$N22))","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(S20:S22,\"N/A\")=ROWS(S20:S22),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(S20:S22<>\"N/A\"),$N20:$N22,S20:S22))/SUMIF(S20:S22,\"<>N/A\",$N20:$N22))","v":"N/A"}]
[null,null,"F1: Verification of","States the subject of checks (e.g., business/design, geometry, & PMI).","Checks become more inclusive.",null,"Business/Design practices","Same and geometry","Same","Same and semantic PMI","Same","Same and process dependent checks","Same and advanced precision geometry checks",4,null,"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A"]
[null,null,"F2: Automation","States degree of automation for verification of model quality.","Model verification becomes more automated and bound to promotion process states.",null,"Manual checks","Same","Ad hoc interactive check","On demand checking","Same","Same and automatic checks through workflow or promotion state change"," Same ",4,null,"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A"]
[null,null,"F3: Certification","States the methods for certifying verification of the model.","Certification becomes more digital and integrated with procedural workflows.",null,"Signature on drawing","Signature on electronic drawing","Separate electronic certificate with traceability to model","Electronic certificate associated with part object","Same","Digital certificate embedded in model file","Same",4,null,"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A"]
[null,"T5: Model Derivatives\n",null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,4,null,{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(P24:P29,\"N/A\")=ROWS(P24:P29),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(P24:P29<>\"N/A\"),$N24:$N29,P24:P29))/SUMIF(P24:P29,\"<>N/A\",$N24:$N29))","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(Q24:Q29,\"N/A\")=ROWS(Q24:Q29),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(Q24:Q29<>\"N/A\"),$N24:$N29,Q24:Q29))/SUMIF(Q24:Q29,\"<>N/A\",$N24:$N29))","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(R24:R29,\"N/A\")=ROWS(R24:R29),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(R24:R29<>\"N/A\"),$N24:$N29,R24:R29))/SUMIF(R24:R29,\"<>N/A\",$N24:$N29))","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(S24:S29,\"N/A\")=ROWS(S24:S29),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(S24:S29<>\"N/A\"),$N24:$N29,S24:S29))/SUMIF(S24:S29,\"<>N/A\",$N24:$N29))","v":"N/A"}]
[null,null,"F1: Content","States the information contained in a derivative model.","Derivative becomes richer and more precise.",null,"N/A","Basic delineation (e.g., shape for MCAD)","Same w/ metadata","Same w/ textual PMI","Same w/ semantic PMI","Same w/ precision for target processes","Same w/ precision for multiple target processes",4,null,"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A"]
[null,null,"F2: Authoring Automation","States the degree of automation for generation of derivatives.","Derivative generation becomes more automated.",null,"N/A","Manual from the Client Desktop","On demand from the PDM interface","Same","Automatic via PDM workflow during the process phases/ stages/ gates","Same and rules determining the type of derivative ","Same",4,null,"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A"]
[null,null,"F3: Validation to & Certificates","States the degree of automation for validation of derivatives to a source, as well as the form of validation certificates.","Validation becomes more automated and certificates become more closely linked to the derivative content.",null,"N/A","Manual without certificate","Interactively with separate electronic certificate","On demand with certificate linked to PDM object","Same with embedded digital certificate","Same and automatic via a promotion process state change","Same",4,null,"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A"]
[null,null,"F4: Provenance","States the depth of provenance information available for derivatives.","Provenance information increases to show traceability to origin.",null,"N/A","None","Reference to source model","Same","Same and reference to  basis model","Complete provenance to original source model","Same",4,null,"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A"]
[null,null,"F5: Managed","States how derivatives are stored and associated with the part definition.","Derivatives are stored in connected systems and associated more closely to the part definition.",null,"N/A","Electronic file directories and disconnected","Document-centric PDM systems, but disconnected","Part-centric PDM systems, and associated","Part-centric PLM system with common connected schema approach across organization","Single, part-centric PLM throughout inter-organization","Single, part-centric PLM throughout extended supra-organization",4,null,"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A"]
[null,null,"F6: Viewables","States the human-readable mechanism for communicating product definition.","Viewables become 3D, annotated, interactive, interrogatable, and holographic.",null,"Paper 2D Drawing","Electronic 2D static drawing","Proprietary 3D viewer, geometric interaction","Geometric and annotation interaction in a standard format","Same with spatial interrogation ","Same with managed mark-ups","Same with holographic",4,null,"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A"]
[null,"T6: ECAD/MCAD Collaboration\n",null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,4,null,{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(P31:P33,\"N/A\")=ROWS(P31:P33),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(P31:P33<>\"N/A\"),$N31:$N33,P31:P33))/SUMIF(P31:P33,\"<>N/A\",$N31:$N33))","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(Q31:Q33,\"N/A\")=ROWS(Q31:Q33),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(Q31:Q33<>\"N/A\"),$N31:$N33,Q31:Q33))/SUMIF(Q31:Q33,\"<>N/A\",$N31:$N33))","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(R31:R33,\"N/A\")=ROWS(R31:R33),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(R31:R33<>\"N/A\"),$N31:$N33,R31:R33))/SUMIF(R31:R33,\"<>N/A\",$N31:$N33))","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(S31:S33,\"N/A\")=ROWS(S31:S33),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(S31:S33<>\"N/A\"),$N31:$N33,S31:S33))/SUMIF(S31:S33,\"<>N/A\",$N31:$N33))","v":"N/A"}]
[null,null,"F1: Condition","States the events that drive MCAD-ECAD collaboration.","MCAD-ECAD collaboration becomes more frequent, predictable, and seamless.",null,"Ad hoc","Design reviews","Design changes","Same","Same","Concurrent design","Same",4,null,"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A"]
[null,null,"F2: Mode","Identifies mechanisms for MCAD-ECAD collaboration.","Mechanisms for MCAD-ECAD collaboration become more capable and unified.",null,"Email and verbal","Exchange of model files","Shared access to PDM systems","User initiated workflow","Same","Application tool integration ","Common application tools",4,null,"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A"]
[null,null,"F3: Commonality","Identifies common/shared resources for MCAD-ECAD collaboration.","The resources used by MCAD and ECAD practitioners become more common and shared.",null,"None","Duplicate component library","Same with  3D component library with time guarantees","Shared library via PDM system","Shared part-centric library via PLM system","Same across inter-organization ","Common application tool",4,null,"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A"]
[null,"T7: Design Analysis & Simulation ",null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,4,null,{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(P35:P39,\"N/A\")=ROWS(P35:P39),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(P35:P39<>\"N/A\"),$N35:$N39,P35:P39))/SUMIF(P35:P39,\"<>N/A\",$N35:$N39))","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(Q35:Q39,\"N/A\")=ROWS(Q35:Q39),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(Q35:Q39<>\"N/A\"),$N35:$N39,Q35:Q39))/SUMIF(Q35:Q39,\"<>N/A\",$N35:$N39))","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(R35:R39,\"N/A\")=ROWS(R35:R39),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(R35:R39<>\"N/A\"),$N35:$N39,R35:R39))/SUMIF(R35:R39,\"<>N/A\",$N35:$N39))","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(S35:S39,\"N/A\")=ROWS(S35:S39),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(S35:S39<>\"N/A\"),$N35:$N39,S35:S39))/SUMIF(S35:S39,\"<>N/A\",$N35:$N39))","v":"N/A"}]
[null,null,"F1: Basis Model Source","States the source of basis model (e.g., product definition) used to create the analysis model.","Analysis models are derived more directly from the native model.",null,"Independent","Unauthorized model","Same ","Authorized model","Model authorized specifically for analysis\n","Analysis integral to design process","Same",4,null,"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A"]
[null,null,"F2: Analysis Model Authoring Automation","States how the analysis geometry, material, and physics models are created.","Creation of the analysis model becomes more automated.",null,"Manual","Manually modified","Same","Directed automated modification","Automatic modification","Automatic updates","Same",4,null,"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A"]
[null,null,"F3: Managed","States how analysis models, results, and decisions are stored, controlled, and managed.","Analysis models, results, and decisions are stored more closely to the bais definition and more digitally.",null,"Paper file cabinets","Disconnected, electronic file directories ","Disconnected, document-centric PDM systems ","Disconnected, part-centric PDM systems","Harmonized PLM schema across organization","Single, part-centric PLM throughout inter-organization","Single, part-centric PLM throughout supra-organization and extended enterprise",4,null,"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A"]
[null,null,"F4: Influence","States how analysis results and conclusions influence design definition.","Influence and automation of analysis increases.",null,"Independent of design","Shared with product and process design teams","Same","Business practices include design simulation results in design review","Same and shared as part of change management process","Change automatically proposed","Automatic update of design definition with digital twin",4,null,"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A"]
[null,null,"F5: Traceability","States the breadth and depth of traceability information available.","Traceability to other disciplines increases in breadth, depth, and capability.",null,"Textual references","Electronic, textual references","System level awareness of other disciplines","Part-level navigation to objects in other disciplines","Element-level navigation to attributes in other disciplines","Same with bi-directional navigation","Same with write back access, as appropriate",4,null,"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A"]
[]
["C2: Product Data/Lifecycle Management Activities",null,null,{"$f":"PDM_Activities","v":"Activities that interrelate product data."},"PDM processes change from manual to automated, document-centric to part-centric, CAD files only to all product lifecycle (PLM) data, disconnected to integration with other organizational disciplines, and extended to the trusted supplier.",null,"File-sharing directory","Document-centric PDM with disconnected models","Document-centric PDM with connected models","Part-centric PDM connected to product related disciplines","Authoritative part-centric PDM is the source for product definition, connected process, & lifecycle related disciplines","Digitally \"one\"  part-centric PDM for inter-organization product lifecycle disciplines","Digital part-centric PLM exchange with supra-organization and trusted suppliers",4,null,{"$f":"IF(COUNT(P42,P45,P53,P57,P61,P65,P70)=0,\"N/A\",SUM(IF(P42<>\"N/A\",P42*$N42,0),IF(P45<>\"N/A\",P45*$N45,0),IF(P53<>\"N/A\",P53*$N53,0),IF(P57<>\"N/A\",P57*$N57,0),IF(P61<>\"N/A\",P61*$N61,0),IF(P65<>\"N/A\",P65*$N65,0),IF(P70<>\"N/A\",P70*$N70,0))/SUM(IF(P42<>\"N/A\",$N42,0),IF(P45<>\"N/A\",$N45,0),IF(P53<>\"N/A\",$N53,0),IF(P57<>\"N/A\",$N57,0),IF(P61<>\"N/A\",$N61,0),IF(P65<>\"N/A\",$N65,0),IF(P70<>\"N/A\",$N70,0)))","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"IF(COUNT(Q42,Q45,Q53,Q57,Q61,Q65,Q70)=0,\"N/A\",SUM(IF(Q42<>\"N/A\",Q42*$N42,0),IF(Q45<>\"N/A\",Q45*$N45,0),IF(Q53<>\"N/A\",Q53*$N53,0),IF(Q57<>\"N/A\",Q57*$N57,0),IF(Q61<>\"N/A\",Q61*$N61,0),IF(Q65<>\"N/A\",Q65*$N65,0),IF(Q70<>\"N/A\",Q70*$N70,0))/SUM(IF(Q42<>\"N/A\",$N42,0),IF(Q45<>\"N/A\",$N45,0),IF(Q53<>\"N/A\",$N53,0),IF(Q57<>\"N/A\",$N57,0),IF(Q61<>\"N/A\",$N61,0),IF(Q65<>\"N/A\",$N65,0),IF(Q70<>\"N/A\",$N70,0)))","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"IF(COUNT(R42,R45,R53,R57,R61,R65,R70)=0,\"N/A\",SUM(IF(R42<>\"N/A\",R42*$N42,0),IF(R45<>\"N/A\",R45*$N45,0),IF(R53<>\"N/A\",R53*$N53,0),IF(R57<>\"N/A\",R57*$N57,0),IF(R61<>\"N/A\",R61*$N61,0),IF(R65<>\"N/A\",R65*$N65,0),IF(R70<>\"N/A\",R70*$N70,0))/SUM(IF(R42<>\"N/A\",$N42,0),IF(R45<>\"N/A\",$N45,0),IF(R53<>\"N/A\",$N53,0),IF(R57<>\"N/A\",$N57,0),IF(R61<>\"N/A\",$N61,0),IF(R65<>\"N/A\",$N65,0),IF(R70<>\"N/A\",$N70,0)))","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"IF(COUNT(S42,S45,S53,S57,S61,S65,S70)=0,\"N/A\",SUM(IF(S42<>\"N/A\",S42*$N42,0),IF(S45<>\"N/A\",S45*$N45,0),IF(S53<>\"N/A\",S53*$N53,0),IF(S57<>\"N/A\",S57*$N57,0),IF(S61<>\"N/A\",S61*$N61,0),IF(S65<>\"N/A\",S65*$N65,0),IF(S70<>\"N/A\",S70*$N70,0))/SUM(IF(S42<>\"N/A\",$N42,0),IF(S45<>\"N/A\",$N45,0),IF(S53<>\"N/A\",$N53,0),IF(S57<>\"N/A\",$N57,0),IF(S61<>\"N/A\",$N61,0),IF(S65<>\"N/A\",$N65,0),IF(S70<>\"N/A\",$N70,0)))","v":"N/A"}]
[null,"T1: Product Definition Authority",null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,4,null,{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(P43:P44,\"N/A\")=ROWS(P43:P44),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(P43:P44<>\"N/A\"),$N43:$N44,P43:P44))/SUMIF(P43:P44,\"<>N/A\",$N43:$N44))","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(Q43:Q44,\"N/A\")=ROWS(Q43:Q44),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(Q43:Q44<>\"N/A\"),$N43:$N44,Q43:Q44))/SUMIF(Q43:Q44,\"<>N/A\",$N43:$N44))","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(R43:R44,\"N/A\")=ROWS(R43:R44),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(R43:R44<>\"N/A\"),$N43:$N44,R43:R44))/SUMIF(R43:R44,\"<>N/A\",$N43:$N44))","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(S43:S44,\"N/A\")=ROWS(S43:S44),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(S43:S44<>\"N/A\"),$N43:$N44,S43:S44))/SUMIF(S43:S44,\"<>N/A\",$N43:$N44))","v":"N/A"}]
[null,null,"F1: Part-Centricity ","States how cohesively product definition is maintained within an authoritative PDM/PLM.","Product definition is managed in a more unified part-centric manner as an authoritative source.",null,"Paper file cabinets","Electronic file directories ","Document-centric PDM system connected to models","Part-centric PDM system for product definition","Common part-centric PLM schema across inter-organization with single authoritative source for organization","Single, part-centric PLM throughout inter-organization is authoritative source"," Single, part-centric PLM throughout supra-organization and extended enterprise",4,null,"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A"]
[null,null,"F2: Associativity","States how broadly and deeply product definition links to other authoritative sources in related disciplines.","Associativity, to other discipline's items, increases in breadth, depth, and capability. ",null,"Textual references","Electronic, textual references","System level awareness of other disciplines","Part/item-level navigation to objects in other discipline systems","Element-level navigation to objects/attributes in other discipline systems","Same with bi-directional navigation","Same with comment or write back access",4,null,"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A"]
[null,"T2: Data Management Approach",null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,4,null,{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(P46:P52,\"N/A\")=ROWS(P46:P52),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(P46:P52<>\"N/A\"),$N46:$N52,P46:P52))/SUMIF(P46:P52,\"<>N/A\",$N46:$N52))","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(Q46:Q52,\"N/A\")=ROWS(Q46:Q52),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(Q46:Q52<>\"N/A\"),$N46:$N52,Q46:Q52))/SUMIF(Q46:Q52,\"<>N/A\",$N46:$N52))","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(R46:R52,\"N/A\")=ROWS(R46:R52),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(R46:R52<>\"N/A\"),$N46:$N52,R46:R52))/SUMIF(R46:R52,\"<>N/A\",$N46:$N52))","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(S46:S52,\"N/A\")=ROWS(S46:S52),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(S46:S52<>\"N/A\"),$N46:$N52,S46:S52))/SUMIF(S46:S52,\"<>N/A\",$N46:$N52))","v":"N/A"}]
[null,null,"F1: Content Management Scope","States the extent of information (e.g., configurable items) that is managed in PDM.","Scope of the content managed in PDM/PLM extends to product and process definition sets.",null,"Electronic documents and 2D drawings","Documents, 2D drawings, and models","Product definition sets","Same with supplementary definition data and associated links","Same with process definition data","Same with product data supplied by other discipline authoritative sources","Same with product data from extended enterprise",4,null,"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A"]
[null,null,"F2: Change Management","States how closely change management (CM) activities relate to the product and/or process definition.","Change management becomes more closely linked to discrete product/process definition content in an authoritative source.",null,"Change textually tied to product definition","Electronic CM system exists disconnected from PDM","CM integrated with PDM","Same and change request digitally tied to product definition part","CM integrated with product lifecycle within PLM","Single inter-organization wide workflows imbedded within PLM","Same and change request digitally tied to discrete item within product or process definition",4,null,"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A"]
[null,null,"F3: Product Structure Management","States the granularity of product structure and the means to represent it.  Note: other BoMs are described C2:T5.","Product structure stored in the authoritative source becomes more detailed and easy to manage.",null,"On drawing(s)","Same and structured data elements duplicated in PDM","Subassemblies partially defined in PDM","Same with product's characterized  attributes in PDM","Substructures fully defined with characterized attributes in PDM","Full up  product structure (i.e, systems) defined and characterized attributes with product variants in PDM","Same and available to extended enterprise",4,null,"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A"]
[null,null,"F4: User Interface Applications","States how applications are implemented to improve usability of accessing PDM data for casual users","Access to contextualized information available from PDM and other organizational sources easier and more interactive.",null,"None","Default tool interface for each application","Same with limited linkage to other discipline sources","Role/task-based application for viewing of data items","Same and contributing to existing data items"," Same and authoring content"," Same with combining data from other sources.",4,null,"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A"]
[null,null,"F5: Governance","States the extent of data governance. ","Extent of governance of product data increases.",null,"None ","Internal policy / guidelines","Governance applied within PDM/PLM capability","Same across organization","Same across inter-organization ","Same across supra-organization","Same across extended enterprise ",4,null,"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A"]
[null,null,"F6: Trusted Data","States the extent of provenance for data.","Data becomes more trusted through authoritative sources and traceable to origin.",null,"Unknown authority ","Authorized and unauthorized sources","Multiple authorized sources for a given data item","Single authorized source for a given data item","Same with traceability to origin","Same with routine audits","Same with access by partner organizations",4,null,"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A"]
