Researching Atoms for Peace
 Luke
Vortman during a pause in the interview while
Michael Anne Sullivan reviews her notes. |
On October 11, 2000, Carl Mora and
Michael Anne Sullivan interviewed retiree Luke Vortman
on his participation in Project Plowshare. He was
interviewed for background material on Sandia's role
in U. S. projects related to the peaceful uses of
nuclear explosives. Vortman, who was employed by Sandia
from 1949 to 1985, recounted a wealth of reminiscences
and anecdotes concerning Plowshare.
Born of a unique combination of Cold War concerns,
technological advances, and scientific initiative,
Project Plowshare had a small but lasting effect on
the history of atomic science in America. Designed
to test the possibility of using nuclear explosives
for peaceful purposes, the Plowshare program began
in a secret meeting room in Livermore, California,
but grew large enough to conduct over twenty-seven
nuclear tests and to participate in large-scale engineering
projects across the globe. The variety of tests performed
for Plowshare included the 1960 Scooter test in Nevada
which used a million pounds of TNT in the largest
conventional high-explosive detonation in the United
States.
The concept of Plowshare, from the scriptural exhortation
to beat swords into plowshares (even though the latter
were apparently not invented until about A.D. 700),
has been credited to Edward Teller. Plowshare began
in 1957 under the technical direction of the Livermore
Radiation Laboratory (later Lawrence Livermore National
Laboratory).
Luke Vortman of Sandia led the team devoted to cratering
engineering, using high explosives to learn how best
to place nuclear explosives to perform excavation.
Among the proposed nuclear engineering projects that
Sandia assisted in examing were the excavation of
a new canal through the Isthmus of Panama and a harbor
at Cape Thompson, Alaska.
Although today the idea that nuclear bombs could
be used in digging and drilling seems fantastic, at
the time, the prospect that nuclear devices could
be put to non-military purpose seemed a worthy venture.
In hindsight Vortman noted that Plowshare "…was a
pretty wild idea." Yet he explained he stayed with
the Program because "…if this effort was going to
fly wouldn't it be great to be a part of it? Because
you can't tell the future, …[a]nd it sort of relates
back to that famous line in South Pacific,
'if you don't have a dream how are you going to make
a dream come true?'"
Beginning as a program with high hopes and great
expectations, Plowshare attempted to harness the powerful
forces of nuclear energy to reshape the landscape
of the earth. Yet the support for the peaceful use
of nuclear explosives crumbled under the growing concerns
over nuclear energy in America. Doubts about the sustainability
of the program, beginning with the American public
and then growing to include the federal government,
gradually deprived Plowshare of funding and support.
Despite its plagued history, however, Plowshare remains
a significant chapter in America's nuclear history.
As part of the story of America's nuclear complex,
Project Plowshare stands as the most genuine attempt
to use this most powerful of forces to achieve peaceful
ends. *
| * Information for this article
was taken from the interview with Luke Vortman,
Leland Johnson's Sandia National Laboratories:
A History of Exceptional Service in the National
Interest (1997), and a project summary prepared
for the History Program by John Herron. |
|