[null,null,"F7: Change Control Process","Performs change on affected end item (e.g., product definition, process definition).","Change control process becomes formalized using industry standard change objects connected to affected items and analyzed for enterprise impact.",null,"Ad-hoc  with no documentation","Formal, textual documentation required for authorization","Same with change control documentation manually associated to design document-centric items as unincorporated or incorporated","Industry standard change objects and workflow (i.e., problem reports, change requests, change notices, change tasks, change authorization)  connected to part-centric PDM; Integrated unincorporated change workflow","Same with optional change review boards for  impact analysis; Change control objects serve as change control documentation and authorization; Change description include annotations (e.g., red-marks) ","Same with standard process across organizational systems (e.g., PLM, MES) for data traceability ","Same with predictive analytics  for corrective actions; Standard process across inter-organization",4,null,"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A"]
[null,"T3: Product Definition Management",null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,4,null,{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(P54:P56,\"N/A\")=ROWS(P54:P56),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(P54:P56<>\"N/A\"),$N54:$N56,P54:P56))/SUMIF(P54:P56,\"<>N/A\",$N54:$N56))","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(Q54:Q56,\"N/A\")=ROWS(Q54:Q56),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(Q54:Q56<>\"N/A\"),$N54:$N56,Q54:Q56))/SUMIF(Q54:Q56,\"<>N/A\",$N54:$N56))","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(R54:R56,\"N/A\")=ROWS(R54:R56),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(R54:R56<>\"N/A\"),$N54:$N56,R54:R56))/SUMIF(R54:R56,\"<>N/A\",$N54:$N56))","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(S54:S56,\"N/A\")=ROWS(S54:S56),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(S54:S56<>\"N/A\"),$N54:$N56,S54:S56))/SUMIF(S54:S56,\"<>N/A\",$N54:$N56))","v":"N/A"}]
[null,null,"F1: Definition Set","States the format of the product definition set.","Product definition set becomes more trusted, digital, unambiguous, and automated.",null,"Paper package","Electronic drawing list","Electronic product definition set with manifest","Same and allows for additional 3D model types (e.g., natives, derivatives).","Product definition datasets managed as PDM baselines","Same and automated, unambiguous, and mandated","Same and available to extended enterprise",4,null,"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A"]
[null,null,"F2: Supplemental Data Reference","States how supplemental data is referenced within the product definition set.","Links to supplemental data become more digital and connected to authoritative sources.",null,"Supplemental data called out","Same and available in organization's repositories","Same","PDM links to organization's authoritative sources.","PLM linked through part objects to authoritative sources ","Same but linked to inter-organization's authoritative sources","Model elements linked to authoritative sources outside of PDM",4,null,"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A"]
[null,null,"F3: Product Definition Authorization","Specifies the use or placement of product definition in the configuration management system.","Authorization becomes more automated and integrated and PDM becomes the single authorized source for product definition.",null,"Manual","Electronic separate from PDM","Same","Same and PDM is informed","Same and digital","Automated in release process in PDM/PLM","Same",4,null,"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A"]
[null,"T4: Process Data Management",null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,4,null,{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(P58:P60,\"N/A\")=ROWS(P58:P60),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(P58:P60<>\"N/A\"),$N58:$N60,P58:P60))/SUMIF(P58:P60,\"<>N/A\",$N58:$N60))","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(Q58:Q60,\"N/A\")=ROWS(Q58:Q60),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(Q58:Q60<>\"N/A\"),$N58:$N60,Q58:Q60))/SUMIF(Q58:Q60,\"<>N/A\",$N58:$N60))","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(R58:R60,\"N/A\")=ROWS(R58:R60),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(R58:R60<>\"N/A\"),$N58:$N60,R58:R60))/SUMIF(R58:R60,\"<>N/A\",$N58:$N60))","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(S58:S60,\"N/A\")=ROWS(S58:S60),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(S58:S60<>\"N/A\"),$N58:$N60,S58:S60))/SUMIF(S58:S60,\"<>N/A\",$N58:$N60))","v":"N/A"}]
[null,null,"F1: Product Definition Association","States how product realization process data are associated with product definition. ","Process data are well connected with product as part-centric and provide a single authorized source for process data.",null,"Manual reference to 2D paper definition via part number","Textual reference to 2D electronic document via part number","Digital reference to product definition drawing","Digital association to product definition model","Digital association to product definition set within PLM","Same but association to items within product definition set","Digital bi-directional association to items within product definition set",4,null,"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A"]
[null,null,"F2: Definition Set","States the format of the process dataset or package (e.g., process derivative models and related data).","Process datasets become more trusted, digital, unambiguous, and automated, and available to trusted suppliers",null,"Paper Package","Electronic document list","Electronic process definition set packaged with manifest","Same ","Process definition datasets available","Automated, unambiguous, digital process definition datasets mandated","Same and digitally available to extended enterprise",4,null,"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A"]
[null,null,"F3: Supplemental Data Reference","States how supplemental data is referenced within the process definition set.","Links to supplemental data become more digital and connected to authoritative sources.",null,"Supplemental data called out","Same and available in organization's repositories","Same","PDM links to organization's authoritative sources.","PLM linked through part objects to authoritative sources ","Same but linked to inter-organization's authoritative sources","Model elements linked to authoritative sources outside of PDM",4,null,"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A"]
[null,"T5: Bill of Materials (BOM) Management",null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,4,null,{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(P62:P64,\"N/A\")=ROWS(P62:P64),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(P62:P64<>\"N/A\"),$N62:$N64,P62:P64))/SUMIF(P62:P64,\"<>N/A\",$N62:$N64))","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(Q62:Q64,\"N/A\")=ROWS(Q62:Q64),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(Q62:Q64<>\"N/A\"),$N62:$N64,Q62:Q64))/SUMIF(Q62:Q64,\"<>N/A\",$N62:$N64))","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(R62:R64,\"N/A\")=ROWS(R62:R64),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(R62:R64<>\"N/A\"),$N62:$N64,R62:R64))/SUMIF(R62:R64,\"<>N/A\",$N62:$N64))","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(S62:S64,\"N/A\")=ROWS(S62:S64),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(S62:S64<>\"N/A\"),$N62:$N64,S62:S64))/SUMIF(S62:S64,\"<>N/A\",$N62:$N64))","v":"N/A"}]
[null,null,"F1: Authoring","States how various xBOMs are generated.","BOMS are generated from digital artifacts with assured provenance",null,"No Digital BOMs","xBOMs are manually parsed from document data","xBOMs are interactively parsed from document data","Design is digitally represented as hierarchical product structure in PDM","Same and eBOMs automatically seeded from digital product structure ","Same and mBOMs automatically seeded from  eBOM","Same and all xBOMs automatically seeded from other xBOMs",4,null,"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A"]
[null,null,"F2: Managed","States how BOMs are stored, controlled, and managed.","All BOM types are managed in a part-centric manner.",null,"Paper file cabinets","Disconnected electronic file directories ","Disconnected, document-centric PDM systems ","Part-centric PDM systems","Harmonized PLM schema across inter-organization","Single, part-centric PLM throughout inter-organization","Single, part-centric PLM throughout supra-organization, controlled access with extended enterprise",4,null,"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A"]
[null,null,"F3: Traceability","States how BOMs trace to and connect with product and process definitions.","BOMs are bi-directionally connected and interact with other BOMS.",null,"Textual references","Electronic, textual references","Same","eBOM digitally traceable to 3D Model(s)","All xBOMs digitally traceable to product definition ","Each xBOM digitally traceable to all other BOMs, discrepancies automatically identified","Same and bi-directional xBOM notification & reconciliation",4,null,"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A"]
[null,"T6: Common Digital Libraries",null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,4,null,{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(P66:P69,\"N/A\")=ROWS(P66:P69),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(P66:P69<>\"N/A\"),$N66:$N69,P66:P69))/SUMIF(P66:P69,\"<>N/A\",$N66:$N69))","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(Q66:Q69,\"N/A\")=ROWS(Q66:Q69),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(Q66:Q69<>\"N/A\"),$N66:$N69,Q66:Q69))/SUMIF(Q66:Q69,\"<>N/A\",$N66:$N69))","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(R66:R69,\"N/A\")=ROWS(R66:R69),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(R66:R69<>\"N/A\"),$N66:$N69,R66:R69))/SUMIF(R66:R69,\"<>N/A\",$N66:$N69))","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(S66:S69,\"N/A\")=ROWS(S66:S69),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(S66:S69<>\"N/A\"),$N66:$N69,S66:S69))/SUMIF(S66:S69,\"<>N/A\",$N66:$N69))","v":"N/A"}]
[null,null,"F1: Extent","States the availability  of common, structured (schema, attributes), digital libraries deemed important to the organization that support product definition and process definition for the MBE.","Common, structured, digital libraries of critical disciplines become available for smarter decision making, reuse, and automation.",null,"No digital libraries","Some shared (i.e., copied) structured digital libraries","Common structured digital libraries for selected product definition types","Same for most (i.e., more than half but not all) product definition types","Same for all product definition types and selected process definition types","Same for all process definition types","Structure digital libraries to support all product lifecycle activities",4,null,"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A"]
[null,null,"F2: Governance","States the extent of library governance.","Library governance is done at a wider level.",null,"Manual by individual","Shared ad hoc","Organization governance team","Same","Inter-organization governance team","Supra-organization governance team","Industry consortium governance team",4,null,"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A"]
[null,null,"F3: Managed","States how libraries are stored, controlled, and managed.","Libraries are managed in common, available PDM.",null,"Paper file cabinets","Disconnected electronic file directories ","Disconnected, document-centric PDM systems ","Part-centric PDM systems","Harmonized PLM schema across inter-organization","Single, part-centric PLM throughout inter-organization","Single, part-centric PLM throughout supra-organization and controlled access for extended enterprise",4,null,"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A"]
[null,null,"F4: Access","States the disciplines that access and reuse common libraries. ","Libraries will be reused among all disciplines.",null,"Ad hoc","Separated by discipline","Same","PDM/PLM share common part-centric libraries for product definition discipline","Same and for process definition","Same for all common disciplines ","Shared when needed, with extended enterprise",4,null,"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A"]
[null,"T7: Data Records",null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,4,null,{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(P71:P72,\"N/A\")=ROWS(P71:P72),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(P71:P72<>\"N/A\"),$N71:$N72,P71:P72))/SUMIF(P71:P72,\"<>N/A\",$N71:$N72))","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(Q71:Q72,\"N/A\")=ROWS(Q71:Q72),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(Q71:Q72<>\"N/A\"),$N71:$N72,Q71:Q72))/SUMIF(Q71:Q72,\"<>N/A\",$N71:$N72))","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(R71:R72,\"N/A\")=ROWS(R71:R72),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(R71:R72<>\"N/A\"),$N71:$N72,R71:R72))/SUMIF(R71:R72,\"<>N/A\",$N71:$N72))","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(S71:S72,\"N/A\")=ROWS(S71:S72),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(S71:S72<>\"N/A\"),$N71:$N72,S71:S72))/SUMIF(S71:S72,\"<>N/A\",$N71:$N72))","v":"N/A"}]
[null,null,"F1: Long Term Archival & Retrieval (LOTAR)","States how the long term archival and retrieval of product definition, engineering authorizations, process definition, & measurement results are managed as a record copy.","Digital content and documents are saved as the record copy with certificates.",null,"2D paper drawing or other physical medium (e.g., film, microfiche, mylar)","2D drawing as electronic file","2D drawing as PDF format, with equivalent derivative model in standard (e.g., STEP AP203) format","Drawing (2D or 3DIV) and documents as PDF/A format, with equivalent derivative model in standard LOTAR formats","Native MBD model, equivalent derivative model w/ semantic PMI in standard (e.g., STEP AP242, QIF-MBD) format, and 3DIV & documents as PDF/A format","Same with process definition data.","Same with standard (e.g., QIF) as-measured data",4,null,"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A"]
[null,null,"F2: Data Package","States the format of the data packages for product and/or process related data.","Data packages become more trusted, digital, unambiguous, and automated.",null,"Paper Package","Electronic documents collected and compressed","Electronic data packaged with manifest","Same and packaged using organization standard format","Same but packaged using inter-organization standard format","Package automated from PLM, managed in PLM","Same and digitally available to supra-organization and extended enterprise",4,null,"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A"]
[]
["C3: Manufacturing Activities",null,null,{"$f":"ManufacturingActivities","v":"Activities involved in making a product."},"Parts become easier to manufacture. Manufacturing processes change from drawing-based to model-based to automation; and from document-centric to part-centric and extends to the trusted supplier.  ",null,"2D Drawings used for all manufacturing related activities","Manufacturing via 2D drawings supported by disconnected derivative or recreated models","Manufacturing via 2D drawings with validated support derivative  models","Manufacturing via drawings (3DIV & 2D) with certified support derivative models","Digital Manufacturing via trusted MBD and support 3DIV drawings","Digital manufacturing from a trusted MBD dataset via part-centric PDM","Digital manufacturing processes are automated and extended to trusted partners via enterprise PDM",4,null,{"$f":"IF(COUNT(P75,P80,P84,P88,P93,P99,P102)=0,\"N/A\",SUM(IF(P75<>\"N/A\",P75*$N75,0),IF(P80<>\"N/A\",P80*$N80,0),IF(P84<>\"N/A\",P84*$N84,0),IF(P88<>\"N/A\",P88*$N88,0),IF(P93<>\"N/A\",P93*$N93,0),IF(P99<>\"N/A\",P99*$N99,0),IF(P102<>\"N/A\",P102*$N102,0))/SUM(IF(P75<>\"N/A\",$N75,0),IF(P80<>\"N/A\",$N80,0),IF(P84<>\"N/A\",$N84,0),IF(P88<>\"N/A\",$N88,0),IF(P93<>\"N/A\",$N93,0),IF(P99<>\"N/A\",$N99,0),IF(P102<>\"N/A\",$N102,0)))","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"IF(COUNT(Q75,Q80,Q84,Q88,Q93,Q99,Q102)=0,\"N/A\",SUM(IF(Q75<>\"N/A\",Q75*$N75,0),IF(Q80<>\"N/A\",Q80*$N80,0),IF(Q84<>\"N/A\",Q84*$N84,0),IF(Q88<>\"N/A\",Q88*$N88,0),IF(Q93<>\"N/A\",Q93*$N93,0),IF(Q99<>\"N/A\",Q99*$N99,0),IF(Q102<>\"N/A\",Q102*$N102,0))/SUM(IF(Q75<>\"N/A\",$N75,0),IF(Q80<>\"N/A\",$N80,0),IF(Q84<>\"N/A\",$N84,0),IF(Q88<>\"N/A\",$N88,0),IF(Q93<>\"N/A\",$N93,0),IF(Q99<>\"N/A\",$N99,0),IF(Q102<>\"N/A\",$N102,0)))","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"IF(COUNT(R75,R80,R84,R88,R93,R99,R102)=0,\"N/A\",SUM(IF(R75<>\"N/A\",R75*$N75,0),IF(R80<>\"N/A\",R80*$N80,0),IF(R84<>\"N/A\",R84*$N84,0),IF(R88<>\"N/A\",R88*$N88,0),IF(R93<>\"N/A\",R93*$N93,0),IF(R99<>\"N/A\",R99*$N99,0),IF(R102<>\"N/A\",R102*$N102,0))/SUM(IF(R75<>\"N/A\",$N75,0),IF(R80<>\"N/A\",$N80,0),IF(R84<>\"N/A\",$N84,0),IF(R88<>\"N/A\",$N88,0),IF(R93<>\"N/A\",$N93,0),IF(R99<>\"N/A\",$N99,0),IF(R102<>\"N/A\",$N102,0)))","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"IF(COUNT(S75,S80,S84,S88,S93,S99,S102)=0,\"N/A\",SUM(IF(S75<>\"N/A\",S75*$N75,0),IF(S80<>\"N/A\",S80*$N80,0),IF(S84<>\"N/A\",S84*$N84,0),IF(S88<>\"N/A\",S88*$N88,0),IF(S93<>\"N/A\",S93*$N93,0),IF(S99<>\"N/A\",S99*$N99,0),IF(S102<>\"N/A\",S102*$N102,0))/SUM(IF(S75<>\"N/A\",$N75,0),IF(S80<>\"N/A\",$N80,0),IF(S84<>\"N/A\",$N84,0),IF(S88<>\"N/A\",$N88,0),IF(S93<>\"N/A\",$N93,0),IF(S99<>\"N/A\",$N99,0),IF(S102<>\"N/A\",$N102,0)))","v":"N/A"}]
[null,"T1: Manufacturing Process Definition",null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,4,null,{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(P76:P79,\"N/A\")=ROWS(P76:P79),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(P76:P79<>\"N/A\"),$N76:$N79,P76:P79))/SUMIF(P76:P79,\"<>N/A\",$N76:$N79))","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(Q76:Q79,\"N/A\")=ROWS(Q76:Q79),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(Q76:Q79<>\"N/A\"),$N76:$N79,Q76:Q79))/SUMIF(Q76:Q79,\"<>N/A\",$N76:$N79))","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(R76:R79,\"N/A\")=ROWS(R76:R79),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(R76:R79<>\"N/A\"),$N76:$N79,R76:R79))/SUMIF(R76:R79,\"<>N/A\",$N76:$N79))","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(S76:S79,\"N/A\")=ROWS(S76:S79),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(S76:S79<>\"N/A\"),$N76:$N79,S76:S79))/SUMIF(S76:S79,\"<>N/A\",$N76:$N79))","v":"N/A"}]
[null,null,"F1: Product Definition Source","States how the manufacturing process definition’s process and fixture models are sourced from the product definition.","Manufacturing process definition activities will be derived from the product definition basis MBD.",null,"Use or derive basis artifacts from authorized 2D drawings, obtained from file directory.","Use or derive basis artifacts from both authorized 2D drawings and ad-hoc derivative models, obtained from file directory.","Use or derive basis artifacts from authorized 2D drawings and support models, obtained via in PDM.","Use or derive basis artifacts from authorized 3D drawing (e.g., 3DIV) and support models, obtained via part objects in PDM.","Use or derive basis artifacts from authorized MBD model, obtained via part objects in PDM.","Use or derive basis artifacts from authorized product definition dataset, obtained via part objects in PDM.","Use or derive basis artifacts from authorized product definition system model, obtained via part objects in PDM.",4,null,"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A"]
[null,null,"F2: Method","States how the manufacturing process definition (i.e., process plans, start model, in-process models, cutting tool & fixture definitions, NC data package, mBOMs) are defined and generated.","Manufacturing process definition becomes more digital and confidently reuse basis MBDs to define process plans and create embellished derivatives of start-process, in-process & final-process models, fixture definitions, NC work packages & mBOMs.",null,"2D drawings and documents of cutting tools, fixtures, and in-process definitions","Same with start-process and in-process models","Same but in-process and fixture models made from basis model and mBOMs documented","In-process MBD made from basis MBD and previous final-process models,  digital cutting tool library used; mBOMs linked with eBOMs","Same; MBD can auto generate “mean” derivative models; digital cutting tool and fixture model libraries used; ","All in-process models inherited from basis MBD; cutting tool & fixture models linked with in-process models; cutting tools auto selected","Auto generated from start-process model to last final-process model equivalent to the basis MBD model and from manufacturing knowledge and process definition system models; mBOMs auto generated",4,null,"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A"]
[null,null,"F3: Managed","States how the manufacturing process definition dataset (MPDD) and contents are stored, controlled and managed.","Manufacturing process definition dataset and contents will be managed as part-centric within the PLM system.",null,"Paper file cabinets","Disconnected electronic file directories ","Grouped as common file in document-centric PDM systems ","Collected with support models in part-centric PDM systems ","Managed as associated objects within part-centric PLM","Same and as part-centric item to connected mBOM and derivatives","Same and extended enterprise’s artifacts are managed within authorized PLM",4,null,"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A"]
[null,null,"F4: Response to Change","States how the manufacturing process definition is notified and responds to changes from either product definition or associated preceding in-process definitions.","Manufacturing process definition, specifically in-process models, response to change notifications are more automated, timely, & guaranteed.",null,"No notifications","Response to ad hoc notification of change","Response to procedural notification of change ","Same with stated response time guarantee","Response to product change notification via PLM","Same with automated state change of related artifacts","Same with automated updates of related artifacts",4,null,"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A"]
[null,"T2: Tooling Definition & Realization\n",null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,4,null,{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(P81:P83,\"N/A\")=ROWS(P81:P83),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(P81:P83<>\"N/A\"),$N81:$N83,P81:P83))/SUMIF(P81:P83,\"<>N/A\",$N81:$N83))","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(Q81:Q83,\"N/A\")=ROWS(Q81:Q83),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(Q81:Q83<>\"N/A\"),$N81:$N83,Q81:Q83))/SUMIF(Q81:Q83,\"<>N/A\",$N81:$N83))","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(R81:R83,\"N/A\")=ROWS(R81:R83),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(R81:R83<>\"N/A\"),$N81:$N83,R81:R83))/SUMIF(R81:R83,\"<>N/A\",$N81:$N83))","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(S81:S83,\"N/A\")=ROWS(S81:S83),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(S81:S83<>\"N/A\"),$N81:$N83,S81:S83))/SUMIF(S81:S83,\"<>N/A\",$N81:$N83))","v":"N/A"}]
[null,null,"F1: Basis","Identifies the basis of information for tooling design (see C1: Design Activity's contexts) and realization.","Tooling definition and realization  confidently reuse the basis MBD.",null,"Visual analysis of product definition","Same","Created from basis 3D model","Same ","Created from basis 3D MBD","Created from basis MBD dataset","Defined automatically from product definition",4,null,"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A"]
[null,null,"F2: Managed","States how tooling definitions and fabrication datasets are stored, controlled, & managed.  ","Tooling definitions, fabrication dataset, and their contents become managed as part-centric within the PLM system.",null,"Paper file cabinets","Disconnected electronic file directories ","Disconnected, document-centric PDM systems ","Disconnected, part-centric PDM systems","Harmonized PLM schema across inter-organization","Single, part-centric PLM throughout inter-organization","Single, part-centric PLM throughout supra-organization and controlled access for extended enterprise",4,null,"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A"]
[null,null,"F3: Traceability","States how tooling definitions are traced back to a basis model and their respective process definitions.","Tooling definition and fabrication dataset become associated to its associated process definition and their part’s basis MBD.",null,"Textual references","Electronic, textual references","System level awareness of other disciplines","Part-level navigation to objects in other disciplines","Element-level navigation to attributes in other disciplines","Same with bi-directional navigation","Same with write back access, as appropriate",4,null,"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A"]
[null,"T3: Manufacturing Process Instructions ",null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,4,null,{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(P85:P87,\"N/A\")=ROWS(P85:P87),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(P85:P87<>\"N/A\"),$N85:$N87,P85:P87))/SUMIF(P85:P87,\"<>N/A\",$N85:$N87))","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(Q85:Q87,\"N/A\")=ROWS(Q85:Q87),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(Q85:Q87<>\"N/A\"),$N85:$N87,Q85:Q87))/SUMIF(Q85:Q87,\"<>N/A\",$N85:$N87))","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(R85:R87,\"N/A\")=ROWS(R85:R87),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(R85:R87<>\"N/A\"),$N85:$N87,R85:R87))/SUMIF(R85:R87,\"<>N/A\",$N85:$N87))","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(S85:S87,\"N/A\")=ROWS(S85:S87),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(S85:S87<>\"N/A\"),$N85:$N87,S85:S87))/SUMIF(S85:S87,\"<>N/A\",$N85:$N87))","v":"N/A"}]
[null,null,"F1: Method","States how manufacturing work instructions are authored and generated.","Manufacturing instructions progress from manual to text to model images to animations to augmented reality.  ",null,"Authored manually using Text & photographs","Authored within delivery system using text, photographs, and model images","Same with model-based animations","Same but authored within authorized source of models (PDM)","Same and with MBD models.","Same with augmented reality","Automatic process instructions based on product type, facility, and available processes",4,null,"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A"]
[null,null,"F2: Managed","States how manufacturing work instructions are stored, controlled, and managed.","Manufacturing instructions are increasingly linked to the part in the PDM system.",null,"Paper file cabinets","Disconnected electronic file directories ","Disconnected, managed in delivery system (e.g., MES)","Same with supplemental data managed in other systems","Managed as objects within a part-centric PLM and published in delivery system","Directional connected from part-centric PLM system to delivery system","Bi-Directional connected between part-centric PLM system and delivery system",4,null,"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A"]
[null,null,"F3: Response to Change","States how the manufacturing work instructions discipline responds to changes in process definition.","Manufacturing instructions response to change notifications are more automated, timely, & guaranteed.",null,"No notifications","Response to ad hoc notification of change","Response to procedural notification of change","Same with stated response time guarantee\n","Response to product change notification via PLM","Same with automated state change of related artifacts","Same with automated instruction segment updates and updates to delivery system",4,null,"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A"]
[null,"T4: Manufacturing Code Generation",null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,4,null,{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(P89:P92,\"N/A\")=ROWS(P89:P92),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(P89:P92<>\"N/A\"),$N89:$N92,P89:P92))/SUMIF(P89:P92,\"<>N/A\",$N89:$N92))","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(Q89:Q92,\"N/A\")=ROWS(Q89:Q92),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(Q89:Q92<>\"N/A\"),$N89:$N92,Q89:Q92))/SUMIF(Q89:Q92,\"<>N/A\",$N89:$N92))","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(R89:R92,\"N/A\")=ROWS(R89:R92),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(R89:R92<>\"N/A\"),$N89:$N92,R89:R92))/SUMIF(R89:R92,\"<>N/A\",$N89:$N92))","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(S89:S92,\"N/A\")=ROWS(S89:S92),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(S89:S92<>\"N/A\"),$N89:$N92,S89:S92))/SUMIF(S89:S92,\"<>N/A\",$N89:$N92))","v":"N/A"}]
[null,null,"F1: Basis Model Source ","States how the manufacturing code is sourced from manufacturing process definition dataset (MPDD)","Manufacturing code generation becomes sourced from content within the manufacturing process definition data including the MBD, product definition, start-process models,  one or more in-process models, finish-process model, and fixture models.",null,"2D drawings from work package","MPDD  contains 2D drawings and ad hoc  derivative models (e.g. STEP) from file directory ","MPDD  contains 2D drawings and derivative models from PDM","MPDD  contains drawings (i.e. 3DIV, 2D) and validated models from PDM","MPDD  contains basis MBD derivative models and 3DIVs via part object in PLM","Same and MPDD includes basis MBD native models","Same with inheritance models from native models.",4,null,"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A"]
[null,null,"F2: Method","States how manufacturing code is generated and validated using CAM/CNC software per manufacturing process definition.","Manufacturing code will confidently reuse linked basis MBDs contained in the manufacturing process dataset to generate CNC machine code.",null,"Manual","Interactively generated and validated with a 3D model.","Same with  basis model and seperate narrative","Same with PMI incorporated in-lieu of narrative","Same with integrated validation","Same with inheritance models","Automatically generated from manufacturing feature-based rules",4,null,"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A"]
[null,null,"F3: Managed","States how CNC datasets (code files, simulation files, models, drawing, and support information) are stored, controlled, and managed.","Manufacturing code definitions, CNC dataset, and their contents will be managed as part-centric within the PDM system.",null,"Paper file cabinets","Disconnected electronic file directories ","Grouped as common file in document-centric PDM systems ","Collected with support models in part-centric PDM systems ","Managed as objects within part-centric PLM","Same and as part-centric item to connected mBOM","Same and extended enterprise’s artifacts are managed within authorized PDM",4,null,"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A"]
[null,null,"F4: Response to Change","States how the manufacturing code generation discipline is notified and responds to changes in either product or process definition.","Manufacturing code generation response to change notifications are more automated, timely, & guaranteed.",null,"No notifications","Response to ad hoc notification of change","Response to procedural notification of change","Same with stated response time guarantee","Response to product change notification via PLM","Same with automated state change of related artifacts","Same with automated code segment updates ",4,null,"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A"]
[null,"T5: Manufacturing Analysis & Simulation",null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,4,null,{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(P94:P98,\"N/A\")=ROWS(P94:P98),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(P94:P98<>\"N/A\"),$N94:$N98,P94:P98))/SUMIF(P94:P98,\"<>N/A\",$N94:$N98))","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(Q94:Q98,\"N/A\")=ROWS(Q94:Q98),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(Q94:Q98<>\"N/A\"),$N94:$N98,Q94:Q98))/SUMIF(Q94:Q98,\"<>N/A\",$N94:$N98))","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(R94:R98,\"N/A\")=ROWS(R94:R98),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(R94:R98<>\"N/A\"),$N94:$N98,R94:R98))/SUMIF(R94:R98,\"<>N/A\",$N94:$N98))","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(S94:S98,\"N/A\")=ROWS(S94:S98),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(S94:S98<>\"N/A\"),$N94:$N98,S94:S98))/SUMIF(S94:S98,\"<>N/A\",$N94:$N98))","v":"N/A"}]
[null,null,"F1: Basis Model Source","States the source of basis model (e.g., product definition) used to create the analysis model.","Analysis models are derived more directly from the native model.",null,"Independent","Unauthorized model","Same ","Authorized model","Model authorized specifically for analysis\n","Analysis integral to design process","Same",4,null,"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A"]
[null,null,"F2: Analysis Model Authoring Automation","States how the analysis geometry, material, and physics models are created.","Creation of the analysis model becomes more automated.",null,"Manual","Manually modified","Same","Directed automated modification","Automatic modification","Automatic updates","Same",4,null,"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A"]
[null,null,"F3: Managed","States how analysis models, input parameters, reporting of results, and decisions are stored, controlled, and managed.","Analysis models, reporting results, and decisions are stored more closely to the basis definition and more digitally.",null,"Paper file cabinets","Disconnected electronic file directories ","Grouped as common file in document-centric PDM systems ","Collected with support models in part-centric PDM systems","Managed as objects within part-centric PDM","Same and in common  PDM throughout inter-organization ","Same and extended enterprise’s artifacts are managed within authorized PDM",4,null,"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A"]
[null,null,"F4: Influence","States how analysis results and conclusions influence both product design and manufacturing process definition..","Influence and automation of analysis increases.",null,"Independent of design","Shared with product and process design teams","Same","Business practices include manufacturing simulations results in design and process review","Same and shared to stakeholders via change management process","Change automatically proposed.","Automatic update of design & process definition with digital twin",4,null,"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A"]
[null,null,"F5: Traceability","States the breadth and depth of traceability information available.","Traceability to other disciplines increases in breadth, depth, and capability.",null,"Textual references","Electronic, textual references","System level awareness of other disciplines","Part-level navigation to objects in other disciplines","Element-level navigation to attributes in other disciplines","Same with bi-directional navigation","Same with write back access, as appropriate",4,null,"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A"]
[null,"T6: Manufacturing Operations ",null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,4,null,{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(P100:P101,\"N/A\")=ROWS(P100:P101),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(P100:P101<>\"N/A\"),$N100:$N101,P100:P101))/SUMIF(P100:P101,\"<>N/A\",$N100:$N101))","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(Q100:Q101,\"N/A\")=ROWS(Q100:Q101),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(Q100:Q101<>\"N/A\"),$N100:$N101,Q100:Q101))/SUMIF(Q100:Q101,\"<>N/A\",$N100:$N101))","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(R100:R101,\"N/A\")=ROWS(R100:R101),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(R100:R101<>\"N/A\"),$N100:$N101,R100:R101))/SUMIF(R100:R101,\"<>N/A\",$N100:$N101))","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(S100:S101,\"N/A\")=ROWS(S100:S101),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(S100:S101<>\"N/A\"),$N100:$N101,S100:S101))/SUMIF(S100:S101,\"<>N/A\",$N100:$N101))","v":"N/A"}]
[null,null,"F1: Basis Model Reference","States how manufacturing operations reference and use basis artifacts ","Manufacturing operations reference and use 3DIVs and basis models.",null,"Paper 2D drawing","Electronic 2D drawing","Same","3D interactive viewable (3DIV)","Same with support model derivatives","MBD dataset","Same with enhanced 3DIV",4,null,"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A"]
[null,null,"F2: Presentation","States how manufacturing operations use process instructions.","Manufacturing operations will contain more digital content.",null,"Textual instructions on paper ","Electronic textual instructions","Same with graphics and photo images","Same with images from model","Same with model-based interactions","Same with interactive model-based animations","Same with augmented or mixed reality",4,null,"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A"]
[null,"T7: Product Procurement ",null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,4,null,{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(P103:P106,\"N/A\")=ROWS(P103:P106),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(P103:P106<>\"N/A\"),$N103:$N106,P103:P106))/SUMIF(P103:P106,\"<>N/A\",$N103:$N106))","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(Q103:Q106,\"N/A\")=ROWS(Q103:Q106),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(Q103:Q106<>\"N/A\"),$N103:$N106,Q103:Q106))/SUMIF(Q103:Q106,\"<>N/A\",$N103:$N106))","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(R103:R106,\"N/A\")=ROWS(R103:R106),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(R103:R106<>\"N/A\"),$N103:$N106,R103:R106))/SUMIF(R103:R106,\"<>N/A\",$N103:$N106))","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(S103:S106,\"N/A\")=ROWS(S103:S106),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(S103:S106<>\"N/A\"),$N103:$N106,S103:S106))/SUMIF(S103:S106,\"<>N/A\",$N103:$N106))","v":"N/A"}]
[null,null,"F1: Content","States how product procurement data packages are generated.","Product procurement data packages automatically  conform to business rules and TDP practices.",null,"2D drawings","2D drawings and derivative model","Same","3DIV and derivative models","3DIV and derivative models as procurement data package","Auto-generated and conforms to business rules and TDP practices","Same and includes quality planning and quality results",4,null,"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A"]
[null,null,"F2: Managed","States how product procurement data packages are managed.","Product procurement data packages are managed in a part-centric PDM.",null,"Paper file cabinets","Disconnected electronic file directories ","Disconnected, document-centric PDM systems ","Disconnected, part-centric PDM systems","Harmonized PLM schema across inter-organization","Single, part-centric PLM throughout inter-organization","Single, part-centric PLM throughout supra-organization and controlled access for extended enterprise",4,null,"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A"]
[null,null,"F3: Response to Change","States how product procurement package discipline responds to changes in product definition.","Product procurement data package response to change notifications are more automated, timely, & guaranteed.",null,"No notifications","Response to ad hoc notification of change","Response to procedural notification of change","Same with stated response time guarantee","Response to product change notification via PLM","Same with automated state change by discipline","Same with automated updates from discipline",4,null,"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A"]
[null,null,"F4: Delivery","States how product procurement packages are delivered to suppliers.","Product procurement data packages are auto delivered to trusted suppliers.",null,"Mail","Email","Same with authenticated file exchange","Standalone authenticated file exchange","Authenticated PLM","Same with automatic notification via email","Auto sent to trusted suppliers with confirmation",4,null,"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A"]
[]
["C4: Quality Activities ",null,null,{"$f":"QualityActivities","v":"Activities involved in manufacturing verification, testing, inspection, and product acceptance."},"Inspection and acceptance of parts becomes easier. Verification, inspection, & acceptance processes change from drawing-based to model-based to automatic; from document-centric to part-centric; and extend to the trusted supplier.  ",null,"2D Drawings used for verification, inspection, testing, & acceptance activities","Verification, inspection, & acceptance via 2D drawings with disconnected derivative or recreated models","Verification, inspection, & acceptance via 2D drawings with validated support derivative models","Verification, inspection, & acceptance via 3DIV drawings with certified support derivative models","Digital verification, inspection, & acceptance via trusted MBD models and support 3DIV drawings","Digital metrology via trusted MBD datasets with associated product characteristics","Quality embellished models; Automated metrology processes, extended to trusted partners via authenticated PLM",4,null,{"$f":"IF(COUNT(P109,P114,P118,P122,P127,P131,P135)=0,\"N/A\",SUM(IF(P109<>\"N/A\",P109*$N109,0),IF(P114<>\"N/A\",P114*$N114,0),IF(P118<>\"N/A\",P118*$N118,0),IF(P122<>\"N/A\",P122*$N122,0),IF(P127<>\"N/A\",P127*$N127,0),IF(P131<>\"N/A\",P131*$N131,0),IF(P135<>\"N/A\",P135*$N135,0))/SUM(IF(P109<>\"N/A\",$N109,0),IF(P114<>\"N/A\",$N114,0),IF(P118<>\"N/A\",$N118,0),IF(P122<>\"N/A\",$N122,0),IF(P127<>\"N/A\",$N127,0),IF(P131<>\"N/A\",$N131,0),IF(P135<>\"N/A\",$N135,0)))","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"IF(COUNT(Q109,Q114,Q118,Q122,Q127,Q131,Q135)=0,\"N/A\",SUM(IF(Q109<>\"N/A\",Q109*$N109,0),IF(Q114<>\"N/A\",Q114*$N114,0),IF(Q118<>\"N/A\",Q118*$N118,0),IF(Q122<>\"N/A\",Q122*$N122,0),IF(Q127<>\"N/A\",Q127*$N127,0),IF(Q131<>\"N/A\",Q131*$N131,0),IF(Q135<>\"N/A\",Q135*$N135,0))/SUM(IF(Q109<>\"N/A\",$N109,0),IF(Q114<>\"N/A\",$N114,0),IF(Q118<>\"N/A\",$N118,0),IF(Q122<>\"N/A\",$N122,0),IF(Q127<>\"N/A\",$N127,0),IF(Q131<>\"N/A\",$N131,0),IF(Q135<>\"N/A\",$N135,0)))","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"IF(COUNT(R109,R114,R118,R122,R127,R131,R135)=0,\"N/A\",SUM(IF(R109<>\"N/A\",R109*$N109,0),IF(R114<>\"N/A\",R114*$N114,0),IF(R118<>\"N/A\",R118*$N118,0),IF(R122<>\"N/A\",R122*$N122,0),IF(R127<>\"N/A\",R127*$N127,0),IF(R131<>\"N/A\",R131*$N131,0),IF(R135<>\"N/A\",R135*$N135,0))/SUM(IF(R109<>\"N/A\",$N109,0),IF(R114<>\"N/A\",$N114,0),IF(R118<>\"N/A\",$N118,0),IF(R122<>\"N/A\",$N122,0),IF(R127<>\"N/A\",$N127,0),IF(R131<>\"N/A\",$N131,0),IF(R135<>\"N/A\",$N135,0)))","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"IF(COUNT(S109,S114,S118,S122,S127,S131,S135)=0,\"N/A\",SUM(IF(S109<>\"N/A\",S109*$N109,0),IF(S114<>\"N/A\",S114*$N114,0),IF(S118<>\"N/A\",S118*$N118,0),IF(S122<>\"N/A\",S122*$N122,0),IF(S127<>\"N/A\",S127*$N127,0),IF(S131<>\"N/A\",S131*$N131,0),IF(S135<>\"N/A\",S135*$N135,0))/SUM(IF(S109<>\"N/A\",$N109,0),IF(S114<>\"N/A\",$N114,0),IF(S118<>\"N/A\",$N118,0),IF(S122<>\"N/A\",$N122,0),IF(S127<>\"N/A\",$N127,0),IF(S131<>\"N/A\",$N131,0),IF(S135<>\"N/A\",$N135,0)))","v":"N/A"}]
[null,"T1: Quality Process Definition",null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,4,null,{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(P110:P113,\"N/A\")=ROWS(P110:P113),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(P110:P113<>\"N/A\"),$N110:$N113,P110:P113))/SUMIF(P110:P113,\"<>N/A\",$N110:$N113))","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(Q110:Q113,\"N/A\")=ROWS(Q110:Q113),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(Q110:Q113<>\"N/A\"),$N110:$N113,Q110:Q113))/SUMIF(Q110:Q113,\"<>N/A\",$N110:$N113))","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(R110:R113,\"N/A\")=ROWS(R110:R113),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(R110:R113<>\"N/A\"),$N110:$N113,R110:R113))/SUMIF(R110:R113,\"<>N/A\",$N110:$N113))","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(S110:S113,\"N/A\")=ROWS(S110:S113),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(S110:S113<>\"N/A\"),$N110:$N113,S110:S113))/SUMIF(S110:S113,\"<>N/A\",$N110:$N113))","v":"N/A"}]
[null,null,"F1: Product Definition Source","States how the quality process definition’s inspection plans and fixture models are sourced from the product definition.","Quality process definition activities will be derived from the product definition basis MBD.",null,"Use or derive basis artifacts from authorized 2D drawings, obtained from file directory.","Use or derive basis artifacts from both authorized 2D drawings and ad-hoc derivative models, obtained from file directory.","Use or derive basis artifacts from authorized 2D drawings and support models, obtained via PDM.","Use or derive basis artifacts from authorized 3D drawing (e.g., 3DIV) and support models, obtained via part objects in PDM.","Use or derive basis artifacts from authorized MBD model, obtained via part objects in PDM.","Use or derive basis artifacts from authorized product definition dataset, obtained via part objects in PDM.","Use or derive basis artifacts from authorized product definition system model, obtained via part objects in PDM.",4,null,"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A"]
[null,null,"F2: Method","States how quality process definition (i.e. inspection process plans, gage definitions, and fixture definitions) are generated.","Quality process definition becomes more digital and confidently reuses basis MBDs to define process plans, and create embellished derivatives,  and create fixture definitions, CMM work packages & BoCs.",null,"Manual via 2D drawings and documents, fixtures and gage drawings","Same with quality visual aids; Inspection plan manually captured from BoCs ","Same and interactive  fixture and gage models made from basis 3D model","Same and 3DIV quality visual aids from basis MBD model; Inspection plan interactively captured from BoC","Same; on-demand augmentation of product characteristics on native basis MBD; BoC exported in electronic format\n","Same; on-demand augmentation of verification methods and/or sampling plans on model-based product characteristics in model","Same; and auto generated from rule-based inspection methods from model-based product characteristics; Inspection plan exported in  standard (e.g., QIF) digital format.",4,null,"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A"]
[null,null,"F3: Managed","States how the quality process definition dataset is stored, controlled and managed.","Quality process definition dataset and contents will be managed as part-centric within the PDM system.",null,"Paper file cabinets","Disconnected electronic file directories ","Grouped as common file in document-centric PDM systems ","Collected with support models in part-centric PDM systems","Managed as associated objects within part-centric PLM","Same and as part-centric item to connected BoC","Same and extended enterprise’s artifacts are managed within authorized PLM",4,null,"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A"]
[null,null,"F4: Response to Change","States how the quality process definition is notified and responds to change from product definition. ","Quality process definition, specifically BoC, response to change notifications are more automated, timely, & guaranteed.",null,"No notifications","Response to ad hoc notification of change","Response to procedural notification of change","Same with stated response time guarantee","Response to product change notification via PLM","Same with automated state change of related artifacts","Same with automated updates of related artifacts",4,null,"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A"]
[null,"T2: Product Characteristics & BoC",null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,4,null,{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(P115:P117,\"N/A\")=ROWS(P115:P117),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(P115:P117<>\"N/A\"),$N115:$N117,P115:P117))/SUMIF(P115:P117,\"<>N/A\",$N115:$N117))","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(Q115:Q117,\"N/A\")=ROWS(Q115:Q117),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(Q115:Q117<>\"N/A\"),$N115:$N117,Q115:Q117))/SUMIF(Q115:Q117,\"<>N/A\",$N115:$N117))","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(R115:R117,\"N/A\")=ROWS(R115:R117),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(R115:R117<>\"N/A\"),$N115:$N117,R115:R117))/SUMIF(R115:R117,\"<>N/A\",$N115:$N117))","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(S115:S117,\"N/A\")=ROWS(S115:S117),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(S115:S117<>\"N/A\"),$N115:$N117,S115:S117))/SUMIF(S115:S117,\"<>N/A\",$N115:$N117))","v":"N/A"}]
[null,null,"F1: Method","States how the quality product characteristics (aka, inspection requirements) are determined, identified, and organized as a bill of characteristics (BoC).","Product characteristics persistently associated with inspection requirements within a MBD, and exported as a BoC in digital standards format.",null,"Manually labeling “ballooning” the drawing just before inspection","Interactive labeling on electronic drawing just before inspection","Interactive labeling on electronic drawing during quality planning with BoC","On-demand tagging of product characteristics with criticality classification during quality planning from derivative MBD model; BoC exported as formatted document","Same via native MBD model, and published as BoC within product definition artifact (e.g., 3DIV)","Same and augmented with criticality classification, verification methods and/or product requirement associations ","Same and BoC exported via a digital standard format (e.g., QIF)",4,null,"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A"]
[null,null,"F2: Managed","States how the Bill of Product Characteristics (BOC) are stored, controlled, and managed.","Product characteristics as BoCs are managed in a part-centric PDM.",null,"Paper file cabinets","Disconnected electronic file directories ","Grouped as common file in document-centric PDM systems ","Collected with product definition in part-centric PDM system","Managed as objects within part-centric PLM","Same and as part-centric item to connected xBoMs","Same and extended enterprise’s BoC are managed within authorized PLM",4,null,"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A"]
[null,null,"F3: Traceability","States how the BoC's trace to and connect with product definitions.","BOCs are bi-directionally connected with models, measurement results and product requirements associations.",null,"Textual references on drawings","Electronic, tag references on drawing (e.g., balloons)","Electronic, tag references to entities on model.","Digital tags are associated to PMI on MBD model.","Same and tags augmented with criticality classifications","Same with tags having digitally persistent universally unique IDs (UUIDs)","Same with associations with product requirements",4,null,"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A"]
[null,"T3: Quality Process Instructions",null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,4,null,{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(P119:P121,\"N/A\")=ROWS(P119:P121),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(P119:P121<>\"N/A\"),$N119:$N121,P119:P121))/SUMIF(P119:P121,\"<>N/A\",$N119:$N121))","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(Q119:Q121,\"N/A\")=ROWS(Q119:Q121),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(Q119:Q121<>\"N/A\"),$N119:$N121,Q119:Q121))/SUMIF(Q119:Q121,\"<>N/A\",$N119:$N121))","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(R119:R121,\"N/A\")=ROWS(R119:R121),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(R119:R121<>\"N/A\"),$N119:$N121,R119:R121))/SUMIF(R119:R121,\"<>N/A\",$N119:$N121))","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(S119:S121,\"N/A\")=ROWS(S119:S121),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(S119:S121<>\"N/A\"),$N119:$N121,S119:S121))/SUMIF(S119:S121,\"<>N/A\",$N119:$N121))","v":"N/A"}]
[null,null,"F1: Method","States how inspection work instructions are authored and generated.","Inspection instructions progress from text to model images to animations to augmented reality.  ",null,"Authored manually using Text & photographs","Authored within delivery system using text, photographs, and model images","Same with model-based animations","Same but authored within authorized source of models (PDM)","Same and with MBD models.","Same with augmented reality","Automatic process instructions based on product type, facility, and available processes",4,null,"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A"]
[null,null,"F2: Managed","States how inspection work instructions are stored, controlled, and managed.","Inspection instructions become increasingly linked to the part in the PLM system.",null,"Paper file cabinets","Disconnected electronic file directories ","Disconnected, managed in delivery system (e.g., MES)","Same with supplemental data managed in other systems","Managed as objects within a part-centric PLM and published in delivery system","Directional connected from part-centric PLM system to delivery system","Bi-Directional connected between part-centric PLM system and delivery system",4,null,"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A"]
[null,null,"F3: Response to Change","States how the inspection work instructions discipline is notified responds to changes in process definition.","Inspection instructions response to change notifications are more automated, timely, & guaranteed.",null,"No notifications","Response to ad hoc notifications of change","Response to procedural notifications of change","Same with stated response time guarantee","Response to product change notification via PLM","Same with automated state change of related artifacts","Same with automated instruction segment updates and updates to delivery system",4,null,"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A"]
[null,"T4: Inspection Code Generation",null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,4,null,{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(P123:P126,\"N/A\")=ROWS(P123:P126),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(P123:P126<>\"N/A\"),$N123:$N126,P123:P126))/SUMIF(P123:P126,\"<>N/A\",$N123:$N126))","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(Q123:Q126,\"N/A\")=ROWS(Q123:Q126),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(Q123:Q126<>\"N/A\"),$N123:$N126,Q123:Q126))/SUMIF(Q123:Q126,\"<>N/A\",$N123:$N126))","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(R123:R126,\"N/A\")=ROWS(R123:R126),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(R123:R126<>\"N/A\"),$N123:$N126,R123:R126))/SUMIF(R123:R126,\"<>N/A\",$N123:$N126))","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(S123:S126,\"N/A\")=ROWS(S123:S126),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(S123:S126<>\"N/A\"),$N123:$N126,S123:S126))/SUMIF(S123:S126,\"<>N/A\",$N123:$N126))","v":"N/A"}]
[null,null,"F1: Product Definition Source","States how the inspection code is sourced from the product definition.","Inspection code generation becomes sourced from content with provenance from the product definition dataset ",null,"Use or derive basis artifacts from authorized 2D drawings, obtained from file directory.","Use or derive basis artifacts from both authorized 2D drawings and ad-hoc derivative models, obtained from file directory.","Use or derive basis artifacts from authorized 2D drawings and support models, obtained via in PDM.","Use or derive basis artifacts from authorized 3D drawing (e.g., 3DIV) and support models, obtained via part objects in PDM.","Use or derive basis artifacts from authorized MBD model, obtained via part objects in PDM.","Use or derive basis artifacts from authorized product definition dataset, obtained via part objects in PDM.","Use or derive basis artifacts from authorized product definition system model, obtained via part objects in PDM.",4,null,"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A"]
[null,null,"F2: Method","States how inspection code is generated and validated using  measurement equipment software per quality process definition.","Inspection code confidently reuses the basis MBDs and follows the inspection plan contained in the quality process dataset to generate measurement equipment code.",null,"Manual","Interactively generated per work request and validated with a 3D model.","Same with authorized model","Same with PMI incorporated","Same with validated to inspection plan requirements","Semi-automatically generated based on minimum metrology feature set with PMI","Automatically generated from  metrology feature-based rules",4,null,"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A"]
[null,null,"F3: Managed","States how CNC datasets (code files, persistent identifiers, models, drawing, and support information) are managed.","Inspection code definitions, CNC dataset, and their contents will be managed as part-centric within the PDM system.",null,"Paper file cabinets","Disconnected electronic file directories ","Packaged as common file in document-centric PDM systems","Collected with support models in part-centric PDM systems","Managed as objects within part-centric PLM","Same and connected to inspection plan with BoC","Same and extended enterprise’s artifacts are managed within authorized PLM",4,null,"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A"]
[null,null,"F4: Response to change","States how inspection code generation discipline is notified and responds to changes in product or process definition.","Inspection code generation response to change notifications are more automated, timely, & guaranteed.",null,"No notifications","Response to  ad hoc notification of change","Response to procedural notifications of change","Same with stated response time guarantee","Response to product change notification via PLM","Same with automated state change of related artifacts","Same with automated code segment updates ",4,null,"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A"]
[null,"T5: Quality Results Management & Analysis",null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,4,null,{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(P128:P130,\"N/A\")=ROWS(P128:P130),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(P128:P130<>\"N/A\"),$N128:$N130,P128:P130))/SUMIF(P128:P130,\"<>N/A\",$N128:$N130))","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(Q128:Q130,\"N/A\")=ROWS(Q128:Q130),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(Q128:Q130<>\"N/A\"),$N128:$N130,Q128:Q130))/SUMIF(Q128:Q130,\"<>N/A\",$N128:$N130))","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(R128:R130,\"N/A\")=ROWS(R128:R130),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(R128:R130<>\"N/A\"),$N128:$N130,R128:R130))/SUMIF(R128:R130,\"<>N/A\",$N128:$N130))","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(S128:S130,\"N/A\")=ROWS(S128:S130),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(S128:S130<>\"N/A\"),$N128:$N130,S128:S130))/SUMIF(S128:S130,\"<>N/A\",$N128:$N130))","v":"N/A"}]
[null,null,"F1: Managed","States how test, measurement, inspection, and statistical results are collected, stored, controlled, and managed.","Quality results will be managed in or linked from a part-centric PDM system.",null,"Paper file cabinets","Disconnected electronic file directories ","Grouped as common file in document-centric PDM systems ","Collected in part-centric PDM systems","Managed as objects identified within part-centric PLM with linkages to quality results management tool","Same with part-centric serialized items","Same and extended enterprise’s artifacts are managed within authorized PLM",4,null,"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A"]
[null,null,"F2: Traceability (Serialization)","States how quality results are tied to serialized parts and to product definition elements.","Quality results are associated to serialized parts and individual model-based product characteristics.",null,"Textual reference to part and serialized parts","Electronic reference to part and serialized parts","Same with references to inspection tags (e.g., Key Ids) ","Same with  references to product characteristic identifiers","Same with references to persistent universally unique identifiers","Digitally associated to model-based product characteristic on serialized part","Same with associations from extended enterprise",4,null,"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A"]
[null,null,"F3: Reporting","States how quality results, recaps, and statistical conclusions are reported and communicate to other organizational disciplines.","Quality results are communicated to the inter-organization and visualized reported via a digital as-measured virtual model.",null,"Individual ad hoc textual part  summary report","Disconnected, results recaps with statistical analysis","Automatic results recaps and statistical analysis","Same and import results for display on derivative model","Results via digital interoperability standards (e.g., QIF) format.","Same with statistical analysis and quality plans.","Same and shown via product characteristics on MBD digital as-measured derivative model",4,null,"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A"]
[null,"T6: Test Equipment Definition & Realization",null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,4,null,{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(P132:P134,\"N/A\")=ROWS(P132:P134),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(P132:P134<>\"N/A\"),$N132:$N134,P132:P134))/SUMIF(P132:P134,\"<>N/A\",$N132:$N134))","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(Q132:Q134,\"N/A\")=ROWS(Q132:Q134),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(Q132:Q134<>\"N/A\"),$N132:$N134,Q132:Q134))/SUMIF(Q132:Q134,\"<>N/A\",$N132:$N134))","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(R132:R134,\"N/A\")=ROWS(R132:R134),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(R132:R134<>\"N/A\"),$N132:$N134,R132:R134))/SUMIF(R132:R134,\"<>N/A\",$N132:$N134))","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(S132:S134,\"N/A\")=ROWS(S132:S134),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(S132:S134<>\"N/A\"),$N132:$N134,S132:S134))/SUMIF(S132:S134,\"<>N/A\",$N132:$N134))","v":"N/A"}]
[null,null,"F1: Basis","Identifies the basis  of information for test equipment design (see C1: Design Activity's contexts) and realization.","Test equipment definition and realization will confidently reuse the basis MBD.",null,"Visual analysis of product definition","Same","Created from basis 3D model","Same ","Created from basis 3D MBD","Created from basis MBD dataset","Defined automatically from product definition",4,null,"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A"]
[null,null,"F2: Managed","States how test equipment definitions and fabrication datasets are stored, controlled, and managed.","Test equipment definitions, fabrication datasets, and their contents will be managed as part-centric within the PDM system.",null,"Paper file cabinets","Disconnected electronic file directories ","Disconnected, document-centric PDM systems ","Disconnected, part-centric PDM systems","Harmonized PLM schema across inter-organization","Single, part-centric PLM throughout inter-organization","Single, part-centric PLM throughout supra-organization and extended enterprise",4,null,"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A"]
[null,null,"F3: Traceability","States how test equipment definitions are traced back to a basis model and their associated process definition.","Test equipment definition and fabrication dataset become associated to their associated process definition and their part’s basis MBD.",null,"Textual references","Electronic, textual references","System level awareness of other disciplines","Part-level navigation to objects in other disciplines","Element-level navigation to attributes in other disciplines","Same with bi-directional navigation","Same with write back access, as appropriate",4,null,"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A"]
[null,"T7: Inspection Operations",null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,4,null,{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(P136:P137,\"N/A\")=ROWS(P136:P137),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(P136:P137<>\"N/A\"),$N136:$N137,P136:P137))/SUMIF(P136:P137,\"<>N/A\",$N136:$N137))","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(Q136:Q137,\"N/A\")=ROWS(Q136:Q137),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(Q136:Q137<>\"N/A\"),$N136:$N137,Q136:Q137))/SUMIF(Q136:Q137,\"<>N/A\",$N136:$N137))","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(R136:R137,\"N/A\")=ROWS(R136:R137),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(R136:R137<>\"N/A\"),$N136:$N137,R136:R137))/SUMIF(R136:R137,\"<>N/A\",$N136:$N137))","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(S136:S137,\"N/A\")=ROWS(S136:S137),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(S136:S137<>\"N/A\"),$N136:$N137,S136:S137))/SUMIF(S136:S137,\"<>N/A\",$N136:$N137))","v":"N/A"}]
[null,null,"F1: Product Definition Reference","States how inspection operations reference and use product definition and models.","Inspection operations reference and use 3DIVs and models.",null,"Paper 2D drawing","Electronic 2D drawing","Same","3D interactive viewable (3DIV)","Same with support model derivatives","MBD dataset","Same with model-based product characteristics",4,null,"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A"]
[null,null,"F2: Presentation","States how inspection operations will use process instructions.","Inspection operations will contain more digital content.",null,"Textual instructions on paper ","Electronic textual instructions","Same with graphics and photo images","Same with images from model","Same with model-based interactions","Same with interactive model-based animations","Same with augmented or mixed reality",4,null,"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A"]
[]
["C5: Enterprise Enabling Activities",null,null,{"$f":"EnterpriseEnablingActivities","v":"Activities that enable an organization to act as a MBE, but do not directly add value to a product."},"Make it easier to enable, develop, implement, and sustain an MBE.",null,"Non-existent MBE","MBE Awareness","Reactive MBE","Repeatable MBE","Digital MBE","Integrated MBE","Optimized MBE",4,null,{"$f":"IF(COUNT(P140,P143,P147,P152,P158,P164,P169)=0,\"N/A\",SUM(IF(P140<>\"N/A\",P140*$N140,0),IF(P143<>\"N/A\",P143*$N143,0),IF(P147<>\"N/A\",P147*$N147,0),IF(P152<>\"N/A\",P152*$N152,0),IF(P158<>\"N/A\",P158*$N158,0),IF(P164<>\"N/A\",P164*$N164,0),IF(P169<>\"N/A\",P169*$N169,0))/SUM(IF(P140<>\"N/A\",$N140,0),IF(P143<>\"N/A\",$N143,0),IF(P147<>\"N/A\",$N147,0),IF(P152<>\"N/A\",$N152,0),IF(P158<>\"N/A\",$N158,0),IF(P164<>\"N/A\",$N164,0),IF(P169<>\"N/A\",$N169,0)))","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"IF(COUNT(Q140,Q143,Q147,Q152,Q158,Q164,Q169)=0,\"N/A\",SUM(IF(Q140<>\"N/A\",Q140*$N140,0),IF(Q143<>\"N/A\",Q143*$N143,0),IF(Q147<>\"N/A\",Q147*$N147,0),IF(Q152<>\"N/A\",Q152*$N152,0),IF(Q158<>\"N/A\",Q158*$N158,0),IF(Q164<>\"N/A\",Q164*$N164,0),IF(Q169<>\"N/A\",Q169*$N169,0))/SUM(IF(Q140<>\"N/A\",$N140,0),IF(Q143<>\"N/A\",$N143,0),IF(Q147<>\"N/A\",$N147,0),IF(Q152<>\"N/A\",$N152,0),IF(Q158<>\"N/A\",$N158,0),IF(Q164<>\"N/A\",$N164,0),IF(Q169<>\"N/A\",$N169,0)))","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"IF(COUNT(R140,R143,R147,R152,R158,R164,R169)=0,\"N/A\",SUM(IF(R140<>\"N/A\",R140*$N140,0),IF(R143<>\"N/A\",R143*$N143,0),IF(R147<>\"N/A\",R147*$N147,0),IF(R152<>\"N/A\",R152*$N152,0),IF(R158<>\"N/A\",R158*$N158,0),IF(R164<>\"N/A\",R164*$N164,0),IF(R169<>\"N/A\",R169*$N169,0))/SUM(IF(R140<>\"N/A\",$N140,0),IF(R143<>\"N/A\",$N143,0),IF(R147<>\"N/A\",$N147,0),IF(R152<>\"N/A\",$N152,0),IF(R158<>\"N/A\",$N158,0),IF(R164<>\"N/A\",$N164,0),IF(R169<>\"N/A\",$N169,0)))","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"IF(COUNT(S140,S143,S147,S152,S158,S164,S169)=0,\"N/A\",SUM(IF(S140<>\"N/A\",S140*$N140,0),IF(S143<>\"N/A\",S143*$N143,0),IF(S147<>\"N/A\",S147*$N147,0),IF(S152<>\"N/A\",S152*$N152,0),IF(S158<>\"N/A\",S158*$N158,0),IF(S164<>\"N/A\",S164*$N164,0),IF(S169<>\"N/A\",S169*$N169,0))/SUM(IF(S140<>\"N/A\",$N140,0),IF(S143<>\"N/A\",$N143,0),IF(S147<>\"N/A\",$N147,0),IF(S152<>\"N/A\",$N152,0),IF(S158<>\"N/A\",$N158,0),IF(S164<>\"N/A\",$N164,0),IF(S169<>\"N/A\",$N169,0)))","v":"N/A"}]
[null,"T1: Product Work Collaboration",null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,4,null,{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(P141:P142,\"N/A\")=ROWS(P141:P142),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(P141:P142<>\"N/A\"),$N141:$N142,P141:P142))/SUMIF(P141:P142,\"<>N/A\",$N141:$N142))","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(Q141:Q142,\"N/A\")=ROWS(Q141:Q142),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(Q141:Q142<>\"N/A\"),$N141:$N142,Q141:Q142))/SUMIF(Q141:Q142,\"<>N/A\",$N141:$N142))","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(R141:R142,\"N/A\")=ROWS(R141:R142),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(R141:R142<>\"N/A\"),$N141:$N142,R141:R142))/SUMIF(R141:R142,\"<>N/A\",$N141:$N142))","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(S141:S142,\"N/A\")=ROWS(S141:S142),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(S141:S142<>\"N/A\"),$N141:$N142,S141:S142))/SUMIF(S141:S142,\"<>N/A\",$N141:$N142))","v":"N/A"}]
[null,null,"F1: Actors","States who is collaborating on product & process information.","Collaboration crosses more boundaries (e.g., security, location, organizational).",null,"Ad hoc","Core group","Cross-functional team","Organization ","Inter-organization","Supra-organization","Extended enterprise",4,null,"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A"]
[null,null,"F2:Methods","States the methods used to  collaborate on product & process information.","Collaboration transitions to joint authoring over increasingly rich media.",null,"Phone and in-person meetings","Same and asynchronous messaging (email, voice mail, instant messaging)","Same and synchronous sharing (voice & video conferencing)","Same and multi-user screen sharing","Same with common access to calendars, schedules, and web-based tools","Same and concurrent, multi-user authoring","Same and augmented or virtual reality collaboration",4,null,"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A"]
[null,"T2: MBE Governance",null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,4,null,{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(P144:P146,\"N/A\")=ROWS(P144:P146),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(P144:P146<>\"N/A\"),$N144:$N146,P144:P146))/SUMIF(P144:P146,\"<>N/A\",$N144:$N146))","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(Q144:Q146,\"N/A\")=ROWS(Q144:Q146),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(Q144:Q146<>\"N/A\"),$N144:$N146,Q144:Q146))/SUMIF(Q144:Q146,\"<>N/A\",$N144:$N146))","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(R144:R146,\"N/A\")=ROWS(R144:R146),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(R144:R146<>\"N/A\"),$N144:$N146,R144:R146))/SUMIF(R144:R146,\"<>N/A\",$N144:$N146))","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(S144:S146,\"N/A\")=ROWS(S144:S146),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(S144:S146<>\"N/A\"),$N144:$N146,S144:S146))/SUMIF(S144:S146,\"<>N/A\",$N144:$N146))","v":"N/A"}]
[null,null,"F1: Leadership","States the extent of the MBE leadership team.","MBE leadership becomes more formalized, full time, and at higher levels.",null,"None","Informal, part-time MBE champion ","Formal part-time MBE Champion","Formal, full-time MBE champion ","Same and organization management support","MBE champion in organization senior leadership position ","MBE Champion is head of supra-organization ",4,null,"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A"]
[null,null,"F2: Structure","States how an organization's business structure supports the MBE strategy.","MBE activities becomes more formalized with more involved in the structure.",null,"None","Ad hoc","Non-authoritative peer group","Team lead with core team","Centralized MBE program with team and cross-functional adjunct members","Same with embedded liaisons throughout inter-organization","Same including extended enterprise with members from supra-organization suppliers, customer, and external experts",4,null,"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A"]
[null,null,"F3: Commitment to Change","States the mechanisms that lead to adoption of MBE within an organization.","Mechanisms for organizational change progress from awareness  to internalization. ",null,"Mechanisms to identify willing partners","Mechanisms to promote awareness (e.g., seminars, early adoption group)\n","Mechanisms to assure understanding (e.g., training, pilots)\n ","Mechanisms to support measured success in piloting (e.g., initial operating environment)","Mechanisms to formalize adoption broadly","Mechanisms to institutionalize, standardize, and perpetuate","Mechanisms are inherent in daily practice throughout organizational functions.",4,null,"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A"]
[null,"T3: MBE People",null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,4,null,{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(P148:P151,\"N/A\")=ROWS(P148:P151),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(P148:P151<>\"N/A\"),$N148:$N151,P148:P151))/SUMIF(P148:P151,\"<>N/A\",$N148:$N151))","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(Q148:Q151,\"N/A\")=ROWS(Q148:Q151),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(Q148:Q151<>\"N/A\"),$N148:$N151,Q148:Q151))/SUMIF(Q148:Q151,\"<>N/A\",$N148:$N151))","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(R148:R151,\"N/A\")=ROWS(R148:R151),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(R148:R151<>\"N/A\"),$N148:$N151,R148:R151))/SUMIF(R148:R151,\"<>N/A\",$N148:$N151))","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(S148:S151,\"N/A\")=ROWS(S148:S151),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(S148:S151<>\"N/A\"),$N148:$N151,S148:S151))/SUMIF(S148:S151,\"<>N/A\",$N148:$N151))","v":"N/A"}]
[null,null,"F1: Training","States how engineers, designers, machinists, inspectors, and others are trained to work with MBE.","Training curriculum becomes more consistent and on demand. ",null,"N/A","Locally managed, inconsistently delivered","Centrally managed, class room based","Same and electronic delivery","Digital, on demand, consistent on all mediums","Role-based, in context of enterprise systems and business processes","Independently audited, aligns with industry best practices",4,null,"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A"]
[null,null,"F2: Support","States how people working with MBE are assisted with problem solutions and instruction.","Support becomes more complete, consistent, and accessible at point of consumption. ",null,"N/A","Info wiki; quick reference guides","Same with FAQ and on-demand instructions","Same with help request mechanism","Same with interactive scripts (e.g., tutorials)","Same with content incorporated in organization's multi-tiered help desk","Same as Inter-organization help content with enterprise help desk",4,null,"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A"]
[null,null,"F3: Certified Roles","States which MBE contributors are certified and level of recognition.","More MBE contributors are certified by more widely recognized bodies.",null,"N/A","Not standardized, no formal certification ","Standardized, certification for key roles","Standardized in business processes; certification for formally recognized roles","Roles granted when formal certification achieved, digital approvals ","Roles and permissions align with training records","Externally accredited and recognized by professional bodies",4,null,"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A"]
[null,null,"F4: Awareness","States how workers become informed about MBE processes and technology.","Information about MBE processes and technology is richer and more readily available.",null,"N/A","Ad hoc","Broadcasts to interested parties","MBE communications portal","Interactive MBE communications portal (e.g., internal wiki / web-page)","Automated feeds from core MBE business functions and capabilities","Metrics from integrated business intelligence capability",4,null,"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A"]
[null,"T4: MBE Process",null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,4,null,{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(P153:P157,\"N/A\")=ROWS(P153:P157),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(P153:P157<>\"N/A\"),$N153:$N157,P153:P157))/SUMIF(P153:P157,\"<>N/A\",$N153:$N157))","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(Q153:Q157,\"N/A\")=ROWS(Q153:Q157),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(Q153:Q157<>\"N/A\"),$N153:$N157,Q153:Q157))/SUMIF(Q153:Q157,\"<>N/A\",$N153:$N157))","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(R153:R157,\"N/A\")=ROWS(R153:R157),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(R153:R157<>\"N/A\"),$N153:$N157,R153:R157))/SUMIF(R153:R157,\"<>N/A\",$N153:$N157))","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(S153:S157,\"N/A\")=ROWS(S153:S157),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(S153:S157<>\"N/A\"),$N153:$N157,S153:S157))/SUMIF(S153:S157,\"<>N/A\",$N153:$N157))","v":"N/A"}]
[null,null,"F1: Business Practices","States how business practices are modified to accommodate the use of authorized 3D Models.","Authorized MBD become accepted by processes and become ubiquitous.",null,"2D drawing based","Same","Accommodate 3D models","Mix MBD-specific practices with legacy practices","Locally operated exclusive end-to-end practices for MBD","End-to-end practices for MBD across the inter-organization","Same and across the supra-organization and extended enterprise",4,null,"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A"]
[null,null,"F2: Repeatable (Documented)","States how MBE processes are documented and managed.","Processes become more digital, interactive, and repeatable.",null,"N/A","Inconsistent, reliant on subject matter expert knowledge","Documented, organization managed ","Documented, inter-organization managed ","Digital in designated inter-organization repository ","Fully integrated process framework","Closed loop processes",4,null,"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A"]
[null,null,"F3: Governance","States how MBE processes are governed.","Processes are governed more centrally across the enterprise.",null,"N/A","No governance","Organization management","Same","Centrally governed, standardized across inter-organization units","Actively managed by centralized team of process specialists across supra-organization","Regular process audits",4,null,"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A"]
[null,null,"F4: Optimize","States how key performance indicators of MBE processes are measured and used for optimization.","Processes become better understood, measured and optimized.",null,"N/A","Not well understood","Efficiency not measured","Key Performance Indicators measured, but inefficient ","Maintained alignment ","Assessed and optimized, tailorable ","Continuous improvement  ",4,null,"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A"]
[null,null,"F5: Industry Standard","States how MBE processes are aligned to industry and/or national standards.","Local processes are first benchmarked against, aligned to industry standards, then influenced by national standards.",null,"N/A","Locally conceived","No alignment ","Benchmark key processes ","COTS systems aligned to industry process  standards","Regularly benchmark all processes","Standards organizations engagement, influence standard definitions; regular process audits",4,null,"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A"]
[null,"T5: MBE Technology",null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,4,null,{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(P159:P163,\"N/A\")=ROWS(P159:P163),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(P159:P163<>\"N/A\"),$N159:$N163,P159:P163))/SUMIF(P159:P163,\"<>N/A\",$N159:$N163))","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(Q159:Q163,\"N/A\")=ROWS(Q159:Q163),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(Q159:Q163<>\"N/A\"),$N159:$N163,Q159:Q163))/SUMIF(Q159:Q163,\"<>N/A\",$N159:$N163))","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(R159:R163,\"N/A\")=ROWS(R159:R163),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(R159:R163<>\"N/A\"),$N159:$N163,R159:R163))/SUMIF(R159:R163,\"<>N/A\",$N159:$N163))","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(S159:S163,\"N/A\")=ROWS(S159:S163),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(S159:S163<>\"N/A\"),$N159:$N163,S159:S163))/SUMIF(S159:S163,\"<>N/A\",$N159:$N163))","v":"N/A"}]
[null,null,"F1: Standardized","States the degree of standardization for MBE  technologies.","Digital technology used for MBE becomes more standardized.",null,"N/A","Non-scalable customized, non-standard, disconnected","Same but connected ","Standardized for discrete workflows with organization customizations","Standardized for discrete workflows with inter-organization customizations","Supra-organization platform","Same with interoperability to external partners",4,null,"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A"]
[null,null,"F2: Integrated","States the alignment between MBE technology and business goals.","Technology becomes more aligned, digital, and accessible across the enterprise.",null,"N/A","Disjointed technologies","Technologies enable distinct, coherent workflows","Technology enables integrated workflows","All MBE technologies are either integrated or interoperable","Technology enables a digital thread across inter-organization and lifecycle phases","Technology enables digital thread extended to supra-organization and external strategic partners",4,null,"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A"]
[null,null,"F3: Verification & Validation","States how the organization proves the veracity of software agents that process MBE data.","Veracity of MBE software is increasingly proven. ",null,"No reliable regime","Functional verification checks on installations and upgrades","Same with verification of no side effects","Same, plus exercise software against canonical standards","Same and exercised on routine schedule","Same with continuous verification","Independent, external verification & validation (V&V)",4,null,"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A"]
[null,null,"F4: Maintained","States how the organization proves that MBE-related technologies have correct and up-to-date software configurations (e.g. versions, patch levels, configuration files).","Qualification of software versions and configurations becomes specialized, continuous, and integrated.",null,"No reliable configuration checking regime","Configuration check of individual technologies","Same","Ad hoc configuration check of dependencies","Routine configuration check of dependencies","Continuous configuration check of dependencies","Same with self-aware and self-organizing technologies",4,null,"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A"]
[null,null,"F5: Tool Availability","States the availability of MBE tools to MBE people.","Tools become more easily accessible in more environments.",null,"None ","None","Pilot projects only","Limited environments","Facility Wide","Inter-organization solutions  in all environments","Available to supra-organization and extended enterprise",null,null,"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A"]
[null,"T6: MBE Information Assurance",null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,4,null,{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(P165:P168,\"N/A\")=ROWS(P165:P168),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(P165:P168<>\"N/A\"),$N165:$N168,P165:P168))/SUMIF(P165:P168,\"<>N/A\",$N165:$N168))","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(Q165:Q168,\"N/A\")=ROWS(Q165:Q168),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(Q165:Q168<>\"N/A\"),$N165:$N168,Q165:Q168))/SUMIF(Q165:Q168,\"<>N/A\",$N165:$N168))","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(R165:R168,\"N/A\")=ROWS(R165:R168),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(R165:R168<>\"N/A\"),$N165:$N168,R165:R168))/SUMIF(R165:R168,\"<>N/A\",$N165:$N168))","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(S165:S168,\"N/A\")=ROWS(S165:S168),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(S165:S168<>\"N/A\"),$N165:$N168,S165:S168))/SUMIF(S165:S168,\"<>N/A\",$N165:$N168))","v":"N/A"}]
[null,null,"F1: Authenticity","States how the organization assures authenticity of models and derivatives.","Authenticity evolves from physical controls to intrinsic digital certificate.",null,"Markings on 2D drawing","Release records","Electronic certificate of authenticity for 2D drawing with associated 3D model","Linked electronic certificate of authenticity for drawings (e.g., 3DIV) with associated MBD model","Intrinsic, digital certificate for derivative models","Intrinsic, digital certificate for native MBD Model","Intrinsic, digital certificate for all MBD artifacts",4,null,"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A"]
[null,null,"F2: Accessibility","States the format information is stored for MBE.","Information becomes more digital and searchable.",null,"N/A","Difficult to access, in non-electronic format","Organization stored, electronic format","Master repositories, local access","Digital, separable, accessible across inter-organization","Digital reporting, search across supra-organization","Extended enterprise interrogation of data across all platforms and systems",4,null,"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A"]
[null,null,"F3: Confidentiality","States how the organization controls access to models and derivatives.","Controls become richer, automatic, and consistently applied across the enterprise.",null,"Physical control","Individual control of files ","Individual control of document sets","Manual redaction, adjudication, and encryption","Automatic redaction, adjudication, encryption, and digital rights","Object-level content protection by digital rights management system","External partners participate in digital rights management system",4,null,"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A"]
[null,null,"F4: Data Access Control","States how data access is controlled and governed.","Access controls become more common and centrally governed.",null,"N/A","Ad hoc","Granted by data creator","Governed by program","Same","Centrally governed data access controls","Same",4,null,"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A"]
[null,"T7: MBE Financials",null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,4,null,{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(P170:P171,\"N/A\")=ROWS(P170:P171),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(P170:P171<>\"N/A\"),$N170:$N171,P170:P171))/SUMIF(P170:P171,\"<>N/A\",$N170:$N171))","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(Q170:Q171,\"N/A\")=ROWS(Q170:Q171),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(Q170:Q171<>\"N/A\"),$N170:$N171,Q170:Q171))/SUMIF(Q170:Q171,\"<>N/A\",$N170:$N171))","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(R170:R171,\"N/A\")=ROWS(R170:R171),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(R170:R171<>\"N/A\"),$N170:$N171,R170:R171))/SUMIF(R170:R171,\"<>N/A\",$N170:$N171))","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"IF(COUNTIF(S170:S171,\"N/A\")=ROWS(S170:S171),\"N/A\",(SUMPRODUCT(--(S170:S171<>\"N/A\"),$N170:$N171,S170:S171))/SUMIF(S170:S171,\"<>N/A\",$N170:$N171))","v":"N/A"}]
[null,null,"F1: Mechanism","States the source and extent of funding for MBE.","MBE funding mechanism progresses from ad hoc projects, to programs, to portfolios.",null,"N/A","Ad hoc","Projects for technology capability maturation","Same and pilot applications for process maturation","Program of MBE related projects","Same and coordinated across multiple funding venues","Portfolio of MBE programs",4,null,"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A"]
[null,null,"F2: Continuity","States the continuity of funding for MBE.","MBE funding continues from competitive short-term to organizationally sustained funding.",null,"N/A","Ad hoc","Single time period","Multiple time periods","Sustained at organization","Sustained across inter-organization.","Sustained from supra-organization",4,null,"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A"]
[null,null,"END"]
[null,null," NSC-614-4279 dated 20220126 Unclassified Unlimited Release (UUR).  "]

{"sheet":"MBE Lexicon","index":2,"n_rows":132,"n_cols":5,"rows_kept":132,"cut":false,"hidden":false,"merged":[]}
["Abbrev.","Term","Definition","Specialization","Organization Comments (Add your comments here)"]
["3DIV","3D Interactive Viewable","A three-dimensional, derivative model that is interactive and is published in a ubiquitous format."]
[null,"Ad hoc","A mode of operation performed as needed."]
[null,"Annotation","Visible, non-shape information contained in a 3D model.","[ASME Y14.41-2019, Annotation] visible dimensions, tolerances, notes, text, or symbols.  "]
[null,"Assertion","In the MBE Maturity Index, a statement to be assessed at the intersection of a maturity level and a facet."]
[null,"Attribute","Non-visible information contained in, or related to, a model.","[ASME Y14.41-2019, Attribute] a dimension, tolerance, note, text, or symbol required to complete the product definition or feature of the product that is not visible, but available upon interrogation of the annotated model.","[DoDI 5000.70, Metadata] Searchable information describing the characteristics of data; data or information about data; or descriptive information about an object’s data, data activities, systems, and holdings."]
[null,"Authenticated","Proven to be genuine as issued by its originator."]
[null,"Authoritative Source","An information provider that is sanctioned for a given lifecycle activity. "]
[null,"Authorized","Approved by an authority for use in a lifecycle activity."]
[null,"Automated","A mode of operation performed for a person by a machine."]
[null,"Baseline","An immutable dataset created at a particular point in time and used for comparison or control."]
[null,"Baseline, Product Definition","See product definition and baseline."]
["BoC","Bill of Characteristic","A list of product characteristics."]
["BoM","Bill of Materials","A list of items, along with quantities and optional activity-specific information, needed to perform a lifecycle activity."]
[null,"BoM, X","Any type of BoM."]
[null,"Bounded Surface",null,"[ASME Y14.46, Bounded Surface Region] A surface subset within a part or on a part surface that is bounded by a set of connected or intersecting edges"]
[null,"Bounded Volume",null,"[ASME Y14.46, Bounded Volume Region] A volume subset within a part that is bounded by a set of connected or intersecting surfaces."]
[null,"Category","In the MBE Maturity Index, an activity that contains topics."]
[null,"Certified","Guaranteed to conform to protocols."]
[null,"Certificate","Evidence that an artifact is certified."]
[null,"Context","In the MBE Maturity Index, a user-defined discipline."]
[null,"Copy, Controlled","Data prepared and copied from an authoritative  source with provenance"]
[null,"Copy, Record","Data prepared and copied for longer term storage and retrieval."]
[null,"Courtesy","An unauthorized artifact (e.g., model) provided to a recipient."]
[null,"Criticality designator","A note of great importance that appears on a product definition."]
[null,"Data","Facts given for storage or processing.","[ASME Y14.41-2019, Data] Information represented in a formal manner suitable for communication, interpretation, or processing by human beings or computers."]
[null,"Data, Process ","Product data that pertains to a process."]
[null,"Data, Product","Data that pertains to the product lifecycle."]
[null,"Data, Supplemental","Data elements included in product definition data to communicate design requirements but not intended to represent an item.","[ASME Y14.41-2019, Supplemental Geometry] Geometric elements included in product definition data to communicate design requirements but not intended to represent an item."]
[null,"Dataset","An identifiable collection of related data that serves a lifecycle activity."]
[null,"Dataset, MBD","A product definition dataset that includes a model-based definition."]
[null,"Dataset, Process Definition","A dataset that contains process definition."]
["PDD","Dataset, Product Definition ","A dataset that contains product definition.","[Y14.41-2019, Product definition data set] A collection of one or more data file(s) that discloses, directly or by reference, by means of presentation (e.g., graphic or textual), representation (e.g., semantics or machine readable), or combinations of both, the physical or functional requirements of an item."]
[null,"Data Package","An identifiable digital container of dataset(s) that is intended for the specific purpose of storage or delivery. "]
[null,"Derivative","An artifact created from a source artifact that may be transformed into a different format.","[ASME Y14.41 - 2019, Derivative] Data duplicated or extracted from the original.  A copy of a derivative is also a derivative"]
[null,"Derivative, Embellished ","The condition of a derivative being embellished from its source with respect to an intended use."]
[null,"Derivative, Equivalent ","The condition of a derivative being functionally equivalent from its source with respect to an intended use."]
[null,"Design Activities","Activities involved in designing a product."]
["DfX","Design for X","An activity that optimizes a design for a goal."]
[null,"Digital","Data intended for interpretation by computer applications."]
[null,"Digital Thread","The linkages of data from authoritative sources that interconnects a digital enterprise. "]
[null,"Digital Twin","A model digitally connected with its realization(s).",null,"A virtual representation of a physical product which is updated with information about a particular physical counterpart, and elucidates the current state and makes predictions about future states to inform decision making."]
[null,"Discipline","An expertise that contributes to the product lifecycle."]
[null,"Drawing, Simplified",null,"[ASME Y14.41 - 2019] A drawing with minimal views and dimensional characteristics that relies on the model to provide complete part definition."]
[null,"Electronic","A computerized document intended for presentation to humans."]
[null,"End Item","See product."]
[null,"Enterprise","A supra-organization that participates in an endeavor.",null,"In the context of organizations, an enterprise is a supra-organization which is above, in position sense, over one or many organizations."]
["Dent","Enterprise, Digital","An organization that uses a digital thread to conduct business activities."]
[null,"Enterprise Enabling Activities","Activities that enable an organization to act as a MBE, but do not directly add value to a product."]
[null,"Facet","In the MBE Maturity Index, an activity within a topic that contains a set of assertions regarding the current state."]
[null,"Interactive","A mode of operation performed by a person interacting with automation."]
[null,"Lifecycle","See product lifecycle."]
[null,"Lifecycle Activity","An activity related to a product lifecycle."]
["LOTAR","Long Term Archiving and Retrieval","A capability that preserves information and makes it available for communities of interest."]
[null,"Manual","A mode of operation performed by a person without automation."]
[null,"Manufacturing Activities","Activities involved in making a product."]
[null,"Maturity level","In the MBE Maturity Index, a state of maturity that contains a set of assertions."]
[null,"MBE Maturity Index","A tool that an organization uses to assess itself as, and facilitate transition to, a model-based enterprise."]
[null,"Model","A digital representation of a thing.","[DoDI 5000.70, Model] A physical, mathematical, or otherwise logical representation of a system, entity, phenomenon, or process."]
[null,"Model, 3D","A three-dimensional spatial model.","[ASME Y14.41 - 2019, Model] the portion of the data set that contains model\ngeometry and supplemental geometry."]
[null,"Model, 3D CAD ","3D model of a physical item that is generated using drafting and design software."]
[null,"Model, Authorized ","See authorized and model."]
[null,"Model, Basis ","The model that a practitioner uses as the starting point for a given lifecycle activity."]
[null,"Model, Courtesy ","See courtesy and model."]
[null,"Model, Derivative","See derivative and model."]
[null,"Model, Final-Process","The final process model for a process definition"]
[null,"Model, Inheritance","A derivative model with one-way associative propagation of source model changes."]
[null,"Model, In-Process","The intermediate process model(s) with a process definition."]
[null,"Model, MBD","See MBD and model."]
[null,"Model, Native ","A model in the format of its originating software application."]
[null,"Model, Process","See process definition and model."]
[null,"Model, Source ","See source and model."]
[null,"Model, Spatial","A model that represents geometric and/or spatial relationships."]
[null,"Model, Start-Process","The initial process model for a process definition"]
[null,"Model, Support","See support and model."]
[null,"Model, System","A logical model of interconnected structures, behaviors, parametrics, and requirements of a system."]
[null,"Model, Trusted ","See trusted and model."]
["MBD","Model-Based Definition","A product definition founded on a 3D model that requires semantic PMI and attributes.","[ANSI Y14.41, annotated model] A model and its associated data elements that define the product in a manner that can be used effectively without a drawing graphic sheet.\n"]
["MBE","Model-Based Enterprise","A digital enterprise that uses models as the foundation for the product lifecycle."]
["MBSE","Model-Based Systems Engineering","A method of system engineering that is based on models."]
[null,"Modeling, Direct","A modeling method that allows designers to interact directly with the geometry of the model. "]
[null,"Modeling, Parametric","A modeling process with the ability to change the shape of model geometry as soon as the dimension value is modified."]
[null,"On-demand","An automated mode of operation initiated by a person."]
[null,"Organization","A group of people who work together for a common purpose of activities."]
["OCM","Organizational Change Management","The mechanisms that integrates change and the ability to adapt change within an organization."]
[null,"Part","A distinct item of a product."]
[null,"Part-Centric","An organizing principle that enables product data management to relate all product lifecycle data to a single point of reference."]
[null,"PDM System","An information system that implements product data management."]
[null,"Precise","Describes a result that has sufficient decision precision."]
[null,"Presentation",null,"[ASME Y14.47 - 2019, Presentation] The manner in which information is displayed for use by a human."]
[null,"Process","Activity that contributes to realizing a product. "]
[null,"Process Definition","Any information that defines a process that contributes to realizing a product."]
[null,"Product","An item intended for a customer."]
["PMI","Product and Manufacturing Information","The annotations in a 3D model that support various lifecycle activities."]
[null,"Product Characteristic","A tolerance or specification applied to a part feature or product that requires verification."]
["PDM","Product Data Management","A capability that manages, controls, and interrelates  product data.",null,"PDM usage is frequently confined to the design stage of product development, although may extend to planning for manufacture.\n"]
[null,"Product Data Management Activities","Activities that interrelate product data."]
[null,"Product Definition","Any information that defines the physical or functional characteristics of a product, to ensure design intent."]
[null,"Product Definition Archive","An information system that stores record copies (44 U.S.C. 3301) of product definition for their long-term archive and retrieval."]
[null,"Product Definition Authorization","The record of transmittal and supporting procedures that authorize product definition for a lifecycle activity."]
[null,"Product Lifecycle","A series of stages through which a product passes during its lifetime."]
[null,"Product Lifecycle Data","See product data."]
["PLM","Product Lifecycle Management","A PDM that extends the scope to include all product lifecycle activities (e.g., design, manufacturing, quality).",null,"Also, a business strategy that enables an organization to manage the product lifecycle.\n"]
[null,"Product Structure","A hierarchical list of items that constitute a product."]
[null,"Promotion","A behavior of PLM that transitions an artifact to the next lifecycle state."]
[null,"Provenance","The lineage that validates the authenticity and/or quality of data"]
[null,"Quality Activities","Activities involved in manufacturing verification, testing, inspection, and product acceptance."]
["QIF","Quality Information Framework","An ANSI/DMSC standard for computer-interpretable quality information."]
[null,"Representation",null,"[ASME Y14.47 - 2019, Representation] The manner in which information is stored for interpretation by a machine."]
[null,"Requirement, Customer","A requirement that address a customer's expectations for the functionality, performance, and quality of a product being developed."]
[null,"Requirement, Inspection","See Product Characteristic"]
[null,"Requirement, Product","A requirement that address a product's purpose, its features, functionalities, and behavior."]
[null,"Semantic PMI","PMI that associates to digital elements."]
[null,"Service Activities","Activity involved in servicing products."]
[null,"Source of Truth","The single authoritative source that contains the original information item."]
[null,"Source","An artifact that is transformed into a derivative."]
[null,"Support","Provided as complementary to a primary artifact."]
[null,"System","An arrangement of elements that exhibits behavior not present in its elements."]
[null,"Systems Engineering Activities","Activities for system engineering of systems."]
[null,"System Model, Process Definition","A system model that encapsulates a process definition."]
[null,"System Model, Product Definition","A system model that encapsulates a product definition."]
[null,"Topic","In the MBE Maturity Index, an activity within a category that contains facets and can be assessed for future state."]
[null,"Traceability","The ability to traverse the digital thread."]
[null,"Trusted","Regarded with confidence by a consumer, and concurrently being certified, authorized, and authenticated."]
[null,"Trusted Data","See trusted and data."]
[null,"Unambiguous","Resolves to the intended interpretation."]
[null,"Validated","Assured to satisfy intent."]
[null,"Validation","An activity that assures that a product satisfies intent."]
[null,"Verification","An activity that assures that a product satisfies requirements."]
[null,"Verified","Assured to satisfy requirements."]
[]
[{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!C173","v":" NSC-614-4279 dated 20220126 Unclassified Unlimited Release (UUR).  "}]

{"sheet":"Assessment Charts","index":3,"n_rows":125,"n_cols":1,"rows_kept":125,"cut":false,"hidden":false,"merged":[]}
["Model-Based Enterprise"]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[{"$f":"'Score Summary'!A9","v":"C1: Design Activities"}]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[{"$f":"'Score Summary'!A18","v":"C2: Product Data/Lifecycle Management Activities"}]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[{"$f":"'Score Summary'!A27","v":"C3: Manufacturing Activities"}]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[{"$f":"'Score Summary'!A36","v":"C4: Quality Activities "}]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[{"$f":"'Score Summary'!A45","v":"C5: Enterprise Enabling Activities"}]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!C173","v":" NSC-614-4279 dated 20220126 Unclassified Unlimited Release (UUR).  "}]

{"sheet":"Score Summary","index":4,"n_rows":172,"n_cols":22,"rows_kept":172,"cut":false,"hidden":false,"merged":[[0,19,0,21]]}
["Do Not Modify - Used for Radar Charts",null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,"Score Summary by Facet",null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,"Score Gaps"]
["MBE","Category",null,"Max Scale","Target","Capability","Readiness","Adoption",null,null,"MBE Category",null,null,null,"Capability","Readiness","Adoption","Target",null,"C-R","R-A","T-A"]
[null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!A7","v":"C1: Design Activities"},null,6,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S7","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P7","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q7","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R7","v":"N/A"},null,null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!A7","v":"C1: Design Activities"},null,null,{"$f":"F3","v":"N/A"},"N/A","N/A",{"$f":"E3","v":"N/A"},null,{"$f":"O3-P3","v":{"$error":"#VALUE!"}},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$f":"R3-Q3","v":{"$error":"#VALUE!"}}]
[null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!A41","v":"C2: Product Data/Lifecycle Management Activities"},null,6,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S41","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P41","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q41","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R41","v":"N/A"},null,null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!A41","v":"C2: Product Data/Lifecycle Management Activities"},null,null,"N/A","N/A","N/A",{"$f":"E4","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$f":"R4-Q4","v":{"$error":"#VALUE!"}}]
[null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!A74","v":"C3: Manufacturing Activities"},null,6,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S74","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P74","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q74","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R74","v":"N/A"},null,null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!A74","v":"C3: Manufacturing Activities"},null,null,"N/A","N/A","N/A",{"$f":"E5","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$f":"R5-Q5","v":{"$error":"#VALUE!"}}]
[null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!A108","v":"C4: Quality Activities "},null,6,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S108","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P108","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q108","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R108","v":"N/A"},null,null,null,{"$f":"$B$6","v":"C4: Quality Activities "},null,null,"N/A","N/A","N/A",{"$f":"E6","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$f":"R6-Q6","v":{"$error":"#VALUE!"}}]
[null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!A139","v":"C5: Enterprise Enabling Activities"},null,6,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S139","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P139","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q139","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R139","v":"N/A"},null,null,null,{"$f":"$B$7","v":"C5: Enterprise Enabling Activities"},null,null,"N/A","N/A","N/A",{"$f":"E7","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$f":"R7-Q7","v":{"$error":"#VALUE!"}}]
[]
[{"$f":"B3","v":"C1: Design Activities"},null,null,"Max Scale","Target","Capability","Readiness","Adoption",null,null,{"$f":"L3","v":"C1: Design Activities"},null,null,null,"Capability","Readiness","Adoption","Target",null,"C-R","R-A","T-A"]
[null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!B8","v":"T1: Product Authority"},null,6,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S8","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P8","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q8","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R8","v":"N/A"},null,null,null,{"$f":"B10","v":"T1: Product Authority"},null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P8","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q8","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R8","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S8","v":"N/A"},null,{"$f":"O10-P10","v":{"$error":"#VALUE!"}},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$f":"R10-Q10","v":{"$error":"#VALUE!"}}]
[null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!B10","v":"T2: Product Requirements Association\n"},null,6,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S10","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P10","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q10","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R10","v":"N/A"},null,null,null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!C9","v":"F1: Authorized Definition"},null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P9","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q9","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R9","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S9","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!B13","v":"T3: Product Definition Description\n"},null,6,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S13","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P13","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q13","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R13","v":"N/A"},null,null,null,{"$f":"B11","v":"T2: Product Requirements Association\n"},null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P10","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q10","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R10","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S10","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!B19","v":"T4: Model Quality & Certification"},null,6,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S19","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P19","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q19","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R19","v":"N/A"},null,null,null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!C11","v":"F1: Form"},null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P11","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q11","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R11","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S11","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!B23","v":"T5: Model Derivatives\n"},null,6,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S23","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P23","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q23","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R23","v":"N/A"},null,null,null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!C12","v":"F2: Associativity"},null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P12","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q12","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R12","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S12","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!B30","v":"T6: ECAD/MCAD Collaboration\n"},null,6,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S30","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P30","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q30","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R30","v":"N/A"},null,null,null,{"$f":"B12","v":"T3: Product Definition Description\n"},null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P13","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q13","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R13","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S13","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!B34","v":"T7: Design Analysis & Simulation "},null,6,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S34","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P34","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q34","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R34","v":"N/A"},null,null,null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!C14","v":"F1: Shape Definition"},null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P14","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q14","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R14","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S14","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!C15","v":"F2: Non-Shape Information"},null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P15","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q15","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R15","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S15","v":"N/A"},null,{"$f":"O17-P17","v":{"$error":"#VALUE!"}},{"$f":"P17-Q17","v":{"$error":"#VALUE!"}},{"$f":"R17-Q17","v":{"$error":"#VALUE!"}}]
[{"$f":"B4","v":"C2: Product Data/Lifecycle Management Activities"},null,null,"Max Scale","Target","Capability","Readiness","Adoption",null,null,null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!C16","v":"F3: Metadata"},null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P16","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q16","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R16","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S16","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!B42","v":"T1: Product Definition Authority"},null,6,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S42","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P42","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q42","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R42","v":"N/A"},null,null,null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!C17","v":"F4: Presentation Views"},null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P17","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q17","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R17","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S17","v":"N/A"},null,{"$f":"O19-P19","v":{"$error":"#VALUE!"}},{"$f":"P19-Q19","v":{"$error":"#VALUE!"}},{"$f":"R19-Q19","v":{"$error":"#VALUE!"}}]
[null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!B45","v":"T2: Data Management Approach"},null,6,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S45","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P45","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q45","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R45","v":"N/A"},null,null,null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!C18","v":"F5: Tolerancing Scheme"},null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P18","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q18","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R18","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S18","v":"N/A"},null,{"$f":"O20-P20","v":{"$error":"#VALUE!"}},{"$f":"P20-Q20","v":{"$error":"#VALUE!"}},{"$f":"R20-Q20","v":{"$error":"#VALUE!"}}]
[null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!B53","v":"T3: Product Definition Management"},null,6,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S53","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P53","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q53","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R53","v":"N/A"},null,null,null,{"$f":"B13","v":"T4: Model Quality & Certification"},null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P19","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q19","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R19","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S19","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!B57","v":"T4: Process Data Management"},null,6,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S57","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P57","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q57","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R57","v":"N/A"},null,null,null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!C20","v":"F1: Verification of"},null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P20","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q20","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R20","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S20","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!B61","v":"T5: Bill of Materials (BOM) Management"},null,6,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S61","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P61","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q61","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R61","v":"N/A"},null,null,null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!C21","v":"F2: Automation"},null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P21","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q21","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R21","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S21","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!B65","v":"T6: Common Digital Libraries"},null,6,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S65","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P65","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q65","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R65","v":"N/A"},null,null,null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!C22","v":"F3: Certification"},null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P22","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q22","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R22","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S22","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!B70","v":"T7: Data Records"},null,6,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S70","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P70","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q70","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R70","v":"N/A"},null,null,null,{"$f":"B14","v":"T5: Model Derivatives\n"},null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P23","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q23","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R23","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S23","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!C24","v":"F1: Content"},null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P24","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q24","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R24","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S24","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[{"$f":"B5","v":"C3: Manufacturing Activities"},null,null,"Max Scale","Target","Capability","Readiness","Adoption",null,null,null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!C25","v":"F2: Authoring Automation"},null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P25","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q25","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R25","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S25","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!B75","v":"T1: Manufacturing Process Definition"},null,6,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S75","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P75","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q75","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R75","v":"N/A"},null,null,null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!C26","v":"F3: Validation to & Certificates"},null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P26","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q26","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R26","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S26","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!B80","v":"T2: Tooling Definition & Realization\n"},null,6,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S80","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P80","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q80","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R80","v":"N/A"},null,null,null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!C27","v":"F4: Provenance"},null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P27","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q27","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R27","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S27","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!B84","v":"T3: Manufacturing Process Instructions "},null,6,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S84","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P84","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q84","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R84","v":"N/A"},null,null,null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!C28","v":"F5: Managed"},null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P28","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q28","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R28","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S28","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!B88","v":"T4: Manufacturing Code Generation"},null,6,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S88","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P88","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q88","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R88","v":"N/A"},null,null,null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!C29","v":"F6: Viewables"},null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P29","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q29","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R29","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S29","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!B93","v":"T5: Manufacturing Analysis & Simulation"},null,6,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S93","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P93","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q93","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R93","v":"N/A"},null,null,null,{"$f":"B15","v":"T6: ECAD/MCAD Collaboration\n"},null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P30","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q30","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R30","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S30","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!B99","v":"T6: Manufacturing Operations "},null,6,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S99","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P99","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q99","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R99","v":"N/A"},null,null,null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!C31","v":"F1: Condition"},null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P31","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q31","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R31","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S31","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!B102","v":"T7: Product Procurement "},null,6,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S102","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P102","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q102","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R102","v":"N/A"},null,null,null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!C32","v":"F2: Mode"},null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P32","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q32","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R32","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S32","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!C33","v":"F3: Commonality"},null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P33","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q33","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R33","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S33","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[{"$f":"B6","v":"C4: Quality Activities "},null,null,"Max Scale","Target","Capability","Readiness","Adoption",null,null,null,{"$f":"B16","v":"T7: Design Analysis & Simulation "},null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P34","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q34","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R34","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S34","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!B109","v":"T1: Quality Process Definition"},null,6,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S109","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P109","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q109","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R109","v":"N/A"},null,null,null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!C35","v":"F1: Basis Model Source"},null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P35","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q35","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R35","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S35","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!B114","v":"T2: Product Characteristics & BoC"},null,6,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S114","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P114","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q114","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R114","v":"N/A"},null,null,null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!C36","v":"F2: Analysis Model Authoring Automation"},null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P36","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q36","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R36","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S36","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!B118","v":"T3: Quality Process Instructions"},null,6,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S118","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P118","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q118","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R118","v":"N/A"},null,null,null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!C37","v":"F3: Managed"},null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P37","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q37","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R37","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S37","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!B122","v":"T4: Inspection Code Generation"},null,6,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S122","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P122","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q122","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R122","v":"N/A"},null,null,null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!C38","v":"F4: Influence"},null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P38","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q38","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R38","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S38","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!B127","v":"T5: Quality Results Management & Analysis"},null,6,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S127","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P127","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q127","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R127","v":"N/A"},null,null,null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!C39","v":"F5: Traceability"},null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P39","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q39","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R39","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S39","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!B131","v":"T6: Test Equipment Definition & Realization"},null,6,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S131","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P131","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q131","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R131","v":"N/A"}]
[null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!B135","v":"T7: Inspection Operations"},null,6,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S135","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P135","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q135","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R135","v":"N/A"},null,null,{"$f":"L4","v":"C2: Product Data/Lifecycle Management Activities"},null,null,null,"Capability","Readiness","Adoption","Target",null,"C-R","R-A","T-A"]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"B19","v":"T1: Product Definition Authority"},null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P42","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q42","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R42","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S42","v":"N/A"},null,{"$f":"O44-P44","v":{"$error":"#VALUE!"}},{"$f":"P44-Q44","v":{"$error":"#VALUE!"}},{"$f":"R44-Q44","v":{"$error":"#VALUE!"}}]
[{"$f":"B7","v":"C5: Enterprise Enabling Activities"},null,null,"Max Scale","Target","Capability","Readiness","Adoption",null,null,null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!C43","v":"F1: Part-Centricity "},null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P43","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q43","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R43","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S43","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!B140","v":"T1: Product Work Collaboration"},null,6,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S140","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P140","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q140","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R140","v":"N/A"},null,null,null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!C44","v":"F2: Associativity"},null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P44","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q44","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R44","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S44","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!B143","v":"T2: MBE Governance"},null,6,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S143","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P143","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q143","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R143","v":"N/A"},null,null,null,{"$f":"B20","v":"T2: Data Management Approach"},null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P45","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q45","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R45","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S45","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!B147","v":"T3: MBE People"},null,6,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S147","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P147","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q147","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R147","v":"N/A"},null,null,null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!C46","v":"F1: Content Management Scope"},null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P46","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q46","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R46","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S46","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!B152","v":"T4: MBE Process"},null,6,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S152","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P152","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q152","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R152","v":"N/A"},null,null,null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!C47","v":"F2: Change Management"},null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P47","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q47","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R47","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S47","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!B158","v":"T5: MBE Technology"},null,6,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S158","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P158","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q158","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R158","v":"N/A"},null,null,null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!C48","v":"F3: Product Structure Management"},null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P48","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q48","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R48","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S48","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!B164","v":"T6: MBE Information Assurance"},null,6,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S164","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P164","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q164","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R164","v":"N/A"},null,null,null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!C49","v":"F4: User Interface Applications"},null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P49","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q49","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R49","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S49","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!B169","v":"T7: MBE Financials"},null,6,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S169","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P169","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q169","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R169","v":"N/A"},null,null,null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!C50","v":"F5: Governance"},null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P50","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q50","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R50","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S50","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!C52","v":"F7: Change Control Process"},null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P52","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q52","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R52","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S52","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
["Do Not Modify - Used for Radar Charts",null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"B21","v":"T3: Product Definition Management"},null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P53","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q53","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R53","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S53","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!C54","v":"F1: Definition Set"},null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P54","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q54","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R54","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S54","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!C173","v":" NSC-614-4279 dated 20220126 Unclassified Unlimited Release (UUR).  "},null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!C55","v":"F2: Supplemental Data Reference"},null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P55","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q55","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R55","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S55","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!C56","v":"F3: Product Definition Authorization"},null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P56","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q56","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R56","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S56","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"B22","v":"T4: Process Data Management"},null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P57","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q57","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R57","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S57","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!C58","v":"F1: Product Definition Association"},null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P58","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q58","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R58","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S58","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!C59","v":"F2: Definition Set"},null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P59","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q59","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R59","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S59","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!C60","v":"F3: Supplemental Data Reference"},null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P60","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q60","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R60","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S60","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"B23","v":"T5: Bill of Materials (BOM) Management"},null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P61","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q61","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R61","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S61","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!C62","v":"F1: Authoring"},null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P62","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q62","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R62","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S62","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!C63","v":"F2: Managed"},null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P63","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q63","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R63","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S63","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!C64","v":"F3: Traceability"},null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P64","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q64","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R64","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S64","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"B24","v":"T6: Common Digital Libraries"},null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P65","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q65","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R65","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S65","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!C66","v":"F1: Extent"},null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P66","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q66","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R66","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S66","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!C67","v":"F2: Governance"},null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P67","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q67","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R67","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S67","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!C68","v":"F3: Managed"},null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P68","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q68","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R68","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S68","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!C69","v":"F4: Access"},null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P69","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q69","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R69","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S69","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"B25","v":"T7: Data Records"},null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P70","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q70","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R70","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S70","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!C71","v":"F1: Long Term Archival & Retrieval (LOTAR)"},null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P71","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q71","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R71","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S71","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!C72","v":"F2: Data Package"},null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P72","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q72","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R72","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S72","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"L5","v":"C3: Manufacturing Activities"},null,null,null,"Capability","Readiness","Adoption","Target",null,"C-R","R-A","T-A"]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"B28","v":"T1: Manufacturing Process Definition"},null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P75","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q75","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R75","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S75","v":"N/A"},null,{"$f":"O76-P76","v":{"$error":"#VALUE!"}},{"$f":"P76-Q76","v":{"$error":"#VALUE!"}},{"$f":"R76-Q76","v":{"$error":"#VALUE!"}}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!C76","v":"F1: Product Definition Source"},null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P76","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q76","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R76","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S76","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!C77","v":"F2: Method"},null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P77","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q77","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R77","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S77","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!C78","v":"F3: Managed"},null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P78","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q78","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R78","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S78","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!C79","v":"F4: Response to Change"},null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P79","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q79","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R79","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S79","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"B29","v":"T2: Tooling Definition & Realization\n"},null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P80","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q80","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R80","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S80","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!C81","v":"F1: Basis"},null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P81","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q81","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R81","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S81","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!C82","v":"F2: Managed"},null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P82","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q82","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R82","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S82","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!C83","v":"F3: Traceability"},null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P83","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q83","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R83","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S83","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"B30","v":"T3: Manufacturing Process Instructions "},null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P84","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q84","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R84","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S84","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!C85","v":"F1: Method"},null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P85","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q85","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R85","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S85","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!C86","v":"F2: Managed"},null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P86","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q86","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R86","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S86","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!C87","v":"F3: Response to Change"},null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P87","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q87","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R87","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S87","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"B31","v":"T4: Manufacturing Code Generation"},null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P88","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q88","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R88","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S88","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!C89","v":"F1: Basis Model Source "},null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P89","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q89","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R89","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S89","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!C90","v":"F2: Method"},null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P90","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q90","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R90","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S90","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!C91","v":"F3: Managed"},null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P91","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q91","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R91","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S91","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!C92","v":"F4: Response to Change"},null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P92","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q92","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R92","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S92","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"B32","v":"T5: Manufacturing Analysis & Simulation"},null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P93","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q93","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R93","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S93","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!C94","v":"F1: Basis Model Source"},null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P94","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q94","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R94","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S94","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!C95","v":"F2: Analysis Model Authoring Automation"},null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P95","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q95","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R95","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S95","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!C96","v":"F3: Managed"},null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P96","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q96","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R96","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S96","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!C97","v":"F4: Influence"},null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P97","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q97","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R97","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S97","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!C98","v":"F5: Traceability"},null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P98","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q98","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R98","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S98","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"B33","v":"T6: Manufacturing Operations "},null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P99","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q99","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R99","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S99","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!C100","v":"F1: Basis Model Reference"},null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P100","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q100","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R100","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S100","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!C101","v":"F2: Presentation"},null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P101","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q101","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R101","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S101","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"B34","v":"T7: Product Procurement "},null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P102","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q102","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R102","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S102","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!C103","v":"F1: Content"},null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P103","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q103","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R103","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S103","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!C104","v":"F2: Managed"},null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P104","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q104","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R104","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S104","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!C105","v":"F3: Response to Change"},null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P105","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q105","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R105","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S105","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!C106","v":"F4: Delivery"},null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P106","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q106","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R106","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S106","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"L6","v":"C4: Quality Activities "},null,null,null,"Capability","Readiness","Adoption","Target",null,"C-R","R-A","T-A"]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"B37","v":"T1: Quality Process Definition"},null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P109","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q109","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R109","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S109","v":"N/A"},null,{"$f":"O110-P110","v":{"$error":"#VALUE!"}},{"$f":"P110-Q110","v":{"$error":"#VALUE!"}},{"$f":"R110-Q110","v":{"$error":"#VALUE!"}}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!C110","v":"F1: Product Definition Source"},null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P110","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q110","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R110","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S110","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!C111","v":"F2: Method"},null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P111","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q111","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R111","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S111","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!C112","v":"F3: Managed"},null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P112","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q112","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R112","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S112","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!C113","v":"F4: Response to Change"},null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P113","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q113","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R113","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S113","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"B38","v":"T2: Product Characteristics & BoC"},null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P114","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q114","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R114","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S114","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!C115","v":"F1: Method"},null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P115","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q115","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R115","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S115","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!C116","v":"F2: Managed"},null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P116","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q116","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R116","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S116","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!C117","v":"F3: Traceability"},null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P117","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q117","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R117","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S117","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"B39","v":"T3: Quality Process Instructions"},null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P118","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q118","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R118","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S118","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!C119","v":"F1: Method"},null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P119","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q119","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R119","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S119","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!C120","v":"F2: Managed"},null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P120","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q120","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R120","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S120","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!C121","v":"F3: Response to Change"},null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P121","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q121","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R121","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S121","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"B40","v":"T4: Inspection Code Generation"},null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P122","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q122","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R122","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S122","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!C123","v":"F1: Product Definition Source"},null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P123","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q123","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R123","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S123","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!C124","v":"F2: Method"},null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P124","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q124","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R124","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S124","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!C125","v":"F3: Managed"},null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P125","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q125","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R125","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S125","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!C126","v":"F4: Response to change"},null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P126","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q126","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R126","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S126","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"B41","v":"T5: Quality Results Management & Analysis"},null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P127","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q127","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R127","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S127","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!C128","v":"F1: Managed"},null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P128","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q128","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R128","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S128","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!C129","v":"F2: Traceability (Serialization)"},null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P129","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q129","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R129","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S129","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!C130","v":"F3: Reporting"},null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P130","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q130","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R130","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S130","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"B42","v":"T6: Test Equipment Definition & Realization"},null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P131","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q131","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R131","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S131","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!C132","v":"F1: Basis"},null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P132","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q132","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R132","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S132","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!C133","v":"F2: Managed"},null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P133","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q133","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R133","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S133","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!C134","v":"F3: Traceability"},null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P134","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q134","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R134","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S134","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"B43","v":"T7: Inspection Operations"},null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P135","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q135","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R135","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S135","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!C136","v":"F1: Product Definition Reference"},null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P136","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q136","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R136","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S136","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!C137","v":"F2: Presentation"},null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P137","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q137","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R137","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S137","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"L7","v":"C5: Enterprise Enabling Activities"},null,null,null,"Capability","Readiness","Adoption","Target",null,"C-R","R-A","T-A"]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"B46","v":"T1: Product Work Collaboration"},null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P140","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q140","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R140","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S140","v":"N/A"},null,{"$f":"O141-P141","v":{"$error":"#VALUE!"}},{"$f":"P141-Q141","v":{"$error":"#VALUE!"}},{"$f":"R141-Q141","v":{"$error":"#VALUE!"}}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!C141","v":"F1: Actors"},null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P141","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q141","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R141","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S141","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!C142","v":"F2:Methods"},null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P142","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q142","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R142","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S142","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"B47","v":"T2: MBE Governance"},null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P143","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q143","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R143","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S143","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!C144","v":"F1: Leadership"},null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P144","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q144","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R144","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S144","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!C145","v":"F2: Structure"},null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P145","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q145","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R145","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S145","v":"N/A"},null,{"$f":"O146-P146","v":{"$error":"#VALUE!"}},{"$f":"P146-Q146","v":{"$error":"#VALUE!"}},{"$f":"R146-Q146","v":{"$error":"#VALUE!"}}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!C146","v":"F3: Commitment to Change"},null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P146","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q146","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R146","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S146","v":"N/A"},null,{"$f":"O147-P147","v":{"$error":"#VALUE!"}},{"$f":"P147-Q147","v":{"$error":"#VALUE!"}},{"$f":"R147-Q147","v":{"$error":"#VALUE!"}}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"B48","v":"T3: MBE People"},null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P147","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q147","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R147","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S147","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!C148","v":"F1: Training"},null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P148","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q148","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R148","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S148","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!C149","v":"F2: Support"},null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P149","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q149","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R149","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S149","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!C150","v":"F3: Certified Roles"},null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P150","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q150","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R150","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S150","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!C151","v":"F4: Awareness"},null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P151","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q151","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R151","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S151","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"B49","v":"T4: MBE Process"},null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P152","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q152","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R152","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S152","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!C153","v":"F1: Business Practices"},null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P153","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q153","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R153","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S153","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!C154","v":"F2: Repeatable (Documented)"},null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P154","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q154","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R154","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S154","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!C155","v":"F3: Governance"},null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P155","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q155","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R155","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S155","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!C156","v":"F4: Optimize"},null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P156","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q156","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R156","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S156","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!C157","v":"F5: Industry Standard"},null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P157","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q157","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R157","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S157","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"B50","v":"T5: MBE Technology"},null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P158","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q158","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R158","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S158","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!C159","v":"F1: Standardized"},null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P159","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q159","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R159","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S159","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!C160","v":"F2: Integrated"},null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P160","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q160","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R160","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S160","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!C161","v":"F3: Verification & Validation"},null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P161","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q161","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R161","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S161","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!C162","v":"F4: Maintained"},null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P162","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q162","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R162","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S162","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!C163","v":"F5: Tool Availability"},null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P163","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q163","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R163","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S163","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"B51","v":"T6: MBE Information Assurance"},null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P164","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q164","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R164","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S164","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!C165","v":"F1: Authenticity"},null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P165","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q165","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R165","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S165","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!C166","v":"F2: Accessibility"},null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P166","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q166","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R166","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S166","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!C167","v":"F3: Confidentiality"},null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P167","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q167","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R167","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S167","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!C168","v":"F4: Data Access Control"},null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P168","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q168","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R168","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S168","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"B52","v":"T7: MBE Financials"},null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P169","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q169","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R169","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S169","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!C170","v":"F1: Mechanism"},null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P170","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q170","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R170","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S170","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!C171","v":"F2: Continuity"},null,{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!P171","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!Q171","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!R171","v":"N/A"},{"$f":"'MBE Maturity Index'!S171","v":"N/A"},null,{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"},{"$error":"#VALUE!"}]

{"sheet":"Peer Comments","index":5,"n_rows":1053,"n_cols":9,"rows_kept":1053,"cut":false,"hidden":false,"merged":[[69,7,70,8]]}
["Peer Reviewer:","[peer reviewers name]",null,null,null,null,null,"MBE Maturity Index Task Group "]
["Comment ID","Comment","Worksheet","Cell in Index\n(e.g., C1; T3; F1; L5)","Source","Date",null,"Response","Date"]
[1,"Many people ask, what is supplemental data in C2:T4:F3?","MBE Lexicon",null,"Sarah Hale",20220131,null,"Added \"Data, Supplemental\" with definition to MBE Lexicon",20220314]
[2,"In contrast to a duplicate copy from one disconnected systems to another, need a term (e.g., \"controlled copy\") that addresses the coping of a digital artifact from an authoritative source with  provenance. ","MBE Lexicon",null,"Curtis Brown",20220228,null,"Added \"Copy, Controlled\" with definition to MBE Lexicon",20220321]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[{"$f":"ROW()-3","v":256}]
[257]
[258]
[259]
[260]
[261]
[262]
[263]
[264]
[265]
[266]
[267]
[268]
[269]
[270]
[271]
[272]
[273]
[274]
[275]
[276]
[277]
[278]
[{"$f":"ROW()-3","v":279}]
[280]
[281]
[282]
[283]
[284]
[285]
[286]
[287]
[288]
[289]
[290]
[291]
[292]
[293]
[294]
[295]
[296]
[297]
[298]
[299]
[300]
[301]
[302]
[303]
[304]
[305]
[306]
[307]
[308]
[309]
[310]
[311]
[312]
[313]
[314]
[315]
[316]
[317]
[318]
[319]
[320]
[321]
[322]
[323]
[324]
[325]
[326]
[327]
[328]
[329]
[330]
[331]
[332]
[333]
[334]
[335]
[336]
[337]
[338]
[339]
[340]
[341]
[342]
[{"$f":"ROW()-3","v":343}]
[344]
[345]
[346]
[347]
[348]
[349]
[350]
[351]
[352]
[353]
[354]
[355]
[356]
[357]
[358]
[359]
[360]
[361]
[362]
[363]
[364]
[365]
[366]
[367]
[368]
[369]
[370]
[371]
[372]
[373]
[374]
[375]
[376]
[377]
[378]
[379]
[380]
[381]
[382]
[383]
[384]
[385]
[386]
[387]
[388]
[389]
[390]
[391]
[392]
[393]
[394]
[395]
[396]
[397]
[398]
[399]
[400]
[401]
[402]
[403]
[404]
[405]
[406]
[{"$f":"ROW()-3","v":407}]
[408]
[409]
[410]
[411]
[412]
[413]
[414]
[415]
[416]
[417]
[418]
[419]
[420]
[421]
[422]
[423]
[424]
[425]
[426]
[427]
[428]
[429]
[430]
[431]
[432]
[433]
[434]
[435]
[436]
[437]
[438]
[439]
[440]
[441]
[442]
[443]
[444]
[445]
[446]
[447]
[448]
[449]
[450]
[451]
[452]
[453]
[454]
[455]
[456]
[457]
[458]
[459]
[460]
[461]
[462]
[463]
[464]
[465]
[466]
[467]
[468]
[469]
[470]
[{"$f":"ROW()-3","v":471}]
[472]
[473]
[474]
[475]
[476]
[477]
[478]
[479]
[480]
[481]
[482]
[483]
[484]
[485]
[486]
[487]
[488]
[489]
[490]
[491]
[492]
[493]
[494]
[495]
[496]
[497]
[498]
[499]
[500]
[501]
[502]
[503]
[504]
[505]
[506]
[507]
[508]
[509]
[510]
[511]
[512]
[513]
[514]
[515]
[516]
[517]
[518]
[519]
[520]
[521]
[522]
[523]
[524]
[525]
[526]
[527]
[528]
[529]
[530]
[531]
[532]
[533]
[534]
[{"$f":"ROW()-3","v":535}]
[536]
[537]
[538]
[539]
[540]
[541]
[542]
[543]
[544]
[545]
[546]
[547]
[548]
[549]
[550]
[551]
[552]
[553]
[554]
[555]
[556]
[557]
[558]
[559]
[560]
[561]
[562]
[563]
[564]
[565]
[566]
[567]
[568]
[569]
[570]
[571]
[572]
[573]
[574]
[575]
[576]
[577]
[578]
[579]
[580]
[581]
[582]
[583]
[584]
[585]
[586]
[587]
[588]
[589]
[590]
[591]
[592]
[593]
[594]
[595]
[596]
[597]
[598]
[{"$f":"ROW()-3","v":599}]
[600]
[601]
[602]
[603]
[604]
[605]
[606]
[607]
[608]
[609]
[610]
[611]
[612]
[613]
[614]
[615]
[616]
[617]
[618]
[619]
[620]
[621]
[622]
[623]
[624]
[625]
[626]
[627]
[628]
[629]
[630]
[631]
[632]
[633]
[634]
[635]
[636]
[637]
[638]
[639]
[640]
[641]
[642]
[643]
[644]
[645]
[646]
[647]
[648]
[649]
[650]
[651]
[652]
[653]
[654]
[655]
[656]
[657]
[658]
[659]
[660]
[661]
[662]
[{"$f":"ROW()-3","v":663}]
[664]
[665]
[666]
[667]
[668]
[669]
[670]
[671]
[672]
[673]
[674]
[675]
[676]
[677]
[678]
[679]
[680]
[681]
[682]
[683]
[684]
[685]
[686]
[687]
[688]
[689]
[690]
[691]
[692]
[693]
[694]
[695]
[696]
[697]
[698]
[699]
[700]
[701]
[702]
[703]
[704]
[705]
[706]
[707]
[708]
[709]
[710]
[711]
[712]
[713]
[714]
[715]
[716]
[717]
[718]
[719]
[720]
[721]
[722]
[723]
[724]
[725]
[726]
[{"$f":"ROW()-3","v":727}]
[728]
[729]
[730]
[731]
[732]
[733]
[734]
[735]
[736]
[737]
[738]
[739]
[740]
[741]
[742]
[743]
[744]
[745]
[746]
[747]
[748]
[749]
[750]
[751]
[752]
[753]
[754]
[755]
[756]
[757]
[758]
[759]
[760]
[761]
[762]
[763]
[764]
[765]
[766]
[767]
[768]
[769]
[770]
[771]
[772]
[773]
[774]
[775]
[776]
[777]
[778]
[779]
[780]
[781]
[782]
[783]
[784]
[785]
[786]
[787]
[788]
[789]
[790]
[{"$f":"ROW()-3","v":791}]
[792]
[793]
[794]
[795]
[796]
[797]
[798]
[799]
[800]
[801]
[802]
[803]
[804]
[805]
[806]
[807]
[808]
[809]
[810]
[811]
[812]
[813]
[814]
[815]
[816]
[817]
[818]
[819]
[820]
[821]
[822]
[823]
[824]
[825]
[826]
[827]
[828]
[829]
[830]
[831]
[832]
[833]
[834]
[835]
[836]
[837]
[838]
[839]
[840]
[841]
[842]
[843]
[844]
[845]
[846]
[847]
[848]
[849]
[850]
[851]
[852]
[853]
[854]
[{"$f":"ROW()-3","v":855}]
[856]
[857]
[858]
[859]
[860]
[861]
[862]
[863]
[864]
[865]
[866]
[867]
[868]
[869]
[870]
[871]
[872]
[873]
[874]
[875]
[876]
[877]
[878]
[879]
[880]
[881]
[882]
[883]
[884]
[885]
[886]
[887]
[888]
[889]
[890]
[891]
[892]
[893]
[894]
[895]
[896]
[897]
[898]
[899]
[900]
[901]
[902]
[903]
[904]
[905]
[906]
[907]
[908]
[909]
[910]
[911]
[912]
[913]
[914]
[915]
[916]
[917]
[918]
[{"$f":"ROW()-3","v":919}]
[920]
[921]
[922]
[923]
[924]
[925]
[926]
[927]
[928]
[929]
[930]
[931]
[932]
[933]
[934]
[935]
[936]
[937]
[938]
[939]
[940]
[941]
[942]
[943]
[944]
[945]
[946]
[947]
[948]
[949]
[950]
[951]
[952]
[953]
[954]
[955]
[956]
[957]
[958]
[959]
[960]
[961]
[962]
[963]
[964]
[965]
[966]
[967]
[968]
[969]
[970]
[971]
[972]
[973]
[974]
[975]
[976]
[977]
[978]
[979]
[980]
[981]
[982]
[{"$f":"ROW()-3","v":983}]
[984]
[985]
[986]
[987]
[988]
[989]
[990]
[991]
[992]
[993]
[994]
[995]
[996]
[997]
[998]
[999]
[1000]
[1001]
[1002]
[1003]
[1004]
[1005]
[1006]
[1007]
[1008]
[1009]
[1010]
[1011]
[1012]
[1013]
[1014]
[1015]
[1016]
[1017]
[1018]
[1019]
[1020]
[1021]
[1022]
[1023]
[1024]
[1025]
[1026]
[1027]
[1028]
[1029]
[1030]
[1031]
[1032]
[1033]
[1034]
[1035]
[1036]
[1037]
[1038]
[1039]
[1040]
[1041]
[1042]
[1043]
[1044]
[1045]
[1046]
[{"$f":"ROW()-3","v":1047}]
[{"$f":"ROW()-3","v":1048}]
[{"$f":"ROW()-3","v":1049}]
[{"$f":"ROW()-3","v":1050}]